The Third Check

Horror Suspense Urban Fantasy

Written in response to: "Write about a character who wakes up in the middle of the night, or is unable to sleep." as part of What Keeps You Up at Night.

The Third Check

Daniel Mercer opened his eyes at 2:17 in the morning.

He didn’t know why.

For several seconds, he lay still beneath the blankets, staring into the darkness. The house was quiet except for rain tapping against the bedroom window.

He started to close his eyes.

Click.

His eyes opened again.

He knew that sound.

The deadbolt on the back door.

Daniel listened.

Nothing.

“Old house,” he muttered.

Except old houses didn’t turn deadbolts.

He walked into the hallway. At the top of the stairs, he stopped.

“Who’s there?”

No answer.

Downstairs, he checked the front door.

Locked.

Garage.

Locked.

The back door stood exactly as he’d left it. Chain hooked. Deadbolt vertical.

Locked.

Daniel twisted it gently.

Nothing.

“You’re getting old, Mercer.”

He returned upstairs, checking all three doors once more before bed.

2:23.

Five minutes.

He closed his eyes.

Downstairs, the deadbolt slowly moved from vertical to horizontal.

Click.

By morning, Daniel had nearly convinced himself the sound had been part of a dream.

Nearly.

Waiting for his coffee, he glanced at the back door.

The deadbolt was horizontal.

Daniel frowned.

He always left it vertical.

Didn’t he?

He turned it upright.

Click.

His phone rang.

Emily.

“Morning, kiddo.”

“Kiddo? I’m thirty-two.”

“You’ll be a kiddo when you’re sixty.”

“Then you’ll be ninety-five.”

Daniel smiled.

They talked about her job, the weather, a leaking faucet. Ordinary things.

Daniel almost didn’t mention the night before.

“Something woke me up last night.”

“What?”

“The back-door deadbolt.”

There was a pause.

“Someone was at the door?”

“No. It was locked.”

“Then how do you know it was the deadbolt?”

“Because I know what my deadbolt sounds like.”

Emily laughed. “Dad, that house is ancient.”

“Fifty-eight years old.”

“Old houses make noises.”

“Deadbolts don’t.”

Another pause.

“It’s probably nothing.”

Daniel’s smile faded.

He’d heard those words before.

Not from Emily.

A long time ago.

The memory vanished when he reached for it.

That evening, Daniel performed the same routine he’d followed for years.

Front.

Back.

Garage.

Again.

Then once more.

Three times.

Standing in the kitchen with his hand on the deadbolt, Daniel frowned.

“When did you start doing this?”

He couldn’t remember.

Hours later, his eyes opened.

2:17.

Then…

Click.

Daniel pulled on his slippers.

At the stairs he stopped.

“Who’s there?”

Silence.

He descended slowly.

Front door. Locked.

Garage. Locked.

He switched on the kitchen light.

The deadbolt was horizontal.

Daniel froze.

“No.”

He had left it vertical.

Three times.

He crossed the kitchen.

Locked. Chain still hooked. No damaged window or frame.

He turned the deadbolt vertical.

Click.

Then he searched the house.

Empty.

At the basement door, he noticed light beneath it.

Daniel hesitated.

He remembered turning that light off.

At least he thought he did.

The basement was empty.

Back upstairs, he found a roll of blue painter’s tape and stretched a strip across the deadbolt and door.

“There.”

If the lock moved, the tape would tear.

Halfway out of the kitchen, something near the back door caught his eye.

Dust.

Gray. Almost white.

Daniel crouched and rubbed some between his fingers.

The kitchen disappeared.

White light burned through the blinds.

Laura stood beside the back door in her nightgown, terrified.

Daniel heard his own voice.

Who’s there?

Laura turned.

Don’t open it.

Daniel jerked backward.

The kitchen returned.

He was sitting against a cabinet, breathing hard.

“What the hell...?”

The microwave read:

2:31.

Daniel stared.

Twelve minutes were gone.

Then he looked at the back door.

The painter’s tape remained perfectly intact.

Underneath it, the deadbolt was horizontal.

Daniel didn’t sleep again.

At sunrise he sat at the kitchen table with every downstairs light on.

The gray powder was gone.

He’d searched for it on his hands and knees.

Nothing.

The memory remained.

Laura.

The light.

Don’t open it.

He called Emily.

“Dad?”

“Did I wake you?”

“It’s seven-thirty on a Saturday.”

Daniel hesitated.

“Do you remember the night your mother disappeared?”

Silence.

“Why are you asking me that?”

“I remembered something.”

“What?”

“Your mother was standing in the kitchen. There was a bright light outside.”

Another silence.

“What light?”

Something in Emily’s voice made Daniel sit straighter.

“You remember it?”

“I thought it was a dream.”

Daniel gripped his coffee mug.

“Tell me.”

“I woke up because my room was bright.”

“Headlights?”

“No. Like daylight. But wrong.”

Daniel felt cold.

“I could hear you and Mom downstairs. I think she screamed.”

“What else?”

“There was a sound.”

“What kind?”

“A hum. Really low. I could feel it more than hear it.”

