What Remains

Horror

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

Written in response to: "Set your story in a place where something terrible once happened." as part of What Lingers.

“She chose this place because it’s already haunted,” said the demon. He peeled the adhesive away from his face removing the heavy horns with a sigh of relief.

“Oh, shut up, Johnny,” said the blood-stained cultist. She spread a dollop make-up removing cream onto the blood caking her face.

“It’s true,” Johnny said. He reached over and scooped a dollop of cleaner on his own face. The red waxy make-up and blood smeared.

“Is it really haunted?” asked the demonic nun. She paused in the act of popping the claw-like fake nails off her fingers.

“Don’t listen to him, Emily,” said the cultist. “It’s just an old church.”

“It is creepy, though,” Emily said, returning to her nails. “Who does a haunted house in a church?”

“Why not? It comes complete with graveyard,” said the priest. He walked into the living room turned dressing room with a muffin.

“Why are you still in costume, Steve?” asked the cultist.

“It’s comfortable,” said Steve. “What do you think, Mallory, do you think I could be a priest?”

Steve swished the robe around and the cultist snorted.

“It’s a bit blasphemous,” said Emily.

“Blasphemous or sacrilegious? I can never tell the difference,” said Steve.

Steve flopped in one of the chairs and crossed his feet at the ankle. The rest of them had pounds of make-up and prosthetics to unglue from their faces but all Steve had to do was take the robe with the dog-collar off and he was in his civvies. Mallory, the blood-stained cultist, rolled her eyes at him.

“Sacrilege,” Johnny, the demon, said. “Blasphemy is only words.”

“Sacrilegious, then, don’t you think?” Emily asked.

“It’s a little late to be worried about it now, Emmy,” Steve said. “The ghosts are resting peacefully for another year.”

Tonight was their last night. They had finished their last show. Halloween was over. The church next door was lit up with shop lights and the crew was dismantling the magic. The last of the Jack o’lanterns had been snuffed out; the pumpkins themselves piled into the truck of one of the local rescue farmers who would to feed them to his animals. The smoke machine was off and returned to the plastic tub it lived in forty-eight weeks of the year. The satanic symbols were being scrubbed off the walls.

Just a few hours ago, though, with the only lights filtered through thick red-tinted fog and the sounds of low growling spilling from hidden speakers, the church had been terrifying. People had been lined up near the graveyard and primed with the story of what had happened here.

“It’s all bullshit,” Mallory said.

“What is?” Steve asked.

“The story that Heather tells them. The one Johnny apparently believes,” Mallory said. “This was a church, yeah, like a hundred years ago, but the town dried up and the people moved out and the church was desanctified. That’s all there is to it.”

“The story that Heather told wasn’t entirely true,” Johnny said. “But that’s not the real story.”

“What’s the real story, then?” Steve asked.

“It wasn’t a satanic cult,” Johnny said. “It was the actual church people. The regular congregation. And it was the preacher that was killed.”

“Me?” Steve asked, placing his hand over his heart dramatically. “Not our dear Heather?”

“I like this story better,” Mallory said, smiling at Steve.

“Shameful,” Steve said to Mallory. “Tell us the story, Johnny,” he said, turning to the half-dressed demon.

Mallory groaned but didn’t stop him. Emily bit her lip but didn’t say anything. Johnny scraped the last of the prosthetic off his face and turned to his audience.

“Where we’re sitting was the original church,” Johnny said. “This was the house of Christoph Hoffman, a German immigrant who moved to this area in the late 1890’s. He was a devout Lutheran but there wasn’t a Lutheran church nearby so he started doing Bible study in the front parlour, in here. It became so popular, probably more due to proximity than anything else, that the parlour became too cramped so everyone in the area came together to build the church next door. They also decided that they needed a real preacher, now that it was a church not just a bible study, and a man named Gottlieb Schafer was given the position.

“When Hoffman died, he gave this house and the church to Schafer who moved in with his wife and their children. I have no idea what credentials Schafer had. If any. But, he seemed to be a decent enough preacher because years go by with nothing exciting happening. The problem started when Schafer died in the seventies.

“The church had never been officially sanctified so the question of who should take over became a problem. Some people thought that they should finally get an official minister and some people thought that it should stay the way it was. Eventually, there was a compromise. Gottlieb’s daughter, a woman named Alice Haight, married a man named Lucas who was a Methodist preacher. Someone got a hold of them and they returned to live here and be the preacher at the church.

“It seemed like the end of the problem but it was only the beginning.

“Lucas and Alice were a younger couple, in their late twenties, early thirties. He was described as good-looking and open-minded and she was pale and fragile. Apparently, she was sick for a long time. And, they were childless. Alice and Lucas lived here in the old house with Alice’s overbearing sister, Dolores, her husband, Ezra, and their two children. It’s cramped and everyone is tense.

“Then, a young couple named Waylon and Evelyn Sefton moved in. They were married right before Waylon was sent to Viet Nam and he returned a completely different person. He was abusive and angry all the time. They moved out here so that they could repair their marriage, thinking that it was the stress of living in the city that was the problem, but now Evelyn feels trapped and isolated. She did the only thing she could think of and started going to church and talking to the preacher, Lucas Haight.

