Into the Icarian Sea

⭐️ Contest #55 Shortlist!

Fantasy Adventure

Written in response to: "Write a story that either starts or ends with someone asking, “Can you keep a secret?”" as part of In On a Little Secret.


    Can you keep a secret?

    Five simple words. This innocent question, posed as it was by a king, caused Daedalus untold grief. He had answered in the affirmative and remained true to his word, yet still King Minos had imprisoned him so that he may never speak of the monarch’s monstrous secret.

    The injustice of it burned Daedalus, but his true lament was reserved for his fellow captive – his son. The boy was just as innocent of wrongdoing as his father, but the imprisonment was infinitely harder on the youth for he knew not the reason for his confinement.

    As the weeks stretched into months, turned to years, as time lost all meaning and the burden of seemingly endless incarceration weighed ever heavier on their souls, Daedalus had watched helplessly as the light slowly faded from his son’s eyes. He knew hope was as crucial to survival as bread and water. A man could endure almost anything so long as the flickering flame of aspiration burned within his breast, there to ignite the dreams and passions that are the refuge of the sane mind amid calamity. He could not allow his son to lose heart, for it was on the wings of hope that the boy would be afforded the possibility of escape.

    Just like the king, Daedalus harbored a secret of his own. A life-long master craftsman, he had turned his capable hand to fashioning a device that would, if all went to plan, serve as his son’s salvation. He knew that in freeing the boy he would ensure his own death by remaining behind, but if that was the price, it was one he would pay gladly.





    “What are you working on?” the lad asked again and again.

    “Freedom,” Daedalus would reply each time through lips cracked and bleeding.

    Thus reassured, the youth would turn once more to the solitary window in their tower-top cell, gazing longingly out at the gulls as they wheeled and soared in the sun-dappled sky. Their prison on the Northern shore of the island offered little by way of comfort but it did command a breathtaking view of the infinite blue beyond. To Daedalus, the panoramic vista, near enough to touch yet achingly just out of reach, seemed a cruel reminder of freedom denied, but he was encouraged by the boy’s desirous contemplation of the world beyond. To a bird that spends long enough in a cage, flying comes to seem a disease. So long as his son held fast to dreams of one day soaring free, anything was possible.

    Fully aware that he held those timid hopes in his careworn hands, cradled like some fragile feathered thing, Daedalus devoted himself anew each day to his task. Time was of the essence and he dare not fail.

    There seemed to be a measure of justice to Daedalus in using his skills to break the shackles of internment, given how those same skills were responsible for their predicament in the first place.

    He had once been known as the greatest architect in Athens, so it was only natural that Minos, King of Crete, had summoned him in his hour of greatest need. The king’s wife had strayed from her marriage bed in the most unforgivable manner, and the monstrosity born of her blasphemous infidelity with the Cretan Bull had so shamed Minos that he wished to conceal it from the world for all eternity. He had commanded Daedalus to build a prison from which the beast could never escape and the craftsman had complied, unknowingly constructing his own cage in the process.

    Daedalus built not a prison but a labyrinth, and, once finished, so convoluted where its endless passageways that none who ventured in could ever find their way out again. Only the craftsman knew the secret to successfully navigating the maze, just as he alone was privy to the secret of the unspeakable abomination that dwelt captive at its center. The secret Minos wished dearly to remain buried. Task complete, the king had imprisoned Daedalus to ensure his silence.

    The punishment was temporary, Daedalus knew. Sooner or later Minos would realize his desire for eternal secrecy could only be attained with the permanent removal of the craftsman. The looming specter of impending execution spurred him onward. Daedalus labored day and night, all the while praying he would finish his task in time.





    While he worked through the lightless hours, Daedalus watched his son sleep and dream his dreams of flight and freedom. He loved the lad beyond the expression of mere words. The boy was his world, the sole light in an existence otherwise stained with shadow.

