They Can't Rest and Neither Can I

Fiction Suspense

This story contains sensitive content

CW: Suicide or self harm, Violence, gore, and/or abuse, Mental health issues, and Child abuse

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the line “I can’t sleep.”" as part of What Lingers.

I can’t sleep.

Every night they come for me. It starts with scratching at my door that leads to banging. The howls of pain and suffering they make at my expense has driven me mad. There’s no escaping them now. I can’t shut them out any longer. I can’t block out the noise. I am trapped and suffocated by their agony and wailing.

I used to ignore them, but the number of spirits continues to grow with each passing week. I can’t stop it. I’ve tried, but I just can’t stop the darkness. It calls to me all day long and then I’m back here each night, terrified and trying to escape the sounds that surround my bedroom.

Tonight, it has to end. I’ve gone too long without sleeping. I’ve cried so much that my eyes no longer produce tears. I write this letter tonight because I must. My time is coming to an end. I’ve been driving down a dark tunnel for far too long with no light on the other side. But that changes tonight.

I bought some new toys on the dark web and they finally arrived today. If the spirits won’t leave me alone, then I’ll take them with me. I shall be haunted no longer. I will have my silence and peace again. If these spirits have not feared me before, they should fear me now.

My goodness, these are my final words and I have not yet introduced myself. The downside of handwritten letters is the inability to edit without making it a total mess or having to start over. But that’s also the beauty of this mess. It’s authentic. It’s how I know this is all real. Perfect, clean things are illusions. Nothing real is pretty and neat. These dirty, awful, blood stained pages of this notebook are real. I am real. And if you’re holding these pages then so are you.

Once again, I’ve forgotten to introduce myself. My name is Nathan Jeffries. I’m 43 years old, and I was born and raised in Mystic, Connecticut. I find myself at a loss for what to write here. I’ve never actually talked about myself before. I’m 5’10”, of average build, and Caucasian. I realize now, in this moment, I don’t know what else to say about myself. I haven’t done anything in my life that’s worth a damn. Except for these spirits. These spirits that I’ll take with me tonight will be my legacy. I will take them straight to hell and they’ll be my trophies, proving my life had purpose. I made some kind of impact on this world, didn’t I? Of course I did. If you’re reading this, then of course I did. Yes. I did.

Look, I know I’m crazy. I hold no delusions of sanity here. I don’t pretend that of the two people on either side of this letter the sane one is the writer. I need you to understand that didn’t used to be crazy either. It’s sort of new for me. Perhaps, I don’t give myself enough credit for how long I’ve held it together. But, I know, without a doubt, I am certifiably insane now. I hear the spirits everywhere, not just at night. They are the loudest and most powerful at night, but I hear them constantly. That’s how I know I’m beyond saving.

I used to be an artist. That’s something I want to share. I still am too, just not professionally. When I was young, I dreamed of painting huge murals all over the world. Murals within cities that would speak to people, give them hope and make them cry. I never made it to art school. No money. No family. Yes, there were people I shared DNA with, that’s true. But family? That would require a mutilated definition of the word.

When you’re young, no matter how hard life is, you still believe you could turn it around and save yourself. Truth is, no one can ever be saved if the universe has already offered you to the beasts. Predators come in all different shapes and sizes. Darkness is everywhere and in everyone.

But back to me. How did I get here? I’ve been asking myself that for so long now. It’s hard to steady my mind but I want someone to know my story. It’s hard to recall anything before the darkness and the hauntings. I see an aging rental house a few streets from the water. Food on the table but not much. A family void of love. Empty walls everywhere.

My father was a mechanic, I think. He bounced around jobs mostly. The best jobs were the ones that took him out to sea for long periods of time. The house was quieter. No screaming. Nothing breaking. No constant stench of whiskey and vomit.

