THE SHAPE OF SILENCE

American Coming of Age Contemporary

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the lines “Why should I believe you?” or “Give me one good reason to trust you.”" as part of Two Sides to Every Story with Emily Martin.

Her parents were proud of the daughter who worked beside them without complaint.

She never chased after young men.

Never spoke of dreams beyond Macaw's city limits.

Never asked for a life different from the one she'd been given.

To them, the grocery store wasn't simply a business.

It was the family.

It had fed three generations.

It would feed the next.

Luna had heard those words so often that she stopped questioning, "Why should I believe you?" and believed them.

Each morning began before sunrise. She unlocked the front door while the village still slept, swept yesterday's dust from the wooden floor, stacked fresh bread on the shelves, polished fingerprints from the front window, and filled the penny-candy jars before the first customer arrived.

By the time the bell above the door rang, everything looked effortless.

No one saw the work behind it.

They saw only Luna's smile.

Mr. Rosario insisted she smiled brighter than anyone else in Macaw.

Mrs. Luxema said the grocery store felt warmer whenever Luna laughed.

Children lingered over penny candy they couldn't afford because Luna always found an extra peppermint somewhere beneath the counter.

Farmers stayed longer than they intended.

Neighbours came for flour but left with conversation.

Some afternoons no one bought anything at all.

They came to spend a few minutes with Luna.

If kindness had a home in Macaw, it stood behind the grocery-store counter.

Yet every evening, after the last customer had gone and the day's receipts had been counted, the warmth disappeared.

The villagers saw Luna.

Her parents saw another day's work completed.

She never blamed them.

They loved her the only way they knew how.

It simply wasn't the way she longed to be loved.

Then continue with the disappearance:

"You are almost done for the day," her father called.

It was an ordinary afternoon.

The kind no one remembers.

Until it becomes the day that changes everything.

Luna lifted a wooden crate of potatoes and carried it toward the back entrance.

Beyond the store, her father crossed the vegetable garden, stopping every few steps to inspect the tomatoes and beans before closing up for the evening.

She smiled.

Then she saw him stumble.

The crate slipped from her hands.

Potatoes scattered across the hard-packed earth, rolling beneath the porch and into the grass as she ran.

"Dad!"

He reached toward her.

His knees buckled.

She never reached him.

Halfway across the field, an impossible weight settled across her shoulders.

It spread through her arms.

Her legs.

Every step demanded more strength than the last.

The afternoon light dulled.

The edges of the world blurred.

Her father's voice drifted away, no longer a desperate cry but a distant echo carried across still water.

She fought for another step.

Then another.

The ground rose beneath her feet.

The earth opened.

And took her.

When Luna opened her eyes, the sky was gone.

She lay at the bottom of a vast earthen chamber whose walls disappeared into darkness high overhead. Thick roots wound through damp clay like ancient hands reaching for something they had once known.

Water dripped somewhere beyond her sight.

Each drop echoed once...

...then dissolved into silence.

She screamed, "Give me one good reason to trust you?"

The earth felt watchful and full.

"Dad?"

Her voice floated upward and vanished before it reached the darkness.

"Mama?"

Only another drop of unseen water answered.

Luna climbed.

The walls crumbled beneath her fingers.

She climbed again.

Clay broke away in damp handfuls, sending her sliding back to the bottom each time she thought she'd found another foothold.

Again.

And again.

Eventually she stopped counting.

There was no sunrise.

No sunset.

No shadows to measure the passing of time.

Only the steady rhythm of dripping water and the ache in her arms.

At last she rested against the cool earth.

Not because she had surrendered.

There was nowhere left to climb.

She waited for hunger.

It never came.

She waited for thirst.

That never came either.

Even sleep refused her.

Instead...

The memories arrived.

Not because she searched for them.

Because the earth released them.

She watched herself unlock the grocery store before dawn.

Sweeping yesterday's dust from the floor.

Stacking tins in perfect rows.

Measuring flour into paper sacks.

She listened to the brass bell ring above the door as another neighbour stepped in.

Each memory appeared as clearly as if she were living it again.

Each drifted away just as slowly.

