Dr. Adam Graham had been a crime scene investigator, had seen countless crimes and caught countless criminals. When he was young, he would’ve told you he thought these criminals were deplorable. He’d been unable to imagine being able to do something like the kinds of things he saw. Unable to understand the criminals he helped catch. Those who showed no remorse were even worse, their smiles in the courtrooms as their crimes were read aloud were burned into the black behind his eyelids. But he grew older, more jaded, and with time came an understanding. He could picture the thrill of it all. The relief of getting away with something was almost nostalgic. Akin to sneaking an extra dessert and your mother never noticing, or cheating on a test in grade school. To cause such harm and walk away without a scratch was a feeling not many could experience. Eventually, he quit his active duty and moved to teaching forensics at the police academy. That's where he laid eyes on Katherine- a hopeful twenty-something girl who he had taken a liking to immediately. It was almost as if the professor sensed her vulnerability the instant she walked into the classroom.
The girl had come to him after class ended one day to confide in him. Her boyfriend hit her again the night before and she couldn’t take it anymore. She didn’t know what to do or what evidence she’d need to report him and keep him away this time. She tried before, but nothing stuck. There simply wasn’t enough evidence to prove he had done anything. Which is why she came to him, she explained- if anyone could help her with evidence, it would be the ex-investigator and forensics professor. Graham had feigned the comforting teacher, holding her and promising that it would never happen again.
“Women are so resilient, you’ll get through this,” He smiled. She chuckled against him, pulling back to wipe the tears from her face. He invited her to his house nearby to discuss the matter in more privacy. She took the bait immediately. Afraid of the boyfriend seeing her with another man gave them perfect cover to make it to the house without being seen. The car ride was short and tense. Graham could remember how sweet her perfume was and the innocence in her big, teary eyes.
It wasn’t hard to get Katherine to share some wine with him. The pretense of relaxing before discussing such a tense matter was all he needed. The drug he slipped in her glass was quick to kick in, the girl’s pupils blowing wide and her speech slurring. Graham took his opportunity without hesitation.
He hadn’t planned on killing her, but the drug limiting her breathing combined with his hands wrapped around her throat ultimately turned out to be too much for the poor girl. He was surprised at his own lack of remorse, but he supposed he did her a favor. If it wasn’t his hands, that boyfriend of hers would've done it soon anyways.
The police had come to speak to him about her disappearance, of course. They had spoken to all of Katherine’s professors, but mostly to ask about the girl’s demeanor in class or if they had noticed anything “off” about her. The lies slipped off Graham’s tongue without hesitation as if it were his second nature.
“Oh what a poor girl, always so lost in her own head, seemed distracted, distant,”
“I always thought something wasn’t right about that guy who she saw after class,”
“I thought I saw bruises under her make up, but I could be wrong,”
Sure, there was the fear of being caught. Graham had worked too hard to get where he was to have some sad dead girl tear it all down. He sighed to himself. They wouldn’t find the body. Even if they searched his house, her rotting corpse lay under the foundation. Sealed away from the world under a dark, hard-to-get-to corner in the dusty basement. A tomb of rubble and concrete hid the professor’s secret.
They would find Katherine’s boyfriend guilty. Even though she had very little friends when she was alive, it wasn’t a secret how he treated her. The boy hadn’t been shy about it either. They would search his apartment, find her blood, hastily cleaned up. They’d find the hair ripped out by the scalp and scraps of her clothes. Graham had seen to it that more than enough evidence to convict was found there, and that none remained in his own home. The day he read the verdict in the paper, big bold letters spelling out, “BOYFRIEND FOUND GUILTY OF KILLING POLICE TRAINEE”, Graham let out a breath he didn’t know he had been holding. That feeling of relief, the childish sense of getting away with something naughty, washed over him in cool waves. There was something else in the undercurrent, too. A feeling of power. He had taken a life and nothing had happened to him, not even an accusation. His sin had no consequences.
A few months went by in a blur of nothing special. Graham felt that dark urge in the back of his mind, the pull to end another life. It was strong, but he was too smart to rush into something like that. Not only did he need a perfect victim, but he knew better than to group the killings too close together. Two girls, close in age, both bodies never found, disappearing so close together- they might suspect a serial murderer. The FBI might get involved at that point and the scrutiny wasn’t worth it. Katherine only crossed his mind in his fantasies of power. He pictured the light leaving her eyes, the small, squeaky noises she made in a desperate attempt to breathe. Reliving the feeling of squeezing the life out of her was the only thing keeping him from acting too soon.
His perfect victim came soon enough, a drunk girl around her mid-twenties sitting alone in the corner of a bar. Graham had sat there long enough to watch her friends leave her one by one, leaving her by herself to try to drunkenly figure out how to use Uber on her phone. The professor took his opportunity. Like a lion pouncing on its prey, he made his way to that dark corner.
“Hey, you okay? Where are your friends?” He asked. She looked up at him, confusion all over her face. Graham took in the sight of her. Big, blue eyes with smeared mascara. Plump, pink lips pursed in frustration. Her hair was dusty blonde and left down, curled and smelling almost too strongly of hairspray. Freckles dotted all across her face. She really was beautiful, Graham felt his excitement growing the more he looked at her.
“Um… I’m not sure? They were here. Maybe the bathrooms? I just wanna go home,” she slurred. Her phone was dropped on the seat beside her. Graham held out his hand to help her stand. She wobbled to her feet and let herself be led out of the bar.
“I’m Margot, my friends are supposed to be here… are you gonna take me home? I’m so tired, Mr…?”
“Adam,” He smiles at her, but it doesn’t reach his eyes. They stay fixated on her as if she were his prey, “I can take you home if you want, my date tonight never showed so I haven’t had that much to drink. Come on, let's go. Can you tell me your address?”
