Laila and Erin have bigger problems than the screams coming from behind the wooden door.
“It’s going to take him forever to die,” says Erin, looking down at her watch. The cool wind sweeps over Laila’s face and she shivers. “We should’ve just clobbered him.”
“Like you’re some kind of expert on getting rid of someone,” Laila scoffs. “This is easy. He’s so stupid, it’s believable that he locked himself inside a cabin.”
“What if the snow melts early?” Erin raises an eyebrow. “We can’t leave until— I have to go to work.”
“You work at a library for monks who are currently on a vow of silence or whatever. I think they’ll survive without you.” Laila doesn’t look at her, talking to the door that they’ve let the snow accumulate outside in the past hour or so. They’ve packed it tightly against it, and with the temperature dropping, it shouldn’t take too long.
“First of all, it’s not a vow of silence. It’s their times of silence. Secondly, brother Jonah and I enjoy nodding and waving at each other. He’ll notice if I’m not there.”
Laila almost acquiesces. A witness, even a silent one, is helpful for something like this. When she first did it, she made sure she was seen at a frat party right after and before. No one even noticed she was gone. But just leaving him here seems irresponsible.
“We should’ve timed this better. Timed it so that if he does break out, we’re not sitting ducks and we have something and some way to finish him off. And timed is so that the snow storm will go on for longer,” Erin adds in a scoff.
It wouldn’t work. Laila’s only up here a few more days and then she has to go back to her real life. This was so not what she was imagining when she came up to visit Erin at college for a few days. The screaming is starting to die down a bit, and they can hear every footstep that he paces behind the door. A plea to let him out, but they’re out of sight of the windows. The metal casing was a bonus that was not advertised on AirBnb, but suited their purposes well.
She can’t control the weather. The storm is still going on, and she has about four layers of clothing on just to keep slightly warm enough so she doesn’t die of hyperthermia. Erin’s monk library is a half hour away, but if Laila’s calculations are correct, he should be dead within a half hour. The cabin doesn’t have central heating and they shed his coat and gloves outside, as if he left them out there by accident. Up north, it doesn’t take long for temperatures to get far below any human without heating or insulation can survive for long. She’s grateful for thermals.
Besides, Erin needs to see this through with her. They wouldn’t even be in this situation if it wasn’t for her. Laila thought she was invited for some best friend bonding time during, not because she thought she would help her with something. You accuse someone of murder once and somehow they think you’re some kind of expert.
“Like, if we just clobbered him on the head—”
“How would we explain that, Erin? We had to do something that no one could trace us to,” says Laila, finally turning to face her. A snowflake falls on Laila’s cheek and she brushes it off. “If we clobbered him, he might not have died right away. Neither of us study biology or anatomy, so we wouldn’t know where to hit him. If we poisoned him, it would leave traces. We need to make it look like an accident.”
A thud comes from inside, weaker than before, and Erin startles before turning back to her friend. “We could have at least tried something, like blaming it on someone else.”
“Getting rid of your boyfriend is something I can get behind, but not framing an innocent person. God, Erin, there’re limits. Besides, didn’t they find a body when the snow thawed a few months ago? And some freshman got in trouble for playing a prank? Two murders is going to look like a pattern.” She’s not an expert, but she does have some common sense, which her best friend is currently lacking. “To think I ever thought…” She trails off.
“None of your logic is going to matter if he gets out,” Erin says indignantly. “He’s pounding on the door right now, what if he gets out and kills us?”
“He’s not getting out. His thumps are getting softer by the second. It’s getting colder, and the snow is starting to pick up,” says Laila dryly. Erin’s eyebrow twitches slightly.
“And what if we die in the cold, too?”
“Why did you ask me to help you if all you were going to do was question my methods? Besides, I though you wanted me to come visit you to see me. Not do this.” Laila flails her hand towards the wooden cabin.
All she wanted was some quality time with her best friend. The last few years had been filled with reminiscing rather than raving. They were supposed to something fun and classic, an upgrade from their adventures they had when they were younger. Laila was not supposed to get roped into doing something illegal. Well, at least something not this illegal. Trespassing would’ve been more fun. Or literally anything else.
