Rummaging through my old nightstand drawer, past faded baseball cards and expired boxes of condoms, my fingers brushed the familiar, cheap plastic of a Kodak FunSaver.
I plopped onto my childhood bed and turned the camera over in my hands. A strip of masking tape across the back read SUMMER ’98 in my high-school chicken scratch.
I was sixteen that summer; a scrawny, pizza-faced kid who owned more wallet chains than pairs of shorts.
“Chuck?” Mom called from downstairs.
“Yeah?”
“Does your desk chair bring you joy?”
“No.”
“Then why are we keeping it?”
My parents had just sold the house after my father retired, which meant thirty-two years of Henderson family possessions had to be dealt with. Worse, Mom had recently discovered Marie Kondo.
The camera offered a welcome distraction.
----
When I handed it to the teenager at the CVS photo counter, he smirked. “My grandma used to love these,” he said.
He called his supervisor, and the two of them disappeared into the back room. Half an hour later, the kid returned with a small envelope.
“Film was pretty messed up,” he said. “But we got eleven photos out.”
I paid and went to my car.
The first picture was of Marty Milch holding a knockoff star-shaped Gibson Explorer above his head. He was throwing devil horns with his free hand, his floppy green Mohawk falling over one eye.
I hadn’t thought about Marty in twenty years.
We called him Metal Marty, mostly because he was always trying to get people to cover Metallica songs with him. Our junior year, when he found out I played bass, he asked me to jam every day for three weeks until I finally gave in. Eventually we formed a band, which Marty named Necrosis. We used my parents’ basement as a practice space. I learned after a few weeks, he’d been consistently asking our neighbors - a young couple who’d just moved to Massachusetts from Colorado - if they could sell him any weed.
Dave, who reluctantly joined the band as our drummer after I begged him to be my buffer, used to call Marty a walking toolbag. He’d often joke that if there were a high school superlative for “least likely to succeed,” surely Marty would win.
I took out my phone and sent Dave the photograph.
Chuck: Remember Metal Marty?
Dave: Unfortunately… why?
Chuck: Found a disposable camera from ‘98. He’s in half the pictures
Dave: Is he still alive?
I searched Instagram. His page, conveniently called MetalMarty68, consisted almost entirely of videos of him playing Metallica songs on guitar.
Chuck: Looks like it.
Dave: Think he ever learned how to play guitar?
Chuck: Judging by the videos I just found online, not really
Dave: haha
Dave and I had stayed in touch over the years, though not as closely as we had in high school. He worked in commercial real estate now, had two kids, and lived in Andover with a finished basement and a Big Green Egg on his porch.
I flipped to the next picture from the FunSaver. There I was, holding a blue Squier bass that hung almost to my knees. Behind us were seven people sitting in folding chairs in my parents’ basement.
I remembered the day: the Necrosis CD release party. We’d recorded a six-song demo on a borrowed four-track and burned twenty copies onto blank CDs. Marty designed the cover; a kraken being impaled by a sword beneath the word NECROSIS in a font nobody could read.
The photographs showed us posing like rock stars; instruments slung low, faces contorted into expressions of contrived rage. Everyone in the audience looked like they were waiting for a severely delayed train.
I laughed. Then I noticed something wedged inside the camera’s cracked wrist strap. I pulled it free.
It was a blue guitar pick. Thick and triangular, the kind I’d bought because some guy at Guitar Center had told me they were better for bass. One side had been scratched with a ballpoint pen: CHUCK. The other: NECROSIS.
I held it against the photograph. My sixteen-year-old self was holding the same pick between his thumb and index finger.
My mind drifted to the night of the CD release party. I remembered the feeling of a frog in my throat beforehand, how I’d spent the afternoon checking and rechecking the tuning, convinced that everyone would notice if I played a wrong note. Dave had been complaining about his broken snare drum, and Marty had been running around the basement telling everyone we were about to make history.
At some point, my father came downstairs and told us we couldn’t get too loud. Marty said something about rock and roll not having a volume knob. My father shook his head and went back upstairs.