    He had known his son was different from the first. A ‘dreamer’ the scholars of Daedalus’ acquaintance said of the boy with smirks that betrayed just how they thought such an individual would fare later in life. Daedalus paid them no mind; he had little doubt his son would one day attain great heights.

    The boy was possessed of constant wonder at the splendor of the natural world around him, which all others took for granted. He delighted in the feel of the gentle breeze, marveled at the soft kiss of sun on skin, and exulted in the rain as it lashed down from the firmament. He voiced an unending stream of questions.

    “How deep is the sea?”

    “Where does the sun go when it sets?”

    “What lies above the clouds?”

    And, most commonly, “How do birds fly?” Daedalus suspected that along with the last went the boy’s unspoken secret desire to do the same.

    Rather than dismissing these queries as the inane ramblings of youth, as would any other father, Daedalus took them as a promising sign of his son’s agile mind and knew it would one day evolve into formidable intellect. As such, he took it upon himself to instruct the boy in the ways of the world.

    “Never fall prey to Hubris,” he cautioned. “Naught but misery awaits he who attempts to rise beyond his given station in life; who places too much stock in his own ability.”

    On other occasions, he advised his attentive pupil, “Beware, too, false modesty. A bird that flies too close to the sea shall perish just as surely as one who ventures too near the sun. Know your place always – be no more or less than you were intended to be. That, my son, is the essence of humility.”

    So excessive was his pride in the boy that Daedalus was in danger of contravening his own advice, but that mattered not at all. The one thing in this life that should never be subject to limiting restraint is the bounds of a parent’s love.

    Fueled by the flames of his burning devotion, Daedalus worked on.





    When the day finally came, the sun rose high, just as it had on every other before. Its setting, however, was a sight Daedalus knew he would not witness. The ominous, triple-strike tolling of the bell in the courtyard below was a sound only heard on rare occasions – days of execution. He wished for more time, but he knew the guards would come for them at any moment. The time for action had arrived. If it was to be done at all, it was best done at once.

    “Now listen to me well, son. Do exactly as I say and freedom shall be yours before this day is through.”

    “But what of you, Father? Will you not be coming with me?”

    “Aye,” Daedalus savagely bit back tears. “In good time, lad. We shall meet again one day, have no doubt of that. For now, you need to go alone. Do you understand?”

    The boy nodded, fighting tears of his own. He saw through his father’s reassurances to the resounding finality of the sound of goodbye beneath.

    “Come then, we haven’t much time.”

    Daedalus retrieved the object of his ceaseless hours of labor from its place of concealment amid the gull’s nests beneath the eaves. It looked to the boy like a bundle of feathers, hundreds upon hundreds of them, intricately woven and bound with candle wax to form…

    “Wings?” he breathed in rapture.

    “Yes, wings, “Daedalus confirmed. “The keys to freedom. We must hurry now.” The drumbeat of heavy footfalls from the stairwell echoed through the small chamber.

    He affixed the plumage to his son’s arms with several strips of worn leather. They seemed woefully inadequate, but there was naught Daedalus could do now but hope they held true.

    “What do I do, Father?”

    There was no time for instruction. The door crashed in amid a cacophony of angry shouts.

    “Just remember all I’ve taught you,” Daedalus replied. “Follow your heart. Do what you were born to.” He then roughly embraced his son, kissed him on the forehead, and pushed him out the window. “Fly, Icarus!” he shouted after the boy’s fast retreating form. “Fly!”





    Icarus fell.

    He plunged headlong to his doom on the jagged rocks below but, in the fleeting eternity of the fall, he felt no fear. In fully accepting his imminent destruction he came to see that death is not the opposite of life, it is part of life – the two as inseparable as the dividing line between sea and sky on the horizon’s edge. To truly come alive is to embrace death, to laugh in its face and, in so doing, transcend it.

    Does not the joy of living derive from the ever-present threat of the grave?

    Icarus spread wide his arms to welcome his fate as the rocks rushed up to meet him. His feathers spread majestically, catching the rising currents and, at the last possible moment, lifted him up and away.

