“What is this?” I asked my teacher, Kirent, who, as far as I could tell, never left the school.
“An old photo album.” He smiled at my curiosity.
“What for?”
“What for? People of the past used to preserve their memories in pictures.” He answered evenly, then closed his eyes as if lost in thought.
“But…” I was afraid of sounding silly. “Why would they preserve them? They only get in the way.”
“What do you remember about your childhood?” he asked instead of answering, looking straight into my eyes.
“I… remember my parents. My grandparents,” I said, going through whatever came to mind. “But vaguely. We played games when I was allowed to visit them from school. There was a house with a big garden.” I hesitated. “It was all so… outdated.”
“Outdated,” he echoed, then said, “Remember that.”
I did remember that conversation, and I tried to preserve my memories. His request, even though I never quite understood it, gave me something to hold on to, especially in times of doubt. Kirent himself was interesting, a little strict, and somewhat mysterious. As a child, I felt that our teachers were kind of alike, though I could never explain in what way. Yet Kirent had something I couldn't find in the others.
Later, life gradually put everything in its place, teaching me to be comfortable, predictable, and to trust the world around me. But sometimes, remembering Kirent's lessons, I began to question things that had once seemed obvious.
Our world is better than that of our ancestors in some ways. We realized how foolish it was to pursue an ideal and took a different path. We don't waste our energy on pointless regrets. We embrace life in the present moment—that is taught from the very first years of school—and we don't make plans for the future.
At least here, in the Confederation, we enjoy the comfort that allows us to remain ourselves while caring for society, and even the world as a whole. It's no secret that many depend on us. I've visited different countries, and I can see that even the example we've set is proving contagious. We haven't merely united half the world. We're creating a new culture.
Yet interestingly, nostalgia has survived as a phenomenon. As a psychologist, I know the statistics. It affects only one in ten people. We accept it. But I'm certain we'd be better off without it.
Today, however, one question puzzled me. Can you be nostalgic for something you've never known? Something you could never even have imagined?
Lately, I've been remembering things quite often… Not my childhood, no. That would make no sense. Rather, my later school years and my independent life after graduation.
“What do you think about having a family, Cristens?” Eliquina asked me after we'd spent several days traveling together during the summer holidays, sharing double rooms in Class A hotels.
“As a psychology student? Or as a friend?” I asked, not trying to sound serious.
“My grandparents had a real family. Three children. Do you think that's a good idea?”
“You mean us?” I was genuinely surprised. Until then, Eli had seemed perfectly normal.
She nodded, a little embarrassed, but without looking away.
“As a friend, I'd say you risk losing all your boyfriends and girlfriends by asking questions like that.”
“No,” I added, noticing her reaction, “I have nothing against family people, but it's such a strange way to live!”
She smiled, a little sadly. “And as a psychologist?”
“Well… I'd suggest therapy.”
“I don't want therapy,” she replied, shaking her head. “But doesn't our world sometimes seem kind of… unnatural to you?”
I was at a loss.
“Forget it,” she said, seeing my expression. “Let's go to the beach.”
As she was leaving, she turned around. “Sarah, tidy up, but don't touch my things.”
“Of course,” replied the robot maid. “But I'd also advise you to consider therapy.”
Eli laughed. “You too!”
Of all the friends and partners I'd enjoyed spending time with in the past, Eli was the only one who had ever asked such questions. Now, many years later, I find myself wondering: what if…? What if the way our ancestors lived wasn't actually… bad, primitive, ignorant?
I got into an Intelcar after another session with a teenager, heading back to my combo-home, and almost jumped when I heard a voice from the driver's seat.
“Hey, buddy!”
The driver was clearly an ordinary human being.
“Jersey Sector?” he asked.
I nodded, then remarked, “But I ordered an Intelcar.”
“I'm Sam,” the driver replied, his easygoing manner making me a little uneasy. “We've been having shortages of standard models lately. And it's rush hour now, so we're making do with what we've got.”
“This never used to happen,” I objected.
“Wouldn't say that.” He looked at me in the mirror.
His thick eyebrows, stubble, and even his facial features revealed an ancient natural lineage. You rarely encountered people like him nowadays.
