Choices

Fiction High School Horror

This story contains sensitive content

CW: Violence, gore, and/or abuse and Child abuse

Written in response to: "Start your story with someone being followed." as part of What Lingers.

Aaron walked into his dilapidated house with a fresh black eye and bloodied nose, courtesy of Matthew Allen. He wasn’t quite sure what he’d done wrong to deserve this, but he wasn’t surprised that it’d happened. He’d become accustomed to beatings and name-calling. He was a chubby boy who was very short for his age so he was an easy target. He never truly fit in anywhere. At his previous two schools he was beaten up for his stature and his intelligence, but they were public schools, filled with rabid baboons who had the brain size of a lentil. He’d since gotten an academic scholarship to one of the finest private schools in the country, Dillingham Grammar. There he wasn’t beaten for his brains (although he was still the smartest) now he was being beaten for his lack of wealth. The second hand books with yellowed pages and wrinkled spines were all it took for him to be cast out and beaten to a bloody pulp before recess on his first day. 

Once he walked inside, he immediately took off his school uniform and put it in the kitchen sink with dishwashing liquid to soak. He didn’t really know how to wash clothes, but he wanted to try to get the blood out before his mum saw it. While the clothes soaked, Aaron went and showered to clean the dried blood from under his nose and eyes.After he showered and dried his uniform he made some toast and went to his room to read. He was lonely a lot of the time with his mother always working, but he always found that he could find a friend in his books. 

Before he went to sleep that night. Aaron knelt beside his bed and began to pray. He prayed that the beatings would stop. He’d never prayed before and wasn’t even sure if God was real. Unfortunately for Aaron, he would find out the truth that very next day. 

Aaron thought about skipping school when he woke up. His head throbbed from the barrage of kicks and punches that he’d suffered the previous day. His mother hadn’t finished work yet and he likely wouldn’t see her for a few more days, so he might be able to get away with it. But then he realises the school will probably call his mum and she’d then begin to worry, so he musters up some courage and begins the walk to school. 

It’s a cold morning with frost built up on car windshields and fog covering the oval that he’s cutting through, it reminds him of flying through a dark cloud on an aeroplane or at least that’s what he imagines it would look like to fly through a cloud as he’s never been on an aeroplane. He sees something off into the distance but can’t quite make out what it is through the fog. He continues walking in the direction as he realises that his mind is just playing tricks on him. Its not some mystical beast or a ghost, it’s just two schoolboys with hoods over their heads, smoking. He lets out a sigh of relief. ‘Thought I was going crazy’ he says aloud to himself as he shakes his head side to side to snap himself out of it.

Unfortunately for Aaron, his relief doesn’t last for long. These two hooded figures were Matthew Allen and one of his brainless worshippers, Tiger. (Tiger’s father had lost a bet in the 90s while drunk at a bar watching the masters the year that Tiger Woods won it for the first time) Matthew said to Tiger in a belittling voice ‘aw look at the poor little guy walking by himself. His little feet are going to get wet because his shoes have holes!’ Tiger found this hysterical, but isn’t smart enough to think of anything to say himself. So Matthew continued. ‘What do you think tiger, should we carry him to help him out? Maybe he can go for a little pre-school swim in the storm drains. Cold water is meant to be great for your health.’ He said with an evil smug grin. 

‘Won’t you guys please just leave me alone?’ Aaron replied desperately.

‘Why would we do that? You know they almost called my father about what happened yesterday, I could’ve gotten in trouble for that.’

‘I didn’t tell anyone that you beat me up! A teacher pulled you off of me dumb-arse.’ Oh no. Aaron knew that he’d screwed up big time. 

‘I didn’t mean to say that it just slipp-‘

‘You’re so dead.’ 

Matthew threw a right hand and it landed flush on Aarons chin, knocking Aaron off balance but not knocking him down. Matthew tried to grab Aaron, but Aaron kicked him in the balls. Sending Matthew down instantly. Tiger then comes in with his giant hands and throws a punch but misses so Aaron begins to run. Tiger bends down to check on his fallen master who’s in the foetal position clutching his balls. Matthew coughs out ‘Just go get him you idiot!’ 

The race is on. Tiger is already about six foot two in just the eighth grade (he got held back two years in primary school.) He was big and puberty must’ve been a distant memory for him, as he was already fully developed and muscular. Not only was he big but he was fast and athletic and Aaron knew he stood no chance of outrunning him. His only shot was to try to hide. 

Luckily for him he knew that there was an abandoned hospital on the other side of the park. He usually walked on the other side of the road when walking by it as the overall creepiness of the long vacated and poorly maintained structure scared him. But that fear seemed obsolete compared to what he was now confronted with. I just need to make it there. In there I’ll be able to hide, he said to himself. Aaron ran through the foggy park, panting like a dog. His short and tubby build wasn’t built for running. He could see the hot breath coming out of his mouth like steam rising from an old-fashioned train. He could hear Tiger breathing now. He was getting closer. Aaron ran in a zig-zag pattern, trying to confuse the dim-witted Tiger. But even he wasn’t stupid enough for that. He’s very close now. Aaron can almost feel tiger’s breath on the back of his neck. ‘I’ve got you now, freak!’ Tiger says laughing. Aaron knew he was right so when he could feel Tiger right behind him, about to grab him. Aaron just dropped to his hands and knees, causing tiger to trip over. Aaron quickly got up and tried to run, but tiger grabbed his leg. ‘Pretty smart move there salvation army. But you’re mine now’ Tiger says grinning, holding onto Aaron’s leg. Aaron tries to wiggle away but can’t break tigers vice-like grip. He has to think fast. Aaron sees a fallen gum tree branch on the ground, its thick and shaped like a police baton. He quickly lunged and picked it up, then rolled onto his back and clanks Tiger on his fat head two times, hard enough for tiger to break his grip and draw some blood, but not hard enough to knock him out. Aaron runs, he can almost see the building through the fog now. Only another fifty metres or so. He hears Matthews voice now. He must’ve recovered from the nut shot and began to catch up. He can see the building now. Matthews gaining on him. He’s running through the vacant carpark of the old hospital and can see the doors but they’re boarded up. ‘Oh no’. He whispers to himself. He still can’t see Matthew behind him, but his voice seems to be getting louder. Aaron runs to the side of the grey building to try and find a window. They’re all boarded up too. Matthews gaining on him. Finally he finds a window that’s had the boards ripped off. Aaron kicked the glass out and jumped in.