    Icarus flew.

    On the thermals he rose, ever higher, even as his heart soared higher still within his breast, propelled by the sheer exhilaration of a dream realized; of the wonderment of flight. Drunk on the sweet nectar of fulfillment, Icarus burst through the clouds to the secret domain above. His unrivaled ecstasy came not in spite of the perilous drop beneath him, but rather, because of it.

    Does not the joy of flight derive from the ever-present threat of the fall?

    The cost of such undeniable pleasure as this would be high indeed, but that mattered not to the boy. He had discovered a secret few ever learn – all men die, the real tragedy is how few ever truly feel alive. Icarus felt alive now, gloriously, unequivocally alive. If the price of that was death, it was one he would pay gladly.

    Higher still, Icarus flew.

    He rose ever nearer the sun, that silent sovereign of the sky whose light brings life but, also, fiery doom. The golden rays which once so delighted the boy with their gentle kisses became burning daggers of menacing intent. Yet, still, he was not afraid.

    Icarus embraced the sun.

    At the very apex of his ascent, he turned lazily over. Suspended in that moment, watching the wax melt and run down his pale arms and the feathers spring free one by one and continue on a thousand separate journies of independent flight – a marvel, each one – Icarus smiled.

    One final revelation came to him then, in his state of rapturous delight, and it was this: there’s a certain relief in surrendering unto destruction; a savage satisfaction in setting one’s world ablaze and watching the flames from the center of the inferno.

    The brief flight had been the pinnacle of Icarus’ very existence – what more had he to live for? Humility is knowing one’s place and when such dizzying heights have been reached, whence can one go but down?

    Icarus fell.

    He threw his head back and laughed in pure, unadulterated exaltation as he plunged from the heavens to the swirling sea below which would ever after bear his name.

    As he rushed to his death, Icarus had never felt more alive.


 ҈   


Posted Aug 18, 2020
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

94 likes 79 comments

Pragya Rathore
August 18, 2020 08:04

You're great at writing historical fiction! The portrayal of Daedalus' love was heartbreaking. Amazing story!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 18, 2020 13:50

Thank you so much. I really appreciate that you’ve been diligently reading my stories. I can’t describe how much that means, but it’s a lot! A lot a lot! You’re amazing!

Reply

Pragya Rathore
August 18, 2020 14:17

I swear upon my honour that it is indeed a most valued privilege. Basically, you're most welcome :)

Reply

I Vee
September 02, 2020 12:08

" there’s a certain relief in surrendering unto destruction; a savage satisfaction in setting one’s world ablaze and watching the flames from the center of the inferno."
"Humility is knowing one’s place and when such dizzying heights have been reached, whence can one go but down?"
These words had me the most I feel like sharing them with the whole world!
I can't seem to find proper words to describe your story so I guess I'll just stick with BRILLIANT. I just love it so much, very well done!!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
September 02, 2020 15:55

Thank you so much. It's one of the coolest things when you read a bit of a story that you really connect with. I'm so glad I could provide that. Thanks for reading 🙂

Reply

I Vee
September 02, 2020 17:28

I live for these kinda feelings to be honest! For a stranger to reach you so deep using nothing but words...It's absolute magic! And you're so welcome ^^

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
September 03, 2020 06:39

I think many of us do, which is were putting deeper truths in fiction becomes powerful. I think it’s important to acknowledge the feelings, without entertaining them too much, though. I think of it like that impulse people get to jump when standing on the edge of a high drop. It’s irrational but powerful and speaks to a deeper desire to explore the unknown and embrace destruction. Rationality is recognizing and accepting the impulse while at the same time stepping back from the edge. Because as comforting as destruction can be, there are always wider consequences.

Enough sermonizing, though. I think one of the wonders of being human is being able to hold contrasting beliefs and ideas in mind, being suspended between majesty and misery, and yet not be defined by either one. That is a gift. A wonderful, terrifying gift. And what better place to explore it than in writing? I’ve just summed up my writing theory, unasked, so thanks for bearing with me 😊 And getting me thinking as well.