Something opened inside Daniel’s memory.

Laura gripping his arm.

Dishes trembling.

A vibration through the floor.

And Laura whispering:

It’s back.

Daniel stood abruptly.

“Dad?”

“She said it was back.”

“Back from where?”

“I don’t know.”

But Daniel suddenly understood something.

Whatever happened the night Laura disappeared—

hadn’t started that night.

“I’m coming over,” Emily said.

“I’m fine.”

“No, Dad. You’re not.”

He looked at the back door.

“Okay.”

After the call, Daniel noticed the coffee mug in his hand.

He stared at it.

He didn’t remember pouring coffee.

The mug was warm.

Then a faint vibration came through the floor.

Daniel looked at the microwave.

8:04.

The hum stopped.

The clock changed.

8:17.

Thirteen minutes.

Gone.

His phone rang.

Emily.

“Dad?”

Static swallowed her voice.

Then:

“Dad... I’m outside.”

Daniel looked through the window.

Her car was in the driveway.

He hadn’t heard it arrive.

“Come in.”

More static.

“Dad?”

“What?”

“Why is your front door open?”

Daniel looked down the hallway.

The front door was closed.

Locked.

“Emily, stay in your car.”

“What?”

“Tell me what you see.”

“The door’s open. Maybe a foot.”

Daniel stood less than ten feet from the closed door.

“Can you see inside?”

“Yes.”

“Can you see me?”

“No.”

“Emily, leave.”

“I’m not leaving you.”

“Drive down the street and call the police.”

“And tell them what?”

“Please.”

That stopped her.

Through the window, he saw her start the engine.

Then came the hum.

Emily heard it too.

Her face changed.

“Dad…”

The kitchen cabinets trembled.

Lights flickered.

Everything went dark.

Emily’s headlights died.

The streetlights vanished.

Dogs began barking throughout the neighborhood.

Then every one of them stopped.

At once.

White light poured through Daniel’s windows.

Not from the street.

From above.

And Daniel remembered.

He was forty-seven again.

Laura beside him.

Barefoot. Nightgown.

Dan. There’s something outside.

Another memory surfaced.

Months earlier, Daniel and Laura stood in their backyard staring at a dark shape hanging above the trees.

No lights.

No sound.

A hole where the stars should have been.

Then it vanished.

Daniel had laughed it off.

Laura hadn’t.

For weeks she said she felt watched.

It’s probably nothing, he’d told her.

Now he remembered.

The night Laura disappeared, the kitchen glowed white.

The dishes trembled.

It’s back, Laura whispered.

Something moved in the hallway.

Daniel’s memory refused to give it a proper shape.

Tall.

Arms too long.

Joints bending wrong.

Laura screamed.

She grabbed the kitchen doorframe.

Her feet left the floor.

“LAURA!”

Daniel tried to reach her.

Couldn’t move.

Her fingers slipped from the frame.

She wasn’t pulled through the door.

The door never opened.

Laura rose into the white light.

Then she was gone.

Something stood beside Daniel.

It looked at him.

And two words entered his mind.

Not spoken.

Placed there.

Not yet.

Daniel opened his eyes.

He was sixty-seven again.

Same kitchen.

Same light.

Same hum vibrating through his bones.

Twenty years.

For twenty years he had checked that door three times every night.

Some part of him had remembered what his mind refused to.

And now he understood the absurdity of it.

The locks had never kept anything out.

They hadn’t spared him twenty years ago.

They had postponed him.

“Not yet,” Daniel whispered.

Something moved in the dark hallway.

His eyes filled with tears.

“You meant me.”

Then came a voice from the front of the house.

“Dad!”

Daniel spun around.

“Emily?”

She stood at the end of the hallway.

She had come inside.

“Emily, get out!”

“I’m not leaving you!”

Behind her, something moved.

Not walked.

Moved.

The darkness seemed to stretch upward.

Emily turned.

Daniel saw her face change.

And suddenly he understood something worse than why they had returned.

His daughter had been in the house that night too.

“Emily,” he whispered.

The thing tilted its head.

The white light intensified.

Daniel ran toward Emily.

“Get away from it!”

She didn't move.

Her eyes were fixed on the darkness behind her.

“Dad...”

Daniel reached her and grabbed her arm.

The thing moved closer.

Emily screamed.

Daniel pulled her toward the front door.

“Go!”

She grabbed the knob.

“It won't open!”

Daniel shoved past her and twisted it.

Locked.

He turned the deadbolt.

Nothing.

He unlocked it again.

Nothing.

The door might as well have been part of the wall.

“Window.”

They ran into the living room.

Emily grabbed the window latch.

It wouldn't move.

“Dad, what's happening?”

“I don't know.”

But he did.

Not all of it.

Enough.

The humming deepened.

Emily covered her ears.

“Make it stop!”

Daniel looked toward the hallway.

The figure was gone.

That frightened him more.

“Emily.”

She looked at him.

“Whatever happens, you stay with me.”

“What is that thing?”

“I don't know.”

“Is that what took Mom?”

Daniel couldn't answer.

Her face crumpled.

“Oh, God.”

