The What-If House

Drama Sad Speculative

Written in response to: "Write a story in which memory or nostalgia becomes a real object." as part of A Trip Down Memory Lane.

The house showed up on a Tuesday, at 3:12 in the morning, six years after Rheanna's mother died.

Rheanna was awake, which was not unusual. Most nights her mind played the whole thing start to finish, like a movie she had never bought a ticket for. The recliner. The knocked-over tray. Her mother's slumped mouth saying the word stroke. She had learned that if she got up and drank a glass of water, sometimes the movie paused.

So she went out to the kitchen. And on the counter, next to the dish rack, sat a bowl of watermelon.

They did not buy a watermelon. It was November in Wisconsin. Beside it lay a single brass key on a ring, and hanging from the ring was a small ceramic elephant, its trunk raised for luck.

Rheanna knew that elephant. It had lived on her mother's windowsill for twenty years. She had wrapped it in newspaper herself and put it in a box in a storage unit, and the box was still there, because she had not been able to open it.

She picked up the key. It was warm.

When she looked out the back window, the yard was wrong. Where the garage should have been stood a small yellow house with a porch light on. Someone had left the curtains open. Inside, in the blue flicker of a television, she could see the back of a recliner.

She should have woken Jericho. Instead she put on her coat over her pajamas, carried the watermelon across the frozen grass, and let herself in.

It smelled like coffee and drugstore lotion and the warm dust of a lamp that had been on too long. It smelled like her mother.

"Is that you, honey?"

Margie was in the recliner with her feet up and a book on her lap. Her reading glasses were pushed up into her hair, and another pair sat on her nose, and a third lay on the side table, folded. Her left hand curled a little at the wrist. Otherwise she was entirely, impossibly herself.

"I brought the watermelon," Rheanna said. It was the only sentence she could find.

"Thank you, yum. Put it in the fridge." Margie looked at her over the glasses. "You look beautiful. You look tired, too, but mostly beautiful."

Rheanna put the watermelon in the fridge. Her hands were shaking. On the shelf door, where the ketchup should have been, there were four pairs of scissors.

She understood, then, what house this was.

She had built it herself, a thousand times, lying awake. In this version, the morning before the stroke, she did not tiptoe in and out with the watermelon while her mother slept. In this version, she walked the few steps into the living room and squeezed her mother's shoulder. Watermelon's in the fridge, Mom. And her mother did not wake up right, and Rheanna knew it in five minutes instead of ten hours. The ambulance came before her mother had spent a whole day alone in that chair. The surgery was the same surgery. But the head start held.

This was the house where the head start held.

She went back the next night, and the next.

The house had more rooms than it should. The hallway ran longer every time, and its walls were covered with photographs Rheanna had never taken. Her mother at Chayton's eighth-grade graduation, holding a balloon shaped like a baseball. Her mother at the hibachi place on Rheanna's fortieth birthday, eyes streaming, a napkin pressed to her mouth. Rheanna remembered that night. Her mother had eaten the whole ball of wasabi in one bite and announced, "That's some spicy avocado!" But that had happened years before the stroke. In this photo her mother was older, and the table was longer, and Chayton was a teenager laughing so hard he'd tipped his chair back.

The photographs were the worst part. They were so specific. That was how Rheanna knew she had made them. Guilt was always specific.

In the kitchen there was a drawer that held nothing but combs. In the bedroom, clothes piled on every chair, none in the dresser. Even here, Rheanna could not make her mother put her clothes away. Some things she did not get to change. She found she did not want to.

They watched game shows. Margie shouted the answers before the contestants did and was usually right. She did crosswords in pen. She asked about Jericho, and about Chayton, and she listened, with the bright, nosy interest Rheanna had not heard in her voice since before the second stroke. Some nights they just sat. Rheanna would put her head on the arm of the recliner and her mother would comb her hair with her good hand, the way she had when Rheanna was eight and sick with the flu.

Rheanna always went home before dawn. The house never followed her. In the morning, the backyard was a backyard again, the garage was a garage, and the key sat in her coat pocket, warm.

She got tired in a new way.

Not the old caregiving tired, the bone-deep kind that came from pressing a call button five times a night. This was thinner. She fell asleep at her desk on a Thursday and woke with the imprint of a keyboard on her cheek. She burned the grilled cheese two nights in a row. She snapped at Jericho over the dishwasher, then cried about it in the car, then could not explain to him why.

"You okay, Mom?" Chayton asked one morning. He was sixteen now, taller than her, with Margie's laugh and none of her patience for crosswords.

"Fine," Rheanna said. "Just not sleeping."

He looked at her for a moment the way her mother used to look at people, reading the weather in their face. Then he said, "Game's at four on Saturday. You don't have to come if you're tired."