They should be by the fireplace in her old dorm or some abandoned building that’s meant to collapse on them.
“I did want to see you,” says Erin. “I just also needed help with something.”
“Real nice, Erin.”
“Oh, come off it. It’s not like you haven’t been using my help for things since you got here,” says Erin, rolling her eyes.
“Asking you to introduce me to a guy is not on the same level as trapping a guy to freeze to death,” Laila replies, her cheeks flushing despite the cold air whirling around them. Her breathe is visible with each heave of her lungs, and each word she speaks. All she can think of is being a million miles away from here.
“You asked me to come along on a date with him.”
“I didn’t want you to feel left out!” Laila looks at Erin who has malice or fear in her eyes. “I came here for you.”
Laila doesn’t know when she stopped being able to read her. They barely needed to speak to know what the other was feeling. She can’t remember the last time she asked Erin how she was, it simply wasn’t done. It didn’t need to be done. Distance could never change what they had.
“Or maybe you’ve just never gone out with a guy before.” Erin raises her eyebrows. “Or really talked to one, ever.”
“Maybe it’s because I’ve seen how your relationships have all ended. Case in question.” Laila points to the wooden cabin again.
It looks quite nice in the snow despite the terror happening inside. It is a charming AirBnb, she understands why its owners decided to rent it out. Deep in the woods to truly get away from everyone and everything. They advertised all of its flaws openly on the listing, lack of heating, not a lot of space, but the one thing that is promised is solitude. It looks like something out of a fairytale with its big fireplace (now devoid of firewood) and chimney. Lined with snow on its roof like a gingerbread house.
Erin stiffens in the snow even more. If they’re not careful, his won’t be the only body they find in the snow. “That was uncalled for.”
“Oh really? That, of all things, were uncalled for. Not asking your best friend to help you orchestrate a murder. Because that was completely called for.” Laila rolls her eyes. “You haven’t even told me why you wanted to do this.”
She hadn’t asked on the first day, either. No, the two were trying to enjoy Laila’s vacation up here while they could. Well, Lailia was trying to enjoy it, Erin seemed passively interested in her at best, annoyed at worst. Every conversation was stilted or ended in a disagreement. Laila was approached by some guy at the library, and even that did not spark the old Erin she once knew.
“Maybe you should’ve asked, ever thought about that?”
“I figured you would tell me. You tell me everything,” Laila accuses, and she can hear her words echo. It reminds her of last year when she didn’t tell her about the pregnancy, then the miscarriage a few months later.
“God, Laila, I can’t read your mind.”
“Fine, then why do you want to get rid of him?” Laila gestures once again to the door, where the pounding has severely died down.
Suddenly, Erin’s eyes start to dart from the door to her, and Laila is like a deer in the woods. She shakes away the thought. “It doesn’t— it doesn’t matter, okay? We should just open the door and hit him on the head. I have to get to the library.” She takes a step forward.
“No.” Laila lunges— not much of a lunge, but feels like it in the snow— and grabs Erin’s arm through her puffer coat and three layers beneath. It’s just familiar enough. “He’s almost dead, listen. He’s not pounding, he’s not screaming. It’s getting colder, it’s almost dark. We can leave him in fifteen minutes when he falls asleep.”
“Oh, who died and made you the expert in murder 101?” Erin snaps, jolting away as if she’s been electrocuted.
“You, apparently, when you asked for my help. Since you clearly don’t know the first thing about this! I’m just making it up as I go, and I’m still better than you at it,” says Laila smugly.
“Oh, please, I know what happened at the frat house. That guy who froze to death outside after he drank too much? You clearly have one MO.” Somehow, Erin manages to belittle her even when Laila is the one who’s actually accomplished something.
Laila freezes. “How do you know about that?” she hisses. No one knows about that, and everyone’s better off for him being dead. Well, she is at least. “You can’t prove anything.”
“I thought we told each other everything,” says Erin mockingly. “I looked it up after you accused me of murder. It’s not that hard if you know you.”
Laila’s mind flails for a moment. There is no way anyone should know this. He was a blip, someone that should have never happened. Hooking up with him had been a mistake, and when he kept coming back, she didn’t have a choice.
