The Dummy

Contemporary Fiction

Written in response to: "Make a character’s obsession or grudge a key element of your story." as part of What Lingers.

Michael was in a foul mood. He’d slept poorly and now felt edgy and cooped up because of it. Irritable and morose, he sat in the kitchen rubbing his eyes as he waited for the coffee to brew. The more he rubbed the itchier his eyes became and the more his vision blurred. The sensation was maddening. His sleep was usually deep and without interruption, but last night he’d been restless, waking every few hours to ruminate on the minutiae of his past and the vast unknowability of his future. Those anxious thoughts seemed distant and less concrete in the light of day and the presence of a black cup of coffee, but the lack of sleep had disquieted him. He realized he’d better make an effort to reset or this day would be lost to his bad disposition. He went upstairs to his closet and pulled out his favorite shirt, pairing it with a new tie from last Christmas that still had the tags. He parted his hair to the left instead of the right. He decided to use his old worn-in backpack instead of his respectable leather messenger bag, even though he felt it made him look less professional. And he decided that instead of taking the crowded highway to work, he would take the coastline. It took longer, but he was up early.

Alone in the car, he nibbled a coffee cake as he drove, crumbs falling into his lap. He had the radio tuned to a local pop station. They were playing music he’d never heard from hip, relevant artists. He liked it. Michael began to feel better. The Day was a different animal than the Night. His mind was deliciously empty. The Day didn’t ask for the same self-reflection that the Night had tried to pry out of him. In the warm car, with the sun out and a hot cup of coffee, he felt safe from the reach of intrusive thoughts. The only thing that could reasonably be asked of him now was to drive safely from Point A to Point B. To ask a man to solve a problem in the midst of his morning commute, be it a crisis of faith or finance, would be absurd. Yes, as he listened to the hum of the engine and looked blankly out over the coastline, he realized things weren’t so bad. After all, he had an okay life. 

To Michael’s mind, the blandness of his life was a gift. He was nice-looking in an average Joe kind of way. He had the unearned confidence of male privilege dashed with just enough white guilt to be perceived as modest. He had a job that was dependable, but rarely challenging. The company paid him a comfortable, though ungenerous, wage and peppered him with enough meager praise to make him think he had genuine value. His family was reliable, though not particularly close or effusive, so they required little from him emotionally. He occasionally chatted with his older brother, but they mostly just talked about basketball. He liked to view himself from a distance at times, as if through the lens of a video camera, and from this perspective he took pride in the fact that his life appeared full of peaceful logic. No nonsense. Rational and linear.

He continued to drive along the winding coast for a while until he reached the area where the highway ended and the stop lights began. In the distance, up ahead at the light, he saw a tall, lanky man walking down the side of the road. He tried very hard not to notice him, but he was hard to ignore. The man was clearly homeless, his clothes rough and weathered. He had on a dirty outdoor coat buttoned to the neck with the hood pulled up over his tangled, blond hair. His faded black high-tops were missing the laces and the front of the right one was wrapped in duct tape. Michael caught a glimpse of the man’s face and realized he had a horrible scar where his left eye should have been. The angry pink flesh was bulbous and rough, marring the rest of his eerily pale features. He felt a shutter of revulsion, but caught himself. Michael was a good person and good people didn’t recoil in horror at the misfortune of others. So he steeled himself and attempted to employ a bit of well-practiced apathy, but the good kind. The man continued to trudge along the side of the road, hunched slightly, making his way closer and closer to Michael’s idling car. When he was only a few feet away, Michael realized the man held something gingerly in his arms. Cradled like the most precious of children, the man clutched a ventriloquist dummy in beautiful, pristine condition. The dummy had all the characteristic accoutrement – black top hat, a tiny, perfectly-tailored tuxedo, garishly exaggerated facial features. It looked just like the ventriloquist dummy that Michael remembered hanging in his grandfather’s dusty basement when he was a child, except for one thing. This dummy was black. 

“African-American,” Michael corrected himself, but he thought maybe that was racially insensitive, to think of an inanimate doll in terms of race. He’d never described Barbie as caucasian and he didn’t think this doll was actually African or American. If anything, it was probably made in China. 

“Like everything else in this country,” Michael thought. 

Now that sounded racist. Or was it xenophobic? Nativist? Whichever one it was, Michael reassured himself he wasn’t any of them. Something about this whole thing had just made him so damn nervous all of a sudden. Michael stared closely at the dummy with rapt attention, unable to look away. The doll gave off a wiry energy as it stared back with wide eyes and a gigantic, shit-eating grin. He marvelled at the dummy’s spotless condition juxtaposed with the man’s squalid one. Michael became aware that the dummy’s owner was staring straight at him. He looked back into the man’s one good eye, trying hard to avoid looking at the unpleasant tissue disfiguring the other side of his face. The man stroked the dummy’s cheek tenderly and began to laugh, showing a mouth full of broken teeth. Michael saw both the dummy and the man wink – in perfect unison. He took his foot off the brake and drove to work in a daze. 

