The first time Jen pretended to be someone else was on Facebook Messenger, in the summer of her junior year, after attending her mother’s required pre-college after-school camp. Jen would return home and lock herself in her bedroom. This was her me time.
For the most part, she ended up chatting with men much older than she was. She found them in a group called “Seeking Sugar Babies.” Neither party ever used the correct name or age.
When one frequent user formed a stronger-than-usual attachment to her, trying to text her constantly during her off hours, the time after 8 p.m. when she sat in front of her TV.
Jen sent him a photo she had found of another girl on the internet.
The woman she sent was pale and lanky, with deep-set eyes. Jen was short, with large breasts.
There was a rush to being someone else in that moment, that initial lie opening up into the ease of a new, assumed identity.
He asked her instead if she masturbated, and how frequently.
She frowned, blocking him.
The image of who she pretended to be still reverberated. She saved it as a pinned photo on her phone.
When Jen felt particularly hollow during her end-of-high-school achievements, she’d look at that hidden photo, even running her fingers over the screen.
—
The second time Jen decided to be someone else was harder to pinpoint, more of a slow descent.
First, she had followed a handful of women who seemed to embody that pretend image of who she was. Following the women was not as alluring as The One. But it began with a similar kind of attraction, a desire to possess the qualities they displayed.
The first woman was her high school friend, who was an actual model. Jen gave up her full ride to a local state school upstate to follow her friend to the city instead.
Their friendship ended. Later, Jen found a group of girls with thick accents from Italian enclaves around New York City, but they fell out during an ill-timed trip to Miami in which Jen puked on the dance floor of a nightclub.
Jen set her sights on a year studying abroad.
Then she met The One.
It was hard to explain whether they truly had something special or whether this was, even for Jen, one of her professed delusions.
They had one dinner date. He touched her hand, stroking her fingers.
“You’re special” he said, but only kissed her once, at her dorm.
Jen soon realized he was dating a woman with small, cherry-sized breasts that bounced under her shirts.
Jen returned with a pit in her stomach and the feeling that all the good in her life remained with someone who was just out of reach.
—
Jen’s father had secured her a job in New York City when she graduated. She was working for a friend as a personal assistant. The Important Woman spent most of her time at her other house in rural Connecticut or, in the warmer months, the Hamptons, so Jen got the run of the three-story townhouse most of the time.
Sometimes her depressed son Eli was home.
During her job, Jen would scan her phone for signs of life from The One. She had created a series of dead-end accounts with other fake photos.
What she had gathered was that The One looked as if he had taken a gap year or two post-college, taking up residence in the south of France.
Eli watched her one morning in the kitchen after she gave the two dachshunds their required kidney medicine.
“Are you going to eat that?” said Eli, picking at a croissant.
“No,” she offered, marking on her map the location of a bar The One had posted a photo from.
The One was smiling goofily, the reflection of his camera hand visible in the dark of his Ray-Bans. She zoomed in on her laptop.
Eli hovered awkwardly close. Small crumbs from his croissant fell around him,
Jen’s mom texted a picture of terry-cloth towels: “Need these?”. Jen felt that flash of annoyance, two people hovering near her.
“Do you need something?” she asked Eli directly.
Eli wore the pants and shirts of the kids who would juggle hacky sacks in her high school’s side yard.
“Do you want to hang with me in my room afterward?” he offered, stressing afterward.
Jen felt that twisting in her stomach, the joining of desire and disgust.
Eli was unable to pass the bar. He went straight from his preppy high school to preppy college to a fancy law school. And yet he was now wearing the kind of cotton tunics you’d find at a depressed mall in nowhere, upstate New York.
Jen looked him up and down. “Not a good idea.”
She closed the tabs on The One’s precise location and reopened the document where she was going through The Important Woman’s personal archive.
Eli finally shrugged, his breakfast pastry done. He left for the back patio, leaving Jen in the kitchen.
She could smell him vaping outside in the bright sun.
–
In the late afternoon, she left for a coffee. The dogs nipped a bit at her ankles.
Around the block, she set herself at a local spot that was almost the size of one of The Important Woman’s walk-in closets.
Jen felt the aftereffects of Eli, the image in her mind of him hovering above her, considering her, chewing. She imagined him taking off his shirt, slowly, standing above her, just briefly.
At a table to the right, there was a group of girls around Jen’s age, taking curated selfies with their color-matching sets alongside their ombré lattes. One girl was recording a video in real time: a direct review of what she was drinking.
Jen looked at her phone, the already zoomed-in picture of the place where The One currently was. Then she looked back to her distant peers, filming their tepid reviews, their skin oily and shiny like donuts.
Of course, Jen thought. it was simple.
She needed them. She needed a group, a friend at least. She needed a trip.
She had a perfect destination.
—
Jen had a better idea for the immediate future. She took the subway downtown.
There was a Pilates studio in her neighborhood, a shoebox-sized place. Jen had been coming here off and on, using her father’s card to buy class packs.
