I think I've decided that you owe me an explanation.
Not for anything important. Although, depending on how you look at it, perhaps it is important.
Anyways, did you finish the peanut butter already?
I gave you that jar a while ago, and I don't think I ever asked. I suppose I could just ask you, but that would require having an actual conversation, and apparently we've become quite bad at those.
I don't really know how to start this.
I suppose I could start by telling you that I'm writing this because I think it might help. That if I put everything somewhere outside my head, maybe I'll finally stop going over it. Maybe I'll stop wondering about things I have no way of knowing, or looking for meaning in things that probably don't mean anything anymore.
I miss you.
There. That's probably the simplest way to say it.
I miss being your friend. I miss seeing you every day, having conversations that started with absolutely nothing and somehow lasted until we had to go somewhere else. I miss the jokes that would have made no sense to anyone standing next to us. I miss knowing that if something happened, there was a reasonable chance I'd get to tell you about it before the day was over.
I miss the ordinary things most, I think.
It's strange how little I remember about some days and how clearly I remember others. I couldn't tell you what we talked about on a random Tuesday, but I remember certain sentences almost word for word. I remember things you said without thinking, things I probably laughed at and forgot about at the time. Apparently, I didn't forget.
We never finished that list of phrases. You know what I'm talking about.
I wonder if you remember it. I wonder if you ever say something that belonged on the list and thought about sending it to me. I wonder if you even remember that there was a list.
Actually, I wonder a lot of things.
It's been two years since we met. About a year since you started disappearing. I don't know which of those dates I should consider more important.
I suppose the first one is easier to remember. The second one doesn't have an exact date. There wasn't a particular day when you stopped talking to me. No argument, no dramatic goodbye, no final conversation that I could go back to and identify as the moment everything changed.
You just started becoming less available.
At first, I didn't think much of it. We had always known that distance would make things different. I had moved to another country, another continent, and we couldn't exactly keep doing what we used to do. It was reasonable to expect things to change.
Besides, you had your own life. I had mine. There were new people, new places, new things to get used to.
I understood that.
I still do, actually.
What I didn't understand was why it felt like you were making an effort not to talk to me.
Maybe you weren't. Maybe I'm being unfair. But I know you still see my stories. I know we're still following each other. I know we have the same friends, and every once in a while we exchange a birthday message or reply to something the other person posts. We're not strangers, technically.
But we're not friends in the way we used to be either.
And I think that's what bothers me. You're still around enough for me to notice that you're not there.
I know you see things I post. Sometimes I even post things because I know you'd like them. A song, usually. Something I think you'd appreciate, or something that reminds me of a conversation we had. I tell myself I would have posted it anyway, which is probably true. But I also know that part of me is waiting to see whether you notice.
And when you do, nothing happens.
When you don't, I notice that too.
I know how ridiculous that sounds. I know I'm spending time thinking about whether someone liked a story. I'm aware that this is not a particularly productive use of my time. I can recognize how stupid it is while I'm doing it, which somehow makes it worse.
Sometimes I wonder if you know how much I still notice you. Probably not. I don't exactly announce it. I don't think anyone would guess how much thought I can give to something as insignificant as a song appearing on my screen.
I still have your location, by the way. I don't check it constantly. I want that on record. But sometimes I remember that I can, and sometimes I do. It's strange knowing where someone is without knowing what they're thinking. I can know whether you're at home or somewhere else, but I don't know whether you ever think about me.
I know you don't live in Dublin anymore, which is unfortunate because I really wanted to visit. I wonder what it's like wherever you are now. Whether you still make music as much as you used to, whether you found people to work with, whether you still listen to Bowie. I wonder if you remember that I still have to show you how to make those tortillas.
I wonder if you remember a lot of things.
I remember the names you called me, too. Mi amor. Princesa.
You didn't even speak the language.
I used to laugh. Sometimes I changed the subject. Sometimes I pretended I hadn't heard you properly. I didn't know what you expected me to say, and I didn't want to make things awkward by asking. I thought we could just keep being friends. I wanted to keep being friends.
I don't know if you understood that.
I've thought about this more times than I care to admit. Maybe you thought I was rejecting something you had never actually asked for. Maybe you were waiting for me to say something, and when I didn't, you decided there was no point in continuing. Maybe you were trying to tell me something and I kept pretending not to understand because I was afraid of what would happen if I did.
I don't know.
And I am sorry if I hurt you.
I don't know how many times I've thought about writing that sentence. I'm sorry if I made you feel like you weren't important to me. I'm sorry if I made you feel stupid for saying those things. I'm sorry if you were trying to be honest with me and I laughed because I didn't know what else to do. I'm sorry if I made you feel like I didn't care.
