The Exit Affair

Horror Suspense Thriller

This story contains sensitive content

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the line “I can’t sleep.”" as part of What Lingers.

Content note: This story contains sexual content, hidden cameras and non-consensual recording, implied domestic abuse, and strong language.

Jenni >> John: I can’t sleep

Jenni >> John: u up?

Jenni >> John: u busy?

John sat in the silent dark of his bedroom reading and rereading her messages. The light from his phone screen directly above his face cast uncanny shadows onto his hollow cheeks, jawline, and brow. His phone vibrated softly upon receipt of her next message, startling him back from his torpor. I can’t sleep either, he thought.

Jenni >> John: Keep ignoring me. I’ll find someone else to play with

Jenni << John: I’m up. Why can’t you sleep?

Jenni >> John: Thinking of u

That message was quickly followed by a photo of a woman from the waist down, sitting on the edge of a bed with her hand deep inside her unbuttoned jeans.

Jenni was John’s dirty secret. Strangely, she had reached out to him. John hardly minded, though he was suspicious at first. She had photos and videos of herself going back a few years, and she presumably knew the people tagged in her photos, though John didn’t ask her about them. She told him that he was cute and said they had mutual contacts from college. She just moved to town and was grateful for someone to talk to. John received and replied to messages from Jenni nearly every day over the following week. His mind wandered to her. He checked for her messages at inopportune moments: at work, at red lights, and even late on a Saturday night when he should be asleep.

Jenni << John: I’m not busy. You want to play?

Jenni >> John: Come quick

Jenni >> John: Before I change my mind

Tonight would be their first meeting. John did a few push-ups, showered, applied cologne and deodorant, and brushed his teeth and hair. He took a photo of himself and sent it, payment for what she sent him. John dressed, listening carefully for her response. Checking his phone to be sure, he saw three other missed notifications, but nothing from Jenni. In the corner, a pair of dirty socks lay balled up on the floor. He put his dirty clothes in the laundry basket in the closet. He looked to a shoebox on the floor, then to the smoke detector, air vent and outlet covers nearest the door with distaste before exiting the bedroom.

In the next room, dishes from last night’s dinner sat in the kitchen sink. Pizza boxes and takeout bags sat stacked atop or stuffed into or around the already-full trash bin. The mess in the kitchen made that room look small, in contrast to the rest of the apartment, which was bigger than he needed, and looked even bigger due to a lack of furniture. What little furniture populated the apartment was mostly flat-pack. I’ll get the trash out tomorrow, John thought.

John grabbed his keys from the hook just above the one framed photo in his apartment, a picture of John and his girlfriend Lauren shivering together as they rode a ski lift. John kissed Lauren’s cheek at just the right moment to catch her genuinely surprised. John insisted on framing that moment when he took her breath away. That trip was just before she moved in with me, he recalled. John would sometimes, but less often lately, look at that picture on his way in or out the door and remember the moment fondly. Tonight, however, John was not stirred by his memories. Instead, he simply turned off the lights and set out.

John had just begun driving when a car behind him turned on its brights. This asshole is trying to blind me, he thought. A minute later, John’s phone screen lit up, barely visible. He considered pulling over, thinking, or hoping, that Jenni enjoyed the picture. He asked his phone to read his notifications. A soulless voice read out, “From Lauren Gee Eff.”

Lauren (GF) >> John: Just got to mom’s. Miss you so much!!

John wondered if Jenni had invited someone else over without telling him.

The tailing vehicle illuminated John’s rearview mirror and dashboard. After five minutes, John decided to turn left at the next light, then right two corners down. The lights stayed on him. John kept driving until he found a gas station. When he turned in, the lights continued on. John breathed a sigh of relief.

Jenni << John: Want anything from the gas station?

John was almost nervous waiting for her response.

John went through the motions at the pump and went inside. He grabbed an energy drink and a bottle of water, then stood in front of the drinks, turned around and thought about his decision again. Deciding that to get two of everything would be more gentlemanly, John grabbed another of each drink, and four power bars and two chicken sandwiches.

John set everything on the counter, feeling embarrassed by how long it had taken him to shop. At the checkout, John added a red gas station rose to his other selections. At this, the attendant gave John a strange look. As the attendant rang him up, John briefly read testimonials on the all-natural male energy supplements.

“Anything else?” asked the attendant.

“Yeah, um,” John looked behind him to see how crowded the store was, as though he would not make the purchase if others in the store could hear what he said next. “A box of condoms.”

“Alright. Anything else?” The attendant seemed even more nonplussed by John’s choice in gas station products, but John read on his face that under no circumstances would he enjoy having a conversation to clear up his confusion. Noticing the attendant’s expression, John could do nothing else but awkwardly stare down, pay for his items and leave. John checked his phone again on the way to his car. Still nothing from Jenni.

