The first rule of flipping a murder house: give it a new personality.
One that looks intentional, careful, and knowledgeable. People want to buy something that has been loved. In a professional way, not an over-lived-in way, and not in a way that would appear to be a cover. Not for a bad foundation, not for worn walls and floors. And certainly not for a murder.
People are funny about buying houses where someone has been murdered. Haunted, cursed, or just plain creepy, they stay away. Prices drop during the disclosure period. Perfect for me: I buy cheap, renovate, and sell them at a premium once I’m no longer obligated to explain anything.
Unless they ask. And no one asks.
There is a science to flipping homes. Buyers want a certain kind of flooring, counters, moldings, and fixtures. Whether they actually know what they’re talking about, or have just heard the buzzwords, it doesn’t matter. It’s what sells, so it’s what I do. I’m in no rush, though; I want it perfect. Tiles, wainscotting, backsplash: everything is precise. People want a house that looks touched by the gods; not one stained by the devil.
I came to this practice accidentally, while looking for a home for myself. I bought my first murder house at twenty-three. My father had given me a modest down payment after graduation, and the only place I could afford came with a history no one wanted. The murder didn’t help, and neither did the half-finished kitchen and bathrooms. The owners had been mid-remodel when the incident happened. After that, they no longer cared whether the bathroom ended up hunter green or winter white. They just wanted out.
My realtor and I waited through two price cuts, then low-balled, knowing another cut was coming. Summer was over, demand had dipped, and the selling agent looked more defeated with every showing. When the price finally tanked, I moved fast. The bones were good. The problems were cosmetic. The money I saved became my renovation fund. Twelve years later, Astrid Logan, Inc. is my full-time business.
There is no shortage of death in Los Angeles. People’s dreams, careers, and relationships died on an hourly basis. Real death was mourned by those it actually affected, but for most other Angelos, if it was interesting enough, it was fodder for novels, movies, and TV procedural series episodes. Human souls were routinely sold for the chance at creative and financial immortality.
I was painting the kitchen doorframe eggshell to offset the midnight blue walls when my realtor Veronica called about a new property. The murder had happened years ago. The family just wanted to let it go and move on. They already had, actually: they had emptied the house and driven a U-Haul to Portland, entrusting the sale to their agent and long-time neighbor, Pamela Marconi. She could take it from here, she had assured them, and would get them the best price she could. Just sell it, they said, and let us know what happens.
I scribbled the address on a paint sample card, and said I’d call Pamela in the morning. I only knew Pamela in passing, but well enough to know that she didn’t get out of bed just to sell a house and move on. She would chase top dollar on an outhouse with a broken door and a wasp nest behind the toilet tank. There may be a deal to be made here.
I drove up a long dirt pathway from the main road, and turned onto the neglected driveway, the sound of broken, crunching gravel under my tires. When I turned off the engine, there was an eerie silence. The house stood less than thirty yards from the street, but it seemed to be isolated from any connection to the world around it. The house itself appeared to be in good condition, just unmaintained. I entered the code Pamela had given me over the phone that morning into the lockbox on the door, and the key tumbled out onto the concrete porch.
Pamela had warned me that the house hadn’t been staged, and she wasn’t exaggerating. But I wasn’t looking for pretty; I was looking for potential, and this house was full of it. Paper, empty boxes, and discarded leftovers of a life here strewn about the open-plan living area, the family was well and gone. I wasn’t walking in on a life being lived here, but one deliberately abandoned. Judging from the outside of the house, it had been forsaken long before they left.
The style of the house was eclectic, like maybe in happier times, the family had tried different renovations to see what they liked best. Despite looking empty and desolate, I could see where there had been warmth, at one time. A red brick fireplace with a large, cream-colored mantle took up about a third of the side wall, and next to it, the wall curved into a semi-circle in the corner: the perfect spot for a Christmas tree, and with the cathedral ceiling, it could be as high as they wished. Opposite the fireplace, a cherry hardwood staircase. My hand slid up the thick, wood-carved railing as I climbed to the second floor, checking for splinters in the railing and creaking in the steps.
The bedroom at the top of the stairs looked like it had belonged to a girl. A bay window overlooked the back garden, with a window seat beneath it. When I moved the seat’s worn cushion, I saw that it was the lid to a storage box. Probably one filled with toys, and then, over the years, fan magazines, music, secret diaries.
