Submitted to: Contest #328

Jeff

Written in response to: "Write a dual-perspective story or a dual-timeline story."

Creative Nonfiction Crime Horror

When I was a senior in high school I had a friend named Jeff. That was back in 1978. I thought he was a little awkward but he didn’t seem to have many friends and my parents raised me to be a true follower of the teachings of Jesus Christ. Empathy. Compassion. It was a little odd at first, but eventually I became friends with Jeff and we got along well enough. He was just weird sometimes. It didn’t matter all that much to me. I had a lot of other things going on and we didn’t spend very much time together. I was mostly just trying to be kind and true to my principles.

“Who was that boy with the thick glasses who you were walking home with today? A new friend from school?” My mother was always getting in my business. I couldn’t wait to go off to college at UC Santa Cruz in September. I grew up here in Ohio where the winters are harsh and I have always wanted to live near the beach.

“Yeah, that’s my friend Jeff.” I didn’t feel the need to say anything more.

The next day was Friday and when I arrived at school I saw Jeff sitting in the principal’s office. I didn’t know why. I figured he would tell me if he wanted to tell me, but he never showed up for any of our classes together that day.

***************

Now it is July of 1991. I was watching the news today and I saw Jeff for the first time since I left for college. I hadn’t even really thought about him since then. Again, he was quiet and unassuming, but there are some memories of him that have stuck with me. He looked much the way he did back in high school. He still wore the thick glasses but now he had a shaggy haircut and some light facial hair.

The news report said that he had joined the army not long after I left for college and he was stationed at a base in Texas and then another in Germany. I was surprised by that. He never mentioned any desire for military service. He was difficult to know. There was always some distance between Jeff and everyone else, but he was a nice enough kid back when I knew him.

***************

One day when we were getting changed in the locker room after gym class I noticed Jeff staring at my genitals. As soon as I looked at him he quickly turned away and began pulling the clothes from his locker and getting dressed. I never had any reason to believe Jeff was gay before that but it made me think then. I decided to just not say anything about it.

A few days later, Jeff invited me to come over to his house to watch the Cleveland Indians game on TV. We were both fans, but I felt a little uncomfortable about it. I had never been to his house before but I wanted to be kind so I told him I could watch the first few innings but then I had to get going so I could do my homework before dinner.

His house smelled bad. The carpets were stained in some places and it was dark with all of the drapes closed. It seemed like the windows hadn’t been opened to let some air in for a very long time. Still, we turned on the TV and watched the game. The Indians were already losing by three runs in the top of the second. No surprise there. They were awful.

At some point I noticed that Jeff was subtly inching closer to me on the couch and when the palm of his hand lightly brushed over my knee I told him that I had to get back home. I had a big trigonometry test the following day. I grabbed my backpack and quickly let myself out and took a deep breath of the fresh air.

***************

Jeff has been all over the news lately. It has become a very big story. I am seeing his face on TV and in newspapers and magazines. I keep hearing his name on the radio and many of my friends and co-workers are talking about him.

I have decided to not tell anyone that I know him, at least for now.

***************

About a week after we graduated from high school I was walking home from the basketball court when I saw Jeff crouched down in an overgrown, grassy field in our neighborhood. I wanted to just keep my head down and continue on my way but I guess he saw me out of his peripheral vision because he stood up and looked at me, saying nothing. I didn’t want to be rude so I waved and walked towards him. He quickly began walking towards me and we talked for a few minutes about the things that each of us would be doing that summer. Neither of us had any real plans. I was mostly just preparing to leave for college. He wasn't doing much.

At some point I noticed a swarm of flies rising up from the patch of tall grass where Jeff had been crouched when I first saw him. There was something dark and furry over there. I told him I had to run. I had to go mow the lawn.

***************

Jeff’s trial began last week in a Milwaukee courthouse. It’s hard to believe the things that he is accused of.

***************

Towards the end of that summer in 1978, I was eating some cereal for breakfast one day when Jeff rang our doorbell. I opened the door and he just stared at me for a little while.

“Aaron, do you ever think about me?” His eyes had a strange light to them.

“Sure Jeff. We’re friends, right? I think about you.”

He just stared at me.

“Do you want to come in? I’m having some Froot Loops. You want some?”

He continued to stare at me a bit longer.

“No. I have to go.”

Without another word he walked away and I left for UC Santa Cruz about a week later. That was the last time I ever saw him in person.

***************

The trial is long finished now. Jeffrey Dahmer was convicted and sentenced for some of the most horrific and psychopathic crimes that one can possibly imagine. I still find it hard to believe the whole thing but there was a mountain of evidence and he confessed so I know it's all true. I don’t really want to get into the gory details. Besides, I’m sure you already know the story.

