Truth or Tale

Fiction Speculative

Written in response to: "Write a story about two people who remember the same event differently." as part of A Trip Down Memory Lane.

‘So, how are we today?’ Dr. Lang addressed the couple sitting across him, who looked like a part of a framed photo with the sky-blue wall paint behind them.

Mr. and Mrs. Keeley were sitting timidly in the brown couch, with some distance between them. The doctor noticed and waited for them to answer.

‘Uhm’, Mrs. Keeley began hesitantly. ‘We…well, I’m okay and a bit anxious about this conversation. I haven’t said a word to him all morning and on the drive here because I was afraid I’d either trigger something or make him angry before we got here. But also…truly I didn’t want to upset myself prior to the session. A bit tense right now, doc’, she concluded.

Mr. Keeley frowned a few times as his wife was speaking and the doctor picked that up as well. It was easily a testament to her reasoning but his expertise told him there was more to his two patients than what he was seeing.

Dr. Lang passed his gaze from Mrs. Keeley to her husband, prompting him to go ahead and share his feelings.

‘I’m okay. Stable’, Mr. Keeley concluded.

Dr. Keeley nodded as a way to encourage them both into this conversation.

‘Well, I appreciate that you both are here for this session. I understand how it all may seem quite invasive and uncomfortable. My job isn’t to worsen that sentiment but to try and alleviate it as we discuss some of what has brought us all here. Mrs. Keeley, please tell me again why you felt you wanted to be here today. Take your time, and perhaps Mr. Keeley and I can try as best as possible to listen’, Dr. Lang spoke carefully. He allowed his Asian accent to control how his words flowed, such that each word sounded well thought out and not rehearsed prior to their meeting.

Mrs. Keeley cleared her throat and finally looked over to her husband, smiling nervously.

‘Well doctor, I think Hank and I have a communication problem which has led to some hostility from both parties. I don’t like talking with him anymore. About anything. I usually keep to myself or read my books and he watches the news or whatever else is on. This has been going on for about a month now, and I can’t take it’, she covered her mouth and let out a light sob.

Dr. Lang looked at her sympathetically when she waved a hand as an apology for the sudden interruption. The psychologist handed her a box of tissues from which she pulled two sheets and patted her cheeks.

‘I miss my husband. Our friendship. I don’t know how we can go back to being friends but I’m here because I don’t want to end up like my pare…’, she broke into sobs again.

Dr. Lang watched for Mr. Keeley’s reaction to his wife’s state surreptitiously as he moved his pen on the notepad he had on his lap. Mr. Keeley bounced over to his wife on the couch and embraced her. She didn’t open herself to it but didn’t refuse it either. She sniffled and wiped her nose with the tissue.

Dr. Lang allowed that moment to stretch until Mrs. Keeley was no longer sobbing.

‘Okay. Thank you for that Mrs. Keeley. If that’s all you’d like to share for now then Mr. Keeley…please respond. Why brings you here today?’, the doctor repeated the question with refreshed enthusiasm.

‘I don’t want a divorce. I want to fix what we’re doing wrong, Dr. Lang. I just don’t feel like she’s…if I can trust her with my truth at this point. That’s why I don’t talk to her’, he spoke while still holding his wife.

Mrs. Keeley escaped his arms and looked into his eyes.

‘You don’t trust me?’

Dr. Lang knew he needed to control the progression of the conversation before allowing a back and forth.

‘Now, hold on Mrs. Keeley. Let’s please allow your husband to finish. Please Mr. Keeley.’

The married man sat up in the couch and rested his elbows on his knees.

‘I don’t feel like I can trust her with my feelings. This is coming from the incident that inspired this session, doc. We were in the kitchen and I was reaching into one of the grocery cupboards to pick something of mine. She walked in and came towards me, then just stood there. Right under my arm until I looked at her. She said “I see you’ve bought yourself new shoes yet you haven’t paid me back the money you borrowed last week. You said you’d give it back to me. Pay day was on Monday. I want my money back.” I didn’t answer her and instead turned to put the peanut butter jar I had in hand on the counter and then she pushed me. Our son was there when she did that. He’s fifteen. I was terrified and angry all at once. So, I took a step back, looked in her eyes and told her not to do that again. Then I looked at my boy, waned to say sorry but just stormed out of the kitchen, Mr. Keeley relayed and then paused.

‘Okay, thank you Mr. Keeley…’

‘Please, just call me Harry’, he said sharply.

‘Harry, thanks for that. Mrs. Keeley, would you like to respond to that?’ the psychologist asked her with his eyes focused on his notes as he recorded what Harry had just said, word for word.

‘I’m sorry, I just remember it a bit differently. I did approach him and ask him to give me my money back, but he didn’t take a step back and then walk out. Harry, honey, you pushed my hand and when you saw our baby in the room, then you stepped back and walked out. I don’t know what would’ve happened if he didn’t walk in, that’s why we’re here. I want to know why you hate me now’, she was looking at her husband when she asked.

Dr, Lang lifted a hand to pause the conversation.

‘I want both of you to think about what the other has said and then find expression for what you feel and perhaps we can explore why that is. It’s important that we establish the root cause of your conflict before we can find a way forward. Mrs. Keeley, you recall hand-pushing and Harry you recall her pushing you. I want you both to think about that and then alert me once you’ve identified at least one emotion linked to that incident and why you think you felt it’, the professional directed them.

Dr. Lang noted a few words on his notepad; adjectives and phrases in list form as he allowed them to carry out the exercise.

Selfish

Past hurts (expressed as anger)

Disrespect

Disregarding/ignorant to each other’s feelings

*Need to recall why they love each other and reinforce that.

He concluded his thought process and noticed Harry had leaned back, his head was resting on the couch with his eyes closed. Dr. Lang sensed the man’s frustration.

‘Harry, let’s start with you’, Dr. Lang requested.

Posted Nov 10, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

1 like 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.