When One Door Closes

Horror Suspense

This story contains themes or mentions of mental health issues.

Written in response to: "Start your story with someone being followed." as part of What Lingers.

The third night after it happened, I decided to go back to the scene of the crime. I knew he'd be there; I knew he knew that I'd come back. There was not point in dragging it out any longer. The last 72 hours I'd been in a daze, simply floating through the daily motions of my life, foggy and untethered to anything tangible. I needed to snap out of it; I couldn't go on like this any longer.

"Face this," I told myself. "Face him, and be done."

I closed my apartment door behind me and started walking towards my car. It all felt surreal. I was still in limbo, head floating in the clouds; in disbelief any of this could have happened and trying to grapple with the fact that it had. The two dispositions fought ceaselessly in my mind, neither one able to concede to the other. I opened my car door, put the key in the ignition and began to pull out of my parking spot before realizing I'd forgotten my phone.

"Fuck," I muttered, annoyed to have to delay the inevitable even longer, but not surprised. I was moving a million miles a minute while simultaneously taking action in what felt like slow motion. Of course something slipped through the cracks. I speed-walked back inside my apartment and instinctively gravitated toward the kitchen table where I last remembered seeing my phone. It wasn't there. No big deal, I probably left it on the couch, maybe it fell between the cushions- nope, not there either. In my bedroom? No, not even hiding amongst the tangled sheets on my bed. I scoured the bathroom, looked in the cabinets in the kitchen, even opened the fridge because, hey, I wasn't exactly in a solid state of mind and admittedly I'd left it in the cheese drawer before. But it wasn't there, it wasn't anywhere.

"What the fuck?"

It was then that I heard my front door click shut, which seemed impossible as I'd closed it behind me when I came in. I shot my head in the direction of the door and saw nothing. I HAD closed it, right? My heart raced as I walked toward the front of my apartment.

"Hello?" I called out.

No response. I put my hands on the door frame and peered through the peephole. Jerry was there with his golden retriever. I opened the door.

"Ope! Sorry about that, Quincy accidentally knocked the door shut," he said.

"Oh," I responded. "No worries, have a good night."

I closed the door and let out the breath I'd been holding. Ok, so maybe in my haste to come inside and grab my phone and head back out again, I'd bypassed closing the door. I've done that before. That would explain it. I took a minute to accept that rationalization, but was jolted out of it when I heard the vibration of my phone. I turned in the direction of the vibration to see it sitting on the kitchen table. I opened the front door again, hoping to see Jerry and Quincy lingering nearby, but they were gone. I took another deep breath and walked slowly toward the table.

"It's fine, you probably just missed it the first time." I told myself, not entirely believing it but not willing to lose what was beginning to feel like my last remaining grip on reality.

I picked up my phone and saw a text from Liz:

Are you still going? Ryan and I are here for you if you need us.

Yeah, about to head out I responded. I'll let you know when I'm done.

I let out another breath and turned to leave when I saw the front door wide open. I stood there motionless, I'd definitely closed it when I looked back outside for Jerry, right? Whatever, maybe I didn't because I got distracted by my phone buzzing. All of this can be explained, I was psyching myself out and I just had to go- but where the hell did I put my keys? Instinct and routine would have had me put them on the shelf by the coat closet, but I could already see they weren't there.

"What the actual fuck is going on," I said breathlessly, panicking.

I began tearing through my apartment, throwing pillows off of the couch and upturning cushions; rifling under magazines and rogue dish towels. I opened the front door again and checked the lock to see if I'd left them in there- nothing. I turned on every light and ripped the shower curtain open, began yelling loudly in the hopes it would deter a would-be intruder.

"HELLO? HELLO??? These walls are thin and my neighbors can hear EVEYRTHING!!"

Silence.

The room started spinning. I knelt down on the floor with my head in my hands trying to control my breathing. There's no way someone else was in here. How would I have missed someone coming into my 400 square foot apartment and messing with my things all in the span of approximately 5 minutes? It didn't make any sense- it wasn't possible. But I also thought what had happened three nights ago wasn't possible, either.

My phone buzzed again- I looked at the screen to see a text from an unknown number:

You'll get your keys back if you promise you won't go.

I stared blankly at the screen as another text came through.

He's not sorry.

I stood there looking at my phone. My hands were shaking when I finally pulled up Liz's contact and hit "call".

"Yeah, um, hey Liz," I said when she answered. "I'm actually not gonna go anymore. No, yeah, I'm fine, but could you and Ryan actually swing by? I know it's getting late, but I can't be alone right now. Ok, thanks so much, see you soon."

I put my phone back down on the kitchen table and hung my head while trying to muffle the oncoming sobs. I only looked back up when I heard the front door click shut, and saw my keys sitting on the shelf by the coat closet.

Posted Nov 03, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.