When Herr Voss asked me to stay after rehearsal, I thought he was going to give me the solo. I watched the other women collect their things, making a show of looking for something in my bag so nobody would notice I was waiting.
I was thirty-eight. I sold real estate in Jersey City. That afternoon I had spent forty minutes persuading a man that the parking space in his listing was, in fact, a loading zone. But now I stood beside the piano with my hands folded, waiting for this man to tell me whether I was any good.
“The younger girls listen to you,” he said.
“Sometimes they’re just looking at themselves in the mirror.”
He finished making a note. “You will take their Sunday rehearsals. Ten until one.”
I already taught Thursday nights. Sundays were for open houses, and I had promised the owners on Mercer Street I would handle theirs personally. They were going through a divorce and communicated through me, including about things that had nothing to do with the house.
“Every Sunday?”
“Until the performance. Is that a problem?”
“No. I’ll work it out.”
He nodded and opened his music. I waited, hoping he might say something about my dancing. Then he turned the page, and I picked up my bag.
***
My father used to take me to dance lessons on Sundays. The studio was above a pharmacy, and I remembered the collar of his coat against my cheek when he carried me up the stairs. Halfway up he would ask whether I wanted to walk.
“Not yet.”
Sometimes I said it even when we reached the top. He would stand on the landing with me while the other children squeezed past, their little ballet slippers hanging from their bags.
He was a pianist. At home I sat beneath the piano, arranging my plastic animals around the pedals while he practiced. Occasionally he had to stop because a horse was lying where his foot needed to go.
“Excuse me, Miss Lisa. There is livestock.”
I could still hear him saying that. His face was harder. There were photographs, but I had looked at them so often I no longer knew which parts I remembered for myself. I trusted the other things. The thumbnail split down the middle. The peppermints in his coat. His pocket watch, with its little lid that sprang open when he pressed the top.
I was four during most of those Sundays. Then I was five, and my mother started taking me. For a while I asked where he was whenever we passed the pharmacy. She would adjust the rearview mirror or tell me to check that I had both shoes. Eventually I stopped asking in the car.
***
Matthias Voss took over the studio in September. Our old director, Denise, introduced him over wine in paper cups, beneath the bulletin board with its class schedules and photographs of girls who now had children of their own. He had worked in Germany for most of his career. Concert productions, theater, a conservatory whose name she pronounced carefully.
He was tall and spare, with white hair combed straight back and a way of looking at people that made them finish what they were saying sooner. Someone asked if he danced.
“Not anymore.”
Denise laughed, although he hadn’t made a joke.
When I introduced myself, he asked my surname.
“Marin.”
“And before?”
“Adler. I kept my married name. Easier for business.”
He looked at me, then down at his cup. I wondered if he disapproved of divorce. Before I could find out, Denise took his arm and led him away.
Within a week he had removed the plastic flowers from reception and told us the Halloween production needed work. The girls had already chosen their characters. We had two Wednesdays, a Morticia, three dead brides, and a Beetlejuice whose mother kept reminding me what the striped suit had cost.
The idea was a confrontation between the Addams family and the people from the other side of the cemetery. A little West Side Story, a little Thriller, with a rumble in the middle. The girls had opinions about who would win, and rehearsals occasionally stopped so they could argue about it.
Voss watched our first run without moving. When we finished, one of the Wednesdays whispered, “Are we in trouble?”
“You’re all arriving at different times,” he said.
“They’re supposed to be fighting.”
“Yes, Lisa. I can see that.”
He went to the piano and played the entrance slowly. Without the recording, I could hear where we were getting ahead of ourselves. He had the older girls cross alone, then brought in the little ones. When the two groups met, they were exactly where they needed to be.
“Better?” he asked me.
“Much.”
I liked that he had asked.
***
By October I was opening the studio before he arrived. I brought coffee until he said he preferred tea, then bought a box of the kind he liked and kept it behind the desk. His knee bothered him when it rained. He didn’t like discussing it, so I moved his chair closer to the piano without mentioning why.
He noticed everything about dancing. A lifted shoulder. A foot turned out from the ankle instead of the hip. A girl watching me instead of trusting herself to finish.
