the rumor

Friendship

Written in response to: "Start or end your story with a character overhearing (or spreading) a rumor." as part of Two Sides to Every Story with Emily Martin.

I was alone in the restaurant on a quiet Saturday night when Steve walked in. The look on his face told me he had something to say. He sat down across from me with a smug grin, almost as if he was enjoying seeing me miserable.

"You know," he said, "I heard she was gay. I told you that from the start."

His words hit me like a punch to the stomach. I remembered him mentioning the rumor before, but I had refused to believe it. There had been something special between us—at least, I thought there was.

She was so much fun to be around. Every time we were together, the world seemed brighter. We laughed at the same jokes, finished each other's sentences, and somehow always knew what the other person was thinking before either of us spoke. It felt as if we had known each other our whole lives instead of only a short time.

I couldn't imagine that everything I had felt was based on a misunderstanding. I kept telling myself there had to be another explanation. Maybe the rumor wasn't true. Maybe people were just talking. I wanted to believe that with all my heart.

The more I thought about her, the harder it became to let go. I had never fallen so deeply for anyone before. Every smile she gave me, every conversation we shared, and every moment we spent together replayed over and over in my mind. I realized I wasn't just disappointed—I was heartbroken.

Steve kept talking, but I barely heard him anymore. His voice faded into the background as I stared out the restaurant window. I wondered if I had imagined the connection between us or if I had simply misunderstood what it meant to her.

For the first time in a long while, I felt completely alone. The restaurant was full of people talking and laughing, yet I had never felt more isolated. I knew one thing for certain: no matter what the truth was, she had changed my life. I only wished I knew whether I had meant anything to her at all.

My mind went back to her last phone call. She had cried when she told me we were done. I thought about the night before, when we had spent our first night together. Was that what had pushed her away? Was I the problem?

I started thinking about the other women I had spent time with. Had I chased them all away because of my awkwardness? Had they gotten tired of me? I always thought I was a good catch, but was that just my mother telling her son what he wanted to hear?

I looked back at Steve to see if he was still smiling. I wondered if he had any real information that could help me, or if he was only there to say things that would cut deeper into my life.

I didn't know what to do. Should I just go home and wait to see if she changed her mind about me?

All this time, I had been thinking about the rumor and wondering if it was true. Maybe I just did not see the signs because I didn’t want to see them, or maybe love had blinded me to what was right in front of me.

These were questions I kept asking myself over and over again. If she was gay, I still wanted her. My heart was set, and all the happy moments we had shared meant too much to just walk away from. I couldn’t simply stop loving her. She was my soulmate, and a part of me would not let her go without a fight.

The next day, while I was at home, the phone rang, and my heart jumped. Could this be her? I ran to the phone and answered.

"Hello?"

"Susan?"

It was her.

She tried to explain that it wasn't me—it was her.

"Okay," I thought to myself. Everyone seems to use that line.

There was a long pause before she asked, "Have you heard the rumor that I'm gay?" I said yes and I love you the way you are

I didn't know what to say. She tried to explain an old boy friend had started that rumor after they broke up an he could not face the fact I did not love him the same amount he love me.so his mind some how used that rumor to justify his feeling. And fact it was over with us. He had a big ego an this lie help him move on with life. At my expense

She tried to explain that the rumor was wrong and that she had enjoyed the night we spent together. She said we just needed more time together.

I quickly said, "How about dinner tonight?"

At the exact same moment, we both said the name of our favorite restaurant. We laughed because we were so in sync with each other.

Very shyly, I asked, "Did the other night have anything to do with our breakup?"

She answered, "No. You're fine. It's me. I couldn't believe how much I love you, and that scared me. I've never been in love like this before, and I panicked. But after spending the day away from you, I realized I need you in my life."

Her words took my breath away. Just hearing her say them made all the pain and doubt I had been carrying begin to disappear. For the first time since she had ended things, I smiled.

Maybe we really did have a future together after all.

All my fears disappeared. We were in love, and nothing could stop us.

Maybe I felt so strongly for her because I had never loved someone this much before. I couldn't imagine my life without her. She had become such an important part of me that I couldn't think clearly when she wasn't there. I know right then a must marry her so we can be together forever I would change for her if she need it.

Posted Jul 27, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.