Reply

I Vee
September 03, 2020 12:36

This is beautifully inspiring. Thank you so much for sharing this here!
For me, and since I only started writing few months ago, my writing theory is a lot simpler and can be put in one word: healing. I'm still exploring what I can and cannot put into words as I'm not really used to expressing, but the journey has been great and I'm loving it so far!
And honestly, I can't wait to read more of your work!

Reply

Elizabeth Inkim
September 01, 2020 23:36

I absolutely love your twist on Greek Mythology. It's such a fresh perspective on the characters and their personalities. Icarus has always been one of my favourites and I didn't think I could love him more, but I do. This was a fantastic story!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
September 02, 2020 08:35

Thank you so much!

Reply

Katina Foster
August 31, 2020 16:55

I enjoyed this retelling of two classic stories, intertwined with each other. I was so focused on the labyrinth that I didn't see Icarus coming. The moral totally changes in your telling, and I think I like it better your way.
Nicely done!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
September 02, 2020 08:40

Thanks. I was debating even including the labyrinth stuff because that's actually a way more interesting story (you could call it a-mazing!) and I didn't want to distract. But it was needed for explanation purposes.
I think it interested me so much because that's obviously the inspiration behind the bull in the maze in Rose Madder, one of my favorite SK books. Maybe that's why it caught your attention as well, being a fellow fan and all. Why aren't there more of us on here?

Reply

Katina Foster
September 02, 2020 12:36

Yes!! Rose Madder is one of my favorites too! Norman Daniels is one of the creepiest bad guys SK has ever written in my opinion.
I'm also just fascinated by myths and legends. Talk about dark... I love the idea of putting a new spin on these old stories - exploring other potential motivations behind the behavior (like Icarcus being pushed and grieving his father). It made me think of another favorite book - "Till we have faces" by CS Lewis.

Reply

B Easton
August 31, 2020 07:48

Hi congratulations! This was a really impressive story, and I genuinely felt the father's emotions.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 31, 2020 08:23

Thanks, glad you enjoyed it :)

Reply

Keerththan 😀
August 29, 2020 08:44

You played well with historical fiction. Wonderful story. Amazing as always. Congratulations for the shortlist.
Would you mind reading my story
"The adventurous tragedy?"

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 29, 2020 08:58

Thanks. Sure thing, will check it out now.

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
August 28, 2020 17:10

Congrats on the short list! Well deserved - this was SUCH a great story. I'm still telling people about it!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 29, 2020 12:06

That means so much. Thank you

Reply

Thom With An H
August 28, 2020 15:42

Congrats Brother, well deserved!

Reply

August 28, 2020 15:14

LOOK AT YOU, MR. SHORTLIST -- YAY YAY YAY
All of Florida celebrates your amazing story - flamingos, alligators, all.
About damn time, I must say.
Champagne!
Chocolate!
Literary awards!!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 28, 2020 15:34

Thank you so much! Flamingos and alligators is pretty much exactly how I picture Florida. And Disneyland. World. Whatever. I lived in California for a while and was always reprimanded for mixing them up. So apparently it's important. Although I still can’t remember which is where.
Your encouragement is so wonderful. I spent a fruitful 20 minutes the other day just reading through your replies to comments on your stories – unrivaled entertainment value! You’re the best.

Reply

August 28, 2020 16:01

Florida also has grouchy retirees, a surprisingly robust meth community, tourists who enjoy price gouging, and the general flotsam and jetsam of the world. What we do need is better writers.
Like Boccaccio, we should write a new Decameron and tell stories about the future world post-pandemic and post-economic meltdown (which should begin in 3, 2, 1)
Thanks for sharing your ample gifts. Can't wait to buy your books off Amazon so Jeff Bezos can pay his alimony properly.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 28, 2020 16:34

I heard a joke the other day along the lines of - Florida now has a dedicated senior shopping day. The other 3 people in the state are delighted to have the stores to themselves the rest of the week 🤣
Shame, we shouldn't laugh. It's going to happen to all of us.

