On the Road Again

Horror Mystery Suspense

Written in response to: "Set your story in a car, plane, or train." as part of Full Throttle.

I saw them too late – reflective glints of two closely spaced eyes, low to the ground, round and bright in my headlights.

THUMP – then my right front wheel lifted off the road and nearly sent me into a tailspin. I recovered the wheel, then cursed my aging Ford Fiesta for its poor handling.

Behind me, in the moonlight, a motionless object lay in the road and receded into the distance. From its size and shape, probably a racoon. I felt terrible, hitting a wild animal like that, but it was over and done with, and I was on a mission.

It was late, Levinsville finally in my rear view mirror, and I had the highway to myself. Like most folks fleeing a bad breakup, I was single-minded in putting at least a hundred miles between me and my ex. My foot had grown heavy on the pedal, I admit - I was doing seventy in a fifty zone, but my brother Jacob, a local cop, told me they never set up speed traps on this stretch of road. At least not late on a Tuesday night. 

Nonetheless, I slowed down, and when I passed the Darnestown exit a few minutes later and cleared a low ridge, the landscape ahead was filled with a gridwork of streetlights, traffic lights, and billboard signs.

Switching on the radio, I searched for a listenable station and finally settled for a fuzzy country song. When I looked back up into my rearview mirror, there was a police cruiser, lights flashing, gaining on me rapidly. That’s when I entered the construction zone, and I was suddenly constrained to a single narrow lane, cement walls on both sides side, with no shoulder.

Shit! The cop was drawing close, his siren audible above the music. Wherever he was off to, I didn’t want to slow him down, so I switched off the radio and did the only thing I could – I floored it. The cop was practically riding my bumper as the Fiesta’s orange needle struggled past ninety.

We continued on, my car’s engine straining, front end shimmying. Less than a mile until the road widened, thank God. That’s when I drifted back to Linda and our breakup, when she threatened to tell my folks how I’d dumped my court-ordered psych meds down the toilet. We’d never seen eye to eye on their side effects – a mental fog that, though they controlled my symptoms, left me like a zombie.

My tension ratcheted tighter when I saw, beyond the “end of road work” sign, another cruiser sitting on the right shoulder, lights flashing to beat the band. I breathed easier when the concrete walls on both sides fell away, and I switched to the slow lane and took my foot off the gas to let the police pass.

The cruiser slowed, too, and pulled up beside me on my left. His passenger window rolled down. From behind the wheel, he poked his finger at me, then to the right shoulder. Yet worse, the cruiser that had been sitting on the side of the road a half mile back was now right behind me, siren wailing.

God damn it! My brother was full of shit – I’d been speed-trapped miles back, then led the cops on a high-speed chase due solely to a misunderstanding.

By the time I pulled over, one cruiser in front of me, one behind, I was fumbling for my license and registration when a loud voice boomed from a loudspeaker.

“Shut off your engine and put both hands out the driver’s side window! Now!”

----

From the backseat of the cruiser parked behind my Fiesta, I watched as two officers, one young, one probably in his forties, carefully inspected the right front end of my car. The younger guy snapped cell phone shots while the other pointed at things while appearing to give the junior officer an on-the-spot tutorial.

The cuffs on my wrists felt humiliating, cold, and too tight, and I kept flexing my fingers, hoping they wouldn’t go numb. How many times I’d watched scenes like this on TV – it felt surreal now. Nightmarish. I couldn’t fathom being in cuffs – me, a line cook at the local greasy spoon with nothing more than a few parking tickets on my record.

I’d told them about the breakup, about hitting what I figured was a raccoon, and how I thought they just wanted past me. But they’d only wanted to know exactly when I’d left Levinsville, and which route I’d taken out of town.

The cruiser’s engine idled, the interior comfortably warm. Occasional bursts of conversation, spiked liberally with obscure cop-speak, squawked from the radio, and I jumped every time. The landscape around me was a fluid interplay of blue and red, and my stomach writhed as yet another cruiser, lights flashing, pulled in behind me. Soon, two cops climbed out, including a portly, older looking guy.

All four officers conferred at the front of my car, until the portly guy approached me, opened the passenger door, and climbed in. When he turned around, I saw the word Sheriff embroidered on his breast pocket. His well-shaven chin doubled as he stared at me, eyes glinting in the cruiser’s dome light. I could smell coffee on his breath.

“Why’d you flee the scene of an accident?” he said.

“Who? That raccoon? I could see it was dead lying in the road behind me. I’m sorry I hit it, but –“

“There was no raccoon in the road, mister Phillips,” he said. “But there’s a husband and father of three back there, who was rushed to the hospital, and the outlook for him is pretty grim.”

Fear gripped me, and my heart roared in my chest as I wondered how they could think I did something so terrible. That was no man in the road behind me, but a smaller animal.

“It was small, whatever I hit. On the highway, just a few… a few miles back!”

My voice trembled, words catching in my throat. I swallowed hard between sentences.

“I already told you – none of us saw any road kill on the highway. No, this happened in town.”

At this, I expelled a breath of relief. My drive out of town had been uneventful. I knew they had the wrong guy, and trusting the justice system as I did, I knew we’d clear this up on short order.

“I’m gonna get you out of the car and walk you up front, so you can see for yourself,” he said. "Let's go."

A minute later, his hand firmly gripping my shoulder, he guided me forward along the right side of my car. When we stepped out front and I turned around, I couldn’t believe what I saw. 