“Stop showing her,” he told me one night.
“She’s stuck.”
“Give her a moment.”
I lowered my arms. The girl hesitated, then completed the turn. He looked at me, and I felt foolish, although I was pleased to have learned something.
Afterward I told him about a client who called me at eleven every night.
“Do you answer?”
“She’s buying her first place. She gets nervous.”
“So do you answer?”
“Yes.”
“Well.”
The next night I let the call go to voicemail. I wanted to tell him that, too.
Soon I was finding reasons to stay while he put things away. I told him about my apartment, my mother’s leaking ceiling, my ex-husband getting engaged to a woman who described herself as a healer.
“What does she heal?”
“I haven’t asked. I’m trying to behave.”
He smiled a little, and I thought about it driving home. The following Thursday I asked if he wanted to get dinner. There was a place nearby with good soup, I said, as if soup made it less of an invitation.
“I eat at home.”
“Sure. Me too, usually.”
He put on his coat. After he left, I stayed another twenty minutes straightening the dressing room. I didn’t want to catch up with him on the sidewalk.
Nina covered my second Sunday open house. On the third, she called while I was kneeling on the studio floor, taping out the cemetery gates.
“You’re paying me for this one.”
“I bought you lunch.”
“You bought me a sandwich and ate half of it.”
“You said it was too much.”
“Lisa. What are you doing?”
I looked toward the office. Voss was on the telephone, facing the window. “The show’s in two weeks. He needs help.”
“Denise managed.”
“Denise had a different way of doing things.”
“And who’s paying you for all this?”
I pulled the tape too hard and had to start again. After we hung up, Voss came out and inspected the gates.
“They’re too close.”
I began peeling up the tape. I had been there since nine, and I still owed an attorney a contract before dinner. He stood beside me while I worked. I wanted him to notice the time and tell me to go home.
“Another foot,” he said.
I moved the gate another foot.
***
I defended him in the dressing room, at the reception desk, on the telephone with mothers who wanted to know why we needed another rehearsal. I said he cared about the production. He wanted the girls to be proud of themselves. I hadn’t heard him say either thing, but I believed it.
Then one Thursday he kept a seven-year-old named Sophie working on the same crossing until she cried. Four counts to the center, turn, four counts back. She kept turning over the wrong shoulder.
“Your other right,” he said.
She tried again. He stopped the music, and her chin began to shake.
“Come get some water, Soph.” I held out my hand.
“She hasn’t finished.”
“We’ll be right back.”
In the hall she pressed her face against my stomach, getting white makeup on my shirt. She kept telling me she knew which way to turn. I rubbed her back until she stopped crying. Through the wall I could hear Voss playing the same few bars, waiting for us.
After class he told me I had undermined him.
“She couldn’t hear you anymore,” I said. “She was too upset.”
“She could do it.”
“I know. That wasn’t the problem.”
He closed the score. I waited for him to answer, but he began packing his bag.
At home I wrote a message explaining myself, erased it, and wrote another. Around midnight I sent an apology for disagreeing in front of the girls. He replied the next morning: Please arrive early. We must repair the ending.
I was relieved. Later, when Nina asked how things were going, I told her about the costumes.
***
My mother finally told me about Germany when I was sixteen. Until then he had been away, which I understood to mean he might come back, even after I had stopped expecting him on any particular day.
He had been a professor of music. An orchestral company offered him work. There had been discussions, my mother said. Plans.
“Were we supposed to go?”
She was trimming green beans at the kitchen counter. She lined them up before bringing down the knife.
“For a while.”
“Then what happened?”
“It was complicated, Lisa.”
I waited. She swept the ends into her palm and dropped them in the garbage.
Years later I found an old concert program. Michael Adler. His hair was longer than I remembered, and he was looking past the camera as if somebody had called to him. I searched for him a few times. There were other Michael Adlers, none of them a pianist I recognized. I didn’t know what I would do if I found him, anyway.
Sometimes I imagined arriving somewhere he was playing. He would see me in the audience and stop. I never got much further than that.
***
Rain ran down the studio windows on the morning of the dress rehearsal. Parents crowded reception with wet umbrellas and garment bags. The room smelled of hairspray and damp wool, and somebody had opened the cupcakes that were supposed to be for afterward.
