The Quiet Game

Horror Speculative Suspense

Written in response to: "Set your story in a place your protagonist hasn't visited since childhood." as part of A Trip Down Memory Lane.

Somewhere past the county line the coffee went cold. Biscuit noticed before she did. Every time she lifted the cup, his nose went to work. Corgi judgment. She could feel it on the side of her face.

Rhonda Hollis had inspected four thousand houses, give or take, and crawled under most of them. She liked the work for one reason: houses don't lie. People lie about houses all day long, and the house tells on them anyway.

Today's job sat on the passenger seat in a manila folder. Estate sale, the Prellwitzes, young couple with their first baby due in March. The wife had asked about the school district twice in one phone call, like the first answer might wear out. The buyer's agent had asked for her by name, an outfit two counties over she'd never heard of. She'd said yes anyway.

She almost didn't look at the address. Then she looked.

Forest View Drive.

She drove the next mile with her turn signal on, going nowhere.

At a red light she called the group home, same as every Friday. Kayleigh answered on the second ring, smiling. You could hear it.

"He eat breakfast?"

"Oatmeal, the whole bowl. He drew you a picture of a truck." A pause. "He hummed the whole time. That's his happy."

"Keep it for me, I'm coming Sunday. If they do sandwiches at lunch, tell them diagonal. Straight across he won't touch."

"Diagonal," Kayleigh said, like she was writing it on her hand.

Rhonda told herself she took the job to see if the place had gotten smaller. Old houses shrink while you're not looking. That was the story she was going with. The truth was that she pressed on bruises to see if they still hurt. Always had.

* * *

The water tower still wore the town's name in letters you could read from the highway. The Piggly Wiggly was a Dollar General now.

The street was shorter than she remembered. Houses were gone off the north end, and the lot numbers jumped.

The house was tan. It had been brown.

On the porch rail sat a decorative goose, its paint flaked down to gray wood.

In nineteen years she had never found an exception to the goose rule: any house with a wooden goose on the porch has a wet basement. She'd bet this truck on it.

She sat a minute with her hands at ten and two. Biscuit whined once, low.

"Yeah," she said. "I know."

She worked the outside first, like always. Trip hazards, downspouts dumping at the foundation. Then the storm door, then the kitchen, and her first note of the day.

Gray laminate, gray walls. A barn door on the pantry, hanging off a galvanized track. Somebody with a remodeling show and a home equity line had gone through the place room by room.

The kitchen had been yellow once. There'd been a cut-glass dish of butterscotch on the counter, and you could look all you wanted. Touching it was a different thing.

The electrical panel lived in the garage: Federal Pacific Stab-Lok, original to the house. She put it in the report in bold. Those panels start fires. "Sorry, folks," she said. Nobody heard her. A habit of empty houses.

Back inside, she ran the furnace and listened to it cycle. This room had belonged to The Price Is Right, volume up. Loud, for a woman who ran a quiet house. Mrs. Oakes had watched half the street's kids for cash and smoked Dorals on the back step. She had one rule, and the kids called it the quiet game.

You sat in the hall closet, under the coat hooks, door shut. First one to talk lost. Longest sit got a tally mark in pencil on the back wall, down low. Two columns. R and L.

Mrs. Oakes had said the house liked quiet. That a quiet house listens for whoever's loudest. Rhonda had taken that for the kind of thing old women say.

She'd been nine that summer. Lyle was six. Rhonda lost every round, giggling or shouting that it wasn't fair. Lyle won them all. Her brother could sit in the dark like other kids sat in front of cartoons.

In August he won a round and didn't come out of it. Not all the way. Not ever. The doctors gave it long names. Rhonda filed the summer under sick brother, and the babysitter under weird.

* * *

The meter beeped damp behind the water heater. "Good goose," she said, alone in the dim.

She stood there holding it, and the holding put her mother beside her, Thanksgiving of 2008, three brandy old-fashioneds in: "He's not not-talking, Rhonnie. He's holding something."

Clipboard done, she stood at the bottom of the stairs and did the last thing she did at every job: what's original, what's not.

Everything had been touched. Everything but the hall closet.

Nobody renovates a hall closet.

She was standing in front of it before she decided to walk over.

The smell reached her before the light did.

Wool. And under the wool, faint and wrong, butterscotch. Two families had lived in this house since 1994, and none of their coats or fabric softener had made it into this closet.

The coat hooks were original. Three of them, set at a child's height, the paint worn to shiny metal on the lowest one. The last people here hadn't needed the low hook. Only kids need the low hook.

She got down on one knee and clicked on the Streamlight, as she would to check a baseboard for termite tubes. The beam found the back wall, down low.

Two columns. R and L.

