Margaret was put to bed with a glass of warm milk, a soft tucking-in, and the usual bedtime story from a fairy tale collection. An endearing peck on the forehead, and a flick of the light switch, before her mother eased the door shut. A muffled “thump” sounded as the edge met the frame.
Soft linen embraced Margaret’s figure, her skull sank into the cotton pillow. A toss to the left to relieve the tension on her shoulders, a toss to the right to face the cool breeze, and another roll to the left, another roll to the right. Margaret was finally drifting into her dreams…burrowing…sinking…cocooned under the heavy duvet.
“I can’t sleep,” she finally admitted to herself. “I cannot sleep and the bed is swallowing me alive!” An excessively long sigh followed as her bare feet landed on the rough, wooden floor. She picked up the rusty chamberstick, and lit the wick of its candle with a flick of the matchstick.
“Annie?” she whispered. “Annie…?” she whispered again, with a sharper tone. Annie had her back turned to Margaret, the weighted blanket pulled up to her ears. Mother hadn’t given Annie a goodnight kiss today, nor had she read to her their daily dose of fairy tales. Margaret and her mother, collectively, had chosen to leave her to rest, as it was quite prominent that she was exhausted.
“Mhmm,” Annie replied, in a high pitched voice.
Margaret decided to venture downstairs by herself. The journey for a second glass of milk, hot milk this time, for hot milk was the cure for insomnia; the drug that delivered a final knockout at the end of every day. It had only occurred to her why she wanted Annie to accompany this journey once she twisted the knob.
“Creeeeeek” the door echoed as it swung open.
Darkness swirled around, masking everything in black other than the glooming halo coming off the candle.
The scene was a parody of The Christmas Carol, Margaret enacted Ebenezer Scrooge, holding the finger-held, brass chamberstick, stomping obnoxiously down the stairs at the annoyance of insomnia. The only difference was that she wore a baby pink night gown, and the door knob hadn’t transformed into a deceased enemy of hers.
“Bah! Humbug!” she exclaimed, in mockery of the situation.
Milk was stored in the cool basement, and she had reached the ground floor. Down a flight of stairs to go before she reached her sweet, sweet dreams.
“Clink, clink, clink,” It was coming from the basement. “Clunk, clunk, clunk,” Something was tapping on glass? Or was it something metallic? Nevertheless, there was definitely some sort of disgruntled conversation behind the door. Margaret stood on her tippy toes and inched towards the source. There was a murmur, then tinkering; A muffled shout, then a prompt response. She had reached the door, and peeked in the tiny sliver.
“Oh for goodness sake, would you settle down!” The goblin exclaimed in a lowered voice. “Let me out! Let me out. Let me out. Let me out. Let me ooout!” The fairy shouted at the top of her lungs.
Margaret tripped on her foot and fell in the room. Her candle stick crashed against the stone-slabbed floor, the flame continued to burn on a sideways candle. Both members of the argument stopped and turned towards her. The room was unbearably silent.
“Oh, what a cliche.” She murmured “So this is how I go out, huh? Like every other story.”
There was not a peep from both of them as they continued to stare. The room was silent once more. Though Margaret figured it’d be smart to take this opportunity and get a good look at what was happening.
It was surely a goblin: A disfigured face of wrinkly, brown skin. Huge, pointed ears, and an even larger nose. His eyes were aglow a bright yellow, and his teeth were covered in thick, yellow film. To tie the look together, a raggedy piece of cloth (that might’ve been a poncho) draped over his short figure.
The goblin had uncomfortably long arms, wrapping tightly around the base of a glass lantern bordered by a metallic frame. It was half his size due to his height being that of a french bulldog. A figure was moving inside of the lantern, emitting a warm, amber light.
It was, without a doubt, a fairy, one that would always appear in her fairy tales. A tutu made by pink peony, iridescent wings with pixie dust spiraling atop, sleek blond hair, pouty lips, and big, bashful eyelashes. She was tragically beautiful, seemingly unworthy of mortality.
“Lend me a hand, would you, pretty girl?” The fairy broke the long silence, tapping lightly at the glass. “This creature! This grotesque creature! Has captured little oh me…” She continued, squeaking in a child-like pitch.
The goblin’s eyes dilated in disbelief. “Good heavens! Would you hold your tongue!” He grumbled, staring menacingly at the fairy.
“What’s your name, pretty girl? Such a dazzling, dazzling girl! Tell me, oh, do tell me!” The fairy exclaimed.
Now what in the world was happening? Margaret was still on the floor, though slowly started picking herself up, patting the dust off her nightgown. “M-Margaret.” She replied.