“In my experience,” Sam continued, “this is already the fifth time we've had to substitute human drivers for robots in the last couple of months. With everything automated and under control, technicians are out of work. At least this gives us a bit of variety.”
Seeing that he had my attention, he went on.
“About a month ago, almost half the taxis in New Calgary went down. Some software glitch or a virus. All the engineers and managers had to get behind the wheel themselves.”
“No way!” I exclaimed. “That wasn't in the news.”
“Of course not!” Sam seemed delighted to have someone to talk to. “Who needs bad news? And what we haven't heard about…”
“Never happened,” I finished the saying.
He nodded.
“But why? I mean, the shortages?” I was genuinely curious.
“Who knows? Maybe it's education and incompetent management, maybe politics, or maybe we're just getting lazier in general. Production's falling, and all we think about is how to have a good time today.”
“So much for stability!”
He was silent for a moment.
“Well, things used to be stable. Now—who knows? They say that a hundred years ago, people were more responsible, actually raised families, and…” Sam hesitated, unsure how to put it.
I merely nodded, not wanting to continue a conversation that was turning negative, and returned to my thoughts.
“What if I want to live in the past and the future?”
The question from Macdy, the fifteen-year-old boy I'd been counseling, wouldn't leave my mind. Formally, I had all the answers. I knew the theory, understood it, had the statistics. And yet his almost childlike sincerity somehow touched me deeply.
I tried to distance myself carefully.
“Living in the present moment is what makes us effective people. It allows us to enjoy life.”
“Yes, I know,” the boy objected. “But it doesn't work for me.”
Throughout my practice, I'd encountered plenty of cases where things “didn't work.” Some people benefited from counseling, others from changes in diet or daily routine, and still others from medication.
But what if, I wondered, in our effort to “accept everyone and everything,” we were actually rejecting other patterns of behavior without even thinking about it?
No, that couldn't be right. Psychology had always been about helping people adjust, and in our time, fitting into society was its highest purpose. Simply align, and life is fine. Even when people couldn't see what was wrong with them, we helped them overcome their aberrations and learn to accept themselves and the world around them. I was certain of that. Modern psychology had finally achieved what the primitive science of the past never could.
“And another thing,” Macdy remarked. “I can't see what comes next. I'd like to become a real engineer someday, not someone who only creates entertainment. But those educational programs have been closed for several years now. They only teach people to maintain what already exists. And robots can handle almost everything there, too.”
I frowned. Such interests were hardly typical of healthy teenagers.
“Do you have any girls you date?” I decided to check that aspect of his life as well.
“I did.” He paused. “Girls and boys. But…” He looked at me. “No, what's the point? You wouldn't understand anyway.”
“Well, give it a try.” I leaned a little closer and nodded.
“Okay…” He hesitated again. “Maybe… just one girl… someone you truly love… could be enough?”
That was an odd phrase. Yet, after that one question stayed with me… Given the freedom to follow our desires, why couldn't we long for something we've never experienced?
As I entered, the door closed softly behind me, and the home com switched on. Sancy appeared in a hologram above the visor, as elegant, attractive, and childishly sweet as ever.
“Cris, are we still on for tonight? I can be there around nine. I've cleared my evening for us.” She smiled playfully. “I wanted to bring Tom—he's a super-flexer—but I know you're old-fashioned about that, so I won't tempt you.”
Sancy reached for the off button, then stopped.
“Oh, by the way!” She lowered her voice to an amusing whisper. “We could have a baby if you want. There's a great program that pays fifty thousand soltars for pregnancy and childbirth. We could split it. Mix business with pleasure, huh?” She winked. “Don't worry about me. Full medical care and guarantees. Then the baby goes straight to a good school—no obligations. The quota's small, as usual, so decide quickly.”
Government quotas were always small.
Sancy was amusing. We met about once a month and were probably each other's most regular partners. Despite her job as an advisor at a large company, she remained naturally uninhibited and open about her desires.
Our school VR guides taught us that decades ago, people had tried to label every sexual preference. I'd never understood why. Everyone simply lived as they wished. Most of the history we learned was a collection of facts, only some explained to us. Apparently, those were the ones we needed to understand correctly. The rest mattered less.
I called Sancy.
“Cris!” She smiled brightly. “Seen my message?”