I'm actually going to be working for that company in a couple weeks, but for now I can still laugh!
And it should go without saying that you'll always get free books from me, in the unlikely event writing ever becomes more than a sanity-preserving hobby.

Reply

August 28, 2020 18:16

Writing is indeed free therapy. Always good to give the superego, id, and ego a workout. :)
Hope your time being an Amazonian works out for the best :)

Reply

August 28, 2020 14:40

Wow two weeks in a row! Congrats you’re awesome 👏🏼

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 28, 2020 15:10

Even a stopped clock is right twice a day...
Sorry, I mean, thank you very much. I've got an excellent team of consultants on here, you see. I don't know how you guys put up with me, but I'm so glad you do because reading and commenting on your stories helps me a lot.
What happened to the hitchhiking symbol? We're doing a handwashing symbol now? The official emoji of 2020! Very clever, Sarah, I like the way you think :)

Reply

August 28, 2020 19:15

Lol is that hand washing? I thought it was clapping 👍🏼

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 29, 2020 07:16

It’s all about perspective. Last year's hand-clapping is this year's hand-washing. 🤳 <- That one is someone spraying themselves with sanitizer before leaving the house. Welcome to 2020, please leave your sanity at the door.

Reply

August 29, 2020 07:22

Lol. My story this week is gonna be about the weirdness too actually. Ill put it up there soon a jangled mess for you and Laura to fix and I can take credit 👍🏼

Reply

Peace Nakiyemba
August 27, 2020 11:46

This is brilliant. I liked the story and the narrator's take on life in general. Well told.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 29, 2020 12:12

Thanks so much for reading and sharing your thoughts, much appreciated 😀

Reply

Mohsen Baqery
August 26, 2020 18:49

I lost my father a couple of years ago. And to be honest, the way they said goodbye to each made me feel a lump in my throat.

I loved the way you portrayed freedom in captivity, Jonathan.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 29, 2020 12:11

I'm glad the emotions came through. Sorry to hear that, though, I know it's tough. After writing this I got to thinking of biblical parallels - father allowing son to be sacrificed for eternal life. Because that's what Icarus got - he lives on in our collective consciousness. And, that, I think is a very important reflection on loss. It hurts, but we can honor the departed in memory and as long as we do, a part of them lives on in us.
Thank you so much for reading. I'm heading over to check out some of your work asap.

Reply

Mohsen Baqery
August 29, 2020 14:53

I would appreciate that Jonathan. I'd actually love to have your comment on my work. 🥂 cheers.

Reply

Pragya Rathore
August 26, 2020 12:20

Congrats on the shortlist, Jonathan! You deserve it :) By the way, how many authors are being shortlisted, do you know?

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 26, 2020 14:09

Thanks. You too, again, I see. Well done!
I have no idea how many, but I think with some logical deduction we can make a guess. Let’s assume a story takes, on average, 10 minutes to read properly. So, allowing for an interruption or two, a judge can read 5 stories in an hour.
Since judges are people and they have real lives, let’s assume that each is required to put in 4 hours per week. That’s 20 stories.
Furthermore, there seem to be approximately 1000 entries per week. At 20 stories each, that means there are 50(ish) judges.
If each judge selects one story for shortlisting, that means there are roughly 50 stories shortlisted each week.
You can see my economics background coming through with all these assumptions and approximations.
So I really don’t know, but, if any judges ever reads this, I would be interested to see how close we are with our guess.

Reply

Pragya Rathore
August 26, 2020 14:20

Your analytical skills put mine to shame, sadly. Wow! Actually, I was asking because this time, a lot of stories have been shortlisted. Congratulations again! :)

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 26, 2020 14:31

It’s like with the virus – does an increase in cases mean more infections… or just that more tests were done? Not the best analogy, but what I mean is – I think it seems more because they’ve made it more visible. Actually, no, that analogy is pretty much spot on, now that I think about it 😊

Reply

Pragya Rathore
August 26, 2020 14:41

I wish I could reply with a clever comeback, but as usual, all I can think is that you're absolutely right :)

Reply

K V CHIDAMBARAM
August 25, 2020 16:48

Excellent, full of paradoxes. Best Wishes.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 29, 2020 12:13

Thank you, that's very kind.