Maybe he would’ve left her alone eventually. With his track record, he probably would. But he was making fun of her between every breath. She could tell by the way he asked about what she was reading and what she used to do back in high school. By the way he laughed at her.
And now she knows. She knows, and she’s been keeping it in her back pocket like some kind of dirty little secret to bring up to blackmail her into this if she didn’t agree.
She steels herself. “Well, thank God one of us has experience with this. Because if I left you to it, you would have gotten caught already.”
“Laila—”
“No, because I won’t stand here and be insulted and belittled by someone who couldn’t do this without me. Or even have enough guts to even try,” Laila cuts her off. “I mean, come on, you keep—”
“You’re not the only one who’s done it!” Erin blurts out and covers her mouth with a mitten covered hand right afterwards, as if it would muffle the words already spoken.
A muted shout from inside makes both of them jump before Laila looks back at her. “What?”
Erin moves her mitten from her mouth and rubs her hand over her face. She hesitates before, “I’ve done it before, okay? You were— you were right last year. I was even going to tell you, but then you just came in and started accusing me— I got— whatever. I just made up the pregnancy, and—”
“You lied to me, Erin.” Laila takes a step back. Lied isn’t a strong enough word for what Erin did. Yet, part of Laila wants to punch the air— she was right.
But another, louder part of her, is going to be sick. “You— you made me feel like I was crazy! You acted like I was all insane of accusing you of murder, but really—” She cuts herself off this time, putting something together. “Is that why you’re killing Tom?”
This is rich. Erin could’ve done this on her own, but she was just lazy. Worse, she’s setting Laila up to be the fall guy. It would make sense, if this was ever discovered to pin it on her anyway. And now she’s gone through all of this effort to make sure it’s not connected to either of them, when for all she knows, Erin’s left a strand of her hair in the crime scene.
The snow around them distorts Erin’s face in a mask of white and wind. Their footsteps are already covered, and the two of them have to move every so often just so that their marks in the snow don’t fill up while they’re standing there. Laila’s not in her body anymore, but looking from the outside in. If her body freezes in the snow, she might not even realize until it’s too late.
“I have to go.”
“What?”
“I have to go,” Laila repeats. “This isn’t…I’m done.”
Erin, at least, has the decency to look guilty. “Look, Laila. I didn’t— I didn’t want to make you feel crazy. I just, I couldn’t tell anyone, and I— it wasn’t going well, already. I needed something to keep it under wraps. It’s not like you came and told me about what you did either!”
Laila shakes her head. “I would’ve if you had the guts to ask me about it and not kept it in your back pocket to blackmail me into helping you. I’m going back home. I don’t— I don’t know you anymore.” It isn’t just the cold that’s making her numb.
“You can’t.” Erin’s voice shakes just barely. “He’s not— he’s not, you know, dead yet.” A dull thud, barely there, comes from inside.
“I’m sure you can manage on your own,” says Laila, the ice around her permeating her voice. “You have before, and you didn’t need my help then.”
She turns around, the woods around her a maze of white, but she’ll figure it out. She doesn’t need to be here anymore, and she never needed to be in the first place. After everything, after all these years, she can’t imagine a place she wants to be less than Erin’s side when that’s where she was made. Leaving Erin scared and alone has somehow become a goal in her twisted life instead of the enemy.
Maybe she should stay, see it through, and finish it before never seeing her again. Avoiding her when she comes home to visit will be difficult, impossible maybe. It’s not like she’ll never see her again, but if she turns back, Erin will win. This is something that should have brought them together, the lighter and lighter thuds and voice coming from the cabin should have been a reason for celebration, but all Laila can hear is who Erin betrayed her for.
“Wait.” Erin’s voice comes out barely a whisper.
Despite herself, she turns around. Erin looks young, in a too big coat and boots, as if faced with shovelling the entire driveway by herself. Her eyes wide, with snow coating her eyelashes. Laila braces herself for a whirlwind threats and false promises.
“Don’t tell anyone.”
Maybe she’s lost her mind, maybe she lost it a long time ago, so all she does is nod. With one last look at the locked cabin behind her, and her friend covered in snow and memory, Laila leaves.
For good.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.