“Yes, irresistible as always.” I tried to sound genuinely appreciative. “Something came up. Sorry. Can you find someone to replace me?”
She looked playfully offended. “I'll try. If Tom's still free.” She paused. “And the baby? I could use a break from work.”
“Let me think. Say hi to Tom. We'll talk in a few days, okay?”
“No problem.” She smiled and waved. “Ciao!”
A month earlier, I'd gone to see my teacher. We hadn't met for several years.
“They're closing the school,” he said almost immediately after greeting me. “Fewer children. And the population is shrinking overall, so… That's how it goes.”
“I know.”
It was simply reality, something that had to be accepted.
“And… where will you go now?” Out of old habit, I still addressed him with the same respect I'd shown him at school.
“I'm not sure yet. The school was my home.” His reply was warm and friendly. “You know what often happens when something like this…”
“Would you like to come and live with me?”
Kirent smiled a little wearily.
“Are you serious, Cristens?”
“I'll take care of the formalities. I have two apartments on the same floor. The second one will be yours. And let people say I'm eccentric.”
I had to call Jack today. I simply felt that way.
He answered quickly on my way home and agreed to talk.
I settled into an armchair in the small conference room I'd set up when I first moved in, and switched on the Viport.
“Hi, Cris!” Jack was sitting on his sofa.
“Hey, Jackie! Good to see you.”
“Thanks for not coming over,” my friend said with a smile. “The place is a mess. But I've done some virtual cleaning. Take a look!”
He showed me his room looking the way it probably never had in real life.
I shook my head.
“Well, my place is actually tidy. Ancestral genes.”
“Oh, come on!” Jack pretended to be genuinely astonished.
“Sorry to bother you, but sometimes I just feel like chatting with a human being instead of an AI, about this and that.”
“Ah, so that's what this is about!” he chuckled good-naturedly. “Yeah, forty years ago at school we could spend hours discussing anything—from aliens to quantum biology.”
“Remember how you used to tell me about your childhood?” I got to the point. “Mine's all so vague.” I hesitated. “Could it be that by forgetting things, we're losing something important?”
Jack frowned.
“I spoke to my father two years ago. I don't even know whether he's still alive.”
“What did you talk about?” I couldn't help asking.
“Oh, everything. Where we're heading. Or sliding. Overall, he sees the advantages of what we've created. But unlike us, he underwent memory therapy as an adult, and you know, he's still drawn back to the past.”
“What do you think yourself? And… what do you remember?”
He fell silent again for a moment.
“I have a few vivid memories. I was sent to school when I was six—later than you. So some things stayed with me. My family, trips to the mountains, art exhibitions.”
It took me a while to put my thoughts into words.
“You know, lately I've been asking myself questions. Maybe strange ones… But what have we—I mean, our world—actually done so well? In what way have we surpassed our ancestors?”
“Well,” he began, “that's easy. We can take on a minimum of responsibility, or avoid it altogether, and life still goes on. Everything keeps working.”
He had always had his own way of finding answers to difficult questions.
“By the way!”
Jack got up from the sofa and walked over to the shelves on the wall, where various objects stood—flowers, crystals, even a couple of old books—and picked something up.
“Look what I've still got from childhood. No idea why they didn't confiscate it.”
He showed me a photo album.
“That's me as a little kid. Don't look anything like me, do I?”
We laughed, looking at a boy with an almost shaved head standing beside an old quad bike.
“Have you heard? Family people have once again contributed twice as much to population growth as everyone else combined. Even though so few of them are left.”
“Yeah… Strange how people can be so obsessed with having children, even when nobody pays them for it.”
I paused, remembering Sancy.
“Though maybe there's something to it.”
“I've been working on a quasi-cloning team for the past year,” Jack admitted.
“Come on! And you never told me?” I tried to tease him.
“Well, considering we haven't talked for about three years, does it really matter?” He chuckled. “We've made a lot of progress. Maybe in fifty years, family people won't be needed at all. Nor will any of the other methods. But it's still far too expensive and unreliable. And in half the cases, the resulting individuals are emotionally unstable. Especially after adolescence.”
I nodded.
“Maybe there was something in the old families that we've overlooked?”
He was silent for a moment.
“I'm not sure. Though who knows?”
