4 likes
6 comments
There are many ways to measure a life’s happiness. This one keeps track of miles.
Elaine noticed the road first.
Not that anything had changed.
It just took longer to reach things.
The stoplight. The turn. The familiar corner where the gas station sat like it always had.
Longer.
Greg kicked the back of her seat.
Once. Twice. “Mom. I’m hungry.”
“I just fed you.”
“No you didn’t.”
“I did. In the kitchen. I watched you eat.”
Caroline shifted beside him.
“I’m hungry too.”
“You’re not.”
“I am.”
Greg kicked again.
“Both of you stop.”
The road ahead stretched in a straight, familiar line. Same turns. It just took longer to reach them.
Elaine shifted in her seat.
The air in the car felt used up, like it had already been breathed too many times. She cracked the window.
Nothing changed.
Greg kicked harder.
“Greg.”
“What?”
“Stop.”
Another kick. Slower now. Deliberate.
In the rearview mirror, his face looked farther away than it should have.
Elaine blinked. The distance snapped back into place.
She frowned.
For a second—
No. Nothing.
She exhaled through her nose and turned up the radio. Static. Then a voice, cutting in and out—
“—reporting clusters across—”
“—not advised to—”
“—early symptoms include—”
She switched it off.
Caroline said nothing the rest of the way.
That was the first thing Elaine noticed.
⸻
At the house, Caroline didn’t run ahead like she usually did. She shuffled. Slowly. Drawing in hand. Elaine watched her pause at the front steps, one hand resting on the railing as if she needed it to steady herself.
“Caroline?”
No answer.
Elaine frowned. “Hey. Look at me.”
Caroline did. Her eyes met Elaine’s for a second—then drifted slightly, like something behind Elaine had caught her attention.
Elaine stepped closer. “Are you okay?”
Caroline nodded. But she didn’t move. Didn’t smile. Didn’t speak.
Elaine reached out and touched her forehead. Warm. A little too warm. She frowned.
“Great,” she muttered. “You’re getting sick.”
Caroline didn’t respond.
Elaine rang the bell. The chime echoed through the entry hall—bright, almost cheerful—like something that belonged at a summer carnival, not here.
⸻
Mark opened the door before the chime ended.
“Hey,” he said, like he always said it. Easy. Unbothered.
Elaine stepped past him without answering.
The house smelled clean. Not like hers. Something citrus, faint and constant.
Lena stood at the counter, one hand wrapped around a mug.
“Hi, Elaine.”
Elaine set her keys down a little too hard. “I’m not staying long. I think Caroline is unwell.”
“That’s too bad. We had planned a fun trip to Sky Zone Trampoline Park,” Lena said. She smiled. Not wide. Not forced. Just… there.
Caroline slipped past Elaine and attached herself to Lena’s side. Lena touched her head with the back of her hand and shook her head. “You can’t stay, my love. Mom will take you home so you can rest.” Then she looked pointedly at Elaine, “You’ll call the doctor and let us know what he says?”
Caroline interrupts, “I made you something.”
Lena set the mug down immediately. “Can I see?”
Caroline held up a page—crayon pressed so hard it had torn through in places.
Lena leaned in like it mattered. “I’ll put it on the fridge to show it off. You’ll tell me about it next time you come. When you feel better.”
Greg was already in Mark’s arms, laughing at something Elaine hadn’t heard.
Elaine stood in the doorway. Caroline joined her, but her downturned mouth and lowered eyes spoke volumes.
No one looked at them. They drove home in silence.
⸻
By the time they were in the kitchen, Caroline was almost asleep on her feet. She looked pale and less… present.
Elaine filled a glass of water and set it down. “Drink that please.”
Caroline didn’t.
Elaine exhaled, already irritated. “Caroline.”
Still nothing.
Caroline finally reached for the glass. Slow. Careful. Like the motion required more effort than it should have.
Elaine watched her.
Something about the way she moved felt wrong. Not dramatic. Just slightly delayed. Like a thought hadn’t quite caught up to the body executing it.
Caroline drank. Half the glass. Then stopped. Set it down. Didn’t finish.
That was new.
Elaine frowned again.
⸻
Later that night, Caroline stood in the hallway.
Not in her room.
Not in the kitchen.
In the hallway.
“Why are you out of bed?” Elaine asked.
Caroline didn’t answer.
Elaine stepped closer.