Then we played.
We sucked. The bass was too loud, the snare was dull, and Marty sang in a whiny scream that made it sound like he was having awake dental surgery. But seven people sat in those folding chairs and watched us, and for twenty minutes I was convinced we were the most important people in the world.
I couldn’t remember the last time I’d felt that way about anything.
When we finished, Marty threw his guitar over his shoulder and bowed. Dave raised his drumsticks. I remember looking at the audience and seeing my father, who’d come down for the last song, politely clapping.
---
A horn blared, and I jerked upright, realizing my car was in reverse with my foot on the brake. A woman in a minivan was waiting for my parking spot. She threw up both hands.
I backed up and waved at the rear view mirror.
---
Back at my parents’ house, I put the pick on the kitchen counter. Then I stood six feet away from it and drank a glass of water.
I looked back at the pick and again searched Instagram for Marty Milch.
His page had sixty-two followers and hundreds of videos with the captions in all caps.
MASTER OF PUPPETS, TAKE 47
ENTER SANDMAN SOLO
METAL!!!!!!!!
His Mohawk was gone, replaced by a thin ring of chestnut brown hair. His beard was gray around the chin.
I don’t know what came over me then. Maybe it was the monotony of cleaning out the house, or the desire to report back to Dave what Marty was up to these days. Regardless of my motive, I direct-messaged him the old photograph of our CD release show.
Five minutes later, he responded:
Holy balls.
Then:
NECROSIS!!!!
Followed by three fire emojis.
He asked me if I’d be around sometime to grab a beer.
I closed my phone.
Then, my mother called from the other room, “Chuckie! Does your high school marching band uniform bring you joy?”
I opened Instagram and responded to Marty:
Sure.
---
We met the next afternoon at O’Halliagan’s, a dive we’d frequented in high school despite the inconvenient fact that neither of us had been old enough to drink there. On the drive over, everything reminded me of him: Plainfield House of Pizza, where he’d once tried to convince the owner to let Necrosis play a show; our high school where he’d been suspended for smashing his guitar after the spring musical; the convenience store where he’d tried to buy cigarettes with a library card as identification.
Marty was sitting at the end of the bar with a full pint glass in front of him wearing a neon-green tracksuit and a scally cap.
“Chuck fucking Henderson!” he called when he saw me enter.
He hugged me so hard I thought I felt a rib crack.
“You look exactly the same,” he said.
“What are you drinking?” I asked.
“IPA.” He paused. “Nonalcoholic.”
I looked down, then back up.
“Eleven years,” he said. “Turns out I’m bad at drinking.”
I ordered the same thing.
For the next two hours, I learned that virtually everything Dave and I had predicted would happen to Marty Milch when we were in high school had been wrong. He owned a music store, Milch Music, downtown. He’d opened it fifteen years earlier after working in music shops through college. He also gave lessons. He had a wife named Melissa and two kids. His son Ethan was seventeen and played guitar.
“Kid’s obsessed with Metallica,” Marty said proudly.
“With you as a father how could he not be?”
Marty threw his arms up. “Melissa blames me too. But he found them himself.”
Marty showed me a picture of Ethan, long-haired and wearing a black Metallica shirt, holding Marty’s old ridiculous guitar.
Something moved inside my chest. Not jealousy exactly. Something adjacent to it. The strange ache of seeing somebody whose life path you purposely avoided having everything you wanted.
“You still play?” Marty asked.
“Bass?”
“No, clarinet. Yeah, bass.”
“Not really.”
“What happened?”
I shrugged. “Life.”
Marty nodded as if life were a reasonable explanation.
“What do you do now?” he asked.
“Insurance. I’m taking over my father’s place.”
“That’s awesome, man. Your dad must be psyched.”
“Yeah.”
I looked down at my beer.
