Mixup

0 likes 0 comments

Fiction

Written in response to: "Include the line “I thought you were dead” or “We buried you” in your story." as part of A Fright to Remember.

     Mark Price and the other Deltas who had attended the funeral got back to the fraternity house at the edge of campus just in time for the evening’s keg party to begin. This party had been scheduled for weeks, so most of the brothers fell in line and voted to have the event as scheduled even though one of their own, freshman pledge Byron “Chip” Lattimore, was to be buried earlier in the day. As chapter president, Mark did his duty and attended the funeral. He also voted to have the party proceed as scheduled, not seeing anything inappropriate about a bit of festivity on the same day a pledge began a dirt nap of his own dumb choosing. Besides, the football team was clear across country in California for an evening road game, and Mark figured the members needed to blow off some steam and have what fun they could crowded around the various wide-screen TVs in the house that would live-stream the game at eight o’clock.

     By kickoff, Mark and most of the other Deltas were already drunk. Most of the guys’ dates were drunk, too, as was the whole pledge class of the sorority housed across the street. They’d all come over in sundresses and barefooted (their uniform look for the night), ready to party, flirt, and watch the guys watch football and cheer with them on cue when some player did something great enough to make the Deltas leap up, spill beer and mixed drinks on themselves, knock over the odd piece of furniture, and roar.

     Mark sat on the big, overstuffed chair in the main living room, holding court in a bit of a stupor as pledges offered to refill his drink and a steady stream of sorority girls perched on the arms of the chair to greet him. One of the sorority girls—Mark thought she was Sarah or Sondra or something like that—was offering him condolences on the loss of a member, lightly rubbing the back of his neck.

     “I’m surprised you guys threw this party tonight,” warbled Sarah-Sondra-Something. “I mean, if we’d had a pledge die, I’m pretty sure our whole sorority would’ve, like, sat around crying on funeral day.”

     Mark shook his head, saying, “I mean no disrespect to Chip Lattimore in keeping to our party schedule. The kid was just a pledge, so it’s not as if he had a lot of strong ties formed yet in the fraternity. His car crash was his own stupid fault, really. No one forced him to drink so much at last Saturday’s party. No one made him get behind the wheel at two in the morning to head home to his apartment. Honestly, I don’t even remember him being here last Saturday. Some of us went to late breakfast Sunday morning, but no one mentioned Chip at all. We heard about his car crash later that day.”

     “I heard all your pledges were there last Saturday. I heard the Delta pledge master had them practically naked in the backyard, drinking a shot after reciting each line of the pledge oath,” murmured Sarah-Sondra-Something, still lightly stroking Mark’s neck.

     Mark shook his head harder, turning his head to argue but finding no one sitting on the chair’s arm. In fact, at that moment the entire room seemed to slog down into an extremely slow-motion, half-lit dream, snatches of conversation and laughter fading in and out, the opening kickoff frozen on the TV screen with the football in midair at the top of its arc. Mark looked around dazedly, wondering if he was just way drunker than usual.

     “She’s right, y’know,” said a voice close to Mark’s ear. Mark turned his head and stared dumbstruck into the face of none other than Chip Lattimore.

     Chip had a little grin tugging at the corner of his mouth and looked clear-eyed. “We pledges were all doing that last Saturday night. Some of the brothers popped us with towels while we recited the oath. Not cool when ya have no pants or underwear on, bro.”

     Mark stood up and stammered, “I…I thought you were dead. No, you are dead. I went to your funeral just today. What in the world…how—”

     Chip furrowed his brow, set a hand on Mark’s shoulder, and said in a concerned tone, “Mark, what’re you talking about? My funeral wasn’t today.”

     “Mark, dear, I think maybe you’re confused.” This from Mark’s mother who, to his amazement, was now standing by him. “You’re entitled to a bit of a mixup, though. Today was a rough day for you.”

     “Mom, when did you get here? Is Dad with you?” Mark babbled, now thoroughly confused. “What’s happening?”

     “Nothing’s happening now, buddy,” assured Chip, clapping Mark on the back. “Everything’s all back to usual, y’know? I mean, look around, check it out. The gang’s all here, I see weed smoke drifting down the staircase, our team’s gearing up to get whupped. Have another drink and let’s enjoy this.”

     Mark shut his eyes tightly for a few seconds and then hissed, “No, nothing’s right, you idiot. You’re dead. You’re not here. This is all…crazy.” Mark looked around the room and saw Chip was right; everything did look like a typical keg party at the ol’ Delta house, even if everything was still oddly muted and flowing slowly as if through thick muck. Then Mark noticed the chair he had been sitting in. This centrally located chair was the honored spot for the chapter president, as everyone knew, but what Mark now saw was that he couldn’t have been sitting in it, for a big wreath with black ribbons on it was placed in the chair.

     “Wait,” mumbled Mark, pointing to the wreath. “When did this get here? What’s happened?”

     Mark’s mother wrapped her arm around his shoulders, softly saying, “Now Mark, you need to remember, dear. Chip here was buried yesterday, not today. Your father and I went to the funeral and paid our respects to Chip’s parents. Then we flew back here last night for today’s funeral. By the way, Chip’s parents understand you were only trying to help by offering to drive him home last Sunday morning. In hindsight, we all know neither one of you was in any kind of condition to be driving. With you being a Delta legacy, I think your father is taking it especially hard. He lived in this house, too, you know, back when it was pretty new. They had a lot of nice fraternity parties like this one back then. He understands, and I’m trying to as best I can.”

     Mark stared back and forth between his mother and Chip, the beginnings of images and events starting to settle into his memory, false memories fading away.

     “What funeral today, Mom? Whose?”

     Mark’s mother sighed and looked at him with pained compassion, saying, “Oh, Mark, Chip wasn’t buried today. We buried you.”

Posted Oct 24, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.