Between the Great Divide and the Shore: A Shallow Bay Tale

Drama Fiction Horror

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

Written in response to: "Write a story that takes place between midnight and dawn." as part of A Fright to Remember.

Davey's spent his whole life in Shallow Bay. He knows the rules, knows how dangerous it is to not follow them and he'd foolishly thought that if he devoted himself to every rule that he could prevent this. Now...now he's someplace he hoped- he prayed -that he would never be.

He followed every rule, every single one. He wrote his name on his shoes, he left candle burning in the swamp, he bleed upon the feral twisted willow on his family's land and all because he was an Elrick, born of the blood of a family of monsters...he now had a harrowing choice to make.

Hope stands before him, a foggy nothingness behind her, The Great Divide those of them in Shallow Bay called it, and behind himself, the shore.

"I will have you one way or the other." Hope tells him. He's known Hope all his life too. Hope had groomed him through every ritual, every rule; she made sure he did them perfectly and Davey trusted her. Davey falls to his knees.

"I loved you."

"And I must admit," Hope begins, her usual warm and soft and delicate facade falling away to the horrifying witch that everyone always told him Hope Larson was. Davey never believed them

"I trusted you. I defended you." He's heartbroken. "You did this just to kill me?"

"Shallow Bay is mine by blood, my blood that feeds the Red Cold River that holds our dead. My body that feeds the lands. You ancestors slaughtered my family for that purpose. To feed the land they robbed from my dying, distraught father. 'When every Elrick is dead, the land will flourish once again.'. That was the promise I made, the one I keep." Hope steps closer to him, her eyes glowing that sickening icy blue, soft warm sunkissed skin now cold and gray and deathly, lips corpse blue. "And while you have been refreshingly, the least like your bloodline...you are still the last Elrick. And I have a promise to fulfill." Hope tells him, kneeling before Davey in the Shallows of the swampy island that Shallow Bay is made of. "But for you...I will give you the choice."

"How can you call this a choice?" Hope's soft smile drops. That cold face returns.

"Your dear little friend Marshall put my land in danger with his stunt. You helped him."

"I didn't know that's what he was doing." Davey sobs. "Please! Please don't hurt him. He and Hattie...They have a baby on the way. Hope please!"

"Hush." Davey silence himself and stares up at her.

"I will give you two choices. You can decide." Hope holds up one hand, a path clearing through the fog. "Come with me, and Marshall is spared. His plan fails but he will survive so long as he is outside my land. No harm will come to him or his child ever." Hope points back behind him towards the shore. Davey glances behind him. "Return and I will take Marshall, his bride and his child in your stead. But you will have your precious Trent and you will never be able to leave Shallow Bay."

"I'll leave it any way." Davey mumbles. His father was right. Davey would die here. He owed Shallow Bay a debt now and it was time to pay it. "Hope, please."

"I said please too." Hope's voice is cold, dark, watery. "When the first David Elrick forced himself on me. When he drowned me. When I came back to my land, land my father toiled and made frutiful for my mother who came from nothing. When he had me tried and burned at the stake. I said please. I begged for my life." Hope grabs his jaw roughly, harshly, and holds him close to her rotting flesh. Claws digging into his skin. "I do like you, Davey. You were the best of them...but I swore I would end your line and one way or another...I will have you. One way or another." Davey stares at her in horror. She smiles. "You have until dawn to decide. Choose wisely. And this time...try not to caught."

And with a snap of her fingers, Davey is alive and he's standing in the center of the town square again, after his fight with Marshall. Before him is the way home, the way to Trent and everything he's ever wanted, and behind, Davey here's the water thrashing in the way it always does before a storm. Davey trembles, he loves Trent, gave himself to Trent, his body, his soul, his life, his heart...but he has to make the right choice here. He can either ruin Shallow Bay or he fix this.

"Godamnit...Marsh! Marshall!!" Davey screams turning and running after his best friend. It's midnight now. He has until dawn to make this right. Only four and a half hours. Dawn always crested at 4:30 in Shallow Bay. The moment that Captain Josiah Larson met the beautiful siren who would refuse to devour his soul in the name of true love. Davey could choose the same love or he could chose the land and that was the choice Josiah had to make and Hope, the daughter that was given the land made from love, watched her father choose his love over what made the home that Hope worshiped. None of this was right, none of this was fair but Hope didn't care. Hope Larson cared for only one thing and it was the land, the water, the legacy of Shallow Bay. Land laid just for, land promised to her, land that had always fed off her because Josiah and Serena Larson created her from the sea foam and mud of the shoreline and Hope simple was the land. She baited Davey since the day he was born, groomed him to be as connected as she was.

Because Shallow Bay was dying and without a fresh new connection, one that could bridge the gap between what Hope wanted and what needed to be carried out from her own vowed curse....it would disappear and Hope just couldn't let that happen.

So Hope did what she always did, she choose her land. Every ghost or legend in Shallow Bay, every lost soul that had bled into her land belonged to her...but Davey had been born into it.

David Beauregard Elrick XIII had been born into the same mud, the same sea foam, the same curse and Hope had found the answer to a problem that was only ever hers and Davey let her have it because how was he supposed to know any different? The version of Hope that Davey knew was nothing like the one everyone always tried to warn him about.

He doesn't see the ghosts in Blood Alley.

"Is Davey going to save us?" Calico-Tracy asks, petting one of her little devil cats.

"I think he might." Jasper Gordon tells her, patting Calico-Tracy's blood covered head between her messy pigtails.

"Does that mean we can finally go to the end of The Great Divide?" Mahalia Jones asks, her body forever twisted from the torture she went though.

"God willing." Zephyr Callahan whispers from his bloody lips.

"Marshall!!" Davey shouts again, his voice breaking with emotion because he wanted to turn and run and find Trent and find a way to leave this Hellish swampy island that he's lived on all his life, that his family has been stuck on for thirteen generations...but he knows for damn sure that the best way he can keep Trent Lockwood, the boy he loves so much that his heart hurts, is to run after Marshall and choose the land.

God willing, Hope lets him see Trent one last time before he dies for good.

Posted Oct 26, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.