“You’re sick. You need to lie down.”
Caroline shook her head.
“I’m hungry.”
Elaine blinked.
“Of course you are. You’re always hungry.”
Caroline stepped forward.
Just one step.
Then stopped.
Elaine studied her face.
Her skin looked even more pale.
Her eyes—Just a little unfocused.
Not enough for anyone else to notice. But enough for Elaine to feel something tightening in her chest.
She touched Caroline’s cheek. “You’re burning up,” she said. Her daughter was increasingly warm, but now—It felt different. Not just heat. Something else.
Elaine hesitated. “Let’s get you to bed.”
Caroline didn’t resist.
⸻
Elaine didn’t notice when it started happening to her.
At first, it was small. She forgot why she had walked into a room. She paused mid-sentence and couldn’t find the rest of it. She stared at the stove longer than necessary. Then longer still.
The house felt… off. Not louder. Not quieter. Just harder to move through.
Distances felt slightly stretched. Like the space between things had changed when she wasn’t looking.
⸻
That night, she woke up thirsty. Very thirsty.
Her mouth felt impossibly dry.
She sat up slowly, listening.
The house was quiet. Too quiet.
Then—A small sound in the hallway.
She froze.
“Caroline?”
No answer.
Elaine got up and walked into the hall.
The floor felt colder than it should have.
“Caroline,” she said again, firmer this time.
A pause.
Then—
“Mommy.”
The voice was soft. Close.
Elaine turned.
Caroline stood just outside the reach of the hallway light.
Watching her.
Elaine exhaled, relieved.
“There you are.”
Caroline didn’t move closer.
Didn’t speak again.
Elaine rubbed her face, irritated.
“You need to go back to bed.”
Caroline tilted her head slightly. A small, precise movement.
Elaine frowned. Something about that—
She shook it off.
“Go on.”
Caroline nodded. But she didn’t move right away.
Just stood there.
Looking at her. Blinking. Waiting.
Elaine turned first.
Walked back toward her room.
Behind her, she heard a soft sound.
A step.
Then another.
⸻
She didn’t realize anything was wrong until the morning.
Until she couldn’t remember if Caroline had eaten.
Or if she had.
Or when.
The details slipped as soon as she tried to hold them.
Elaine stepped into the bathroom.
The mirror was already fogged from the shower.
She leaned in and wiped a small circle clear with her palm.
Her reflection appeared.
Familiar. Almost. She stared at herself a moment longer than necessary.
There was something about the set of her face. Not different. Just… delayed.
Like the image needed a second to catch up.
Elaine frowned.
She lifted her hand.
Her reflection didn’t move at exactly the same time.
Or maybe it did. The difference was small. Small enough to doubt. She exhaled, rubbing the dampness from her skin.
“Get it together,” she muttered.
Her reflection said nothing.
But for just a second—it felt like it was watching her instead of copying her.
⸻
After washing her face, brushing her teeth and getting dressed, she stood in her own kitchen, staring at the empty counter, and felt the quiet absence of something she should have known.
Not fear.
Not yet.
Just a thin, unfamiliar gap.
She reached for the memory of the night before.
Found it.
Then lost it again.
Her throat felt dry. Uncomfortably dry.
Elaine swallowed. Nothing changed.
In the stillness, she noticed it—how far away everything felt.
Not the room. Not the walls. Just… herself.
Like something had stepped between her and the life she was supposed to recognize.
And for the first time, she didn’t trust the answer her own mind gave her.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Hey! I read your story and wanted to share some thoughts. There’s a really strong core idea here, and I think with some refinement it could land even more effectively.
First, what’s working well:
The atmosphere is your strongest element. The way you build unease through small, subtle changes—like distances feeling off, delays in movement, and the mirror moment—is really effective. You’re clearly aiming for a slow-burn, unsettling kind of horror, and that’s coming through.
I also liked how you avoided over-explaining what’s happening. Letting the reader piece things together adds to the tension, especially in scenes like the hallway and the reflection. Those moments are strong and memorable.
Now for some areas you could strengthen:
One thing that would really help is tightening the prose. Right now, a lot of sentences and phrases are repeated or slightly reworded versions of the same idea. For example, you often describe something, then restate it in a slightly different way (“Not louder. Not quieter. Just…” or “Not this. Not that.”). That technique can be powerful when used sparingly, but when it shows up too often, it starts to slow the pacing and reduce the impact.