“Well, they’re both young, with problematic family lives, and good-looking. They’re spending a lot of time together. Rumors start to fly. When Evelyn got pregnant, it’s suggested that the baby might not be Waylon’s but might be the young preacher’s.

“Then, Alice Haight died.

“Of course, it was probably just a coincidence. She had been sick for years; some sort of cancer. But, once the rumor mill starts turning it’s hard to get it to stop. Dolores, Alice’s sister, convinced the entire congregation that Lucas killed Alice so that he could run off with his married mistress and raise their illegitimate child. Waylon was convinced, too, and started really beating on Evelyn to the point that she ran away, taking the baby with her.

“That, maybe, would have stopped the rumors had Lucas not left with Evelyn.

“Now, according to the newspaper report, the reason that Lucas left with Evelyn was so that he could get her settled back with her family and talk to the Methodist church about leaving this particular congregation. For some reason, he didn’t feel safe there, anymore. Still, it was a bad look. Then, Waylon Sefton died. Again, probably it was just coincidence. The man was an alcoholic and enjoyed a cigarette in bed, but the timing was unfortunate. Dolores sees this as absolute proof and Waylon Sefton is just another victim to this torrid affair.

“Only, I don’t think that Lucas and Evelyn could have had anything to do with Waylon’s death, or even known about it, because the day after he died, they returned with her brother to collect her things. Dolores saw them coming and got all the men in the congregation together for some vigilante justice. They got Lucas and Evelyn into the church and killed them, execution style, one bullet hole to the head each, right on the altar in front of Jesus.”

The room was silent for a moment.

“Now, that seems sacrilegious,” said Steve.

“Jesus, Steve,” Mallory said.

“That’s awful, why would they do that?” Emily asked.

“They believed they were justified,” Johnny shrugged. “I mean, two people were dead, both killed by a corrupt preacher and his mistress.”

“Did anything happen to them?” Emily asked.

“The killers?” Johnny said. "Oh, yeah. Ezra Baum, Dolores’s husband, was convicted of killing them both. A couple of men were charged with accessory. Dolores was charged with conspiracy to commit murder because it was all her crazy rumor-mongering that started the whole thing.”

“As fucked up as all that is,” Mallory said. “It still doesn’t mean the place is haunted. I didn’t see any ghost that we didn’t make.”

“I don’t know, I felt weird near the altar,” Emily said.

“Emily, please, you just think that now because of Johnny’s story, which may or may not be true, anyway,” Mallory said.

“No, really, there was always just a creepy feeling there, like, a sadness,” Emily said.

“Whatever,” Mallory said. “Fine. I didn’t feel anything. Steve?”

“Nah, sorry, Emmy,” Steve said. “I like a good spooky story but I’m not a believer.”

“Well, believe what you want to believe,” Johnny said. “I researched it and it’s all true. You can read the newspaper reports yourself.”

“I guess that’s why Heather got this place for cheap, though, huh?” Steve asked. “I guess no one wanted to attend Sunday sermon at a Murder Church.”

“It was abandoned shortly after that, yeah,” Johnny said. “It was in pretty rough shape when she bought it.”

“If that’s all true, though, it seems pretty, I don’t know, pretty sick to make the tragedy into an attraction like this,” Emily said.

“Again, a little late now, Emmy,” Steve reminded her.

“Well, I didn’t know all this, Steve,” Emily snapped. “This was just a gig. I didn’t realize it was Heather replaying a real tragedy. I don’t know if I’d have taken the part had I known.”

“I would have,” Mallory shrugged. “There aren’t a lot of roles out there, you know, can’t be that picky.”

“It’s kinda cool,” Steve said. “A little bit of local color for those in the know. Like an Easter egg in a movie.”

“That’s messed up, you guys,” Emily said. “These were real people and not that long ago.”

“I agree,” Johnny said.

Johnny stood up and wrapped his bath robe around him.

“Well, I’m headed off to bed,” he said.

It was three in the morning and he wasn’t a young man anymore. The others believed that Johnny had an arrangement with Heather to sleep in her guest bedroom during the show because it got out so late and he lived so far away. But, Heather Holloway, nee Sefton, rented this house and the church from him. He had inherited it when his parents, Dolores and Ezra Baum, died in prison.

They had met when Heather turned eighteen and learned of her mother’s death. Up until then, she had believed her Aunt and Uncle, her mother’s sister and brother-in-law, were her parents. But, shortly after her eighteenth birthday, they told her the truth, believing that it was time that she knew the truth. It had taken a while for her to overcome the sting of that betrayal. In that time, she had discovered Johnny Baum, the last remaining relative of the entire sordid affair. He had been a broken and haunted man. It had been Heather who suggested the play. She had written it and it had seemed to release something inside him.

Once a year, Heather and Johnny put on a show of a version of what had happened to their parents fifty years ago. Heather always played the role of her mother, the ghost in the graveyard who primed their audience with the awful tale of her death as soon as they got to her headstone. Johnny played his mother.

For the masses, it was a Halloween tradition. For them, it was part therapy, part haunting. After a lifetime of trying to understand something that could never be understood, this macabre ritual was the only thing that remained of the two people who had died in the parlour where he had just told their story.

Posted Nov 06, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.