At first, everything seemed dark. The rafters dissolved into shadow; beyond the barn window, October held its deep plum colour without surrendering any sweetness. I listened. Somewhere below the hill, a chime sounded, although no wind disturbed the bells. Then came laughter, intimate and unexpected, as if a door had opened in the night. One golden light appeared, followed by another. A third rose slowly and remained suspended above the rooftops. I watched without moving. Something was gathering in the village, and the darkness, which had seemed so absolute, was making room.
Gradually, colour resolved into familiar shapes: a coral ribbon, an amber lantern, an ivory crescent over the bakery. Paper ghosts swayed beneath the eaves, their expressions more welcoming than alarming. The square prepared for the celebration I watched from a distance every year. I had become accomplished at mistaking proximity for participation. Music reached me across slate-blue gardens; ‘Trick or treat!’ rose from a doorstep, followed by laughter. I imagined standing beside someone glad I had come. Almost belonging required remarkably little courage. It also offered remarkably little comfort.
My ears distinguished quieter preparations beneath the laughter: a beetle shifting in a terracotta pot, tissue paper unfolding, scissors shaping a witch’s hat. Anticipation moved through russet hedges. Pumpkins illuminated the doorsteps; their carved smiles lavish and unguarded; one wore a crooked crown of autumn leaves. Halloween. I extended my wings against the window: a small umber silhouette against the brightness. Midnight, a bat whose whole body could shelter beneath a leaf. Beyond me, the village wore gold. I wanted to arrive without apologising for the shade I cast.
I wanted to be a butterfly. One summer evening, I had watched a butterfly open its wings upon the lavender. Amber deepened into vermilion; turquoise seemed to hold the memory of sunlight on water. Rose shaded into violet, interrupted by pearl-white markings and a sudden, impossible green. I remained motionless before that exquisite abundance. Below it, faces lifted. Someone murmured, ‘Look,’ with such tenderness that the word seemed a gift. They waited for its wings to open again. I watched from behind a leaf, astonished by the welcome beauty could receive, and wondered what it might feel like to be awaited rather than merely tolerated.
Butterflies adorned the things people kept cards, painted cups, embroidered ribbons. Bats became silhouettes cut from black paper. Sometimes a window closed as I approached, before anyone could notice the care with which I flew. My small considerations escaped attention: yielding to a tired moth, listening for a beetle that had lost its way. Perhaps unfamiliarity, rather than dislike, explained those retreating faces. Nevertheless, butterflies seemed universally cherished to me. I assembled their colours in my imagination as though they were credentials: citron, copper, turquoise, pearl. I wanted no ovation. Only an unhurried welcome, and a place someone had thought to leave beside them.
My first attempt involved a yellow leaf. Against my wing, it remained obstinately botanical. A violet ribbon proved more persuasive until I caught its end and tumbled into clean straw. Beside the basket, a woman in a pumpkin-coloured shawl looked up from her paper scraps. She neither recoiled nor reached to capture me. ‘An unconventional entrance,’ she observed, leaving room for me to retreat. Her amusement contained no cruelty. I stayed. On this enchanted evening, I discovered that human words were suddenly intelligible to me.
Her name was Marigold. She was preparing decorations for the village party. ‘I want to be a butterfly,’ I ventured. To my astonishment, she understood. She raised blue tissue paper; moonlight silvered her hair, and a spark travelled along its edge. ‘Is that usual?’ I asked. ‘On Halloween,’ she said. ‘When something is made to be shared.’ She considered her materials. ‘Blue, certainly. Orange. And enough pink to make restraint unnecessary.’ Her hands remained still while I approached. The spark waited beneath her fingertip.
I described the butterfly and the human faces lifting to welcome it. Marigold listened, cobalt trimmings gathering around her hands. ‘We can honour that. But nothing that restrains your wings.’ I had intended to conceal them entirely. With my permission, she fashioned weightless panels above my shoulders, leaving my flight unimpeded. Rose and indigo lay beside brown without cancelling it. Being helped without being corrected was disconcerting. She made space for what I admired without removing what I was.
Other villagers arrived: a man carrying gold paper, a neighbour with thread, two children looking for their cardboard moon. Hearing our plans, they stayed, astonishment giving way to practical generosity. Silver markings; greener; copper curls hovering briefly above the table. Stars on the man’s waistcoat brightened whenever he laughed. Nobody found my longing absurd. Nobody hurried me. Beneath their patient attention, the paper acquired a luminosity moonlight alone could not explain. I had expected human hands to close windows. Here they were opening possibilities.
I chose blue with silver moving through it, then orange gathering warmth from an unseen sun. Pink softened into violet; green emerged like foliage glimpsed through flowers. Marigold placed pearl-white markings along the edges, each kindling beneath her touch. Finally, she added a dark outline. ‘As you remembered.’ I studied it. The colour I had hoped to escape gave the others definition. Human fingers had made something beautiful from my description; its darkest part was not a mistake.
