Submitted to: Contest #333

An Empty Plate Is Never Empty

Written in response to: "Start or end your story with an empty plate, empty glass, or something burning."

Desi

This story contains themes or mentions of mental health issues.

I wake up knowing I am eighteen years old.

I know this the way you know your own name, the way memory settles into bone and refuses to leave, even when the body it belongs to is suddenly wrong. My mind is heavy with years, with guilt and hunger and shame that has learned how to sit quietly, but when I open my eyes, I am staring at a ceiling I have not seen in a decade, and my legs—when I swing them over the edge of the bed—do not reach the floor.

I am not confused about who I am.

I am confused about where I am.

There is a girl sleeping beside me.

She is eight years old. Her cheeks are soft, her breathing uneven, as if even sleep makes her anxious. She does not know what is coming. She does not know what she will spend years trying to fix, punish, and erase. She does not know she will grow up believing that her body is the reason people are allowed to be cruel to her.

I know all of this.

That is the difference between us.

I am not her—I am with her, trapped behind her eyes, watching her life replay itself while carrying the full weight of what it will become.

From the kitchen, steel clangs against steel, oil spits in a pan, and my father’s voice slices cleanly through the morning.

“Amaya.”

The girl stirs.

“Amaya!” he calls again, louder now. “Get up.”

The door opens before she can move properly. He stands there, already displeased, already assessing.

His eyes go to her body first.

“You’ve been eating too much,” he says, like this is a fact, like this is something already proven.

She sits up slowly, blinking. “I just woke up.”

“That doesn’t change anything,” he replies. “Look at you.”

I feel her confusion rise, sharp and helpless. She doesn’t know what she has done wrong yet. She only knows that something about her is wrong.

“Come here,” he says.

She obeys, because she always has.

He makes her stand straight. He tells her to lift her arms. He looks at her stomach like it has personally disappointed him.

“You’re getting fat,” he says. “At eight. Do you understand how bad that is?”

Her throat tightens. Mine does too, though I no longer need this body to feel the damage.

“I’m not—” she tries.

“Don’t talk back,” he snaps. “From today, exercise every morning. No sweets. No second helpings. Twenty jumping jacks. Now.”

She hesitates, just for a second, because she is tired and small and still believes adults might change their minds if she looks scared enough.

They don’t.

She drops to the floor.

“One… two…”

By ten, her arms shake. By fifteen, her breathing breaks. Her face twists with effort, with fear, with the desperate need to do this correctly so she will not be scolded again.

“This is for your own good,” he says. “No one likes a fat girl.”

When he leaves, she stays on the floor.

I stay with her.

I want to tell her that this moment will never leave her, that it will crawl into every mirror she ever looks into, every meal she ever eats, every kindness she ever believes she doesn’t deserve.

But she cannot hear me.

***

I am ten when I watch her learn that pretty is conditional.

The classroom smells like chalk and sweat and something sour I can never quite name. She sits at her desk, trying to take up less space, trying to be invisible.

A girl leans over. “If you lost some weight,” she says lightly, “you’d actually be really pretty.”

Another laughs. “Yeah. Right now you’re just cute.”

Cute is what you call something you don’t want to choose.

“I don’t care,” my younger self says, too quickly, because she cares more than anything.

The teacher hears. She smiles like she is being kind.

“They’re just being honest,” she says. “You should be grateful.”

The word grateful sticks.

In the bathroom, the girl presses at her stomach, at her arms, pinching skin between her fingers like it is something she could tear away if she tried hard enough.

“Why can’t you just be normal?” she whispers.

I stand behind her in the mirror, older, quieter, knowing that this question will become a habit.

***

At fifteen, the cruelty becomes efficient.

No one needs to say it out loud anymore.

In tuition class, boys snicker when she walks in. She wears clothes that are too big, too layered, hiding what she has learned is unacceptable.

“She doesn’t belong here,” one mutters.

She hears. She always hears.

At home, she stops eating.

“I ate already,” she tells her mother.

She lies easily now.

Her stomach growls at night, loud enough to scare her. She presses her hands against it and whispers, “Control. Just control.”

By sixteen, the hunger works.

The weight falls off. Compliments arrive.

“You look so good now.”

“Finally taking care of yourself.”

“See? It wasn’t that hard.”

She feels proud.

I feel grief.

***

At seventeen, she believes she has earned her place.

Boys look at her. Teachers soften. The world feels kinder.

Then the pressure returns. Fear tightens its grip. One night, alone, she breaks.

She eats until it hurts. Until shame fills her throat and doesn’t let her breathe. Then she eats again.

The cycle comes back louder, crueler.

The weight returns. More than before.

So do the voices.

***

Now I am eighteen again.

I sit alone at the table.

In front of me is an empty plate.

Not forgotten. Not abandoned. Finished.

I know exactly what this plate means.

Either I have eaten one full meal—without counting, without punishing myself, without promising I will make up for it later—and decided, finally, to stop letting the world decide whether I deserve to exist comfortably in my own body.

Or I have eaten for the last time.

The plate does not tell you which.

But I do.

Because for the first time in my life, I am not afraid of what comes next.

Posted Dec 17, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

7 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.