Michael did nothing productive for the rest of the day. The only thing he could think about was the man and his dummy. He tried to work on the quarterly report, but instead found himself staring at his computer screen thinking about that wink. He opened a Google Doc and started a memo, but then just kept putting the word “ventriloquist” in different fonts. He scribbled doodles of the dummy’s face on Post-its. No matter what he did, his thoughts only centered on one thing. He had so many questions. How had the man gotten it? Why had he kept it? Why had the dummy been black? There was just something about the whole thing he…didn’t like. If a homeless man was going to spend his last remaining dollar on something, would it really be a ventriloquist dummy? And if he did, wouldn’t it be easier to just get, you know, a regular white one? That was logical, right?

That night he went home and told his girlfriend everything. Kelly was very quiet. She sat next to him on the couch and listened intently, twirling her hair in the way Michael found irrationally annoying. 

“It’s a jarring image,” she said when he finished. “A white guy carrying essentially an effigy of a black man. Probably using it as a prop in some grotesque political agenda. I can see why you were disturbed.” 

“Political agenda? Somehow I don’t think so. I was thinking more like…well, for one thing, how was he able to keep it in such perfect condition. And why hadn’t he sold it for alcohol or drugs or something?”

“Michael! What an awful thing to say. Just because this poor man is allegedly unhoused, you think he shouldn’t be allowed to keep one valuable possession? That doll might have real meaning to him. And must all homeless people be in the throes of active addiction? What if he wasn’t even homeless?”

“He was homeless. I could smell him from the car.” 

“I can’t believe you tonight. You usually have more empathy.”

“Maybe I’m just tired.”

Kelly didn’t get it, but there was clearly something there. Why had the doll been black? If it had just been white, Michael felt sure he would have wondered about the whole thing a lot less, but that thought did little to comfort him. He knew he couldn’t say it out loud. Plus, it made him feel like maybe he wasn’t such an enlightened person after all, even though he obviously was. So the only logical conclusion was that there must be something wrong with that crazy homeless guy and the black ventriloquist dummy. Otherwise, it wouldn’t have bothered him so much. His obsession with solving the mystery left him increasingly unproductive at work. No one noticed. He was surprised. He’d felt sure that his work held some intrinsic value, even if it hadn’t been the most glamorous. Unfortunately, though, it seemed everything at the company functioned virtually the same regardless of whether he was engaged or checked out. He even continued to receive the same amount of tepid praise, despite his complete lack of effort. He now spent most of his work time researching the history of ventriloquist dummies, ventriloquist performers, types of dolls in general. Had his Google search history been made public, it would have given even the most maladjusted internet user a brief pause. His mental health was becoming precarious.

Several weeks later, Mallory interrupted Michael while he was staring at his blank computer screen, punching him a little too hard in the left bicep and saying good morning in her usual way, with too much emphasis on “good.” Michael hated it. The two had an unlikely friendship. In a conservative office, Mallory was the only woman of color and the only person who was openly gay. That would have probably been hard enough, but Mallory’s job was also one of very few requiring a PhD, as well as highly skilled specialization. This made her indispensable. The combination of her job security, higher education, and “alternative lifestyle” didn’t sit well with a lot of the mid-level longtimers. Her initial reception in the office had been frosty. Over time, though, Michael had grown fond of her and found they shared a love of astronomy and The Three Stooges. His acceptance had served to make her life at the office much easier. 

He hadn’t yet told her about the dummy. For some reason, he’d been avoiding it. Kelly hadn’t been any help because she didn’t get it, but Mallory was different. She was Hispanic and a lesbian. He felt sure she would be able to tell him what the problem was. As they headed to the break room together to grab a cup of coffee, Michael talked her through it. 

“It’s a little homophobia creeping in, Mike. That’s all,” Mallory said.

“No. Definitely not.”

“It’s a fear of performative homosexuality. You can be an ally all you want, but a lot of men can’t handle it deep down. It’s nothing to be ashamed of – you responded as though a man was walking around with his hand literally shoved up another man’s ass. It made you uncomfortable. I actually commend you for examining your feelings and wanting to confront them. It takes a lot to admit to your prejudices and to want to move past them.” Mallory took a loud slurp of her coffee.

“I don’t have any prejudices.”

“Everyone does.”