“I think so.”

The lights flickered once.

Not the lamps.

The white light outside.

For an instant, the room went dark.

Daniel saw something standing behind Emily.

Then the light returned.

Nothing there.

Emily began crying.

Daniel pulled her against him.

“I've got you.”

The words brought another memory.

Laura screaming.

Her fingers slipping from the doorframe.

Daniel unable to move.

Not yet.

He understood.

Twenty years ago, it hadn't wanted Emily.

It hadn't wanted him.

It wanted Laura.

Tonight was different.

Daniel looked down at his daughter.

Maybe it wasn't different enough.

The hum changed pitch.

Pain exploded behind Daniel's eyes.

He dropped to one knee.

“Dad!”

Images tore through him.

Laura rising into the light.

The figure watching.

Emily at twelve, standing halfway down the stairs.

Daniel had forgotten that.

Emily had seen it.

She had been there.

And the thing had looked at her too.

Daniel forced himself upright.

“No.”

“What?”

He looked toward the kitchen.

“No.”

The white light was moving through the house now.

Across the floor.

Toward them.

Daniel pushed Emily behind him.

“You already took her.”

The light stopped.

Emily stared at him.

“Dad?”

Daniel faced the empty hallway.

“You hear me?”

The hum continued.

“You took my wife.”

Something appeared at the far end of the hall.

Daniel's legs wanted to give out.

He stayed where he was.

“You don't get my daughter.”

The figure moved forward.

Daniel backed Emily toward the stairs.

Then he felt it.

Pressure.

Not hands.

Something inside his skull.

A thought that wasn't his.

You.

Daniel stopped.

Twenty years.

Not yet.

He understood.

A strange calm came over him.

“Dad?”

Daniel turned to Emily.

For a moment she wasn't thirty-two.

She was twelve again, sitting at the kitchen table after her mother disappeared, asking when Mom was coming home.

Daniel had never been able to answer.

He touched Emily's face.

“I love you, kiddo.”

Her eyes widened.

“Dad, don't.”

“Listen to me.”

“No.”

“Whatever happens, you run.”

“I'm not leaving you.”

“You already did once.”

She stared at him.

“When you were eighteen. You went to college and got the hell out of this house.”

“What does that have to do with anything?”

“I think you knew.”

Emily's expression changed.

Daniel did too.

She had hated this house after Laura disappeared.

Sleepovers at friends' houses. Staying late at school. Begging to spend weekends with relatives.

At eighteen, she'd left.

Not because she wanted to leave Daniel.

Because some buried part of her wanted to leave the house.

“You remembered,” Daniel whispered.

Emily shook her head.

“No.”

“Not here.” Daniel touched her forehead. “But somewhere.”

The hum rose.

Daniel looked toward the figure.

“Take me.”

“Dad!”

The light surged forward.

Daniel shoved Emily with everything he had.

She fell backward through the living room archway.

White filled Daniel's vision.

For one instant he saw Laura.

Not as she'd been that night.

Laura laughing in the backyard on their twentieth anniversary.

Laura holding newborn Emily.

Laura asleep beside him on a Sunday morning.

Then… nothing.

Emily opened her eyes.

Sunlight.

She was lying on the living room floor.

For several seconds she didn't move.

“Dad?”

Her voice sounded small.

Emily sat up.

The house was silent.

“Dad?”

She searched every room.

Bedroom.

Basement.

Garage.

Kitchen.

Empty.

Daniel's car was outside.

His wallet sat on the counter.

Keys beside it.

Reading glasses on the kitchen table.

Phone on the living room floor.

His slippers lay near the stairs.

“Dad!”

Nothing.

Emily grabbed her phone.

9:42.

She stared at it.

The last thing she clearly remembered was sitting in her car outside.

Her father telling her to leave.

After that… nothing.

She called 911.

While it rang, something near the back door caught her attention.

Gray dust.

A thin layer of it covered part of the kitchen floor.

And through it ran footprints.

Bare feet.

Daniel's.

Emily knew them because of the crooked little toe on his left foot.

The prints crossed the kitchen.

Then stopped.

In the middle of the floor.

No prints returned.

No prints continued.

They simply ended.

“911, what's your emergency?”

Emily couldn't answer.

She was twelve years old again.

Sitting at this same table.

Police officers throughout the house.

Her mother missing.

Daniel sitting across from her, pale and shaking.

He kept saying the same thing.

I locked it.

Someone asked him what he meant.

The door.

Then again.

I locked it.

And finally:

I checked it three times.

Emily lowered the phone.

“Oh, Dad.”

The back-door deadbolt turned.

Click.

Emily froze.

Outside, somewhere beyond the kitchen window, came a low, steady hum.

And suddenly she remembered the light.

Her mother's scream.

Her father shouting.

The impossible figure at the bottom of the stairs.

She remembered why she had spent her childhood trying not to sleep in this house.

Why she'd left as soon as she was old enough.

Why, despite loving her father, she had never spent another night beneath this roof.

Emily looked toward the kitchen window.

The morning sky was perfectly clear.

The humming continued.

She remembered that, too.

Posted Sep 14, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.