At first she welcomed their passing.

Every forgotten chore lightened a burden she had carried for years.

The aching shoulders.

The sore hands.

The endless routine.

One by one they disappeared.

She felt lighter.

Freer.

She almost smiled.

Then another memory came.

Mr. Rosario pushed open the grocery-store door with exaggerated importance, removed his cap, and bowed so deeply she laughed before he spoke.

"Luna," he announced, "I have arrived. Your day may now officially begin."

She laughed.

Even here.

Even in the darkness.

She opened her mouth to answer...

The memory dissolved.

"No."

She reached into the empty air.

"Please..."

Nothing returned.

Only silence.

Then came the smell of fresh cinnamon bread.

Mrs. Luxema sat at the counter, brushing crumbs from the faded scarf around her shoulders while telling Luna about something ridiculous her grandson had done that week.

Luna leaned closer.

She wanted to hear the ending.

She never did.

The earth gently carried the memory away.

"No..."

This time her voice trembled.

The chores had never mattered.

These did.

Another memory appeared.

Children crowded around the penny-candy jars, arguing over peppermints and licorice.

A farmer tipped his hat before collecting his flour.

Mrs. Luxema tucked another loaf of fresh bread beneath her arm.

Mr. Rosario laughed at his own terrible joke.

They came.

They smiled.

They left.

One by one, the memories faded before she could hold them.

Luna chased everyone.

She reached for faces. For voices. For laughter.

Each slipped quietly beyond her grasp.

The earth remembered.

Luna was beginning to forget.

She closed her eyes and searched for one face she could still call her own.

None came.

Only a feeling remained.

Someone had once loved her.

She could no longer remember who.

Luna held on to that feeling as tightly as she could.

Somewhere above, someone was still holding on to her.

Posted Jul 25, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

12 likes 4 comments

August 06, 2026 04:37

Your name is familiar to me as I looked down the list of stories with this prompt. (I chose the same one.) You have so many stories and so many earned points. And I have never read any of your stories. You also started in Reedsy before me. I came back from other writing because this prompt appealed to me. But this about you. I agree with everything Harry Stuart said. A beautiful and unsettling story. Because of the theme this week I knew something would change with Luna's orderly routine. And then when her father needed her the most, she couldn't get to him. At least she is with someone. We need a sequel to solve this dilemma. Great story. From Kaitlyn

Reply

Lily Finch
August 06, 2026 20:24

Hi Kaitlyn,
Thanks for saying such nice things about my writing. I'm unsure if it's beautiful and unsettling. - I am glad that you knew something would change with Luna's orderly routine.
"But this about you?" I do not understand this line.
Thanks for reading and commenting,
Lily

Reply

Harry Stuart
July 25, 2026 13:01

I have owed you feedback for several months now.  Apologies for the delay, as I always enjoy reading your stories. This one is beautifully packed.  The prose is melodic - it flows effortlessly with images of summertime.  The references to flowers and sunlight carry us through Luna's journey. Nice touch to reinforce those images in the names of the townsfolk, Mrs Luxema and Mr Rosario. 

Some of my favorite lines:

-Silence settled between them while cicadas carried the evening where conversation no longer could.

-Together they watched the shadows creep across the flowers until daylight quietly surrendered.  

-The word felt warm somehow, like sunlight remembered by stone.

-The seasons turned without asking permission.

-She closed her eyes and breathed in lavender, fresh bread, and sunshine warmed into old cotton. None of it brought back a name, but all of it felt like home.

A nostalgic, sentimental story of how loss and grief are shaped by the spaces of silence and the continual trudge of time.  Enjoyed it, Lily!

Reply

Lily Finch
July 25, 2026 18:57

Harry, why, I am just so gracious with your comments. I am happy, too, that you enjoy this one so much. I wrote the story from a variety of emotions that surrounded me as I took on poor Luna's plight and that of the villagers who shared equally in the pain of loneliness.
It's wonderful to me how humans migrate to what draws us together and, without ever mentioning it, create a bond because of it.
Thanks for reading and for the kind words about my stories. You read without ever commenting; that makes me smile.
Lily

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.