“I don’t. And I’m definitely not homophobic. I mean, obviously, I’m friends with you.”

“Okay, how about for the sake of our friendship and to save HR a lot of paperwork, I just assume you were making a joke?”

“I was.” 

Weeks went by and Michael still thought often about the man and the dummy. He hoped that as time passed, he would forget it and never think of it again. He was watching a Lakers game one night when his phone rang. It was his brother, Peter. He rarely called since moving to Michigan five years ago. Peter was some type of Psychology professor and Michael didn’t understand his work no matter how many times he explained it. Largely, Michael found Peter’s explanations pedantic, but tonight he found himself craving the heavy-handed lecturing of his older brother. The two chatted for a few minutes about Pete’s kids, Kelly, the Lakers, and then Michael began telling him everything he could remember about the pale white homeless man and the black ventriloquist dummy. There was silence after he finished. For the first time in a long time, he felt a sense of relief. His brother was the smartest person he knew, the most educated, the most well-read. If anyone could tell him what was wrong with this whole situation, it would be him.

Pete chuckled, “Aw, Mike! Your paternal instincts are showing!”

“My what?” Michael’s sense of relief vanished.

“It makes sense. You’re not getting any younger. I bet Kelly’s dropped hints about wedding bells, even if you’re too dense to notice. Ha! This patriarchal representation of Madonna and child led you to concretely realize your own paternalistic desires. In your youth, you were young and handsome and you sowed your wild oats, but–”

“I’m still young and handsome!” 

“Handsome maybe, but not as young. So this image of a man and his child–”

“It wasn’t a child! He was a homeless dude carrying a black dummy.” 

“I’d say that phrasing is a little reductionist, Mike, if not a little crass. Plus, for our purposes here, the race of the child is wholly irrelevant.”

“Because it’s not a child, it’s an AFRICAN AMERICAN DOLL!”

“Oh, Michael, race is merely a social construct. Anyway, what we’re trying to get to the root of is why this particular image awoke such a visceral response. It’s obviously tied to your perception of manhood as it relates to the role of the father. We really need to dig into the role our own father played in our life. I’d love to do that with you! You’ve just never expressed any interest.”

“Pete, I’ve got to go.” Michael said, massaging his left temple in defeat. “You’ve been a big help.”

Months went by and Michael had mostly forgotten the man and the dummy. He thought of it rarely with a sort of residual shudder, just one of life’s mysteries meant to remain unsolved. The dummy hadn’t bothered any one else the way it had bothered him, so he knew he was meant to be unbothered. He’d come to accept it was best not to read any more into it than that. Michael was very late leaving work one night after a project had gone off the rails. He was cranky and drained, so he decided to stop at his favorite 24-hour donut shop. He’d been going there for years. The store was owned by a tiny Asian woman named Oak. She always had perfectly polished red nails that matched equally red lipstick that never smudged. Kelly had been in a few times with him over the years and told him that she probably had the color tattooed on her lips, a thought that both horrified and fascinated Michael. Michael found Oak’s presence soothing, the dim lights and dingy atmosphere in her little shop were a comfort to him. As he sat and ate his donut, he found himself telling her about the man and the dummy. 

After he’d finished, Oak handed him six glazed donut holes. 

“On the house,” she said.

“Thanks.”

“I know just what you’re talking about.”

“Yeah?”

She took a sip of icy water from a giant plastic cup. 

“A couple years ago, there was a man that used to stop in here. A white guy, around my age. He was handsome and sweet. He’d make me laugh and ask how I was doing. I had sort of a crush on him. But then one day, I was running some errands and I saw him out walking. He had this little rat of a dog with him, a chihuahua or a yorkie or something.”

She said as she’d gotten closer she’d realized the dog was dressed in a flowered dress. She’d tried to avoid the man all together, but he’d noticed her and stopped to say hello. Even as she reflexively smiled and laughed, Oak couldn’t stop staring at the tiny, clothed dog. It horrified her to think of it, a grown man walking around with a dog in a dress! Michael thought of Peaches, his childhood dachshund, a pudgy, short-haired thing whom he’d adored. Every winter when the weather turned cold, his father had dressed her in a thick plaid coat so she wouldn’t catch a chill on long walks. He decided not to bring that up. Instead he asked Oak what happened next.

“What happened next? Nothing, that’s what. It was too much, such a turn off. So I started hiding in the back whenever I saw him come in and eventually he stopped coming in all together.”

“Oh. But what was it that bothered you so much?”

“I don’t know. Who cares? I just didn’t like it. You know how weird white people can be with their pets. I don’t mean you,” she said, giving him a small wink. “You’re one of the good ones.”

Posted Nov 03, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.