Reply

Maya W.
August 24, 2020 14:24

Woah, this was amazing! I love Greek mythology, and this had this sort of epic poem vibe that I loved. I can't stress enough how amazing this story was, as someone who's read a lotta different versions of the myth, I really enjoyed this one. Would you mind checking out some of my stories here? Thanks!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 25, 2020 07:29

Thank you so much, I'm glad it worked. Will check yours out asap.

Reply

Thom With An H
August 24, 2020 13:20

I am not a genius but I know it when I see it. This story was so different from the others I've read. To be able to so easily change from one style to another is truly a gift. I also found it so compelling how you created a new "truth" from this story. The original fable taught the lesson that you should not overdo your life. It is a warning against overreach and hubris. A valuable lesson to say the least but you changed the whole moral. Life is about the moments of greatness and sometimes, in fact many times that outweighs the consequences. I am a huge football fan and more and more we are finding that playing football can end you life early and diminish the quality of your life as well and yet players still play and I understand why. What I wouldn't give to be on that field of battle. Fighting the good fight with my teammates. Leaving it all on the field. Life isn't about how many days you live, its about how you live your many days. I'm just rambling now, great job again. I'm glad I get to read your stories.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 25, 2020 04:32

Next time I try to get out of the car wearing my seatbelt or look for my phone while using it as a torch, I'll remember that at least one person thinks I'm a genius.
Your insight is in the genius neighborhood though - I didn't think of this story in sporting terms, but I should have because you hit the nail on the head there.
I was thinking just the other day that one of the reasons I love sport is they're the greatest, unscripted stories around. All the key elements are there - an angle (underdog vs. reigning champ), subplots, history, etc. And the game itself... we live for those twists and turns, the player who comes out of retirement to prove a point or the rookie who gets a start in the big game and impresses. Or doesn't. And the last-minute score to tie the game... then comes the kick. It's not surprising that the Superbowl and soccer WC final are the two most-watched televised events in the world.
Even the off-season is exciting - Cam at the Patriots? I'm a fan of the former but not the latter, so mixed feelings there. Again, just like a good story!
So thank you for your amazingly supportive comment and also for putting just what I was thinking into words. Like a good writer!

Reply

Thom With An H
August 25, 2020 05:34

I’ll see you at the next genius meeting. Is it my turn to bring the chips?

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 25, 2020 07:09

Sounds like a support group for intellectuals. Geniuses Anonymous? “Hi, I’m a recovering genius. I haven’t had a think in 5 years.” 😊

Reply

Thom With An H
August 25, 2020 11:08

Hi Jonathan. I know it was hard to say that. 😀

Reply

Katrina Lee
August 24, 2020 12:41

The writing style fits the myth like a glove, and you maintain it throughout the piece, which shows how skilful you are at summoning a particular type of tone that constructs an overall believable ambience, as the readers situate themselves in the story. And I love how you shift the internal landscape from Daedalus to Icarus, so we get an interesting mix of perspectives.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 25, 2020 07:31

This was a very well written comment, thank you! Such praise from a military professional is much appreciated. Sorry... but seriously, since you are an English major and clearly know your stuff, it means a lot. Thanks.

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
August 23, 2020 17:51

This is incredible, Jonathan - what a poignant and yet inspiring take on the tale of Icarus. I love your writing style. I can't exactly put my finger on it - it's simple and yet not really simple. It flows so effortlessly - I am completely caught up in your writing. I need to go read some others now but will be returning to your page soon.

Reply

נιмму 🤎
August 31, 2020 01:20

wait what does it mean to get your story shortlisted?? I didn't realize that was a thing until now...