****

Once inside, Aaron begins looking for places to hide. He runs up the and down the halls flinging door handles down, trying to find an open door and after trying five or six times, finally success. Aaron yanked the heavy door open and slams it behind him. 

Inside the room he hears Matthew yelling out to him. ‘You can’t hide in here forever you know. I will find you. And the longer you wait. The worse the beating will be.’ Aaron takes a deep breath and then he hears Matthew speaking to someone. Tiger had come in now too. Aaron looked around the room he was in. The render and paint had mostly chipped off of the walls, leaving only the big cement blocks exposed. There were carvings on every single block. Most of them were just meaningless graffiti. But one wall stood out. It just said-

R

U

N

Aaron felt a shiver run down his spine as he looked at this. He was so spooked that he considered leaving the room and facing Matthew. Just to take his lashings and get out of there. That thought doesn’t last long at all. If he just hides out in here for a while, Matthew and Tiger will get bored and then he can leave. 

In the grey, concrete walled room, Aaron heard whispers but they weren’t Matthew’s and Tiger’s voices, no they were deeper and more guttural. Aaron crouched down, like a soldier in a trench, trying to keep his head from being visible through the small barred window that’s in the door. He put his ear to the door and the whispers became more clear. They were not in English. They sound almost ritualistic and other worldly. He hears two loud bangs. Followed by the sound of something hard dropping, bouncing and then rolling along the concrete floor outside. Aaron was now terrified. But he felt like he had to see what was happening. 

With his knees trembling, Aaron began to straighten his legs out of his crouched position to peer out of the small eye-hole that was in the door. When he did look out, he screamed before shoving his own palm across his mouth to quiet himself down. He just saw a hooded man in black, with a large axe down the hall and the severed heads of Matthew and tiger lying on the ground.

‘Aaron come out here now, my son. I will not hurt you.’ A deep and haunting, yet calm voice called out. How does he know my name Aaron thought to himself. ‘Of course I know your name, Aaron. I know your thoughts too. You cannot hide from me, dear boy. I do not wish to harm you. Please come and join me.’ Aaron was shaking. He starts to think to himself this can’t be r- when this thing begins to speak again. ‘Of course it is real! Now come out to the hall and join me.’ Aaron looked around for an exit. The window was boarded up with some kind of hard wood that he knew he could not break. He ran to it anyway trying in vain he began kicking and punching and pulling at the wood as he wept. Terrified and trapped he fell to the floor in a ball, crying uncontrollably and yelling ‘wake up! wake up you idiot! Its all a bad dream!’ 

‘Oh but it isn’t child. If you won’t come out, then I’m afraid that I must come in.’ 

Aaron heard the door open but there were no footsteps. 

His eyes were still tightly closed when he felt a cool breeze and a sense that someone was standing above him. He tried to open his eyes but couldn’t. His mind was too afraid of the evil that his eyes might see. 

‘Open your eyes boy!’ This thing shouted. His tone had shifted from calm to frustrated. Just do what he wants and this will all go away Aaron thinks to himself. Terrified, he opened one eye, then the next and began to sit up. He saw this figure up close now. It was faceless under the black hood of its cloak. The only feature that it had was eyes. But not human eyes, not even animal eyes. They’re shaped like a human’s eyes but there’s no colour. Just the brightest shade of white that Aaron had ever seen. 

Without even thinking Aaron blurts out in a shaky voice. ‘What are you?’ 

The figure took a moment to think about this, raising his skeleton like ten fingered hands to his featureless face and stroking where his chin should’ve been before answering. 

‘Some people call me God or Satan or Lucifer or Jesus. The truth of the matter is, I am all of them.’ Aaron now looked confused as well as scared, so the being continued 

‘You see my son I created all of this. I created Adam and Eve, however, I also put the snake into the garden. The life that I have given you is about choices.’

‘Why’d you kill those two boys?’ Aaron whimpered.

‘I gave those boys a lot of advantages in life, they chose to repeatedly abuse those advantages. So I needed to intervene. I heard your prayer and I have answered it.’ 

‘What?! I didn’t mean kill them!’ Aaron exclaimed through the muffled tears.

‘Trust me child, this was the best way. I see and hear all things, past, present and future. Those boys needed to be removed. Now it’s time for you to return to your home. If you stay there and do not mention what you’ve seen today, your life will continue on as normal. Very few of my creations know the truth. I trust that you will never speak of this. However, if you do choose to speak, you will be punished for what happened to those boys outside of this room. Choices my son. Choices.’ 

Posted Nov 01, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 1 comment

Paul Leary
November 12, 2026 10:11

Great story - creative .

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.