That’s Not What I Meant

African American American Bedtime

Written in response to: "Include the words “That’s not what I meant” or “That went sideways” in your story. " as part of The Tools of Creation with Angela Yuriko Smith.

“I’m okay.”

That’s what I said.

But that’s not what I meant.

I said it out of habit.

Out of convenience.

Out of not wanting to explain something I didn’t even fully understand myself.

And the crazy part is—

no one questioned it.

No one stopped and asked if it was true.

Because it sounded believable.

It sounded complete.

Like something that didn’t need a follow-up.

And that’s the problem with words.

Sometimes they say just enough to end a conversation—

but not enough to tell the truth.

“I’m fine.”

That one came easy too.

It rolled off my tongue without effort.

Like I had practiced it.

Like I had trained myself to respond that way before anyone even had a chance to ask deeper questions.

But I wasn’t fine.

Not really.

I just didn’t know how to say what I actually felt.

Or maybe…

I didn’t feel safe saying it.

So I filled the space with words that sounded right—

but meant nothing.

And the more I did it—

the more those words started to replace the truth.

Until one day—

I realized I couldn’t even tell the difference anymore.

Between what I was saying…

and what I actually meant.

That realization hit me harder than I expected.

Because it meant I wasn’t just being quiet—

I was rewriting my own reality.

Convincing myself that things were okay when they weren’t.

That things didn’t matter when they did.

That I didn’t need anything—

when I clearly did.

And every time I said the wrong thing—

it created distance.

Between me and the truth.

Between me and how I actually felt.

Between me and anyone who could have understood—

if I had just said it differently.

But I didn’t.

Because the truth is harder.

It takes more effort.

More vulnerability.

More risk.

And I wasn’t always ready for that.

So I settled for easier words.

Safer words.

Words that didn’t require anything from me—

or from anyone else.

Until one day—

I said it again.

“I’m okay.”

And something in me paused.

Because for once—

I heard it differently.

Not as a response.

But as a pattern.

And I realized how many times I had used those same words—

in moments where I needed something completely different.

And I couldn’t ignore it anymore.

So I stopped.

Took a breath.

And said what I actually meant.

“I’m not okay.”

It felt unfamiliar.

Uncomfortable.

Like I was stepping into something I hadn’t fully practiced yet.

But it also felt…

honest.

And that honesty created space.

Not just in the conversation—

but in me.

Because for the first time in a long time—

I wasn’t hiding behind something that sounded right.

I was standing in something that was real.

And maybe that’s what I needed.

Not better words.

Just truer ones.

Because saying the wrong thing over and over again—

doesn’t protect you.

It just delays the moment you finally have to say what you meant all along.“I’m okay.”

That’s what I said.

But that’s not what I meant.

I said it out of habit.

Out of convenience.

Out of not wanting to explain something I didn’t even fully understand myself.

And the crazy part is—

no one questioned it.

No one stopped and asked if it was true.

Because it sounded believable.

It sounded complete.

Like something that didn’t need a follow-up.

And that’s the problem with words.

Sometimes they say just enough to end a conversation—

but not enough to tell the truth.

“I’m fine.”

That one came easy too.

It rolled off my tongue without effort.

Like I had practiced it.

Like I had trained myself to respond that way before anyone even had a chance to ask deeper questions.

But I wasn’t fine.

Not really.

I just didn’t know how to say what I actually felt.

Or maybe…

I didn’t feel safe saying it.

So I filled the space with words that sounded right—

but meant nothing.

And the more I did it—

the more those words started to replace the truth.

Until one day—

I realized I couldn’t even tell the difference anymore.

Between what I was saying…

and what I actually meant.

That realization hit me harder than I expected.

Because it meant I wasn’t just being quiet—

I was rewriting my own reality.

Convincing myself that things were okay when they weren’t.

That things didn’t matter when they did.

That I didn’t need anything—

when I clearly did.

And every time I said the wrong thing—

it created distance.

Between me and the truth.

Between me and how I actually felt.

Between me and anyone who could have understood—

if I had just said it differently.

But I didn’t.

Because the truth is harder.

It takes more effort.

More vulnerability.

More risk.

And I wasn’t always ready for that.

So I settled for easier words.

Safer words.

Words that didn’t require anything from me—

or from anyone else.

Until one day—

I said it again.

“I’m okay.”

And something in me paused.

Because for once—

I heard it differently.

Not as a response.

But as a pattern.

And I realized how many times I had used those same words—

in moments where I needed something completely different.

And I couldn’t ignore it anymore.

So I stopped.

Took a breath.

And said what I actually meant.

“I’m not okay.”

It felt unfamiliar.

Uncomfortable.

Like I was stepping into something I hadn’t fully practiced yet.

But it also felt…

honest.

And that honesty created space.

Not just in the conversation—

but in me.

Because for the first time in a long time—

I wasn’t hiding behind something that sounded right.

I was standing in something that was real.

And maybe that’s what I needed.

Not better words.

Just truer ones.

Because saying the wrong thing over and over again—

doesn’t protect you.

It just delays the moment you finally have to say what you meant all along.“I’m okay.”

That’s what I said.

But that’s not what I meant.

I said it out of habit.

Out of convenience.

Out of not wanting to explain something I didn’t even fully understand myself.

And the crazy part is—

no one questioned it.

No one stopped and asked if it was true.

Because it sounded believable.

It sounded complete.

Like something that didn’t need a follow-up.

And that’s the problem with words.

Sometimes they say just enough to end a conversation—

but not enough to tell the truth.

“I’m fine.”

That one came easy too.

It rolled off my tongue without effort.

Like I had practiced it.

Like I had trained myself to respond that way before anyone even had a chance to ask deeper questions.

But I wasn’t fine.

Not really.

I just didn’t know how to say what I actually felt.

Or maybe…

I didn’t feel safe saying it.

So I filled the space with words that sounded right—

but meant nothing.

And the more I did it—

the more those words started to replace the truth.

Until one day—

I realized I couldn’t even tell the difference anymore.

Between what I was saying…

and what I actually meant.

That realization hit me harder than I expected.

Because it meant I wasn’t just being quiet—

I was rewriting my own reality.

Convincing myself that things were okay when they weren’t.

That things didn’t matter when they did.

That I didn’t need anything—

when I clearly did.

And every time I said the wrong thing—

it created distance.

Between me and the truth.

Between me and how I actually felt.

Between me and anyone who could have understood—

if I had just said it differently.

But I didn’t.

Because the truth is harder.

It takes more effort.

More vulnerability.

More risk.

And I wasn’t always ready for that.

So I settled for easier words.

Safer words.

Words that didn’t require anything from me—

or from anyone else.

Until one day—

I said it again.

“I’m okay.”

And something in me paused.

Because for once—

I heard it differently.

Not as a response.

But as a pattern.

And I realized how many times I had used those same words—

in moments where I needed something completely different.

And I couldn’t ignore it anymore.

So I stopped.

Took a breath.

And said what I actually meant.

“I’m not okay.”

It felt unfamiliar.

Uncomfortable.

Like I was stepping into something I hadn’t fully practiced yet.

But it also felt…

honest.

And that honesty created space.

Not just in the conversation—

but in me.

Because for the first time in a long time—

I wasn’t hiding behind something that sounded right.

I was standing in something that was real.

And maybe that’s what I needed.

Not better words.

Just truer ones.

Because saying the wrong thing over and over again—

doesn’t protect you.

It just delays the moment you finally have to say what you meant all along.

Posted Apr 17, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.