She thought for a moment, tapping her chin dramatically to indicate how hard she was thinking. He let her do this for a minute before sighing in feigned annoyance. She giggled. He felt the laugh rattle through his body from where she leaned against him.
“Sorry Adam, I can’t remember. It’s a friend’s place, I’m not from here. Can I just sleep here?” She motioned to the concrete below them and laughed again. Graham smiled to himself. He might not even have to drug her if she was this gone. He didn’t respond, instead just helping Margot into the passenger seat of his car. Almost instantly, she laid her head back and passed out. Perfect, he thought, the pretty ones always talk too much. The drive to his house was silent, but he could feel the excitement rising in his throat.
Getting the girl awake and into the house was almost more work than it was worth, but once she was inside and laid out on his couch all the frustration was gone. The straps of her dress had fallen and her skirt had ridden up. He couldn’t wait another second. Climbing on top of her, pinning her to the cushions. She groaned at the sudden weight on top of her and opened her eyes. Her mouth fell open- whether ready to ask a question or scream, it didn’t matter. All that came out was a choked gasp as Graham put one hand on her throat and used the other to hike her dress up even more. She started squirming, but she was no match for his strength.
“Shhh, its ok Margot. Women are resilient, you’ll get over this one day, I just need-”
He had taken her underwear off, but he wanted to see her cry when he violated her. But when he looked up, it wasn’t the crying face of Margot.
Katherine stared back at him, her face angry stone despite the hand around her neck. He jumped, scrambling off the couch and hitting the floor with a THUD! Graham looked back up where the girl was laying, but she had sat up already and was trying to pull her underwear back on. He knew it wasn’t Katherine, it couldn’t be. Her corpse was rotting under his basement. He buried her. He piled the dirt over her and resealed the floor above it.
He was seeing things, probably just his brain connecting this experience to the last one. The circumstances were similar enough, he thought. But as he got back to his feet and got Margot by the wrist again, all he saw was Katherine. Her face was not panicked like Margot’s was. It was almost as if she was staring right through him. Graham blinked hard several times, assuring himself he was just seeing things. When his gaze returned to her face, it was once again Margot. Her eyes filled with tears, face ruddy from her crying.
“Please let me go.. I’m sorry if I gave you the wrong impression, I just want to go home,” She whimpered. Graham closed his eyes and sighed, debating his choices.
“Yeah, Dr. Graham, let her go,” It was Katherine’s voice. His eyes snapped open, grip loosening enough for Margot to wiggle out and dart towards the door. His mind raced, fear making his heart beat faster than he thought was possible. The sound of the door opening and slamming shut was barely audible over the rush in his ears. She was dead. There was no way Katherine had been in his living room. Certainly no way she had spoken to him. He had never felt guilt over what happened, so why did it suddenly seem like the only thing he could feel?
Almost as if on autopilot, Graham got up and walked to the basement door. He leaned on the door, pressing an ear to it. A minute went by without incident. He turned the handle slowly. The light from the living room spilled into the dark stairwell, creeping on the walls at a snail’s pace. When he was sure nothing was lurking in the shadows, he stepped forward and descended into the basement. He held his breath at the bottom of the steps. His brain conjured up all sorts of ideas for what could be hiding in the darkness, but he braced himself and flicked on the light.
Nothing. It was just his basement. Graham sighed. He questioned what he expected down here, he had never believed in ghosts before. Shaking his head, he started back up the stairs. Halfway up the door slammed shut. He jumped, but rationalized that it could’ve been a draft or something. Nothing was down here after all, so it couldn’t have been a ghost. He tried the handle. It didn’t turn an inch. He tried harder, maybe it just got stuck. It was an older house, things like this happen. It still didn’t budge. The fear was crawling back, creeping up the back of his neck like icy tendrils.
“Adam, you’re losing it!” he whispered to himself. He sat at the top step and put his head in his hands, “There’s nothing here. She’s gone, she’s buried,”
“Are you sure you don’t want to check that?” Katherine’s voice spilled from the base of the stairs, winding up the hall and gripping Graham’s heart with fear.
He had to dig her up, had to see her body. Prove to himself that she was just bones in the dirt now. A pickaxe hung on the wall with the other tools. Graham grabbed it with shaky, sweaty hands. He began to hack away at the concrete, fear fueling him even when his arms were ready to give out. Once he hit dirt, he started digging with his hands. Deeper and deeper, but nothing was there. This was the right place, he knew for sure. Where was she? Even just one bone, to prove to himself that he was imagining things. He dug for hours, hands caked in dirt and blood, almost the whole basement floor torn up and smashed to pieces.There was no body down here. Had Graham made up the whole thing in his head? Did she somehow rise from her grave? His mind spun. Stumbling up the stairs, he found the door open as he had left it when he first came down. He felt like he was in a daze, his vision blurry and unable to focus. A noise in the kitchen drew him out of his stupor. It sounded almost as if someone were uncorking and pouring wine. Shakily, he made his way into the kitchen.
“Oh, Dr. Graham! There you are, I poured us a drink. I know you’re stressed, so just relax and have a sip,” Katherine smiled, her hand extended and holding the wine glass. Then, she snatched it back suddenly.
“I almost forgot the most important part!” She exclaimed. Pulling a little bag out of her pocket, she sprinkled some kind of white powder into the glass and swirled it around to mix before offering it back to him. She was still smiling.
“N-No, no! I killed you! I buried you!” He stumbled backwards and hit the counter. She took a step closer, still holding the wine out to him. His shaking hands reluctantly took it. She gave him a look that said, go on now. Drink. It burned down his throat. Her smile widened cartoonishly, almost splitting her face in two. She sipped from her own glass and held it up in a toast,
“Oh, you know us women. We’re resilient!”
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.