The children offered a polished tin lid as a mirror. Above my brown fur, colours opened into astonishing depths: blue, translucent orange, violet edged with pearl. I turned slowly. Was this the ease of approaching people without anticipating withdrawal? Then my ears appeared in the reflection. Instinctively, I lowered them. ‘What if everyone recognises me?’ I asked. A child steadied the mirror without coming closer. For once, a human face waited while I decided what to do.
‘I imagine they will.’ Marigold set aside her scissors. ‘Butterflies make people happy,’ I said. ‘If I could be beautiful enough—’ ‘You waited until that beetle left before landing on the basket.’ I looked up. ‘I noticed. And I want your company, Midnight. The paper is lovely. It isn’t the reason.’ She laid a saffron flower within reach. ‘Keep the colours. Loving them doesn’t oblige you to disappear.’ I had rehearsed explanations for my presence, not imagined a person wanting it.
We descended past amber windows and jewel-wrapped sweets. Beside a pumpkin stood a smaller lantern. ‘A turnip,’ Marigold explained. ‘People in Ireland and Britain carved those before pumpkins became popular. Migrants carried the custom to America and found pumpkins easier to carve.’ She recalled Scottish guising: costumed callers offering songs or jokes for treats. ‘And souling, when people received cakes in exchange for prayers for the departed. The customs have changed; their histories overlap.’ I watched a door open to laughing visitors. Tonight, those inherited gestures felt like invitations. A russet leaf accompanied us towards the square.
The square shimmered with human invention. Paper stars hovered above their strings; smiling ghosts drifted between pumpkins. A fiddler released golden motes beneath the chestnut tree. Adults and children wore clouds, comets, velvet witch’s hats, and one impractical sandwich. A woman’s knitted daisies opened at every greeting; a man wore strawberry leaves. Wrapped sweets filled a cauldron-shaped bowl beside toffee apples and sugar-web biscuits. Cinnamon, baked pumpkin, and damp foliage scented the air. From above, I watched families greet neighbours and strangers make room for one another. Nothing beautiful had been reserved for the few.
Where lantern gold thinned into blue, I hesitated. Marigold stopped beneath my perch. ‘There’s no hurry.’ A volunteer dressed as a sunflower approached with paper leaves: ochre, crimson, green. He greeted Marigold, then looked up at me. Surprise crossed his face, followed by a smile. He placed a green leaf on the branch rather than reaching for me. Something you hope for, it read. I held it carefully. Writing down a wish seemed more exposing than wearing one.
‘Remarkable colours,’ he said. ‘A garden in flight.’ ‘I’m a bat,’ I replied too quickly. He glanced at his sunflower petals. ‘Fortunately, nobody needs to become their costume.’ I laughed. He left a pencil beside the leaf; with a little Halloween magic, it felt light enough to guide. I wrote: I hope there is a place for me. The stem curled around a twig. Green light settled in its veins. ‘The tree listens,’ the man said. ‘The rest falls to us.’ Human wishes stirred around mine.
The man in strawberry leaves noticed a garland slipping beyond his reach. ‘Could you help, Midnight?’ Marigold had introduced us. I rose through lilac shadow, lifted the ribbon, and restored its sweep of scarlet and gold. Human faces turned upwards. This time their attention held delight rather than alarm. The applause was brief and warm, requiring no further performance. ‘Thank you.’ I settled on a branch while conversation resumed beneath me. They had witnessed a bat flying and found something to welcome.
The evening opened around me: painted acorns, apple-bobbing, a perch kept vacant. A woman wearing moth wings admired my violet paper. She studied butterflies, she explained. ‘Lepidopterology: the study of butterflies and moths. Their wings carry minute, overlapping scales. Some colours come from pigments; others, including many luminous blues, from microscopic structures interacting with light.’ I imagined that invisible architecture. ‘Understanding it doesn’t diminish the wonder.’ Nearby, a man in a silver hat admired my copper curls. Acceptance accumulated quietly: a name remembered, knowledge shared, space beneath my branch left undisturbed.
Below my branch, Marigold began to dance. She glanced upwards. ‘Join us?’ I confessed my ignorance. ‘Distinguished company,’ she assured me, indicating the human sandwich revolving with splendid disregard for rhythm. I flew circles above the dancers, keeping clear of their faces; Marigold turned beneath me. Our different movements found the same music. Golden notes traced our paths. Blue and rose sparks drifted from the costume. Beneath its borrowed radiance, my own wings carried me into a celebration made by people, with room for a bat.
A breeze passed between the cottages, lifting plum-coloured bunting and loosening a copper curl. My orange panel caught against a branch. The paper tore. I stopped. Its fragment descended beside a pumpkin, a small sunset falling out of reach. An old certainty returned: the loveliness was provisional, and without it I would be unwelcome again. For a moment, the square seemed drained of colour. Yet carmine skirts still turned beneath golden notes. I could not immediately believe their music still included me.
