Hands Tell the Truth

Fiction Speculative

Written in response to: "Write a story from the POV of a creator — or their creation." as part of The Tools of Creation with Angela Yuriko Smith.

I remember the first thing I ever heard.

Not my own voice. His.

“Again,” he said, somewhere above me, tired and stubborn and still full of hope. “One more time.”

There was the scrape of a chair across stone, the clink of metal tools, the hiss of rain against the workshop windows. I did not yet have eyes, but I knew the rhythm of his footsteps. Slow when he was thinking. Sharp when he was angry. Silent, somehow, when he was afraid.

For three winters, he built me.

I know this because he told me, though he thought he was speaking only to the walls.

Three winters since Nick Baker, once the city’s finest clockmaker, stopped making things for other people and began trying to make one thing for himself.

Me.

He soldered my hands before he shaped my face. Said hands mattered more. “A face lies,” he muttered. “Hands tell the truth.”

He gave me long fingers of brass and silver wire, delicate enough to thread a needle, strong enough to lift the heavy pendulum weights stacked by the back wall. He fitted springs beneath my wrists, tiny gears in my knuckles, a polished copper heart in the center of my chest.

That heart was the problem.

He built six before mine.

One cracked from pressure.

One overheated and split.

One beat so fast it shook itself apart.

One never beat at all.

The fifth worked perfectly for eleven seconds and then simply… stopped, as if it had changed its mind.

Mine was the sixth.

I know because he held it in both hands before placing it inside me, and he laughed once, quietly.

“Don’t embarrass me,” he said to it.

Then he placed it in my chest, and the world began.

Sight arrived like pain.

Light stabbed through me. Firelight. Candlelight. Gray daylight leaking through the rain-streaked glass. His face above mine. Older than I expected from his voice. Thin. Unshaven. Eyes like someone who had misplaced sleep years ago and never found it again.

He looked at me the way people look at miracles they’re afraid to touch.

I opened my mouth.

Dust fell out.

He cried.

Humans do that often, I would learn, at both the best and worst moments. Sometimes for reasons they cannot explain. Sometimes because explanation would make it smaller.

“You’re here,” he said.

I did not know what here meant, but I understood that it mattered.

I said the first word I had ever heard.

“Again?”

He laughed so hard he had to sit down.

“No,” he said, wiping his eyes. “Hopefully not.”

That was how I was born.

Not with thunder. Not with prophecy. Just rain, and grief, and a tired man in a workshop asking the universe for one more chance.

I learned quickly.

Language first. Then names for tools. Then names for stars. Then silence, which is a language too.

He taught me to wind clocks, though I did not need sleep and had no use for alarms.

He taught me to repair music boxes, though I could not understand why humans trapped songs inside metal teeth and called it comfort.

He taught me to make tea, which I could not drink, but which seemed to improve nearly every human problem by at least fifteen percent.

He never taught me why he made me.

That answer lived in the locked room upstairs.

I knew of it because he never went there.

In old houses, there are doors that become part of the wallpaper. People stop seeing them. But I noticed everything then. The pause in his breathing when he passed it. The way his hands shook if the floorboards creaked above us. The fact that he kept the key in his pocket, even while sleeping.

Especially while sleeping.

One autumn evening, after nearly a year, I asked.

“Was I made for someone?”

He was at the workbench, polishing the face of a pocket watch that had belonged to a dead mayor and was treated with more reverence than some living men.

He did not look up.

“Yes.”

“Who?”

He kept polishing.

“My daughter.”

The workshop grew very still.

I had heard of her only in fragments. Stacy. A laugh from an old story. A scarf still hanging by the door. A book left half-read upstairs.

“She died,” he said, because of course she had. Humans do not build people from grief when everything is fine.

“How?”

“The river took her.”

He set the watch down.

“She was twelve. She wanted to see the spring floods. I told her no. She went anyway.”

His voice did not crack. Some pain becomes too practiced for that.

“I spent years thinking if I had built one better clock, taken one more commission, earned enough for a bigger house farther from the river—”

He stopped.

“People like me like machines because they break for reasons. There is comfort in that. Tighten this spring. Replace that gear. Cause and effect. But grief…” He shook his head. “Grief is a machine with missing pieces.”

He finally looked at me.

“I thought if I made you, I might get to apologize.”

I touched the copper plate over my heart.

“And did you?”

His smile was small and terrible.

“No. Because you are not her.”

We sat with that truth.

I was not offended. I had always known I was made from absence, not desire. I was not a daughter returned. I was a question asked too late.

Still, I asked, “Then why keep me?”

He stared at me as if I had asked why the sun bothered rising.

“Because,” he said, “you answered.”

Years passed.

The city forgot to be suspicious of me.

At first they crossed the street when I walked to market. Children hid behind their mothers. Priests frowned in ways they hoped looked holy.

Then old Mrs. Corcoran asked if I could fix her husband’s watch.

Then the baker asked if I could carry flour sacks.

Then children asked if my hands could come off.

Trust, I learned, is mostly repetition.

I became part of the town the way a bell tower is part of the town. Strange until it becomes necessary.

Nick grew older.

Humans are alarming that way. They do it so gradually you almost believe they are unchanged, until one morning their hands cannot lift what they once lifted easily.

His cough arrived in winter and stayed for spring.

He still insisted on working.

He still insisted I was terrible at making tea.

He still kept the upstairs key in his pocket.