There were a few white lies that made it all easier. Sure, she had told her parents that in the interim, when she was working this job as a personal assistant, a bigger-than-life favor, she was freelancing as a writer. It was true that her first freelance gig out of college was a position for a well-known magazine’s newsletter. Unfortunately, she had been fired.
“I’m still writing for them,” Jen told her dad.
You go get ’em, her father had probably offered, not looking further.
Jen’s parents weren’t exorbitantly rich, but they were rich enough in white-collar professions that were far enough away from New York City that their life was perfectly and fabulously comfortable.
They expected her to succeed, which was proving harder than imagined. Jen was smart, smarter than she let on, but she was on the verge of Not Succeeding,
The teacher that day was new. She looked older than Jen. Jen watched all her moves religiously, the vigor of her long legs.
After class, Jen had to head back uptown to feed the dogs as a favor, so she stayed longer at the townhouse as she mindlessly scrolled through social media, still stuck on the Pilates instructor, her arms stretched high, ebullient, like the possibility of living could be changed.
A series of influencers passed by Jen’s feed quickly, in a gaggle of girl groups, somewhere where the ocean made a rocky coast look like luxury. Here were girls similar to the Pilates instructor, except multiplied.
That was it, she told the twin dogs, propped up on velvet pillows like a character in a Dutch Renaissance painting.
I’ve found my friend.
—
The process of courting Stephanie, the Pilates instructor, took two phases.
The first involved running up a large tab at a string of wine and hotel bars in the West Village. In her presence, Jen often felt so much less like her old, failing self.
“You’re too kind!” Stephanie offered, smiling her beautiful grin.
The presence of Stephanie, who laughed openly and yet was at times a harsh critic of the other women kept Jen engaged. She felt the courtship had to continue a bit before she could launch their plan in the south of France.
At night, with the glow of her phone, she kept a religious vigil on tracking The One. As the summer waned and early fall set in, it was still apparent he was on his time abroad.
The second phase was making the image of wealth solid. Besides lying and telling Stephanie she was working in PR, Jen courted her in the second perfect way: using the empty townhouse as her own.
This involved coordination that took all her talents.
Leaning on the doorframe one afternoon, with The Important Woman out in the Hamptons for as much of the early fall as she could muster, she locked eyes with Eli. He was supposedly studying for the bar but had American Ninja Warrior up on his laptop.
“I have a proposition for you,” she tried her best to speak in a seductive drawl, a win-win in negotiation.
Eli actually laughed, and Jen curled up with him on the couch, a hand on his leg .
The following weekend Eli agreed to her plans, graciously.
The townhome was now, deliciously, Jen’s. She invited Stephanie over under the pretense that this was the house where she grew up.
The entire weekend was a success, Stephanie’s wide eyes taking in each of the gaudily lavish details of the house.
Stephanie revealed more of her personality to Jen that weekend while they spent it at the empty townhouse.
“I’m the oldest daughter of three girls,” she offered. “And I really feel like I’m destined for something here, in New York.”
She was perky, happy, her lean physique perfectly small and curvy in everything she wore.
“Orlando has nothing like this,” she offered, eyes wide, her arms sweeping the rooms of the East Side house.
The following week, Eli returned, looming over Jen one afternoon as she was transcribing notes.
“Forget something?” he said, dropping a framed photo she had forgotten. One was from when she was ten; it must have been placed in the room where she had staged a guest bedroom as her childhood room.
“You leave this for me?” He was smirking, a hand now touching her shoulder.
“ I’m not into people attracted to children,” Jen added, grabbing the photo and stuffing it into her bag. She slapped Eli’s hand away before getting up.
The sickly twin dogs were howling downstairs, aware it was their dinnertime.
Eli smirked, trying to block her path, but she wiggled away. It was fine to keep him curious; he wasn’t going to tell on her.
The dogs stopped howling as the wet, sloppy food hit their golden doggy bowls.
—
Flamant Rose was a hotel with grand arches, abutting a rocky cliff, just a stone’s throw from the downtown of the off-season French Riviera town where The One was staying. Jen was sure of his whereabouts because he had either conveniently and dumbly left his social media location tracking on. The real-time dot soothed her.
The tables out front were chained together, rather than arranged in the pleasantly chaotic way they would have been during high season, as they appeared in all the curated photos Jen had selected on Pinterest to assure Stephanie that she not only came here often but that it was fabulous, even in early December.
Stephanie was already a bit temperamental, Jen could sense, particularly when she started poking around at the edges of things.
Jen had bought the tickets then funded the hotel stay, though.
Stephanie seemed meaner than before, too. But Jen wasn't exactly presenting a truthful version of herself in this exchange, so she tried to move past it at first.
They plopped down in the outdoor chairs, despite the weather no longer being summery. The whole place had an uncharacteristically bright quality.
“Well, they’re hideous,” Stephanie blurted out, pointing to a seemingly joyous group of middle-aged women sitting around a wrought-iron table, the edges of their chairs decorated with the hotel’s pink flamingo design.
Jen felt one of those unmistakable gut punches/
Jen considered the smiling, freckled faces of the laughing women, and her heart hurt in that way it sometimes did when she felt the true pang of loneliness that seemed to unite every stage of her life.