The right front of my car was severely smashed in, the headlight shattered and dangling near the pavement on a wire. In the Sheriff’s flashlight beam, I saw the huge smear of drying blood on the smashed in region. The blood reached clear up to the hood, and it seemed hard to believe that a small raccoon could cause that much splatter.

“We’ve taken samples of this blood, already, Mister Phillips, and we’re impounding your vehicle as part of our investigation. What concerns us most, though, is this.”

The Sheriff stepped forward and pointed at a blood-soaked, tattered piece of fabric wedged between two crimped pieces of the car’s front grille. One corner of the fabric was clean of blood, showing a checkered pattern.

“This matches the pattern and color of the shirt worn by the man now fighting for his life.”

Just then, the Sheriff’s cell phone rang, and he answered it. He spoke for about half a minute, then hung up.

“Mister Phillips,” he said, his face like stone, “I’m afraid the victim has died. This is now a homicide investigation.”

My mind raced as I tried to find some rationale for the damage to my car, the huge amount of blood, the torn fabric.

“But… I didn’t hit…”

Dizziness swirled in, and my legs turned to rubber. A flash of searing pain as my shoulder struck something hard on the way down. Then darkness…

----

I’d hardly slept in the cramped cell at the Levinsville jail. My right shoulder throbbed constantly with pain, and it screamed if I moved my arm. A big scrape on my face, too, from when I hit the pavement, and it hurt to move my jaw.

Blurred memories from last night ebbed and flowed as I struggled to remember the drive out of town, hitting the animal in the road, the police chase, and the questioning later at the station. I remembered volunteering to take a polygraph, to prove I didn’t hit the man walking along Cooper Street. The man who had died.

I'd used my one phone call to ring Linda. Frankly, I was surprised when she answered, especially so late a night. I pleaded with her to come down to the station and explain what kind of man I was, and how this was all some dreadful misunderstanding, but she said she’d arrive sometime this morning. When she told me I needed a lawyer, I blew up, shouting I didn’t need a goddamn lawyer. That’s when she hung up. Whether she'd show up today, I had no idea.

Raising my one good hand to test the scrape on my face, I saw ink smudges covering my fingertips, from when they took my prints during the booking process. The booking officer said he’d scan the prints and upload them into a national print database.

A half hour later, Sheriff Jones – I’d learned his name only after we reached the station – came to my cell with his chief detective. The detective looked bleary from lack of sleep, a younger fellow, with close-cropped blonde hair and steel blue eyes. He introduced himself as Detective Myers.

“I have a picture to show you," Myers said. "Something we caught as the suspect’s car, after the accident, drove past the bank and was caught on their monitor camera.”

He unfolded a sheet of printer paper and held it up for me to inspect. Sure enough – there was a light-colored Ford Fiesta, photographed moving right to left in the direction I had driven. But I pointed and grinned when I saw the head of the driver.

“He’s wearing a cowboy hat!” I said.

“Yes, he is,” said Myers.

“Well, then that can’t be me!” I said. “I don’t own a hat like that. Never even wore one.”

This was great news. One of their best pieces of evidence against me would help exonerate me.

“Well, then can you explain how we found a hat matching this description beneath the rear hatch of your car?” Myers said.

“Impossible!” I said. 

I was on a nightmarish emotional rollercoaster. I’d gone from relieved to terrified to relieved more times than I could count in the past eight hours. Now, my heart was back in my throat, thumping.

The detective removed a blue rubber glove from his pocket, stretched it on, stepped outside my cell, and came back in holding a crumpled, tan cowboy-style hat in his gloved hand.

“Your prints are on this brown band down here near the brim,” he said. 

This couldn’t be happening. How could my prints be on a hat I’d never seen before?

Just then, another guy, in a white shirt and striped tie, appeared in the doorway.

“Sheriff, we just got results back from that AFIS run on his prints.”

“And?” Sheriff Jones said.

“You ain’t gonna believe it, Sir,” he said, a sheepish, almost guilty expression on his face.

The Sheriff reached out, and the man handed him a sheet of paper. As his eyes scanned it, they grew wide with amazement. He leaned back against the wall to steady himself.

“What the hell’s going on here?” he said. His face had gone pale, and I wondered if he was about to faint.

“What?” Myers said.

“His prints match those of Silvers?" Sheriff Jones said. "Jeremy Silvers?”

Who the hell is that, I wondered, my gaze shifting quickly among the three men.

“Who’s Jeremy Silvers?” I said, as everyone in the room but me looked like they’d just seen a ghost.

“Serial killer,” Myers said.  “Raped and strangled seven women over five years.”

I was reeling back in terror when Myers spoke again.

“Problem is – Silvers died twelve years ago. In the electric chair…”

Posted Nov 17, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 likes 3 comments

November 19, 2026 08:57

I really enjoyed the escalating suspense. Each new revelation and twist came at the right moment, keeping me guessing about what truly happened. The narrator’s vivid, believable reactions—his panic and flashes of relief—made the confusion and fear feel real and believable. The final reveal was especially chilling and left me wondering who the narrator truly is and what exactly happened. Great work!

Reply

Alex Merola
November 17, 2026 18:55

Scott, spooky story, nice build up to the end. A who's who? It made me think, twins? ghost? doppelganger? or maybe he's the real serial killer who faked his death? 🤔 I'll have to think of this a bit more. Thanks for a good read.

Reply

Scott Speck
November 17, 2026 21:00

Alex, thanks for reading and commenting. I wonder if his identical twin might've been the serial killer. And is he delusional, since he stopped taking court-mandated psych drugs? Hmmm...

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.