“Oh Mar—ga—ret!” The fairy clasped her hands together, placing them besides her cheeks. Her legs bundled and leaned forward with her torso. “I’ve been trapped! Isolated! Encaged in this tiny little lantern.” She bashed her eyelashes. “The goblin uses me as light! It forces me to grant wishes! And I can live like this no longer.”
“Would you settle down!” the goblin growled. “Margaret, I know how this looks.” he turned towards her. “But think of this, what practicality would I get from hauling a lantern half my size everywhere? And if she really could grant wishes, wouldn’t she be out of the lantern by now?”
“Oh boo! There you go again, one of your cunning lies.” The fairy started again, “Would you, Margaret? Would you help with opening the trap door, just right down here?” She points.
They waited for a response. “I—I don’t” She struggled to respond. “I don’t understand. Why are you in my basement? Why do you have her captured? How am I of any use to resolving this situation?”
“Do you mean to question me?” The goblin questioned.
“You are the one…holding the lantern.” Margaret replied.
“Now, don’t start making assumptions just yet. You might think she cries tears of gold, or that flowers bloom when she passes by. The helpless, angelic fairy is being held hostage by a hideous creature! Well, that last part is true, but for good reason! She is not the whimsical being that nursery fairytales describe, but that of a conceited, twisted being.” The goblin stopped to catch his breath.
“And I am no evil, Margaret. Nothing more or less than a brownie, or hobgoblin as some call me. Like Robin Goodfellow from The Midsummer Night's Dream! Every night, when the moon hangs on the dark dome, I have been sweeping floors, shooing dust bunnies, threshing grain and folding clothes down in the basement, only in exchange for some warm milk and a hearty bowl of porridge.”
“Porridge?” Said Margaret.
“With a generous sprinkle of hot honey. The girl with pigtails would always leave a big bowl for me by the hearth before she went to bed.” He paused to think. “Annie was her name, wasn’t it?”
Mother had been pleased with how promptly Annie finished her chores this past year, and felt vexed by Margaret’s mannerisms. That devious little child, I’ll get her back next time.
The fairy cleared her throat. “Mhpm, mhpm! Might you be finished with your little rant?”
The brownie ignored her. “My old age is all I am now, Margaret. There is no trickery in my words, nor any ill-intentions in my actions. Mischievous I was, and tired I am now.”
Margaret thought for a moment. “Why have you trapped the fairy, then? If not for what she is describing?”
“Oh Mar—Ga—Ret! I knew you would come to my rescue!” The fairy squeaked gleefully. “The air is heavy with sorrow! Dampened by my torrent of tears! Oh how ravenous I am for freedom, to be able to spread my wilted wings through under the cold, silver stars once more.” She gasped weakly, swaying back and forth, before collapsing with her hand on her forehead, palm facing up. “Oh pretty, pretty, pretty…pretty pleaseee…Don’t let this freakish being get the best of you! What had the fairy tales taught you, Margaret? Be the hero! Bring me salvation! Who would you choose? The distressed fairy, or the heinous goblin, Margaret?” She sniffs.
Margaret pressed her brows together in contemplation.
The brownie pressed his brows together in disbelief. “Comical is all this is! Is she part of a theatrical play? Why is she speaking in riddles?” He spoke in an astonished tone. “If you must know, Margaret, she is of no evil, as there is no such thing in the world, it is the word men came up with for desire and greed. Fairies bear frail and malformed children quite frequently, this one in particular couldn’t come to terms with the fact.” He paused. “These fairies kidnap children of the human kind at night, swapping their own offspring as changelings in replacement.”
“Changelings?” Margaret asked.
“Yes, as its name suggests. Their looks imitate the stolen child, though most end up looking a bit off due to the limits of magic. An extra toe, sharp ears, constant shrills, and a voracious appetite, occasionally accompany the transformation.” His gaze turns towards the door. “There aren’t many people left who can bear to stomach my unsightly appearance. Annie was such a gentle soul…It is such a shame…”
That is simply not true. Margaret and Annie had been arguing about whose turn it was to feed the hens just yesterday, she was so mad at mother for picking Annie’s side that she decided she vowed to never talk to her again. Never in all of eternity. Annie is sleeping soundly upstairs now, the Annie I had known all my life. My big sister.
“Unfortunately, I do not know where she took Annie. Their little den I assume. Do not be deceived, Margaret, for the fairy is a shapeshifter. She appears differently to everyone—the manifestation of what the viewer considers to be the ideal of being fair and innocent. In truth, Margaret, she bears no shimmering wings; those were only spun up in recent decades by gentlefolk to put children to sleep, stripping away ambiguity, and sorting the word into two neat piles of good and evil. But the world isn’t neat, Margaret. I was only painted as the villain due to my crooked face.”