Because I did.
I cared about you. I still do, unfortunately.
I don't know what I was supposed to do differently. I don't know if there even was anything I could have done. Maybe you didn't want anything from me. Maybe you were perfectly happy with the way things were, and I'm just looking back at ordinary conversations and giving them meanings they never had.
But what if you weren't?
What if you were waiting for me to say something, and I didn't? What if you went home after one of those conversations feeling embarrassed, or disappointed, or convinced that I didn't feel the same way? What if you thought I was leading you on when I genuinely thought we were just being ourselves?
I hate that I can't ask you.
Actually, I hate that I feel like I can't ask you. There's a difference. I could send you a message right now. I could ask how you've been, how music is going, whether you've finished the peanut butter. I could pretend I haven't spent the last year wondering why we stopped talking.
But I don't want to be the person who keeps reaching out when the other person has stopped making an effort. I don't want to ask whether everything is okay when I suspect the answer is that everything is perfectly fine, just without me.
And I don't want to ask you what I meant to you, because I'm afraid of the answer. Or perhaps I'm afraid there won't be one.
I know I'm doing it again. Turning everything into a question. I wish I could just leave things alone.
I also don't know why I still think about you so much.
That's what really frustrates me. I know I'm obsessed with this. I know it's been too long to be giving someone this much space in my head, especially someone I barely speak to anymore. I have other things to do. I meet people, make friends, have conversations, listen to music, go about my life. It's not as if I'm sitting around waiting for you to come back.
Except sometimes I am, in a way.
Not consciously. I don't wake up expecting a message from you. But I'll see something and think you'd find it funny. I'll hear a song and wonder if you know it. I'll hear a phrase that reminds me of our list and suddenly I'm thinking about you again. Sometimes I post something because I know you'd like it, and then I hate myself a little for checking whether you saw it.
Why?
Seriously, why?
I don't even know what I would do if you came back. Would I be happy? Of course I would. Would I want things to be the way they were? I think so. But what if they couldn't be? What if we'd have to talk about everything that happened, and I discovered that I had misunderstood the entire situation? What if you told me you had feelings for me and I realized I still didn't know what I wanted?
I don't know if I want you back in that way. I don't know if I ever did.
I just know I want my friend back.
And maybe that's not fair either. Maybe I can't expect you to remain the person I remember just because I haven't figured out how to stop missing him.
One year. That's all we got.
Sometimes I think that's why I can't let it go. We never got to find out what kind of friends we would have been if we had lived in the same place longer. We never got the chance to become the people who could go months without talking and then pick up exactly where they left off. We never got to have the ordinary years that make a friendship feel permanent.
We had one year, and then I left.
Maybe the distance was enough to end it. Maybe it was already ending before I went. Maybe something changed between us that neither of us knew how to address.
I wish I knew.
I don't want to make you sound like a bad person. You're not. At least, I don't think you are. I know you have your reasons, whatever they are. I know people change, circumstances change, and sometimes friendships are only meant to last as long as the circumstances that brought people together.
I understand that.
I just wish understanding it made it easier.
I think I've been waiting for something. I don't know what. A message that isn't a birthday greeting. A reply that turns into an actual conversation. Some indication that you have also noticed the distance and that it bothers you, even a little.
I want to know if you miss me.
Not necessarily in the way I miss you. Not necessarily enough to want to do anything about it. I just want to know if I cross your mind sometimes. If something reminds you of me. If you ever start telling someone a story and realize I was part of it. If you remember the things you used to call me, or the conversations we had, or the fact that I still owe you tortillas.
I want to know that I wasn't the only one who thought our friendship mattered.
I don't need to have been the most important person in your life. I don't even need to be someone you miss regularly. I just want to know that, for a little while, I was as difficult to forget as you have been for me.
Maybe that's selfish. I don't know.
I started writing this because I thought I needed to say goodbye. I thought that if I could explain everything to you, even if you never read it, I might finally be able to stop thinking about it.
I suppose I wanted to put it somewhere, get it out of my head, and be done with it. I'll probably burn this when I'm finished. It seems fitting. There's something embarrassing about keeping a letter addressed to someone who doesn't even know it's been written.
But I keep finding more things to say.
I hope you're happy. I hope the music is going well. I hope wherever you are now feels like somewhere you want to be. I hope you have people around you who make you feel understood, and that you get to do all the things you once talked about doing.
And I hope, occasionally, that you remember me.
Not because I want you to feel bad. Not because I want you to come back. Just because I'd like to know that, somewhere, there's another person who remembers that year the way I do.
Anyway, I think that's enough.
I still have to show you how to make those tortillas.
See you in Cali?
- Future gardener
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.