John had almost returned to familiar streets when, as if to bear out his paranoia, the same bright lights flashed behind him. The two cars travelled together for another five minutes. John paid more attention to the blinding light in his rearview mirror than anything ahead of him.

Left at the light.

Through this light and the next.

Right, and right again.

Roll through the stop.

GET OFF MY ASS! John shouted in his head at the other driver. Thoughts raced through John’s mind, intensified by the driver behind him. His thoughts had been harder to contain or quiet since he found the cameras. He couldn’t sleep.

Just go home. She won’t miss you. She doesn’t even know you. She already invited someone else over.

No. You’re in. She was joking. She’s not like that.

She’s only five minutes away now. If you don’t go now, you never will. You’ll be trapped, if you aren’t already.

Just before his destination, John turned left while the lights behind him continued straight.

John parked his car. Calm down, he thought. He sent off one more message to Jenni as he crossed the parking lot and climbed the stairs to her apartment.

Jenni << John: Still up for some fun?

John gave the door three soft, almost imperceptible knocks. While he waited, he noticed that the video doorbell installed at this apartment was the same as one he had just ordered. To his surprise, a woman in her early thirties wearing a thick gray cloth bathrobe and an expression of unmasked irritation answered the door. She was recovering from a black eye and might’ve had a broken nose years ago. She looked like she could be Jenni’s older sister or cousin.

“Yes?” The woman had no patience for John, or much else at eleven thirty on Saturday night. She looked John up and down through a cracked door. John heard crying inside. “This had better be good, asshole. Well, what is it? Tom, can you get Sarah back down? I’ll be just a minute.” John heard a grunt from inside.

Sweat rushed to his palms and brow as he stuttered out a response, “I must have the wrong apartment. Sorry to bother you.” The door slammed before John finished his meager apology.

John meekly returned to his car, drove to a nearby dumpster and threw his gas station purchases inside. On his drive back, John imagined a woman who he had never met, whose voice he had never heard, softly say his name just once, somewhere no one was watching him. If he had that, John dreamed he might finally sleep. No lights followed him home.

The light was on when John returned to his apartment. The dishes were drying and the trash was gone. In the bedroom, Lauren was packing her things into an empty overnight bag.

“You’re home,” John said. Silence suffused the apartment. Exhausted, John provided the smallest possible nutriment to the conversation. “Thanks for cleaning up. Did you forget something?”

“We need to talk,” replied Lauren. She continued to pack. She did not look at John.

Usually that phrase meant a new chore or task or admonition, but John was especially tired tonight, and the meaning of her words had not yet reached him. “I thought you were at your mom’s,” said John.

Lauren turned her phone around, revealing a twenty-three-year-old in big sunglasses, a floppy sun hat and a revealing bathing suit, sitting in a beach chair and smiling brightly. Jenni.

“What is this?” John waited for an accusation. An argument. An explanation. An apology. Anything. Instead Lauren gently slid her phone across the combination desk and chest of drawers, inviting John to confirm. John picked her phone up reflexively when it was offered to him. Lauren returned to her task.

“You’re checked out, John,” said Lauren. “Look at the kitchen. No, it’s not about the kitchen. We don’t talk anymore. Can you really say this is working?” Lauren continued packing as she spoke. John could not tell which task she prioritized.

“Of course not, Lauren.” John was holding back tears. He unclenched his grip, her phone still in his hand, unsure of when he had made a fist. The room felt hotter than it should, almost hotter than it ever had. The air in the room was too heavy and thick to breathe. John moved to sit on the edge of the bed. He was alone, and had been for a long time, and felt that loneliness all at once.

Why? It was all he could think about. His mind was stuck like some complex clockwork contraption dependent on a single faulty gear, resetting and retrying endlessly.

“No. No, you’re right. This isn’t working. I know that. I’ve known for a while. We’re just treading water. But what was the point of this?”

“Of Jenni?” Lauren asked rhetorically. “I wanted to know if you were still in this relationship, or if you were just waiting for me to get fed up and leave you. I love you, John. But we’re not okay.”

More silence.

“We need to talk about the camera,” John said. He cleared his throat. “Cameras. I never wanted to. Ask you. Talk about it. I wanted to ignore it. I thought you did too. That first one I found, in the smoke detector. I left that first one out for us to talk about when I got home from work, but it was already gone.”

“You’re talking like I put it there,” Lauren said. “I was just as shocked as you were.”

“It’s the only thing that makes sense to me! You’re Jenni, right? Then you already know. I already told you. You put it there.”

“No. No, John. That’s not right. I asked you to change the battery because it started beeping! I don’t know how you can ignore things like that. Dishes sit in the sink. The trash piles up and over itself. You let the laundry pile up the same way. You don’t talk to me…” her voice trailed off. John briefly imagined Lauren as she was in that picture they took when he loved her.

Lauren moved to the edge of the bed and attempted to take John’s hand. They both sat uncomfortably in the bedroom and absorbed the silence they had created.

