The Particular Metallicity of Red Velvet Cake

Fiction Inspirational Urban Fantasy

Written in response to: "Write a story in which a character can taste, smell, hear, and/or feel color." as part of Better in Color.

There are people who say the world is full of color.

There are fewer who can taste it.

And then there is me, who cannot escape it.

The first thing I ever remember tasting was sunlight.

Not the warmth of it on my skin—that came later, when I learned language and sensation had names—but the color itself. Yellow. It came in bright, sharp notes that hit the back of my tongue like citrus peel. Not sweet like lemonade, not soft like butter. Tangy. Piercing. Alive.

I was two, maybe three, sitting on the kitchen floor while my mother peeled an orange. Sunlight spilled through the window in thick golden rectangles, and I crawled straight into one of them.

I remember making a face.

My mother laughed. “Too bright, huh?”

I didn’t know the word bright. I only knew the taste—like biting into something not meant to be eaten.

That was the beginning.

For most children, colors are things you learn to name.

For me, they were things I learned to endure.

Brown came next. I discovered it in the safe, grounding way toddlers discover everything: through food. Chocolate cake. My first birthday I can vaguely recall—candles, clapping, the soft crush of frosting between my fingers—and the deep, comforting sweetness of brown coating my tongue.

Brown was kind.

Brown was warm, patient, forgiving. It lingered like caramel and didn’t stab or burn or overwhelm. Brown made the world feel solid.

Green was a surprise.

Minty—not just mint, but something sharper, cooler, like the first breath outside on a winter morning. It made me shiver even in summer. Grass, leaves, the deep dark greens of hedges—they all carried that same clean, almost medicinal taste.

I chewed on leaves once, just to see if the taste matched.

It did.

My mother was less impressed.

By the time I started school, I understood something was different about me.

Other kids didn’t wince when the sky stretched wide and blue overhead. They didn’t squint and swallow like they’d just taken a mouthful of seawater.

Blue is the worst.

Not in a painful way, not exactly. It’s just… relentless. Salty, expansive, endless. The ocean poured directly onto my tongue whenever I looked up. A clear sky felt like drowning in a taste that never stopped.

Clouds helped. White doesn’t taste like anything. It’s a relief, a blankness, like silence in a room that’s been too loud for too long.

I learned early to look for white.

My mother took me to doctors.

“Synesthesia,” one of them said, tapping his pen thoughtfully against a clipboard. “A cross-wiring of sensory perception.”

“Will it go away?” my mother asked.

The doctor smiled the way adults do when they don’t have answers but want to seem kind. “It’s not an illness. Just… different.”

Different didn’t help when the classroom walls were painted an aggressive shade of blue and I spent entire afternoons tasting salt until my tongue felt raw.

Different didn’t help when the teacher used bright yellow markers and every word she wrote on the board felt like it was squeezing lemon juice straight into my mouth.

Different didn’t help when I tried to explain to other kids and they laughed.

“What does my shirt taste like?” a boy asked once, tugging at the neon green fabric.

“Mint,” I said.

He grinned. “That’s stupid.”

It wasn’t stupid. It was overwhelming.

I learned to cope.

You would too, if every color had a flavor and the world refused to dull itself for your comfort.

I wore neutral tones. Browns and soft grays, occasional whites. My room became a sanctuary of muted shades. My mother, to her credit, repainted it twice before settling on something that didn’t make me gag when I opened my eyes in the morning.

I avoided art class when I could.

Paint was a nightmare.

Imagine dipping your hands into something thick and textured, then lifting them to a canvas while your mouth fills with a dozen conflicting flavors—tangy yellow, minty green, salty blue—all colliding until you can’t tell where one ends and another begins.

My teacher called it “expressive.”

I called it unbearable.

And then there was red.

Red didn’t show itself right away.

It lingered at the edges of my life, present but not dominant. A stop sign glimpsed from the backseat. A crayon in a box I rarely opened. The faint blush of my mother’s lipstick.

When I finally tasted it, I was seven.

It happened on a playground.