You could try picking the strongest version of each idea and cutting the rest. This will make your writing feel sharper and more confident.
Related to that, some sections feel a bit over-fragmented. The very short paragraphs and frequent line breaks create a choppy rhythm. That can work for tension, but if everything is broken up the same way, it loses contrast. You might experiment with combining some lines into fuller paragraphs so that the more fragmented moments stand out when you really want them to.
Another area to look at is character grounding. Elaine’s emotional state is a bit distant, which may be intentional, but giving us a little more of her internal reaction could make the story more engaging. For example, when she notices something is off with Caroline, we get the observation, but not as much of how that makes her feel beyond mild irritation or confusion. Even small additions of internal response could raise the stakes.
You might also consider strengthening the escalation. The story introduces strange details early on, but the level of tension stays fairly consistent throughout. If you build those moments so each one feels more intense or more undeniable than the last, the ending will land harder.
Finally, clarity in a few spots could be improved. There are moments where it’s slightly hard to tell exactly what’s happening versus what’s being perceived as “off.” Sharpening those distinctions will help the reader stay oriented while still feeling unsettled.
Overall, you’ve got a really strong concept and a clear sense of tone. Focusing on tightening the language, varying your pacing, and deepening the character perspective would really elevate this piece into a real masterpiece of a short story in my opinion.
Reply
Carrie, I want to thank you so much for taking the time to read my story so thoughtfully—I really appreciate the level of detail you gave here.
I’m glad the atmosphere and slow-burn tension came through, because that was definitely my intention. It helps a lot to know those elements are landing.
Your notes on tightening the prose and varying the pacing really resonated. I can see how the repetition and fragmentation might start to dilute the impact if overused, so I’m excited to refine that and make those moments more intentional.
I also really appreciate your point about grounding Elaine more and strengthening the escalation—that’s something I felt was close, but not fully there yet, so your feedback helped clarify exactly where to push it further.
This was incredibly helpful, thank you again for taking the time to break it down so clearly.
You rock!!!! I look forward to reading your work ❤️
Reply
If I may offer some critique: 1) While it can be very tempting to add a several paragraph and line breaks to direct the pacing of the story, I would advise against this. It often ends up doing the opposite. It can feel meta, like a horror movie with too many jump scares. For example, the first few sentences, finishing with the one word “longer,” can just be one paragraph. IMO, it will make that one word sentence more impactful. 2) Your opening line seems out of place about happiness and miles, like it was accidentally copied from another story. I just didn’t get the connection to Elaine’s slow deterioration. The next line was a better opener. But personally I’m not a strong believer in earth shattering opening line hooks, so take that with a grain of salt. 3) Where’s Greg? Asleep? Dead? I understand that it was the middle of the night near the end, but something simple like looking at his bedroom door and then forgetting about it to acknowledge him might help.
Hope this helps, happy writing.
Reply
Steven, I sincerely thank you for taking the time to voice your thoughts and to do so as clearly as you did. It is incredibly helpful to hear reader interpretations because we often lose perspective on our own stories. Your analysis was extremely informative, and I will definitely heed your advice when I am composing my next story. I really thank you for reading my story and for the time it took you to engage with me. I am interested in your work, and will be looking to read something of yours soon. Cheers.
Reply
Hi. This is almost identical to your other story, "Out of Reach." They read like they are AI-generated variations of each other. You should disclose when you use AI in your art; not doing so is duplicitous.
EDIT: If a reader has any doubt whether this author uses AI, they need look no further than the reply to my comment.
Reply
Hi — I really appreciate you taking the time to share this with me.
I hear what you’re noticing, and I understand why that might raise questions. These pieces do sit in similar emotional and structural territory, because they’re coming from the same set of themes I’ve been trying to work through and deepen.
What I also want to be transparent about is this: once I submit a story to a contest or publication, I can’t go back and edit that version. It stays exactly as it was at the time of submission. But that doesn’t mean the story is “finished” for me creatively. I often feel a pull to return to those same narratives afterward — to push them further, strip them back, or rework them from a more evolved place. Not to replace the original, but to keep exploring what’s underneath it and make it more fully human each time.
I understand how that can look from the outside, especially if you’re reading multiple versions close together. But for me, it’s less about repetition and more about iteration — staying with something long enough to really see what it’s made of.
I appreciate you engaging with the work and being honest about your reaction.
Reply