My mother waited tables during the day and slept elsewhere at night. I never really knew her. I will always remember her face though. She had a constant scowl and never made eye-contact. Actually, she did look at me once. I had never felt so observed before or since. It was the worst feeling. Worse than all the beatings from my father.

I was eleven when that bastard finally stopped coming home. My mother stopped coming home around that time too. I never found out what happened to my father, but I can’t say I was anything more than morbidly curious about his possible end. Did I care if he was still alive somewhere? No. I wished for the opposite and in all likelihood, that wish was granted. He wasn’t a likable man and only made enemies everywhere he went. My mother was the opposite side of that coin. She made friends everywhere she went. Temporary friends, but she always managed to wrangle up company.

With the drunk gone and my mother appearing in every house except for mine, I spent my remaining adolescence alone. I liked it that way. Unlike my parents, I’ve never wanted to be seen. I never understood people’s fear of loneliness. People have a way of disrupting life, not adding to it. It’s only when it’s silent that I can truly feel alive and free. Silence can’t judge you. Silence expects nothing from you. That’s what makes these shrieking spirits so unbearable. The night used to be my oasis. The time and place when I could quench my thirst for the silencing of people and problems. Now my nights are constant torture. A screeching reminder that the world is filled with pain and sorrow.

Once I was old enough, I worked some odd jobs, paid for some courses and eventually wound up as a property and casualty claims adjuster. Not a glamorous gig. Overlooked and unremarkable. And that’s how I wanted it. That’s how I survived. Living in the house I inherited from my mother, and ultimately collecting dozens of spirits.

No matter what’s happened in my life, I’ve never stopped painting. My first painting was in school. I was 9 years old and finally able to express myself. My depressed art teacher wasn’t supportive but that didn’t matter to me. I only ever needed myself anyway. But once that first stroke of color hit the canvas, I found my life’s true companion — painting.

When my father was gone, I painted every wall, floor tile, and ceiling in the house. With my mother avoiding this place, I was alone. So, I made that house a home. It became an extension of my dreams and desires. This house is like someone cracked open my head and poured it onto every inch of wood, plaster and drywall. Through my art, I found myself. I healed myself. And it was a peaceful existence for a while.

The day my mother came home was the day she finally looked at me. She saw me. She saw all of me. It was a nightmare. She never spoke a single word. She just left in silence. It was the only time silence had hurt me. It was a pain I couldn’t stand. However, that pain left when she passed shortly after that. But it came back with a vengeance. She wasn’t the first spirit in this house but her haunting of this place has been the hardest part of this personal hell. She is silent, but here just like the others. Her presence is loud and clear, though she’s never come upstairs. She’s always remained in the basement. She’s been there for over a decade now.

The other spirits that filled this house over the years have seldom kept their distance from me. It’s odd that when you live a life of solitude, it seems like everything and everyone always wants to interrupt it. It’s as if a quiet life to yourself angers people. It drives them up the walls. There’s always someone who wants to be let into your bubble, your world. I don’t let anyone in. Many have forced their way in but I’ve quickly done away with them. I want nothing but to be alone. The spirits know that. That’s why they stay. That’s why they won’t leave me. They want me to suffer as they suffered.

The noises are getting louder now. They’re almost through the door. Now is the time to end this madness. I’m going to wrap up this final letter that’ll likely land in the hands of the police, like all my others. Like I said earlier, I found my toys on the dark web. It’s also there that I learned how to vanquish these spirits. Unfortunately, it means ending my life as well. Tonight, I shall make a sacrifice and an offering. I shall be the offering and my new toys will be the sacrifice. I never asked their names and I never removed their bindings. Like all the others before them, I will only hear their muffled screams until the beauty of silence falls upon this home. Except this time, I shall go with them. My only regret is that I can’t add their faces to my paintings. A small price to pay to end this nightmare.

As promised in our previous correspondence, I’ve led you to the bodies. The spirits, however, are mine to keep.

Sincerely, The Mystic Maniac

Posted Nov 02, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

4 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.