7 days ago

Jenni >> John: Professor Woodhull said to look you up if I ever moved here. He mentioned another fav of his too. Lauren? u know her

Jenni << John: Yeah, actually. We’re together.

Jenni >> John: is it serious

Jenni << John: It’s complicated.

Jenni >> John: wdym

Jenni << John: I keep hoping she’ll end it so I don’t have to.

5 days ago

Jenni << John: Can I tell you something really fucked up?

Jenni >> John: tell me

Jenni << John: I found a camera in my smoke detector last month.

Jenni >> John: what did u do

Jenni << John: Took a photo. Left it on the desk and went to work. I figured if she saw it, we’d talk about it. When I got home it was gone. I didn’t know how to bring it up after that.

Jenni << John: I bought all this stuff to check for more. Lens finders, RF detectors. Found one in the bathroom vent. One behind the outlet cover by the bed. One was in our bedroom wall, camouflaged to match the wallpaper. The last one was in the living room overhead light. We hardly use that space, but with the doors open that camera can see everything except the bathroom.

Jenni << John: I can’t sleep there. I got a motel four nights last month. She probably thinks I’m cheating.

Jenni << John: The worst part is you’re supposed to be able to trust your partner, right?

Jenni << John: So why can’t I talk to her about this?

Jenni << John: You must think I’m crazy.

Jenni << John: I get if this is too much.

4 days ago

Jenni >> John: ur not too much babe

Jenni >> John: and ur not crazy. Get out of there!

Jenni << John: Thanks. Means a lot.

Jenni >> John: have u told the landlord?

Jenni >> John: whoa babe do u think Lauren is filming u? u should probably talk to her

Jenni << John: Who else could it be? This is on loop nonstop in my head. The cameras are newer. Should I change the locks? I ordered a doorbell cam, but I doubt I’ll catch anything.

3 days ago

Jenni >> John: I wanna drink 2nite. Where’s a safe place? Show me sumthing only the locals know. u can join if u want

“Look at the bottom of this drawer, John. I did the same thing you did. I even hired professionals,” Lauren said. John was still reading the conversation from her phone. He could pull it up himself, but he could tell that she wanted her phone back. Because she wanted it, he could not let go. He wanted answers first.

He checked her recent apps and saw a video doorbell app. When he opened it, he saw that she was logged in as Tom. He knew that view. He had been there an hour ago. John checked for activity around eleven thirty. He saw the door shut in his face.

“Who is Tom?” John asked. He studied her face for a reaction.

“I don’t think I know anyone named Tom. Why, who are you talking about?” Lauren replied. John was certain that she regretted handing over the phone. She watched John the way that John watched for messages from Jenni.

John heard Lauren out. She had every accusation, argument, and answer ready, every excuse. She would even pretend to apologize. She swore it wasn’t her fault. She was as much a victim as John was. She was a sleepwalker when she was younger and needed the cameras. The cameras made her feel safe. She felt closer to John when she could check in on him. She wanted to see him climb on top of her and take her like an animal, but she didn’t know how to ask. John’s favorite excuse: she knew he might not give her what she wanted, and she would rather have forgiveness than permission. Of everything she said, this he believed was closest to the truth. When John refused to listen to anything else, she said that Tom was her uncle. She cried while talking about Tom, as John had never seen. Her crying felt, if not more real, at least more vulnerable than anything she shared with John that night. John wanted to care, but he no longer believed anything she said. If she had told him that the sun would rise again in the morning, he would have a good enough reason to doubt it. 

Nevertheless he had loved her once not so long ago. He cradled her in his arms at the foot of their bed. She cried violently into him. She blew her nose into his shirt. He rocked her back and forth with a gentle care that would be gone by morning.

In the end none of it mattered. John could not do what he always did. He refused to acquiesce to her whims. If he lived that way he would never sleep again. Her bright light would have kept him blind and trapped and looking only backward.

Two months later, before his lease was up, John moved out of his apartment. Lauren was already gone. He could never be certain whether he was being recorded there. John had not seen Lauren since she left. He was hopeful that she had not seen him either. He missed her, especially as he remembered her in the snow, but that relationship was over. He wouldn’t go back. He couldn’t.

Jenni << John: I can’t sleep.

Posted Nov 06, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 2 comments

Yunhan Hsiao
November 13, 2026 03:28

This is a clever and original idea for a thriller. It's a good slow burn of paranoia and emotional exhaustion, and I can feel how unsettling and suffocating the atmosphere is throughout the piece. Keep going!

Reply

Matthew Stacks
November 13, 2026 14:39

That’s so kind of you to say. Thank you. This is my first attempt. I finished the story with less than a day to edit and life got in the way. I am proud of myself for getting this done, and at the same time I can’t read it without thinking about the editing I wish I could have done. It should be about 30% shorter, and I wish I could have put in the snow motif that I had planned. Working on such a tight turnaround deadline (imo) really helped me to exercise that muscle and fight the perfectionist mentality.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.