Voss sat at the piano while I helped the girls. Ava’s Wednesday collar wouldn’t lie flat. Sophie had pulled her veil over her face and couldn’t see through it.
“You’re going to walk into something.”
“I’m a ghost.”
“You can haunt us with it pinned back.”
She considered this, then let me fix it.
We ran the confrontation twice. On the third attempt, the two lines advanced, stopped, and turned toward the audience together. Even Voss nodded. Then Sophie stepped on her veil. The comb pulled loose, and I went to her before he could speak.
“It’s too long. That’s my fault.”
Behind me, Voss took a silver watch from his waistcoat pocket. I had seen him check it before, but always from across the room. This time I was beside the piano when the lid sprang open.
There was a little blue horse inside. One leg had peeled away.
I knew that missing leg. I had worried it with my thumbnail until my father told me to leave the poor animal alone.
“Lisa. Shall we continue?”
I held out my hand. He looked at it, then closed the watch.
“Where did you get that?”
There was a dent beside the hinge. I had dropped it on the pharmacy stairs. He had told my mother it slipped from his pocket.
“Let me see.”
The girls were watching us. A mother opened the door to ask whether we were nearly finished.
“Not here,” he said.
I asked Ava to take everyone to the dressing room.
***
In the office, he placed the watch on the desk. The horse had come from a sheet of stickers. I had put the others on my bed frame and my mother’s sewing machine. Beneath it was the inscription I hadn’t been able to read at five.
For our Sunday man. Anna and Lisa.
I sat down. He moved a box of safety pins out of my way, and that small courtesy made me want to throw something.
“How long have you known?”
“Since Denise introduced us.”
I remembered my paper cup and his questions. All those evenings afterward, telling him things. “And you were just going to let me carry on?”
“I didn’t know how to tell you.”
“You’ve had two months.”
He looked toward the door. Outside, a child called for her mother.
“Michael.”
He lowered his head. “Matthias is also my name. I use Voss professionally.”
“Why are you here?”
“Denise needed someone. I had returned.”
“You didn’t come looking for me.”
“No.”
I looked at his hands. His thumbnail was smooth now. Thirty-three years was enough time for a nail to grow back. There must have been other changes I hadn’t recognized, but I couldn’t make myself study his face.
“You let me bring you tea.”
He pulled out the other chair and sat. “I thought we might have time to know one another.”
“I asked you to dinner.”
“Lisa—”
“You could have come. We could have sat somewhere. You could have told me.”
“There are things about what happened. Your mother and I—”
“Then tell me.”
He arranged his hands on his knees. I waited while he looked at the floor, and I wanted to help him. Even then I wanted to ask a question he could answer.
“Did you ever want to call?”
“Of course.”
“But you didn’t.”
He rubbed his knee. I almost asked whether it was hurting.
***
I stayed for the performance. Sophie made her turn. Ava looked beautifully unimpressed with the dead people gathering around her. When the music ended, the parents stood and clapped, and the girls broke character at once, grinning and waving into the crowd.
Voss came toward me afterward. I handed him my studio keys.
“You needn’t decide tonight.”
“I’ve decided.”
“What about the girls?”
“I’ll say goodbye to them myself.”
He held the keys without closing his hand. I wanted him to put them down and come after me. In every version I had imagined of finding him, he had known what to do when he saw me.
He asked who would cover Thursday.
***
The next Sunday Nina called at nine. I was waiting for the coffee, still in the shirt I had slept in.
“You want Mercer Street back?”
“No. Keep it.”
“You okay?”
“Not especially.”
She was quiet for a moment. “Come have breakfast. I’m starving.”
After we hung up, I opened the drawer where I kept the concert program. I thought about calling my mother, but I wasn’t ready to hear what she might say. There would be more to it. There was always more to it when somebody had done something they couldn’t take back.
Whatever he told me, I would still have grown up without him. He had missed the years when I needed someone to carry me upstairs. I had spent two months making his tea and rearranging my Sundays, and I couldn’t earn those years back.
My phone buzzed. Nina was downstairs, double-parked. I put the program away and went to find my coat.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.