Sarah Grill

Sarah Grill – Editor

Big 5 editor who read too much Nancy Drew as a kid. Thoughtful, uplifting feedback on upmarket fic, thrillers, and nonfic; inquire within!

Overview

Hi! I'm a commercially-minded developmental editor with a decade's worth of experience in the publishing world (Simon & Schuster, Macmillan, Writers House, and Alloy Entertainment). Mystery, thriller, and suspense are my sweet spot, but I've dabbled in a bit of everything over the years, from book club fiction to young adult to narrative nonfiction. My editorial wish list can best be described as "coming-of-age with a murder": smart, satisfying, big-hearted reads with some darker edges.

Digging into developmental edits is one of the best parts of my job; I love to roll up my sleeves with authors and work out the kinks of pacing, story, and character until everything shines. I can never resist a good line edit and will happily whip out a red pen for a thorough copyedit. As an editorial partner, I'm enthusiastic, eagle-eyed, and supportive of the vision you want to share with the world.

Having spent several years in the industry, I'm very aware of how "behind the curtain" traditional publishing can feel, and I'm here to help you gain insight and confidence as you prepare your manuscript, query letter, or final polish. I can't wait to see what you're working on!

Services
Fiction
Contemporary Fiction Mystery & Crime Psychological Thriller Young Adult
Non-Fiction
Entertainment True Crime
Languages
English (US)

Work experience

Simon & Schuster

Mar, 2024 — Present
Acquiring a thoughtfully curated list of smart, upmarket fiction with a specialization in mystery, thriller, and atmospheric suspense. Providing in-depth editorial letters and detailed line edits, drafting jacket copy and sales pitches, evaluating submissions.

Macmillan

Mar, 2018 — Mar, 2024 (about 6 years)
Rose in the ranks from editorial assistant to editor, gaining key skills in crafting edit memos, copyediting and proofreading, and honing my commercial tastes. Built a wide-ranging list of award-winning and bestselling titles, including A FRAGILE ENCHANTMENT by Allison Saft, THESE SILENT WOODS by Kimi Cunningham Grant, A MYSTERY OF MYSTERIES by Mark Dawidziak, and LENNY MARKS GETS AWAY WITH MURDER by Kerryn Mayne.

Portfolio

These Silent Woods: A Novel

Grant, Kimi Cunningham

Minotaur Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review
This Day Changes Everything

Underhill, Edward

Wednesday Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Pinky Swear: A Novel

Girard, Danielle

Atria/Emily Bestler Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review
A Fragile Enchantment

Saft, Allison

Wednesday Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review
Such Sheltered Lives: A Novel

Sheinmel, Alyssa

Atria/Emily Bestler Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review
What the Woods Took: A Novel

Gould, Courtney

Wednesday Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Speak of the Devil: A Novel

Wilding, Rose

Minotaur Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review
So Happy Together: A Novel

Worley, Olivia

Minotaur Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Lenny Marks Gets Away with Murder: A Novel

Mayne, Kerryn

St. Martin's Press

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review
Make-Up Test

Howe, Jenny L

Griffin

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Query Letter Review

Sarah has 15 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Gerard A.

Gerard A.

Aug, 2026

I have collaborated with Sarah twice and both times she has provided clear and professional feedback that has improved my fiction query package.
LouAnn K.

LouAnn K.

Jul, 2026

Very professional. Excellent advice.
pamela F.

pamela F.

Jun, 2026

Sarah offered constructive and detailed feedback on my query letter. I really appreciated her thoughtful edits and explanations.
Bobbi J.

Bobbi J.

Jun, 2026

Sarah provided thoughtful, detailed feedback that helped me see strengths and weaknesses in my manuscript more clearly. Her comments were specific, encouraging, and clearly grounded in experience. I found her insights valuable and believe they will be helpful as I continue revising. I appreciated...
Read more
Taylor B.

Taylor B.

May, 2026

So grateful for Sarah's valuable feedback on my manuscript! She gave such detailed in-line edits and a very thorough edit letter that caught a few plot holes/inconsistencies/plot contrivances I hadn't even considered. Hopped on a call to go over my edit letter, too, which was so helpful. Can't wa...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Sarah and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Sarah

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Beth D.

Seasoned editor and proofreader with more than 20 years of experience in multiple genres. I have worked with several best-selling authors!

Maineville, United States

100% reply rate

View profile

Peter R.

Ex-UK journalist (Fleet St, BBC Radio), living in New York. Former NYC book editor now lit agent, book coach, author of fiction+nonfiction.

New York City, NY, USA

100% reply rate

View profile

Shelley R.

Fiction editor with 15 years’ experience, helping authors shape market-ready novels that agents request and publishers acquire.

100% reply rate

View profile