A boy fell. Scraped his knee. Nothing dramatic—just a stumble, a cry, the ordinary chaos of childhood—but when he lifted his leg and I saw the bright, blooming red of blood against pale skin, something inside me locked into place.

The taste hit a second later.

Metal.

Not just any metal—sharp, coppery, unmistakable. Like biting your tongue. Like the scent of coins pressed into your mouth.

I gagged.

The boy kept crying. Teachers rushed over. Someone handed him a tissue. The world continued.

But I stood there, frozen, with that metallic taste spreading across my tongue like a stain.

Red wasn’t like the others.

Red meant something.

Years passed.

I got better at hiding it.

That’s the thing about difference—you learn quickly which parts of yourself the world is willing to accept and which parts it isn’t. I kept my mouth shut, literally and figuratively, when colors overwhelmed me. I smiled when expected, nodded at the right moments, and pretended the sky didn’t taste like saltwater.

High school was easier in some ways.

People were too busy with their own lives to notice mine.

I found ways to navigate. Sunglasses helped with brightness, though not with taste. Choosing where to sit, what to look at, how long to linger in certain spaces—it became a kind of choreography.

And then there was Mara.

Mara wore color like it was a language she was fluent in.

Bright scarves, deep jewel-toned dresses, shoes that caught the light and threw it back in defiance. Where I minimized, she amplified.

The first time I saw her, she was standing by her locker, laughing at something someone had said. Her hair was tied back with a ribbon so vividly blue it made my mouth flood with salt.

I almost turned away.

Almost.

But then she looked at me.

“Hey,” she said, like we already knew each other.

We didn’t.

“Hi,” I managed.

She tilted her head. “You look like you just licked the ocean.”

I blinked.

“What?”

She grinned. “That ribbon, right? It’s intense.”

I stared at her.

Most people would have said “bright” or “cool” or “nice.” No one had ever described color in a way that even brushed against my experience.

“You have no idea,” I said.

She laughed again, and just like that, something shifted.

I didn’t tell her immediately.

You don’t lead with something like that. “Hi, I’m the person who tastes colors” isn’t exactly a conversation starter.

But Mara was… observant.

“You react to things,” she said one afternoon as we sat on the bleachers after school. “Not like everyone else.”

I shrugged. “Everyone reacts to things.”

“Not like you do.” She leaned back, looking up at the sky. “You look at blue like it personally offended you.”

“It kind of does.”

She turned her head, studying me. “Okay, now I need to know.”

I hesitated.

This was the moment, the pivot point. The place where I could either stay safely misunderstood or risk being something else entirely.

“I taste it,” I said finally.

“Taste what?”

“Color.”

She didn’t laugh.

She didn’t frown or look confused in that polite, dismissive way people do when they think you’re joking.

She just… waited.

“Yellow is tangy,” I continued, the words coming easier now that they’d started. “Brown is sweet. Green is minty. Blue is salty, like the ocean.”

“And red?” she asked softly.

I swallowed.

“Metallic.”

Mara didn’t treat it like a party trick.

She didn’t ask me to guess the taste of random objects or test me like I was some kind of novelty. Instead, she adjusted.

“Is this okay?” she’d ask, holding up a scarf before putting it on.

“Too much?” she’d say, glancing at a particularly vivid painting.

Sometimes it was.

Sometimes it wasn’t.

But the fact that she asked—that she cared—changed something fundamental about how I moved through the world.

For the first time, I didn’t feel like I had to endure everything alone.

The red velvet cake came later.

It was Mara’s idea.

“Everyone talks about it like it’s special,” she said one evening as we sat in a small bakery near the edge of town. “But no one can ever explain why.”

The bakery was a warm, brown place—wooden tables, soft lighting, the comforting sweetness of baked goods hanging in the air. It was one of the few public spaces I genuinely enjoyed.

“Maybe it’s just hype,” I said.

“Or maybe it’s magic.” She grinned. “Come on. Let’s find out.”

She ordered a slice.

I watched as the server placed it on the table—a neat triangle of deep red cake layered with white frosting. The color was rich, almost velvety even before tasting, and just looking at it made that familiar metallic edge flicker at the back of my tongue.