After switching off the Viport, I thought about how much we'd both changed over the years. I'd hoped to find in him the voices of the past. But he'd become far more absorbed into this world than I had.
I stepped out of my apartment and knocked on the door next to mine.
“Come in, Cris,” I heard Kirent's voice from the other side.
The door slid aside automatically, letting me in.
My old teacher was watching television. They say the word itself has survived ages of technological change.
He turned toward me with a smile.
“Did you sense I was coming?” I asked, half joking.
“Who else would come to see me?”
His eyes seemed to glow with… warmth. Warmth and the wisdom of years gone by.
“Can I get you something, like in the good old days?”
“Yeah, sure… Do you have any mojito tonic?”
I smiled to myself, already knowing the answer.
He brought me a glass from the kitchen.
“Why are you watching that, teacher? You already know more than anyone!”
Kirent smiled.
“Every little piece of information carries…” He deliberately stopped and looked at me.
“Yes, yes. Energy and a new, precious meaning,” I replied, remembering his lesson.
The teacher nodded approvingly.
We spent some time warmly reminiscing about the past.
“You know,” I began as I was about to leave, “I remember that conversation about the old photo album. I mean, your questions and what you asked me to do. And…” I stopped, gathering my thoughts. “I have a question. Could it be that we were wrong to become so… different from what we used to be?”
He looked at me knowingly.
“Do you want an answer?”
I nodded. “I want to understand what lies ahead of us.”
Kirent narrowed his eyes thoughtfully.
“I think we're heading for a crisis. But afterward…” He smiled with both his lips and his eyes. “We'll find the right path. We always have.”
He patted me on the shoulder.
“You need some rest. You've got another full day of work tomorrow.”
We shook hands. Through his artificial skin, I could feel the hard, ageless joints beneath it. Yet there was genuine warmth in his handshake and in his eyes.
“Thank you, Kirent, and good night,” I said. “And don't forget to plug into your charger for the night.”
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Good story! Interesting plot and nicely written. May I make one suggestion? As I read it, the action of the story seemed to ramble on a bit in the middle, causing me to lose interest. I think the story could be tightened up, perhaps shortened a little, to produce more sustained action and forward momentum to keep the reader focused. But overall very nice.
Reply
Dear Bruce,
Thank you for your sincere and thoughtful feedback. It's very important for me to understand where a story may be losing momentum. I'll definitely keep your observations in mind when revising it for publication. I really appreciate your honesty and attention to detail!
Reply
The what if says many things. I have books filled with photos and often sit and browse through the myriad of memories. Today my computer contains pictures I never look at. The world has changed but what if.
This is well written and I enjoyed the read.
Reply
Dear Ron,
Thank you for your feedback. I'm glad the "what if" idea came through. I want to believe that a healthy path into the future should also cherish the experiences of the past. Maybe we're changing too quickly?
I appreciate your thoughtful reading.
Reply
“But I'd also advise you to consider therapy.” Even the robot maid has an opinion about her reproductive choices, Erian. I laughed, then found it rather chilling: apparently everyone is free to want whatever they like, provided they want the approved things.
Reply
Thank you, Marjolein! I'm glad you laughed before feeling that chill. :) I suppose the strangest thing about a society that accepts almost everything is how easily it can forget that people might still want something old-fashioned. And who gets to decide which desires need therapy? Thank you for catching that contradiction!
Reply
Exactly. Once acceptance becomes compulsory, it starts to look suspiciously like the thing it replaced. Just with better branding. :)
Reply
Your main character being a psychologist in a world that has handed the reigns of invention over to technology seems like an odd mix of dystopia and utopia. Giving up on ambition would kill me but I'm sure there would be some people very happy to just live in the moment. Fewer people have a traditional family but there are new variations than hopefully work for the people involved that weren't accepted before. Mostly I empathise with the frustration that would bubble up in creative people in that world who don't want to build things for entertainment. It feels like the people of your story have become pets of technology, valued but not trusted to run their own lives.
Reply
Dear Graham,
Thank you for such a thoughtful analysis! I appreciate the different angles you explored, in particular your observation about people becoming “pets of technology.” That's a striking way to put it! I also value a lot your perspective on the uneasy balance between utopia and dystopia, and how differently people might respond to such a world. You've captured some of the tensions I hoped readers would notice!
Reply