Welcome Home, Elena

Horror Suspense Thriller

Written in response to: "Write a story in which two (or more) characters want the same thing — but for very different reasons." as part of The Lie They Believe with Abbie Emmons.

The listing had been sitting for months, the way certain houses sit in photographs—caught between memory and neglect, waiting for someone to decide what they are worth.

“Seven acres,” Elena said, scrolling slowly, reverently, like she was reading Scripture. “Original farmhouse, late 1800s. Restored greenhouse. Barn, stables, paddock. And look at that silo—oh my goodness, Daniel, that silo is gorgeous.”

Daniel leaned over her shoulder, not really looking at the silo.

He was looking at the shadows behind it.

“Mm,” he said, noncommittal. “Yeah. Gorgeous.”

The photo showed the farmhouse at dusk. That was the first thing he noticed—the timing. Whoever took the listing photos had chosen twilight for several shots. Amateur mistake, if your goal was to make a place feel safe. Twilight blurred edges, deepened corners, let the eye invent things that weren’t quite there.

Or that were.

He zoomed in.

“Look at the windows,” Elena said, tapping the screen. “Original wood frames. You can tell they’ve been refinished but not replaced. And the porch—Daniel, that wraparound porch is a dream.”

He wasn’t looking at the porch.

He was looking at the second-floor window.

“Yeah,” he said slowly. “Dream.”

There was a reflection in the glass that didn’t match the angle of the setting sun. He tilted the phone, squinting.

“Daniel, are you even listening to me?”

“I’m listening,” he said. “Farmhouse. Barn. Silo. Greenhouse. Paddock. Rustic charm. You want to make jam and raise chickens and live out your cottagecore fantasy.”

She gave him a look. “It is not a fantasy. It’s a lifestyle.”

“And you’ve always wanted it.”

“Yes,” she said simply.

That part was true. Elena Morales had been collecting old things her entire life—furniture with history, books with inscriptions, chipped teacups that had outlived their sets. She liked things that had been lived in, worn smooth by time and hands.

A farm like this wasn’t just a property to her.

It was a story.

“What about you?” she asked. “You’ve been weirdly quiet.”

Daniel handed the phone back. “Just thinking.”

“About?”

He hesitated just long enough that she noticed.

“About how it’s been on the market for eight months,” he said. “That’s a long time for something like this. Especially at that price.”

Elena shrugged. “Maybe people don’t want the upkeep. Farms are a lot of work.”

“Or maybe,” Daniel said lightly, “there’s a reason people aren’t buying it.”

She rolled her eyes. “You think everything has a reason.”

“I’m a paranormal investigator,” he said. “It’s literally my job to think that.”

“Your job,” she said, “is to debunk people who think their houses are haunted.”

“Sometimes,” he said.

And sometimes, he didn’t.

They drove out to see it on a Saturday.

The road narrowed as they left the main highway, asphalt giving way to gravel, then to something that was more suggestion than surface. The trees grew closer together here, their branches knitting overhead like a canopy.

“Elena,” Daniel said, slowing the car. “When’s the last time you saw another house?”

She didn’t answer immediately.

“…Ten minutes ago?”

“Fifteen,” he said.

She looked out the window, frowning slightly. “It’s rural. That’s kind of the point.”

“Right.”

He checked the GPS again. One more mile.

He could feel it now—that subtle shift in atmosphere that he’d learned to recognize over the years. It wasn’t dramatic. No sudden cold spots or flickering lights.

Just a pressure.

Like the air itself was paying attention.

“There,” Elena said, sitting up straighter.

The trees opened abruptly, and the farm revealed itself all at once.

It was exactly like the photos.

And not at all like them.

The farmhouse stood at the center, white paint faded to a soft, weathered cream. The wraparound porch curved gracefully around its front, supported by slender columns. To the right, the barn loomed, its red boards darkened with age. Beyond it, the silo rose like a sentinel against the sky.

The greenhouse caught the light, its glass panes gleaming faintly even under the overcast sky.

“It’s beautiful,” Elena whispered.

Daniel didn’t answer.

He was listening.

There’s a sound that places make when they’re empty. A kind of quiet that isn’t quite silence—wind through grass, the distant creak of wood, the soft hum of insects.

This wasn’t that.

This was quieter.

Too quiet.

“Daniel?”

“Yeah,” he said. “Yeah, it’s… something.”

The realtor was already there, standing on the porch and waving as they pulled up.

“Welcome!” she called as they got out of the car. “You must be Elena and Daniel.”

“Elena,” Elena said, shaking her hand warmly. “This is Daniel.”

“Marcy,” the realtor said. “So glad you could make it. I have to say, this place really is something special.”

Daniel caught the slight hesitation before she said “special.”

“What can you tell us about it?” he asked.

Marcy smiled, a little too brightly. “Well, it was built in 1892 by the Whitaker family. They ran a successful dairy operation here for decades. The property has been in a few different hands since then, but it’s always been… well-loved.”

“Well-loved,” Daniel repeated.

“Yes,” she said quickly. “Of course, it’s been vacant for a little while now, so it could use some attention. But structurally, it’s sound. And the charm—well, you can’t fake that.”

Elena was already halfway up the porch steps.

“Can we go inside?” she asked.

