Dear Carlotta,
It’s been a while since I last saw you. What grade were we in? Second grade? I remember how you loved sugarcoating your words and actions, but honestly, I'd rather hear your sour side. Reason? Cause, it’s the truth.
You seemed more mature than the rest of us. I wonder what saved you from being called a ‘teacher’s pet.’ Your intelligence helped you rise and earn approval, but you don't know how your shadow overshadowed everyone else’s gifts and success. Your behavior overshadowed what the teachers could see in me. I don’t know if you ever knew, but she saw me as a kid with no future success. You have no idea where I am today, and to be honest with you, I had no idea I would be here either.
Were you afraid back then? If so, what was it? I know you didn’t like me for some reason. But I have a little confession to make: I was no fan of yours either.
Oh, dear Carlotta, you have no idea. I hope you are doing well now.
Dear Carlotta,
How much have we grown? How old are you now? I know I was 12. You are an extraordinary, difficult, and mysterious person. You introduced me to leadership and backstabbing. Let’s see if I can refresh your memory: are you still friends with Keke, Brandi, and the other two? You would be the leader, and it all had to go your way. Lesha would tell me things about you, and I was just being honest with my responses. Although, with everything, I knew there were some things you wouldn’t want anyone to know, especially the things you would say behind your ‘friends’ backs. It's funny how there were moments I heard you say some things about your ‘girls,’ and somehow, you got away with everything, and throughout the school year, you girls were still close. Looking back now, your complex picture book of reflection was more complex to me than the designs on a kaleidoscope.
You had such a way of expressing yourself with your actions. One day you were nice and friendly, but the next day, you were the opposite. There was a point where I thought we could be friends, but when I found out who you really were, I felt so backstabbed because you were the one who told others about my clothes, how I didn’t have style, and made others make fun of me for you. You made me blame them for being bullies when the worst of all of them was you. What should I consider you? Just having you in my memory, I consider you a hypocrite. A hypocritical person who had something to say about others but was not happy to hear what others had to say about you. We both know that the “look in the mirror” phrase was so common, but I totally regret not telling you when we were both in the same environment.
Oh, poor Carlotta, if only you knew the pain you caused with your influence. Why did you hate me so much? I tried to stay out of your way, but you seemed to want to find something to make me look bad in front of everyone in the class. What’s the point of showing off a trend when it won’t last for a few months?
To this day, I just keep wondering how you're holding up. I wouldn’t be surprised if I found out you kept going with your schemes and getting away with them.
You took advantage of my lack of confidence, but just so you know, I am here. I’m alive, which is why I am writing you this descriptive letter.
Poor, sweet Carlotta, I hope you see yourself now, and as for me, I am glad that your humiliations and backstabbing haven’t influenced me.
Dear Carlotta,
How much have we grown? We went from being children to becoming women, but I can see that we both have different paths, and your name just haunts me. Just remember seeing you, including the makeup, you straighten blond hair and your expensive clothing would for sure continue to be your trademark. I cared less about being your friend and joining your little club or circle of friends. I only said hi to you because I was taught good manners. I found out about the things you did in the past and also how you were so loved by the other half of the class, but I came up with conclusions of my own. All of which led me to believe in your past victims over your friends and admirers
I cared less for your fame and luxurious belongings, like your car with your name on the license plate, Carlotta, if that is even your real name. I also cared less if you were the newsflash of the school. Although the things you got yourself into were nothing more than just scandalous.
Poor Jeremy, he deserved better. He was such a good kid, and he did not need to change a thing to just look like a cool boyfriend. What have you done to him? You took advantage of him not once, but 3 times. Poor Kayla, I don’t think she wants to hang out with you anymore now that you are entangled with her ex. They were the perfect couple, but here’s a question for you: did you have something to do with their breakup? Are you happy? What more can you ask for?
Why did I one day catch you trying to have a peek at my locker? All I had were books and stethoscopes. Why were you staring at my snow boots? Not like they were anything you would wear. Of course, you did bring those white boots that seem a lot nicer; I must admit. Jokes on you; I only wore mine when the snow was too thick.
You had such a nice haircut. The big difference was that my hair would curl when I did it, while yours stayed straight. It suits you just fine.
Dear Carlotta,
Poor dear sweet, delusional, insecure Carlotta. You never seemed to learn what words and actions can do to you. You would find a way to make me feel less; you would call me names behind my back, and the things you thought of me did reach me somehow. I could see if you wanted me around or not. Here is what I think: it was never up to you where I was or who I was with. Have you ever wondered why I am still here?
Your behavior has made me stronger; it made me more secure in myself, and it helped me be a leader, not a follower. Wear flowers in your hair and keep making or ‘inspiring’ your group of friends to wear them, as well as the hair buns; keep talking in secrecy and try to show off, looking like innocent little girls when many know your true colors. I will keep my headbands and hats because they are my style, and I will continue to be me, with no shame.
Did you ever think before speaking? Have you ever considered good manners, like it’s not nice to stare?
I never needed to be your friend. I never wanted it. I didn’t need you to agree with my point of view regarding our surroundings; I just wanted your respect. Respect. Something you never gave me. Don’t you think we are too old to be childish? You tell me. Are you happy? How do you treat your husband?
Dear Carlotta,
I hope you are not who I know.
I was raised not to hold a grudge.
I am willing to talk.
I am willing to listen.
My arms are open whenever we meet again.
Yours truly,
Mariliz
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
I wrote this story a long time ago. I was in college, reflecting on my life and all I've been through. The events that happened in my life are not limited to just what was surrounding me but also to who was involved.
This individual, or individuals, had an effect on me at the time, but also has a current effect on how I am now and my point of view on things. After sharing this story in my Creative Nonfiction course I took in college, I decided to share this already written story, and my peers had positive things to say about the content and its power. Even my teacher had a positive view of it, which made me even more proud of it.
I hope that when I share it here on this platform, it causes the same effect and readers can identify with the main character since I know that we all have had Carlottas in our lives.
Reply