Behind a flowerpot, I watched the fallen orange glow. I grieved its graceful curve, its concentrated warmth. Marigold’s kindness had not diminished my love of beauty. The man in the silver hat crouched nearby, holding the copper curl. ‘You’ve misplaced a sunset.’ He set it down and withdrew his hand. Marigold followed with the torn paper. ‘Shall we repair it?’ Neither reached for me. I moved closer of my own accord. Neither had mistaken a damaged costume for a diminished friend.
At the decorations table, Marigold joined the tear with green paper; her neighbour laid copper across the seam. Gold followed the repair, unfolding into a leaf-shaped shimmer. ‘It still works?’ ‘Why wouldn’t it?’ She touched the patch. ‘There’s care here, too.’ The altered pattern pleased me. Beyond the lantern, the strawberry costume needed adjusting; the children’s moon bore a dent; the sandwich danced despite a missing corner. These people had not come to demonstrate perfection. Tentatively, I stopped demanding it of myself.
I unfolded my real wings beside the lantern. Light revealed chestnut deepening into bronze, delicate lines branching through translucent folds. I remembered the butterfly scholar’s explanation. These were not scaled wings, nor was their warmth iridescence. Yet attention revealed intricacies I had overlooked. ‘Beautiful,’ she murmured from beside Marigold. I almost explained that she was looking beneath the costume. Then I understood that she knew. Her human eyes followed the curve of my wing with the wonder I remembered beside the lavender. Its beauty had not appeared tonight. Someone, including me, had finally noticed.
At the far end of a bench, a boy in a dove-grey cloud watched the dancers. I recognised his posture: attention reaching forward while his body stayed apart. A silver paper raindrop lay at his feet. I waited for someone more radiant to approach, then remembered Marigold’s patience. I settled on a low branch nearby. ‘Would you like company?’ He looked up, startled, then nodded. His name was Rowan. He thought his costume foolish. I described my violet ribbon and the decidedly unglamorous basket of straw.
His laughter came hesitantly, then freely. I let the saffron flower fall into his open palm. Against his grey cloud, another petal unfolded; silver raindrops brightened. Marigold joined him on the bench while I remained overhead. Soon Rowan’s cheerful inaccuracy with the teal acorns had us laughing. Grey held the flower’s warmth beautifully. A golden spark rose between us. I scarcely noticed. What held my attention was a human face losing its reserve, not because I resembled a butterfly, but because I had stayed to listen.
Before the procession, the villagers assembled a butterfly from the scraps. Rowan chose silver; Marigold, yellow. From my perch, I nudged brown paper towards luminous turquoise. Nobody suggested a brighter contribution. They lifted the finished wings. Silver trembled, yellow warmed, brown acquired the depth of amber. The butterfly rose from their hands, leaving colour suspended behind it. Human laughter filled the square. I flew beside their creation, my contribution recognisable among theirs. Together we had made something none of us could have fashioned alone.
The Halloween procession wound around the square: families, friends, neighbours pulling decorated carts. Pumpkin lanterns bobbed beneath pointed hats. Our butterfly travelled overhead, casting turquoise, rose, and amber across the cobbles. I flew above Marigold and Rowan, watching human hands clasp, separate to make room, then find one another again. Where the path narrowed, they slowed. When someone paused, they waited beneath the hovering rainbow. Its colours touched everyone without choosing favourites. Beauty lay in the spectacle, but also in its pace: nobody had to struggle alone to remain within it.
The butterfly settled above the table, turquoise yielding to silver, then brown. I watched for my contribution without embarrassment. Rowan looked up. ‘Will you come back tomorrow?’ ‘Without these?’ I lifted the patched paper. ‘Of course,’ he said. Marigold smiled. ‘We’ll keep your branch clear.’ The promise was small and wonderfully practical. No one asked me to preserve the enchantment or return more beautiful. Tomorrow our words might become unfamiliar, but they would recognise my flight. I would know the open window, the waiting branch, the faces lifting with pleasure. The invitation was for a bat.
At the wishing tree, I read my first words: I hope there is a place for me. Beneath them I added: There is. And there is room for Rowan. Emerald travelled through the leaf. Crimson, ochre, and silver wishes stirred around it, each holding an ordinary hope. I no longer wished to exchange my shape for admission. Instead, I wondered who else might be watching from beyond the lanterns, mistaking distance for safety. Tomorrow, I could look for them. Beyond the square, indigo night held violet rooftops and bronze branches. Its quieter colours were no longer empty.
I flew home in my patched costume, copper curls askew. Butterflies remained exquisite; I would always marvel at their violet, turquoise, and impossible orange. But admiration no longer required my erasure. Beneath the rafters, I set down the borrowed wings. Their last sparkle faded. For a moment I waited for the old darkness to return. Instead, I remembered Rowan’s laughter, Marigold keeping my branch clear, my brown fragment rising among the brighter colours. Nothing had transformed me into someone deserving of welcome. I had been deserving before I left the barn. And I had something to give attention, kindness, a place beside me. Outside, October held its deep plum sweetness. I stretched my own wings into it, imagining tomorrow’s flight. I had wanted to become a butterfly so that someone would welcome me. Now I could remain a bat—and welcome someone else. The light came from within. It grew when I shared it.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.