“Of course.”

Daniel followed, his gaze flicking once more to the second-floor windows.

For a moment, he thought he saw something move.

But when he blinked, it was gone.

The house smelled like dust and old wood.

Not unpleasant.

Just… old.

Elena walked through it like someone returning home. She ran her fingers along the banister, traced the edges of doorframes, paused in the kitchen with a soft, almost reverent sigh.

“Original cabinetry,” she said. “Oh, this is incredible. Daniel, look at these hinges—they’re hand-forged.”

“Mm-hmm,” he said, scanning the room.

No EMF spikes. No temperature drops.

But the pressure was still there.

Subtle.

Watching.

They moved from room to room. Living room, dining room, a small study. Each space carried the same quiet weight.

“Upstairs?” Marcy said.

Elena nodded eagerly.

Daniel followed more slowly.

The stairs creaked under their weight, the sound echoing slightly in the otherwise silent house. At the top, a narrow hallway stretched in both directions, lined with doors.

“Three bedrooms,” Marcy said. “And a full bath at the end.”

Elena stepped into the first room, gasping softly. “The light in here…”

Daniel stayed in the hallway.

He was looking at the second door on the left.

Something about it felt… wrong.

Not dramatic. Not even obvious.

Just… off.

“Daniel,” Elena called. “You have to see this.”

“In a minute,” he said.

He stepped toward the door.

“Is this room empty?” he asked.

Marcy glanced over. “Yes. All the rooms are empty.”

He reached for the knob.

It was colder than it should have been.

“Daniel,” Elena said again, a note of impatience creeping in.

He opened the door.

The room was empty.

Of course it was.

Bare walls, wooden floor, a single window looking out over the paddock.

Nothing unusual.

Nothing at all.

He stepped inside.

And the pressure changed.

It wasn’t stronger.

Just… closer.

Like stepping into a conversation that had already been happening.

“Daniel?”

He turned.

Elena stood in the doorway, her expression shifting as she looked at him.

“What is it?” she asked.

He hesitated.

“I don’t know yet,” he said.

And that was the truth.

They walked the property afterward.

Elena fell in love with the greenhouse immediately.

“Look at this,” she said, pushing open the door. “It’s still intact. With a little work, we could grow everything—herbs, vegetables, even flowers year-round.”

Daniel stepped inside, the glass walls trapping a faint warmth.

“This is what you want,” he said.

“Yes,” she said. “This is exactly what I want.”

He believed her.

That was the problem.

They moved on to the barn. The wood groaned softly as they entered, the interior dim and cavernous.

“Imagine this restored,” Elena said. “We could keep horses. Or goats. Or—”

She stopped.

“What?” Daniel asked.

She shook her head. “Nothing. I just thought I heard something.”

“What did it sound like?”

“…A voice,” she said slowly. “But that’s ridiculous.”

Daniel didn’t say anything.

He had heard it too.

Not clearly.

Just… something.

They didn’t linger.

The silo was last.

It stood a little apart from the rest of the structures, its concrete surface worn and cracked. The door at its base was slightly ajar.

“Do we go in?” Elena asked.

Daniel looked at it.

Everything in him said no.

“Yes,” he said.

They approached together.

The air felt heavier here.

Denser.

Elena pushed the door open.

The interior was dark, the circular walls rising up into shadow. The smell was different here—earthier, damp.

Daniel stepped inside first.

“Hello?” he called.

His voice echoed strangely, swallowed and returned in fragments.

No answer.

Elena stepped in behind him.

For a moment, nothing happened.

And then—

A sound.

Clear.

Distinct.

A whisper.

“Stay.”

Elena froze.

“Did you—”

“Yes,” Daniel said.

They looked at each other.

Same word.

Same voice.

Same impossible certainty that it hadn’t come from either of them.

Elena swallowed. “We should go.”

Daniel nodded.

They left the silo without another word.

They drove home in silence.

The sun had set by the time they reached the highway, the world outside the car reduced to darkness and the occasional sweep of headlights.

“Well?” Elena said finally.

Daniel kept his eyes on the road.

“Well what?”

“Do you want it?”

He exhaled slowly.

“Yes,” he said.

She turned to him, surprised. “Really?”

“Yes.”

“For the same reasons I do?”

He didn’t answer right away.

“No,” he said finally.

She studied him. “Why, then?”

He hesitated.

Because if he said it out loud, it would make it real.

“Because something’s wrong with that place,” he said.

Elena’s expression didn’t change.

“I know,” she said.

He glanced at her. “You do?”

“I felt it,” she said. “In the house. In the barn. In the silo.”

“And you still want it?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

She looked out the window, her reflection faint in the glass.

“Because it’s not just wrong,” she said. “It’s… unfinished. Like a story that got cut off in the middle.”

Daniel tightened his grip on the wheel.

“And you want to finish it.”

“Yes.”

He nodded slowly.

“I want to understand it,” he said.

She smiled faintly. “Of course you do.”

They drove the rest of the way in silence.

Two people.

Wanting the same thing.

For completely different reasons.

And neither of them willing to let it go.

They made an offer the next morning.

And somewhere, deep in the quiet of an empty farmhouse, something listened.

And waited.

Posted Mar 20, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.