Two Bodies And A Shovel

Fantasy Horror Thriller

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

Written in response to: "Set your story in a place where something terrible once happened." as part of What Lingers.

Brown, brown, brown. Brown as far as Miller could see as he pulled on a brown coat and shrugged off his brown mood and tilted his brown hat so that he could gaze better upon brown walls with licks of red.

Haley Lee Jones raises her head. It’s late for trick-or-treaters. And they’d ring the bell, not stomp on the door like the police.

Miller couldn’t get warm. He was on his third cup of coffee and wearing three layers, but this November weather was getting to him. Wind, it was the wind. It got through your sleeves. Crawled its way through you. Chilled you right and straight.

Miller rubbed his face, skin raised. Goosebumps again. But Halloween was over, it was only the cold.

“Sounds like…”

Sounds like.

“A door opening.” Miller finished.

And it was a door opening. Miller didn’t turn his head.

“What do you think, Harvey?” he asked, gazing upon brown ceilings.

“I don’t think anything. I don’t even know what we’re doing here.”

Miller didn’t disagree. “How long has it been since?”

“’Bout a year.”

Miller shook his head. “A year exactly.”

Haley looks around and doesn’t hear a knock. The others are still drunk-dead on the couch and Vivy’s puking her guts up in the toilet so they aren’t expecting anyone outside. But the stomps don’t come again. It’s a creak that comes instead. It sounds like…

“Sounds like…” says Haley.

A door opening.

“And why are we here?”

“Why are you late coming in?”

“Traffic.”

“But did you have to open the door like that and let the wind in?”

“No choice. Why are we here?”

“One-year anniversary. Worried about fans. Copycats.”

“Copycats in the house of the Bannion murders?”

“Brave new world, Harvey.” Miller sighed. “Lots to worry about.”

Miller walked through. This next room was brown, still brown. And red.

“So.” he began, and assumed that Harvey was behind him. And sure enough there was a creak behind him that sounded like

a door opening

and Miller continued. “So, this is where Haley Lee Jones got killed. The others fled and he caught them in the garden over yonder. But she got stabbed here. Then he mangled her body, pushed her down the stairs.”

He pointed to the floor beneath him. “Then he stepped out just as the second girl was walking down the stairs and gutted her too.”

Haley doesn’t know what getting stabbed feels like. It happens twice and then not again, but by that time she’s faint and lies on the floor like a child and her mother is not there. There’s something wet on her neck and her mouth tastes like iron, but she’s cradling her tummy. Then she hears a sound like a creak. That’ll be Vivy, oh Vivy, all done puking as she stumbles out.

Yes, it’ll be Vivy, because that creak sounds like…

Sounds like a door opening.

Haley Lee Jones can scream. It’s all she can do.

“No.”

Miller frowned. “No?”

“No. Vivy was drunk. She fell down the stairs by herself. Then he gutted her.”

Miller

stopped.

“You,” he didn’t look round, “aren’t Harvey.”

“No.”

“How long have you not been Harvey?”

“Since Harvey walked through the door.”

Miller kept brown eyes fixed straight on brown walls in front of him. And didn’t look round.

“Figures.” he said to the thing behind him. “You don’t sound like him.”

“No.”

Miller wiped a sweaty brow with sweaty fingers.

“So, which one are you?”

“Haley.”

“Haley Lee Jones. It’s fucked what he did to you.”

Miller cleared his voice and waited a while. Then he tried again.

“I’m sorry.” then he added, for his own safety: “I’m very sorry.”

“Look at me.”

Miller looked round.

The body of Harvey Eisner was looking at him with vicious hungering, the kind of hungering of someone who can never have what you have. It was Harvey Eisner’s face on Harvey Eisner’s body, but that face was stretched and tugged this way and that, as if draped over a skull that just didn’t quite fit right. Helped by a grin pulled back to the ears that showed yellow teeth. Blood fled from the face and into the eyes, bloodshot eyes that belonged to a dead man.

It was some vicious beast looking back at him. And behind that it was Haley Lee Jones looking through the veil.

“I want to rest. I want my justice.”

Miller found some warmth in him after all, running down his trouser leg. “They got your killer, you know? Got him the night after he murdered you.”

It was a moment before the spectre answered.

“And I’m still dead.”

“And you’re still dead.” Miller stuck his hands down into his pockets and felt the sweat run down his face. Warm, warm, warm. November, it felt too warm for November, it couldn’t be November surely.

“Where is my justice?” the voice grew a little deeper. The face pulled back a little more.

“They shot your man nine times. Once in the balls. He died suffering.”

“That isn’t my justice.” said the shape of Haley Lee Jones through fierce eyes. “There is no justice here for me. Can I taste this justice? Can I smell this justice? Can I feel this justice under my own two feet?”

Her face was all a blur to him. And it was only when he saw his own trembling hands that he understood why.

“What… what do you want?”

Miller heard a creak as the thing stepped forward. It sounded like a door, just like a door opening.

“Give me my dues. Give me my commiserations. Let me be remembered.”

The shape of Haley Lee Jones raised a finger and pointed. And to the place she pointed hunched over a body, a body whose door had opened and whose soul had fled.

“Take a shovel and go down that hill. Take my body and anoint it with all the love and care passed down from mother to child. Bury me and heap dirt upon my grave in multitudes under the gaze of a weeping willow.”

Haley Lee Jones raised her full, red face, eyes burning, mouth still locked in an awful grin or grimace like some wild beast.

“And pay your rites to the dead as they did down old country.”

Miller took a shovel. And stepped out.

And when it was done and the earth was set upon her and Haley Lee Jones was lain entombed, Miller turned round and spoke a word. A word only.

Haley Lee Jones is looking up at brown, brown, brown. Brown stained with red. It’s a man’s face in front of her but she can’t really tell what it is, and he turns away. And there’s a creak.

And it sounds like…

Just like.

Miller tossed the shovel aside and kept walking.

Posted Nov 06, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

1 like 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.