“Go on,” Mara said.

I hesitated.

Red had always been something I encountered in flashes, in moments. Blood, stop signs, scattered details. I’d never sat down and deliberately eaten something that was so intensely, unapologetically red.

“You don’t have to,” she added, reading my expression.

“I want to,” I said.

And I did.

Carefully, I picked up the fork and cut a small piece. Cake and frosting together. Balanced.

I brought it to my mouth.

And then I tasted it.

At first, it was exactly what I expected.

The sweetness of brown came through immediately—soft, rich, familiar. The frosting added a creamy layer that blurred the edges, made everything gentler.

And then the red arrived.

Metallic.

Sharp.

But not the way it had been before.

This wasn’t the sudden, jarring taste of blood on a playground. It wasn’t harsh or alarming. It was… woven in. Integrated. Like a thread running through the sweetness, giving it depth rather than overpowering it.

I closed my eyes.

The flavors—colors—moved together in a way I’d never experienced before. The tang of something faintly yellow lingered at the edges, the sweetness of brown anchored everything, and the metallic red… it didn’t dominate.

It belonged.

“Well?” Mara asked.

I opened my eyes.

“It’s… different,” I said slowly.

“Good different or bad different?”

“Good.” I took another bite, more confident this time. “It’s like… the red isn’t trying to take over. It’s part of it.”

She smiled. “So red doesn’t have to be overwhelming.”

I shook my head, a small laugh escaping me. “Apparently not.”

We went back to that bakery more times than I can count.

It became our place.

Sometimes we’d talk for hours. Sometimes we’d sit in comfortable silence, sharing a slice of cake and watching the world pass by outside the window.

I started to notice things I hadn’t before.

How colors interacted.

How they layered, blended, softened each other.

Red didn’t always have to be sharp and metallic. Surrounded by the right shades, it could become something else. Something richer. More complex.

Mara called it “context.”

“Nothing exists in isolation,” she said once, gesturing around us. “Everything is influenced by what’s around it.”

I thought about that a lot.

About how I’d spent most of my life trying to avoid certain colors, certain experiences, instead of understanding how they could change in the right environment.

About how red, the color I’d feared the most, could become something I looked forward to tasting.

The last time we went to the bakery, it was raining.

Gray skies, soft and muted. The kind of day that feels like a pause.

Mara was quieter than usual.

“You ever think about leaving?” she asked, tracing patterns in the condensation on her glass.

“Leaving where?”

“Here. This town. Everything.”

I shrugged. “Sometimes.”

“Me too.” She smiled faintly. “I got accepted to a program. In another state.”

Something in my chest tightened.

“That’s… amazing,” I said.

“It is.” She looked at me. “But it’s also far.”

I nodded.

Blue skies. New places. Different colors. Different tastes.

“You should go,” I said.

“Yeah?”

“Yeah.” I managed a small smile. “You can’t stay here just because I’m bad at handling color.”

She laughed softly. “You’re not bad at it. You just experience it differently.”

“Same difference.”

“Not really.”

We sat in silence for a moment.

Then she pushed the plate toward me.

“Last slice?” she said.

Red velvet.

Of course.

I took a bite.

Sweet brown. Creamy white. And that now-familiar metallic red, softened and shaped by everything around it.

It didn’t feel overwhelming anymore.

It felt… meaningful.

Mara left two weeks later.

The town didn’t change, but it felt different without her.

Colors were still colors. Yellow still tangy, green still minty, blue still overwhelmingly salty.

Red still metallic.

But now, when I encountered it, I remembered the cake.

The way it had tasted when it wasn’t alone.

The way it had been part of something larger, something balanced.

People say the world is full of color.

They’re right.

They just don’t always realize how much those colors depend on each other.

How even the sharpest, most overwhelming shades can become something else entirely when given the right context.

I still taste everything.

I always will.

But now, when I see red, I don’t just think of blood or metal.

I think of velvet cake.

Of sweetness and complexity.

Of the particular metallicity that, once softened, becomes something worth savoring.

Posted Apr 24, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.