Margaret hadn’t realized that her cheeks were wet from tears, and her nose was stuffy with snot. “You’re lying! You’re lying! You are!” She smudges her tears with a sleeve. “Annie is upstairs, she is! My big sissy…” Anger spread across her face.
“Release that poor fairy! Release her!” She starts marching towards the goblin, who was still clinging tight to the lantern, her hands tightened into fists.
“Stop now, Margaret! Stop right this second!” He yelled. “The lantern is sealed with magic! I cannot fend both of us once the fairy escapes, for she is far too powerful, and I am far too old.” He starts backing up.
“Liar! Liar! Liar!” She yelled, while continuing to advance forward.
“I knew you could do it, Margaret! Look past his lies, open the trap door!” The fairy said encouragingly.
Margaret had come face to face with the pair, and wrapped both her arms around the lantern. She pulled back, and the goblin pulled the other way. “Hand it over!” She yelled, tears spilling off her eyes. “There is still time to undo this!” The goblin pleaded. The lantern casted a flickering shadow of the struggle across the basement walls: A pull to the right, and a pull to the left, another pull to the right, with Margaret placing her foot on the goblin’s tiny body, assisting with pushing him away and prying the lantern out of his grimy little hands. The lantern came loose, and Margaret stumbled backwards with her arms wrapped around the lantern. The goblin also flew backwards, slamming against the floor.
“Good girl. Such a clever girl. Now set me free.” The fairy stared at her, eyes glimmering, through the thin glass.
“NO!” The goblin held his hands out to Margaret, as she pinched the tiny lever, freeing the ethereal being.
The door swung open, and the fairy flew out with grace.
She bashed her eyelashes, and twirled her fingers at the goblin, “Boop!”
“Now…Dance!” she giggled. “Dance till your feet fall off, and blood whelms out of your heels.” she giggled again.
Golden dust traveled through the air, and circled the goblin. He started dancing, tapping his feet, clapping his hands, swaying to a non-existent tune. An uncanny smile spread across his face. The fairy giggled.
“Now that I’ve released him from himself, what is your wish, dear?” The fairy turned towards Margaret. “For releasing me.”
There wasn’t a doubt in her mind. There wasn’t a moment of pause. “I want Annie.” Margaret said, while sniffing with a snot filled nose. The goblin was still dancing.
“Very well, dear.” She twirled her fingers at Margaret, and golden specks circled her from head to toe. “I must go now, dear.” She giggled, her eyes crinkled into two upside-down crescents.
There was a little poof of fairy dust followed by thick smoke, before the fairy disappeared.
There was once again silence in the air, other than the tapping of feet.
“Tattarrattat…Tattarrattat…” Something was pounding on the basement door. “Oh Mar—Ga—Ret—!” a shrill voice came from behind it. “Little sissy, open the door for me, would you?” It said, “My fingers are conjoined! I cannot get a grip on the handle. Oh I do not know why, little sissy. But would you open the door for me?” The voice was both adult-like, and child-like, a parallel between harsh and piping “For your big sissy.”
The goblin was still dancing, still smiling, and tears streamed down his tense face.
“Tattarrattat…”
“Coming, sissy.”
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Be careful what you wish for with fairies! I can't tell if she got conned or made the right choice, but I think that only makes it better.
Reply
She definitely got conned! In the end I wrote that Annie had conjoined fingers, which connected to most changelings being deformed in some way, though I should've emphasized that more for clarity. Thank you for reading my story!
Reply
You’re welcome. Thanks for writing it.
Reply
Very vivid imagery and imaginative language! Creates a darkly whimsical picture in my mind. Definitely could see there being so much more to this story!
Reply
Thanks Sophia! That's the picture I wanted to paint :)
Reply
Amazing
Reply
Thank you so muchhh!
Reply
Hi Leah, I found the reversal of the traditional fairy-tale roles especially unsettling. The fairy's sweetness initially makes her seem trustworthy, but her delight in making the brownie dance reveals something far darker. And that final voice behind the basement door, with its mention of conjoined fingers, is such a chilling detail. Did you always envision Margaret's wish having such a disturbing consequence?
Reply
I'm so glad you enjoyed the story, Shalom. And Yes! I've always envisioned the ending to be a big reveal that Annie had been replaced by a changeling from the start.
Reply
Amazing stuff! Obviously, I guessed correctly. haha
Just curious though, do you by any chance plan to publish a refined version of this or probably some other book in the near future?
Reply