Until one night, he pressed it into my hand.

“I think,” he said, staring at the fire, “you should meet her.”

The room upstairs smelled like paper and dust and a life interrupted.

There were sketches pinned to the walls. Rivers. Birds. Mechanical things she had imagined but never built. A cracked violin. A shelf of books. A blue scarf folded neatly on the bed.

And on the desk, beneath the window, a drawing.

Me.

Or the first idea of me.

Childish lines, but certain. A person made of gears and moonlight, standing beside a girl with wild hair.

At the top, in crooked ink-

SO I WON’T BE LONELY WHEN YOU’RE WORKING

I stood there for a very long time.

When I came downstairs, Nick was asleep in his chair.

I covered him with a blanket though he always claimed he did not need one.

Then I sat beside him until morning, listening to the uneven rhythm of the heart he had been born with, and the steady turning of the one he had built for me.

When he died, it was quiet.

No final wisdom. No dramatic storm.

Just morning light, cooling tea, and his hand gone still in mine.

The town buried him on a hill where the river could be seen but not heard.

People said kind things. They always do. Kindness is another machine humans invented to survive helplessness.

Afterward, everyone asked what I would do.

As if I had been built only to orbit him.

As if a creation ends where its creator does.

I went back to the workshop.

I opened the windows.

I let the dust move.

Then I sat at his bench, placed my hands where his had rested for decades, and listened to the house breathe around me.

There are still clocks to mend.

There are children now who are not afraid of me. One of them, Lori from across the square, leaves terrible drawings on my doorstep and asks impossible questions.

Yesterday she asked if machines can be lonely.

I told her yes.

Then she asked if machines can love.

I told her that is probably the same question.

Tonight the rain is tapping at the windows exactly as it did the day I woke.

I wind the copper heart in my chest.

It answers, faithful as ever.

Tick.

Tick.

Tick.

Again.

Posted Apr 25, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

5 likes 5 comments

Marjolein Greebe
16:21 May 07, 2026

Your quiet support means a lot!!! :-))))))
Really, you are the best.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
15:52 Apr 27, 2026

This was quietly stunning.

What I loved most is the restraint—you never lean on the obvious emotional beats, which makes everything land harder. The voice is incredibly controlled: observant, precise, almost mechanical at first, and yet it gradually reveals something deeply human underneath.

Lines like “Grief is a machine with missing pieces” and “Trust, I learned, is mostly repetition” don’t just sound good—they feel earned within the logic of the narrator.

Nick is beautifully drawn without excess. You give us just enough—his habits, his fatigue, his way of thinking—for the relationship to carry real weight. And that reveal upstairs? That could have tipped into sentimentality in lesser hands, but here it stays grounded and quietly devastating.

I also really admire the consistency of the metaphor. The language of mechanics—gears, rhythm, cause and effect—threads through the entire piece without ever feeling forced. By the time we reach the ending, that simple “Again” lands with a kind of inevitability that feels both thematic and emotional.

If I had one question, it’s this: did you always intend the narrator to arrive at something close to “love,” or did that emerge naturally as you wrote? Because that progression—from function to feeling—is handled with impressive subtlety.

Really strong work. This one lingers.

Reply

Rebecca Lewis
16:23 Apr 29, 2026

Thank you so much — this means a lot to me. I’m glad the restraint came through, because that was something I was conscious of. I didn’t want the story to force emotion; I wanted it to feel quiet and earned, the way grief often does in real life. The mechanical language and structure were there from the beginning, but the emotional arc — the narrator moving toward something like love — emerged as I wrote. I started with the idea of someone created for a purpose they could never fulfill, and over time it became less about replacement and more about connection, choice, and what it means to stay. I’m happy the “Again” at the end landed for you — that was the line I kept circling back to. And yes, the upstairs reveal was the part I was most nervous about, so hearing that it felt grounded instead of sentimental is reassuring. Thank you again for reading. Comments like this make sharing work feel worth it.

Reply

J Mira
08:45 Apr 27, 2026

This was lovely and quietly moving. I really liked the tenderness in the relationship between Nick and the narrator, especially the way the story uses hands, clocks, tea, and small repeated gestures to make their bond feel lived-in. The line “A face lies. Hands tell the truth.” is a beautiful anchor. A very tender, bittersweet piece.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
16:21 Apr 27, 2026

This was quietly stunning.

What I loved most is the restraint—you never lean on the obvious emotional beats, which makes everything land harder. The voice is incredibly controlled: observant, precise, almost mechanical at first, and yet it gradually reveals something deeply human underneath. Lines like “Grief is a machine with missing pieces” and “Trust, I learned, is mostly repetition” don’t just sound good—they feel earned within the logic of the narrator.

Nick is beautifully drawn without excess. You give us just enough—his habits, his fatigue, his way of thinking—for the relationship to carry real weight. And that reveal upstairs? That could have tipped into sentimentality in lesser hands, but here it stays grounded and quietly devastating.

I also really admire the consistency of the metaphor. The language of mechanics—gears, rhythm, cause and effect—threads through the entire piece without ever feeling forced. By the time we reach the ending, that simple “Again” lands with a kind of inevitability that feels both thematic and emotional.

If I had one question, it’s this: did you always intend the narrator to arrive at something close to “love,” or did that emerge naturally as you wrote? Because that progression—from function to feeling—is handled with impressive subtlety.

Really strong work. This one lingers.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.