The conversation brought back a particular memory of my father. I was seventeen. The Berklee College of Music brochure was on the kitchen table. I’d asked if I could apply. He laughed, then told me I wasn’t “dumb enough to become a starving musician like that Marty fellow.” He’d winked and said, “Besides, if you go to music school, who’s going to take over Henderson Insurance?”
It was the first time he’d told me he expected me to run the business.
“You okay?” Marty asked.
“Yeah.”
Marty drained his beer. “You should come by the store sometime. We can jam.”
---
On Monday morning, my father was in his office. He’d officially retired six weeks earlier and had come to work every weekday since.
The blue pick sat on top of my desk. I’d brought it with me without even being aware.
Around eleven, my father appeared in my doorway.
“You change the Whitmore deductible?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“They asked us to.”
“They don’t know what they want.”
“They’re the client.”
He came inside. My father had spent forty years building Henderson Insurance from a desk in the back of a dry cleaner into a business with eleven employees and a brick office building. People trusted him. I was proud of him.
He looked at the papers on my desk. “You get the Ardsmore account transferred over?”
“I’m working on it.”
“It’s been three weeks.”
“I know.”
“It’s not that complicated.”
“Then why don’t you handle it?”
He raised a brow. I hadn’t meant to say it quite that way.
He pulled out the chair across from me and sat down. “What’s going on?”
“Nothing.”
“Don’t give me that. You’ve been walking around here like you’re a moody teenager again.”
I looked at the pick on my desk.
“Did you ever think I’d do something else?” I asked.
My father folded his arms and leaned against the door frame. “Like what?”
“I don’t know. Music.”
He let out a small laugh. “You mean when you were seventeen?”
“I mean ever.”
“Everybody thinks about doing something else.”
“Did you?”
“Sure.”
“What?”
He shrugged. “I don’t know. I wanted to be a professional baseball player when I was a kid.”
“You always told me you couldn’t hit.”
“I could hit.”
“You hit one home run in Little League that you never stop talking about.”
“It was a big one.”
I smiled against my will.
My father picked up the blue pick and turned it between his fingers. “I miss when you used to play bass. I used to have to drag you upstairs to eat.”
I didn’t remember that. Or maybe I did, but hadn’t thought about it in years.
“You were pretty good, too,” he added.
“Come on.”
“I’m serious.”
“Then why’d you tell me I wasn’t dumb enough to become a starving musician?”
He rubbed his forehead. “Where is this coming from?”
I didn’t respond; just looked at the framed photograph on his desk. The two of us at a Red Sox game when I was maybe ten. My father had one arm around me, his other hand holding a beer. I was wearing a batting helmet several sizes too large.
He placed the pick back on my desk. “Transfer that Ardsmore account, will you?”
Then he walked out.
I leaned back in my chair, opened Instagram, and found Marty’s page again. The newest video showed him in the back room of his store, playing “Master of Puppets.” This one was take 49. His son stood beside him with the old knockoff Explorer, waiting for his turn. When Marty finished the riff, he looked over at the kid and grinned.
The video had sixty-three views.
I watched it twice.
Then I opened my messages and found Dave.
Chuck: You ever wonder what happened to Necrosis?
Dave didn’t respond right away. He was probably walking some rich asshole around an all-glass high-rise office suite downtown.
I stared at my computer screen, then back at the pick.
After a few moments, my phone vibrated.
Dave: We grew up.
I put my phone down, worked for another hour, then shut down my computer.
On the way out, I stopped at my father’s office. He was still there, reading something at his desk.
“I’m heading out,” I said.
“Okay. See you tomorrow.”
I stood in the doorway.
“Dad?”
He looked up.
“Thanks for coming to our CD release party.”
He smiled.
Outside, I sat in my car and took out my phone. I found Marty’s Instagram profile and watched the video again.
I opened the message with Marty.
Chuck: You around Saturday?
Marty: ALWAYS
Chuck: What time?
Marty: DOESN’T MATTER
I put the phone in the cup holder and started the car.
The whole drive home, I kept the pick in my hand, stroking the hard plastic between my thumb and index finger. On Saturday, I’d use it to play bass.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.