The two bedrooms on either side of the hallway were spacious but lacked similar charm. Down another hallway, was the primary bedroom. I gasped when I saw its size: the bedroom was spacious enough for a king-sized bed, a large TV, two chests of drawers and a home gym. I started to think this house was not renovated, but built from scratch; a bespoke castle for a family that expected to live there forever.
I knew halfway through my tour that I wanted the house, but I needed to be strategic in my approach with Pamela. She could smell blood when it came to a sale, and despite the family’s wishes to just get it sold, she was going to get everything she could for it. But I also didn’t want to lose it, if she sensed I was not interested. I called and left a voicemail.
“Hi Pamela, it’s Astrid. Thanks for letting me see the house. I do have a few questions. Give me a call when you’re free. Talk to you soon.”
She called back forty-five minutes later. The family wanted eight hundred thousand for it. I was dumbfounded: it was easily worth twice that. Why did they want to sell it so quickly?
Would they take seven-fifty? She said she would check. Within an hour, she texted me to send over my offer. I tried to silence the noisy question marks in my head and took the deal, feeling excited for the first time in years. Wondering too, if this was my new home, not just my new project.
My inspector deemed the foundation solid, and the house termite-free, so I got to work. Once I had cleared the debris, I started sanding the wood floors downstairs, and checked the fireplace grout and mantlepiece for cracks. Apart from a few minor touches, it looked like an easy refurbish. The archway from the living room had wood carvings that matched the staircase handrail. It had been carved with care, but needed varnish. The walls of the dining room were framed with arched windows, and generous windowsills. Plenty of space for a house cat to sit on at night and survey its prey.
The kitchen was magnificent: a large island with shelving behind cherry mahogany doors, double ovens, a pizza oven, and a wine fridge. Stone floors, and dimmable track lighting, let the room match the mood: bright and full of family energy, or soft and romantic. My electrician would be here on Monday to check the wiring, but even if it needed work, it would be worth it. My current home would be on the market soon, and that would give me enough to start the renovations.
Normally, I would hire a cleaning crew to get the house to a workable starting place, but in this case, I felt that doing it myself would help me not miss the personal touches I might otherwise overlook. I didn’t want to miss a single detail.
I started in the girl’s room. The wood floors had been abrasively scrubbed. They would need to be sanded and stained. There were irreparable tears in the wallpaper. Better just to completely remove it. The furniture was gone, but there were scraps of her life left behind: a random pillow, a teddy bear in a cheerleading costume, a kitten poster barely hanging by a taped corner on the wall next to the door. I picked up a handful of large trash bags and started the work of clearing the room of its remains. I was about to take all the trash out when I remembered the window seat storage.
The hinge creaked as it opened, releasing a familiar odor: decomposition and neglect. Whatever she had stored in here had died a long and lonely death. It was mostly empty but for some of the same type of memorabilia I had just cleared from the floor: some mutilated Barbies; pieces of clothing she must have thrown in the box, rather than putting away correctly; and a high school yearbook.
My high school yearbook, embossed with the year I had also attended.
I sat on the floor and flipped through it. Mine was in a box in my parents’ garage somewhere, and I was fine with it staying put. Not because high school held bad memories, but because it held almost none at all. I was ready to move on to the next chapter in my life as soon as I had traded my last required reading for my diploma.
I was surprised to find myself in group photos of clubs I had no memory of joining, and for at least a few of them, leading. I flipped to the back of the book to the sophomores. As I got closer to the page, the book fell open, bookmarked by a loose photograph. Two young girls in an embrace, beaming together at the camera. They were sitting on this window seat, with a sunset illuminating the bay window. They looked like their lives couldn’t be more perfect in a moment twenty years ago that may have only lasted for that moment. One of the girls I assumed, used to live in this room. The other one was me.
I lay in my bed that night, puzzled. Why couldn’t I remember anything about that year? Did I want to know? My instinct was to let those memories rest where they had been hiding. There was a reason they lay in the shadows, wasn’t there? I fell asleep resigned to just cleaning the house and flipping it. I didn’t need to stay in a place whose history I had long ago decided to bury. I had been allowing it to rest in peace. Why disturb my own?
For the next few weeks, I worked on the house. I was making this a beautiful house for the next family. The one who didn’t have to know anything about whatever had happened here. Whatever I had needed to forget. My focus on renovations had always served me. I could work like a machine and block out everything else. But just in case, I left her bedroom for last.