Her column held four marks. She'd have sworn she never won a round in her life. Then she remembered: late July, the week Lyle stayed home with an earache. Four easy marks against nobody. Four was right.

His column did not stop.

It ran down the wall and across the subfloor, then climbed the side wall. Small vertical strokes in groups of five, the handwriting growing up as it went, from a six-year-old's wobble to the flat tired strokes of a grown man. A mark had meant a win, and after that August the marks became days. One a day.

She didn't count them. She didn't have to. She knew roughly how many days it had been since August 1991.

So did the wall.

The last mark was so fresh the graphite came off on her thumb, a gray smudge like ash.

On the floorboards sat a yellow Ticonderoga, its end chewed to splinters. Lyle chewed his pencils that way. Every one he ever owned. Thirty-five years, and this one wasn't even dusty.

"Okay," she said, to the coats. Her voice came out small. "Okay."

Behind her, out in the hall, the furnace hummed on, the only sound in the house. She held on to it.

Her body understood first. The back of her neck went, a prickle like static, and then her stomach.

His body went to Sheboygan, then to the group home in Fond du Lac, but the part of him that was playing had been in this closet for thirty-five years.

Winning.

She is nine. The dark smells like Mrs. Oakes's winter coat. Somebody small is breathing next to her.

Her phone buzzed against her hip.

Kayleigh. Wrong voice. The smile was gone, and something wet and shaking had taken its place.

"Rhonda, he talked. At lunch, in front of everybody. The caseworker's been called already. Thirty-five years, and he just said it."

The floor tilted under her knees, or felt like it.

Rhonda heard herself ask what he said. Level. Nineteen years of bad news had taught her to hold it there.

"Two words." Kayleigh laughed, and it broke in the middle. "He looked up from his sandwich and said, 'Your turn.' Cut diagonal, like you said."

Plates clattered behind Kayleigh's voice.

"What does that mean?" Kayleigh asked. "Is it a game thing?"

"I don't know."

The lie sat in the closet with her, and the house, which had never lied to anybody, heard it.

"He said it at 12:40," Kayleigh said. "I looked at the clock. I wanted it exact, for his file."

Rhonda looked at the smudge of graphite on her thumb.

The last round came up whole, the way drowned things surface, all at once and with edges.

August 1991. The closet dark. Her chest full of a scream with nowhere to go. And Lyle, six years old, leaning close, his whisper hot on her ear.

"Say something, Rhonnie. Then you get to go."

So she did. She said I quit, and the door opened, and she walked out into the light and never came back in. He gave her the loss. He took her turn and kept it.

A quiet house listens for whoever's loudest. Somebody has to be playing.

Otherwise it goes looking.

The furnace clicked off. Through the storm door, Biscuit barked in the truck, each bark a little farther away, and the truck wasn't moving an inch.

She thought about the Prellwitzes and the baby coming in March. The panel nobody would flag in bold. She was sorry. It wasn't going to be enough.

She thought about Lyle in that cafeteria, saying his two words and going back to his sandwich. Back to humming. Done, now. He'd always been fair about turns.

She picked up the pencil and sat down under the coat hooks, knees to her chest, the way you sit when you're nine. She pulled the door shut.

The dark was smaller than she remembered. Funny. Everything else had shrunk too.

She made one mark under the R.

Then she was quiet. She'd always been bad at this game. She'd just never given it a fair try.

Posted Nov 09, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

10 likes 6 comments

November 15, 2026 06:04

The tally marks learning a grown man’s handwriting made thirty-five years feel longer than any ghost could.

Reply

November 10, 2026 09:22

I really enjoyed how you used vivid sensory details, such as the cold coffee, the corgi's "judgment," the butterscotch dish, or the scent of wool and graphite. These small touches made the setting feel real and evoked strong emotions. I also appreciated how you explored complex family bonds, memory, and trauma with subtlety and sensitivity. The relationship between Rhonda and her brother Lyle, and the way their childhood game echoed into adulthood, felt authentic and deeply affecting. The ending, with Rhonda returning to the closet, was especially powerful and moving. Great work!

Reply

Jim LaFleur
November 10, 2026 10:42

Love the way you notice the details. Thank you, Veronika!

Reply

November 10, 2026 12:24

You're welcome, Jim.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
November 10, 2026 07:04

“He gave her the loss.” — that hurt, Jim. Winning had already become horrifying, but finding out why Lyle kept playing made it worse. And the diagonal sandwiches are such a tender detail: she’s been looking after him all these years without knowing he was doing the same for her.

Thank you for sharing. I enjoyed reading it.

Reply

Jim LaFleur
November 10, 2026 07:34

Thank you, Marjolein!

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.