It is 2004 now and he has been dead for about ten years, beaten to death in the prison showers by another inmate serving a life sentence.

Sometimes I still remember how my old friend Jeff looked that last time I saw him standing there on my doorstep with that strange light in his eyes. I just wonder what he was thinking about as he stared back at me.

The End

Posted Nov 14, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

18 likes 10 comments

CQ Scafidi
22:20 Nov 19, 2025

Wow, Thomas Wetzel. You did it to me again. This was exceptional. You ratchet up the tension beautifully, and then the ultimate Rod Serling twist ending that I absolutely did not see coming. I remember the case, and you captured his quiet, disarming, and unassuming nature perfectly. Taking us inside his childhood home was brilliant. I loved your story.

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
16:57 Nov 20, 2025

Thanks so much, CQ! I appreciate your time and compliments. I'm glad that I was able to successfully "hide the shark" until the end. (They say that the brilliance of the film Jaws was Spielberg's decision to build tension by not showing the shark until the third act.) I knew if I referred to him as Jeffrey it might tip my hand too early. Part of what I enjoy about writing is the structural stuff. First I start with a general idea, then I consider different ways to express that idea (tense, tone, pacing, formatting, etc.) and then I pick a path and get started. I really love doing this, and especially when people like you enjoy the end product. I appreciate you, my friend.

Reply

Mike White
15:33 Nov 19, 2025

I liked the way you wove the memories together with the present-day reflections, and how the unease grew gradually as each section revealed more about Jeff. I think this would be a really interesting concept to explore even deeper too, looking at trauma/guilt/complicity that kinda stuff

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
19:33 Nov 19, 2025

Thanks, Mike. Glad you enjoyed this. I liked the idea of gradually unspooling the disturbing behavioral signs for the reader in the same way that it played out for the MC. I also knew that calling him Jeffrey would blow the reveal. For a country with a rich heritage of serial killers, I think we are all very proud of Dahmer. First ballot Hall of Fame Psychopath.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
13:17 Nov 19, 2025

He was thinking you'd make a nice stew. Hehehe - I know - not funny but I recall a lot of tongue in cheeks jokes after his arrest. This is very creepy and clever - I remember the whole story back in the day and it made me glad to be a female living on the east coast - far away. I like the use of the prompt and the creative nonfiction tag because I guarantee there were many similar situations as your main character experienced. At first I assumed Jeff was just maybe a bit autistic because of how you described him as different. And you were kind to him - so maybe he tortured less animals?

We all likely know a character like Jeff, maybe not to that extreme but he could be right next door. I kind of figured it was going in that direction with the clump of fur scene but it was still a real rug-ripper that was based on Jeffrey Dahmer -an actual serial killer we all know and were fascinated by in a strange way...and from a distance. You definitely nailed the dual timeline. Kudos!

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
18:51 Nov 19, 2025

Well, with Dahmer I think they were actually tongue AND cheek jokes. (Sorry. That was gross but you’re the one who brought up the stew.)

You captured the essence of what I was aiming for. The idea that many of us have probably crossed paths with some very dangerous people without even knowing it.

The FBI recognizes three childhood characteristics that are indicative of a future serial killer. 1) Cruelty to animals, 2) Head trauma and, this is the odd one, 3) Bed wetting. If you see any kid displaying those 3 behaviors you’re gonna want to call the Behavioral Sciences team at Quantico immediately.

Thanks for reading!

Reply

Tricia Shulist
15:16 Nov 17, 2025

Interesting story. And creepy! I had no idea who Jeff was. Great twist. Thanks for sharing.

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
22:39 Nov 17, 2025

Thanks for reading, Tricia. I knew that if I referred to him as Jeffrey it would probably tip readers off to the big reveal too early. Besides, he probably just went by Jeff in high school. Where I went to school, kids named Jeffrey usually got beat up on a pretty regular basis.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
03:15 Nov 16, 2025

Really? You attended high school with him?

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
04:35 Nov 16, 2025

No. Not autobiographical, just creative nonfiction. I bet somebody had that experience though.

I did go to college with this guy who I became friends with and only when there were a few days before graduation he told a bunch of us that he was the son of Gary Heidnik, the serial killer who Buffalo Bill from Silence of the Lambs was based on. (Not Hannibal Lechter but the other guy with the pit in his basement.) He just told us this at the bar one night and then walked out. It was like he needed to say it. We all just stared at each other, speechless.

Thanks for reading, Mary.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.