But closing her door didn’t shut her out. Working late one night, I felt a pull to her bedroom. The yearbook lay open on the window seat, to the page where I had left the photograph. When I picked it up, a breeze flowed in, where I had cracked the window open, and flipped the pages, opening to the sophomore photo spread. I scanned the page to see if I could match the girl in the photo.
Then, as though her photo were illuminated, I saw her: Claire Bowden. Her name didn’t mean anything more to me than her photo had. I didn’t understand why I needed to know these details if they still meant nothing to me, and the uninvited preoccupation was starting to annoy me.
I finished the tiling in the bathroom and left for the night. On the drive home, I thought about her. Not the her I didn’t remember from then, but the one I was discovering now. Was she trying to tell me something, or was this just my mind playing with me? Maybe it had wearied of the same processes I was always putting it through, and it wanted a new toy to rattle at me.
Hot water poured from my rain showerhead, melting the day, and Claire, from my skin. Maybe what my brain needed was not a new project, but some rest. The next day was Sunday. I would take the day off and go back fresh on Monday. Maybe everything would look different to me, then. Maybe Claire would prove to be an unnecessary distraction, not an irksome haunting.
I slept deeply that night, and Sunday was just what I needed: a late lie-in with coffee and a crossword puzzle, two loads of laundry cleaned, and a trip to the farmers’ market. I slipped into my clean sheets that night, feeling relaxed and refreshed from the day, and ready to go back to the house in the morning.
But my memory had other plans. I jolted awake at three a.m., my clean sheets stained with sweat. Suddenly, I remembered everything.
My heartbeat throbbed as the jigsaw pieces of fractured memories snapped together. I had lived a couple of blocks from her house, but only for that semester. My dad’s work had moved him around a lot that year, and everything felt temporary and inconsequential. All I remembered of high school was the burning desire to get the hell out of it.
I had gotten to know Claire in history class, both of us struggling with it. Our brief friendship grew out of late-night calls and shared class notes. I liked her. She was funny, and she made a confusing and difficult time easier.
I had gone to her house that night to return her notes. There was a shortcut between the back sides of our houses, three or four houses between us. Once we figured out I could climb up to the bay window from the trellis on her back wall, I almost never used the front door. As I rounded the corner from her next-door neighbor’s fence, into her backyard, I saw shadows moving in her bedroom. Her blinds were open, but the pink sheer curtains were drawn, and the lamp on her bedside table seemed to be the only light in the room, blurring the silhouettes in the window.
The figures were arguing. One of them looked like Claire, but the other one, I wasn’t sure. I didn’t know her family well, only that she didn’t get along with her stepfather. I watched for a moment, then I saw the taller figure push Claire, hard. She jerked backwards, and the lamp flickered out, swallowing the room in darkness.
I turned and ran, tearing back through the shortcut, back into my house, the sounds of shouting and fear, and the smell of wet, soggy grass flooding my senses. In the relative safety of my room, with my door shut behind me, I started to cry: for her, for myself, for the unbearable state of being young and powerless, watching something terrible unfold, with no agency to stop it.
I stood at the end of the driveway and stared at the house, the excitement I’d felt when I bought it, replaced with sour resentment. What had it brought me here for? To remember a horrible night, the announcement the next morning at school, that Claire had died in an “accident”? The feeling of helplessness and guilt that followed?
I hadn’t spoken up for her. I didn’t know what to say, because I didn’t really know what I had seen. When you’re 16, in a strange town, in a school you don’t know, with teachers you don’t trust, no way forward seems clear. So, you carry it until you learn how to bury it. You make your work your life.
You restore. You refurbish. You paint over stains for people who also need their pasts scrubbed clean. And you make a great living at it, so you can justify it as the only way to deal with a past you can’t repair.
I walked up the staircase to Claire’s room and sat on the window seat. Through the bay window, I could see the corner of the neighbor’s fence, and the patch of grass I had stood frozen on, that night.
“It’s OK,” I whispered to the terrified, baby-faced version of myself I imagined standing there. “You did what you could.”
Most people would freeze in that situation, regardless of their age. I knew that now. I could forgive it.
I collected the rest of the trash, and tucked the yearbook under my arm. The photo of us fell into my hand, and I looked at her one last time, before I tucked the yearbook away with the rest of my high school memories.
“I’m sorry,” I said to her beaming face, so trusting of her future and her happy place in this world.
I thanked her for who she was then and what she had helped me become, and I switched off the light and shut the door.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
A classic horror story. Thoroughly enjoyed it, especially Astrid's interactions and reactions. Very well written.
Reply