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 31, 2020 06:05

No idea... I think it's like a hit list but for short people. Creepy, right?

Reply

B. Velazquez
August 22, 2020 18:04

Don't ask me how I cam upon your story. I have no idea but I thoroughly enjoyed it. Well written and entertaining. As someone who's gotten in trouble for keeping a secret 🙄, the first line drew me. With great power comes great responsibility (was it, Voltaire who said this or Uncle Ben? 😆) I digress ... Great writing. Keep at it.

Reply

August 21, 2020 01:25

Pure art. So graceful and poignant.

Loved every word.

Reminded me of this painting:

https://www.bl.uk/collection-items/landscape-with-the-fall-of-icarus

And this poem:

http://english.emory.edu/classes/paintings&poems/auden.html

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 21, 2020 06:12

Thanks. It was a nice change of pace because I've been doing too much humour lately.
That poem and picture are awesome! I got partial inspiration from art of a different sort - Iron Maiden. The most literary band in the world. Glad you enjoyed it.

Reply

D. Holmes
August 19, 2020 02:53

The way you've expanded this myth by adding more characterization and metaphor is beautiful. I loved the addition of "A bird that flies too close to the sea shall perish just as surely as one who ventures too near the sun" - I'd never thought of it that way before, and it was a nice juxtaposition to Daedalus' traditional warning of not to fly too near the sun. Actually, this story was full of juxtaposition (freedom/captivity, life/death, flying/falling), which is why I think the revamped ending worked well, with Icarus chasing an adrenaline high.

Minor point. "Time was of the essence and he dare not fail" - should it be "dared"? I suck at grammar tho so I could be wrong.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 19, 2020 16:11

As a past winner and writer of a great (if visually untidy) story recently i don't think you're allowed to say you suck at anything writing-related. I see what you mean about dare/dared - Grammarly always shouts at me when I write old-fashioned style. I did that intentionally in an effort to sound more, well, old-fashionedy (Grammarly is shouting at me now for that awesome word i just made up, actually). I'll read it again though to see if it needs adjusting.
Thank you so much for reading and commenting, really appreciate it 😀

Reply

D. Holmes
August 20, 2020 02:53

Ah, I see. Yes, "dare not fail" does give me epic quest, old-fashionedy (who says it's not a word lol) vibes. Apologies, no need to change, just wanted to point it out in case. And of course! Your stories are a pleasure to read :)

(Also, that's really kind of you to say, thank you - but honestly, my grammar barometer tends to be: ...does that sound ok?...maybe?...ok moving on, haha.)

Reply

Amy DeMatt
August 18, 2020 23:38

I am blown away by this. This is a story that works on more than one level and truly belongs in a publication. The surface story of Icarus and Daedalus is beautifully told and would stand alone, but your deeper themes (no light but for darkness, no joy but for suffering) are very "adult" themes that make this work just as appealing and compelling for a more sophisticated audience. You have a real talent for drawing the reader in, for creating a story that people want to read. Truly, it would be a waste not to share this with a wider audience. I hope that you will pursue--and I'll be looking forward to reading more!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 19, 2020 16:17

Thank you so much. It came from an idea I had for a novel which tells an alternative version of the story - Icarus flies safely away and goes on to live a life of quiet desperation and regret, always wondering what would've happened had he used his wings to their full potential. Lots of opportunity to explore the idea of regret and seizing the moment, etc in there. But, alas, I'm not novel ready yet, so an idea it shall remain. For now, at least.
Thanks so much for reading and your support and encouragement. And also for finally writing another great story!

Reply

Bianka Nova
August 18, 2020 12:56

Being familiar with Greek mythology, I wasn't really interested in the story, but I love the poetry of your storytelling!
Favorite line: "death is not the opposite of life, it is part of life – the two as inseparable as the dividing line between sea and sky on the horizon’s edge" :))

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 18, 2020 13:50

Thank you. I love your honesty, it’s very refreshing. And I’m glad you like that line. I once heard a quote along the lines of - The opposite of a profound truth is another profound truth. I love the idea of opposites being intertwined, of all things being connected. Like the idea that success would be meaningless if failure wasn’t a possibility, etc. I like working things like that into my stories. Thanks for reading.