"I'll be there," she said.

She meant it. She fell asleep in the car in the rink parking lot, and woke up in the third period, and missed his goal.

That night she went to the yellow house early and stayed late.

"How many nights is this?" Margie asked.

They were on the porch. It was always warm on the porch of the yellow house, a late-summer warmth with crickets in it, even when the real yard was buried in snow.

"I don't know," Rheanna said. "Thirty?"

"Forty-one." Her mother tapped the crossword. "I keep track. Someone has to."

"I like it here."

"I know you do." Margie took off one pair of reading glasses and folded it and set it on top of another. "Honey. Do you know what this place is made of?"

Rheanna didn't answer.

"It's made of every time you said what if," her mother said. "What if you'd woken me up. What if you'd made me eat better. What if you'd caught it sooner, the second time. What if you hadn't taken my phone." She said that last one gently, and Rheanna flinched anyway. "You built me a whole house out of it. You put in the scissors. That was nice. Nobody else would have remembered the scissors."

"I should have walked in," Rheanna said. "That morning. Five more steps."

"Maybe." Her mother did not argue, and that was somehow worse and better at the same time. "And maybe I'd have had another stroke the next week. You don't know. Neither do I. That's the thing about this house. Nobody in it ever has a bad day." She smiled. "Do you know how boring that is?"

Rheanna laughed, and it turned into something else halfway through.

Her mother waited. She had always been good at waiting.

"I remember," Margie said, "telling you something once. After the second one, when I still had my words. Do you?"

Rheanna did. She had carried the sentence for seven years.

"You said if you got bad, I should leave you in a nursing home and stop visiting." Her voice cracked on it. "You said, You live your life."

"And you didn't listen. You came every day."

"Of course I came."

"I know. I was so proud of you, it made me mad." Margie reached over and took Rheanna's hand, the curled one with the good one. "You're doing it again. You're visiting every day. Only this time I'm not even here."

The crickets went on. Across the yard, through the kitchen window of the real house, Rheanna could see the stove light she always left on for Chayton.

"I don't know how to stop," she said.

"Sure you do." Her mother squeezed her hand. "Same way you do everything. You just do it, and then you cry in the car."

They went inside together. Margie settled into the recliner and pulled the soft pink blanket up over her knees. Rheanna tucked it around her feet. Then she stood for a long moment in the middle of the living room.

There was the tray beside the chair. Pens, pills, scissors, eyeglasses, all of it neat and upright, nothing knocked over. In this house, nothing ever got knocked over.

"Go on," her mother said, without opening her eyes.

Rheanna went to the kitchen. She took the key from her pocket, the little elephant swinging, and opened the fridge. The watermelon was on the middle shelf where she had left it the first night. It had not softened at all. Nothing here ever did.

She set the key beside it and closed the door.

Then she walked the few steps back into the living room, the five steps she had spent seven years walking in her head, and she bent down and kissed her mother on the top of her head, and squeezed her shoulder.

"Watermelon's in the fridge, Mom."

"Thanks, honey." Her mother's voice was already far away, like a radio station going out of range. "You look beautiful."

Rheanna woke up on her own couch with the afghan over her legs. Gray light. Snow on the windowsill. Somewhere in the house, the shower running, which meant Chayton was up early, which meant it was Saturday.

She went to the back window. The garage was a garage.

On the fence beside it, a cardinal sat with its feathers puffed against the cold. It stayed there a moment longer than a bird needed to, red as anything against all that white. Then it was gone.

Rheanna made pancakes. She burned the first one, the way you're supposed to, and ate it standing at the counter. When Chayton came down with wet hair, she handed him a plate and asked what time warm-ups started.

"It's a scrimmage," he said. "It's freezing. You really don't have to come."

"I know," she said. "I'm coming anyway."

That night she slept straight through, for the first time in years. She did not dream about the yellow house. But in the morning, when she reached into her coat pocket for her gloves, her fingers found something small and smooth, a little ceramic elephant, trunk raised, no key attached.

She set it on the kitchen windowsill, where it could see the yard.

It's still there.

Posted Nov 12, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

8 likes 2 comments

Marjolein Greebe
November 15, 2026 15:29

“Same way you do everything. You just do it, and then you cry in the car.” Rheanna, that sounds like a mother who knows her daughter rather than a ghost delivering wisdom. I loved that Margie says “Maybe” instead of absolving her of everything; she doesn’t need certainty about that morning to deserve a life now.

Reply

Rheanna Smith
November 17, 2026 12:26

Thank you! I'm in the process of finishing a memoir about my mom and caring for her after her stroke. So this story came from something I said in that memoir about all the "what-ifs."

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.