To nurse the feeling of decay, Jen pulled up the GPS tags she had been tracking, tracing The One, near a small hiking path named after a French philosopher.
Stephanie ordered a preposterously large drink alongside a niçoise salad on Jen’s room tab.
If Jen were truthful, the way her friend ate was hideous, like a rabid animal, her lips almost foaming.
Perhaps that was imagined, but it felt real.
—
Stephanie was awful, complaining: The room was not it. The town was too gray. The weather wasn’t warm enough. Hadn’t Jen been here at this time of year?
Jen’s phone pinged with a text from her dad: Are you traveling? I got a notification of a foreign fee.
As these events cascaded into a few lackluster tours and a spa day, so the rift between the two widened.
Stephanie started threatening to leave later in their week.
Stephanie was dramatically flinging clothing into her bag, shooting looks over at Jen, who was perched on the side of her bed, desperately waiting for The One.
Jen hadn’t thought any of this through. She had oversold and underdelivered.
Jen wanted her and Stephanie out to dinner at just the right time, when The One happened to be nearby, in a carefully plotted cascade of events. The One would know, when he saw her again, that he needed her immediately.
All of that could happen, she reasoned. But now she was all but stuck with terrible, bad-attitude Stephanie,
Her father’s credit card was declined just now, as he believed it had been stolen.
Jen kept refreshing her phone, methodically, hoping for a sign of life.
“Are you even listening?” Stephanie said, adding “I’m getting the fuck out of here,”
Jen’s phone pinged with a location, like a magic interlude, like God’s luck bestowed upon the once forsaken.
“No” Jen let out, in uncharacteristic gasp.
“You can’t. You see, we’ve got to go out to dinner tonight.” She kept clinging, trying to find the words to explain how she could reverse-engineer his location into a plan for where he might be.
“It was supposed to be easier,” she let out, her inside thoughts escaping.
“Easier?” Stephanie repeated, her face contorted into cruelty.
“You clearly have never been here, and you’re hopelessly embarrassing wherever we go.”
Stephanie started smashing her suitcase shut. It was one of those rich-people brands that people who don’t actually know what rich people own tend to buy.
“You’re actually pathetic.” she added, finally.
But just then, a flash, a pang, a sudden burst of energy on Jen’s phone: a picture had been posted.
The One’s face appeared in a photo taken by someone else. The carousel offered another image, and then another.
A woman with short, bobbed blonde hair, a slightly gapped front tooth, and a petite frame shockingly came into view. She was tagged, a woman with endless followers.
All Jen could mutter again, no, no, no, as she physically sank to the floor.
“You’re worse than I expected!” Stephanie let out, viscerally disgusted.
Jen started crawling towards the bathroom, crying uglily, snot running down her face, Every photo on this unknown woman’s profile was riddled with The One, from hands on her thighs, to selfies of the two of them, the last one with a large diamond protruding on her extended hand.
She needed to barricade herself immediately, Jen panicked.
Stephanie began knocking furiously, reminding her that she had to retrieve her toiletries before leaving.
Jen wrapped herself in the bathroom towels, curling by the bathtub, when she finally texted her dad back.
“I fucked up,” she wrote, to which soon enough there was a group call between the three of them, echoing with Stephanie’s slamming of the door, the final sign that she was safe.
Jen crawled back out, on speaker phone, and bolted the door, finally alone, still on the carpet.
—
Stephanie woke up in the adjoining town, the one that was better known. She sat out on the deck even, opening her shirt, showing off her slender and perfectly formed breasts.
“I’m free now,” she texted a friend.
“It was easier than I thought,” she added, with a devil’s horn.
In fact, the entire situation had almost fallen into Stephanie’s lap. Sure, she had seen her own share of hopelessly desirous men who courted her, but a young woman without friends, pretending to be someone else, was just too easy to lead on.
Before she finally cut and ran, Stephanie had pilfered through Jen’s bag, looking for her other credit card.
Sure enough, she booked the resort nearby without any issue. For good measure, she took herself shopping, too.
“She was so desperate,” Stephanie added back to her text chain. “I almost felt bad.”
Her friend gave her a tear emoji, before switching the conversation to her boyfriend’s addiction.
A man who seemed rich sat down next to Stephanie. He was old, but smelled nice.
While it was cold, she kept her shirt unbuttoned.
On the corners of his shirt were small flamingos, pink and common, dotting the fabric, a great sign that she was aligned all along.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
I liked your story. Especially Jen and her sneakiness. I get a feeling she’s lost to who she really is as a Self. Seduction is a powerful position. Like another commenter, I can see her choices getting real mischievous mayhem.
Reply
I look forward to reading your story. I definitely will get to it before Friday night!
Reply
You managed to cram so much into under 3,000 words! Nice job! It definitely has that contemporary/cosmopolitan feel to it. I felt I had almost read a novella. This could easily be expanded into one. These characters, while shallow on the surface, could easily be made into deeper characters for a longer narrative. Poor Jen is so manipulative but easily manipulated. I would even like to see her in a deeper relationship with Eli that ends disastrously. Thanks for sharing.
Reply