Reply

Bianka Nova
August 18, 2020 14:11

Thank you and kudos to you! I like the way you think - you transfer that really well in your writing :)
Seeing most of the comments here, I think I might be a bit too honest. Sometimes it may come out sounding harsher than it's meant, and that's not too encouraging to an aspiring writer. But I do it with good intentions, because I believe that to be the point of the whole exercise - to learn from each other (us being both the authors and fellow readers). A lot of positive and ecstatic comments are a good ego booster, but they won't improve your work. :))

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 18, 2020 14:34

I agree 100% I think it goes without saying that, since we’re all writers, we recognize the effort (and sometimes agony) that goes into the creative process, so there are no bad stories.
And you were hardly rude. Honesty is important – like you say, its how we learn. And even when being critical, it can be done gently, which is what I find so incredible here – no one is harsh or disrespectful in the comments. Not that I’ve seen, anyway. For the internet? That’s unheard of!

So no, you weren’t harsh at all. I once accidentally read a Nora Roberts and, while romance isn’t my cup of tea at all and I told myself I didn’t enjoy it, I read to the end. Which says a lot. So that you read my story even though the subject matter didn’t grab hold of you is a special compliment. Thank you.

Reply

Elle Clark
August 18, 2020 08:03

Oh this was constructed so beautifully. It’s difficult to retell such a well-known myth with any level of fresh insight so the reinterpretation of the end was a great choice. Your tone, which you keep consistent throughout, is a perfectly pitched mix of narrative and introspective.

You didn’t spend any more time than you needed to setting up the background info. For those who don’t know the myth, you’ve included enough to tell them and for those who do, you’ve not bored them by rehashing too much of it.

My favourite line was the one about not limiting a parent’s love as it was so beautiful and so true. I loved the sentence about loving Icarus ‘beyond the mere expression of words’ too for the same reason.

You alternate between sentence lengths beautifully. Having ‘Icarus fell’ as one sentence separated from the rest is so powerful and hits like a punch. Same with ‘Icarus flew’. The similarity in those two works so well to structure the end, too.

Note of caution about the lyrics at the front (though not if you’re not interested in winning): no story with song lyrics can win because of copyright. So if you want to aim for that, you’ll need to remove them.

I also really loved the hints you drop in along the way that provide some dramatic irony. My favourite was the bit about him achieving great heights. It really made me think, “Oh, you have no idea how high.”

This is an expertly woven retelling. My only wish is that you’d trodden new ground because your ideas are so inventive and clever but this is also a perfect version of its type.

I think you get more technically advanced with your writing every story you put up. This can be used as an example of several different techniques if others wanted to learn from you.

Excellent writing.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
August 18, 2020 13:49

Thank you so much. Your comments are always lovely to receive.

I wouldn’t have done it without the fresh perspective to offer, and it was a wonderful learning experience for me because not having to focus on the general plot allowed me to concentrate on the language, imagery, symbolism, etc. And the human/relationship elements, which I frequently neglect, not by choice, but because they often get cut in the cutting/editing process. Or trimmed down at least.

And fear not (knot?), many new grounds await trodding in future. I may even have another for this week. Warning – it will be humor, but that’s not my fault, one of the prompts is all but begging for it. I’m not going to ask if you’re doing another because I’ll probably be banned from here for harassing people to write stories. So I won’t do that. But, hypothetically speaking, another would be nice… Just sayin 😊

Oh, and I will cut the quote. Not because I think we have an award-winning story on our hands here, but because I wouldn’t want to disqualify myself before the race has even begun. Also, I never knew that. It’s probably in the Ts ’n Cs somewhere, but why read the fine print when you can get inside info delivered direct to your stories, free of charge?

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.