Eve Diary

Creative Nonfiction Fiction Teens & Young Adult

Written in response to: "Tell a story through diary/journal entries, transcriptions, and/or newspaper clippings." as part of Stranger than Fiction with Zack McDonald.

Eve Diary

This is a work of fiction.

Eve is invented—deliberately, cleanly, on purpose. But the materials she’s made from aren’t invented. They’re taken from life: the way a room can feel slightly wrong without being “wrong,” the way the body reacts before the mind arrives, the way language starts as a tool and ends up acting like a leash.

This book began as one stubborn thought I couldn’t outpace:

Explanations arrive too fast.

Not because they’re always wrong—because they’re often correct—but because they can land like life rings thrown before you’ve even checked whether you’re drowning… or just standing in shallow water, cold, still breathing, still here.

In the city, that speed can look like competence. You learn to become readable. You learn the polite masks. You learn the correct face. You learn to say you’re Fine before anyone finishes asking. Mirrors help with that—not only literal mirrors (windows, screens, reflective glass), but the social ones: every interaction that rewards you for being “good,” for being “easy,” for being the version of yourself that doesn’t slow anyone down. Live like that long enough and you wear the mask even when nobody’s there to see it.

Eve leaves that kind of place and discovers the problem with quiet: it doesn’t distract you. It doesn’t hurry you.

It doesn’t do the work of closure for you. So the small things become audible again.

Each one is explainable. That’s the trap. Separately, they’re harmless. Together, they start to behave like a pattern—something that doesn’t ask permission.

At a certain point, Eve gives one name to what she keeps circling:

Shadow.

I can’t tell you what it “really is,” because I don’t know what counts as proof for something you can’t verify. I don’t know. Eve doesn’t know. And any voice—mine included—that rushes to certainty here is worth distrusting.

Shadow might be invented: a mind building shape because shapelessness is unbearable.

Shadow might be a defense: a dimming, a covering, a way to keep living.

Shadow might feel external: a presence close enough to change how a corridor feels.

Shadow might be neither “inside” nor “outside,” because that division can be its own comforting shortcut.

If you’re looking for a clean verdict—ghost or illness, supernatural or psychological—this book won’t give you that relief. Not to be clever. Because certainty can be a mask too.

So I’ll offer one optional idea—nothing formal, not a method, not self-help. Just a simple test you can run on yourself while you read.

Take the book to a mirror. Read forward the way a story is meant to be read—page after page, not one sentence held up like a charm.

While you read, keep your eyes on your reflection. Look directly into your own eyes. Don’t answer what you’re reading. Don’t argue with it. Don’t diagnose it. Don’t try to solve it.

Read. Listen to what you read.

Notice what you feel: what arrives, what leaves, what tries to become a label.

Because mirrors aren’t neutral. And neither are masks.

I won’t ask you to believe in Shadow.

I’ll only ask you to notice what happens when a name exists.

And to keep one question open:

If there is a label… who answers to it?

Don’t answer. Listen.

I’m Eve

I’m writing because my head tries to be helpful too early.

It throws explanations at me before I’ve even checked what I’m feeling—like life rings landing at my feet when I might not be drowning at all. I might just be standing in shallow water, numb, still breathing, still here. In the city, that speed kept me functional. It made me readable. It taught me to answer before the question finished forming.

Too many mirrors.

Not only the obvious ones—glass, screens, windows—but the way other people’s faces become instructions. The way you learn the correct expression. The way you learn to look Fine before you’ve even looked inside yourself.

Fine is a password. Fine is the code.

I used it so often it started using me.

Here, that same speed doesn’t feel like competence. It feels like I’m locking doors from the inside and calling it safety.

So this is a diary. Not the polite kind with dates and summaries and the careful voice that pretends I understand myself. Not a record for court. Not “evidence.” I’m not trying to prove anything. I’m trying to keep a place.

A place where what I notice can exist without being forced into a verdict.

I don’t know who this is for.

Sometimes I tell myself it’s for me, because that’s the safest answer. But even that feels like a shortcut. The truth is I don’t fully know who reads when I write. Maybe it’s me later, trying to remember whether I made this up. Maybe it’s the part of me that doesn’t speak in clean sentences—the part that tenses first and explains later. Maybe it’s someone I can’t name yet, because the usual categories of “me” and “not me” are starting to feel like comfort tricks.

I’m not proud of that uncertainty.

’m just done pretending it isn’t there.

There are things I don’t know. There are things that confuse me in a way that isn’t dramatic, just persistent—like a loose thread you can ignore for hours until it’s the only thing you can feel against your skin. Separate moments that are each explainable. That’s the problem. If they were obviously impossible, I could throw them out. If they were obviously dangerous, I could act. But they’re small, reasonable, ordinary enough to be dismissed one by one… and strange enough together to start behaving like a pattern.

A chair in the middle of a room, and a moment I can’t account for.

A name arriving like memory, not like sound.

A door that seems to be in the wrong place for a heartbeat, even though the wall doesn’t move.

A night silence that feels too even—too smooth—as if life forgot to leave scratches.

A shadow edge that sharpens too clearly and then acts like it never happened.

A line on paper with something heavier around it. Not in the air. In the paper itself.

Each of these can be explained. Separately, they’re nothing. Separately, they don’t require a response. Separately, they are the kind of “nothing” you can live on top of for years.

Together, they change how I breathe.

And here’s the part I’m still learning to admit: I’m afraid of my own automatic responses more than I’m afraid of the house. I’m afraid of how quickly I seal things shut. How quickly I reach for comfort as a mask. How quickly I tell myself a story so I don’t have to stay with what I actually feel.

Doors don’t care about my explanations.

That sentence came to me like a fact I’d known for a long time and kept forgetting. The doors here don’t argue. They don’t validate me. They don’t accuse me. They just are. Which means I can’t negotiate my way out of this with the right language. I can’t “be reasonable” until the feeling goes away.

So I’m writing instead.

Writing is the one place where I don’t have to perform Fine. Where I don’t have to be “good.” Where I can put things down without deciding what they are. Putting down is not the same as locking up. Putting down says: I see this. Locking up says: I’ve decided what this is, and I’m done.

I’m not done.

If you’re reading this—whoever you are—I’m not asking you to believe me. I’m not even asking you to understand. I’m asking you not to rush me. Not into a diagnosis. Not into a ghost story. Not into a neat lesson with a clean ending. I’ve lived inside neat lessons long enough to know how quickly they become cages.

What I want is simpler and harder:

A record of noticing.

A place where the loose thread can stay loose without being cut, and without being denied.

Just in case,

And if I start reaching too fast for an answer—if you see me trying to make this comfortable, trying to make it a finished story—then I need the only instruction that doesn’t feel like a command, the one that leaves me in the moment instead of pushing me out of it:

Don’t answer. Listen.

Posted Mar 05, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

4 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.