Jennifer Herrington

Jennifer Herrington – Editor

Passionate editor & book coach helping authors at every stage craft and turn romantic story ideas into unforgettable books they love.

Overview

I’m a passionate, experienced editor and book coach who has worked with bestselling, award-winning, and debut authors alike. What drives me most is helping writers create stories they’re genuinely proud of—and guiding them toward the publishing goals that matter most to them.

I love love stories in all their forms—from sweet to extra spicy—across every heat level and age category, including young adult, new adult, and adult fiction. I work across a wide range of romance subgenres, including contemporary, paranormal, romantasy, romantic comedy, and romantic suspense, and I’m especially drawn to full-length novels where there’s space to deeply develop character, emotion, and story.

I also have a soft spot for projects where romance plays a strong supporting role, such as women’s fiction, suspense, and cozy mysteries. As a lifelong sports fan and former sports reporter, I especially enjoy working on sports romances and stories featuring athlete protagonists. I’m equally excited by dark romance that pushes boundaries and YA stories that capture the intensity and vulnerability of first love.

Before launching my freelance business, I worked as an editor with Kensington Publishing and interned with Entangled Publishing. I’ve now spent over a decade editing romance and romantic fiction, supporting authors at every stage of their journey—from early coaching and manuscript assessments to developmental editing, copyediting, and proofreading.

I’m also a writer, which means I understand how vulnerable—and at times isolating—the revision process can feel. I’ve experienced feedback that nearly made me walk away from writing altogether, and that experience shaped the editor I am today. It’s why I prioritize a supportive, encouraging, and honest environment where authors can grow with confidence.

With thoughtful feedback, constructive critique, and a deep understanding of genre expectations, story mechanics, and the marketplace, I help authors strengthen their manuscripts while preserving their unique voice and vision.

Every author’s path is different—and I’d love to see if I’m the right fit for yours.

Services
Fiction
Contemporary Romance Dark Romance Paranormal Romance Romantic Comedy Romantic Fantasy Romantic Suspense Women's Fiction Young Adult
Languages
English (CAN) English (US)
Certifications
  • Ryerson University, Publishing Certificate
  • Simon Fraser University, Editing Certificate
  • University of Waterloo, General Arts
  • Conestoga College, Broadcasting Diploma
  • Ryerson University, Children's Publishing Professional Development Award
  • Editorial Freelance Association member
  • Editors Association of Canada member

Work experience

Self-employed

Jan, 2018 — Present
I provide editorial services (editorial assessment, developmental editing, line editing, proofreading) and book coaching to authors in the genres of romance and romantic fiction. I work through a series of editing passes with each author helping to tighten the story while maintaining the author's voice and vision for their book. I also provide book coaching services for romance authors whether it's working through an outline and completing a first draft or working through the editing process with some extra TLC. (Previously known as Editing with Love - 2016)

Lyrical Press/Kensington Publishing Corporation

Jan, 2016 — Mar, 2020 (about 4 years)
I proofread galley manuscripts to correct typos, formatting errors, grammar errors, and minor discrepancies. Followed Chicago Manual of Style and Merriam-Webster Dictionary. I recorded any errors on proofreading recording form.

Kensington Publishing Corporation (Lyrical Press)

Feb, 2014 — Mar, 2020 (about 6 years)
I read queries, presented potential acquisitions to managing editor, provided developmental editing to acquired books, formatted manuscripts, reviewed copyedited manuscript with author to explain any recommendations, completed requested copyedits, provided proofread, reviewed proofreading recommendations with author, and reviewed galley copy. I acted as the liaison between the publisher and author for cover, back cover blurbs, marketing plans, etc.

Entangled Publishing

Feb, 2012 — Dec, 2019 (almost 8 years)
I read partial, full submissions, and client manuscripts and provided reader report and editorial recommendations. I also provided first and second pass editorial notes and letter to my mentor.

Portfolio

Developmental Editing
Reporter's Sentry (Hunt Security Book 4)

Caldwell, Jasmine C.

Steam Heat Press

Reputation: A Toronto Royals Story

Sharp, Elizabeth

Elizabeth Sharp

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Caterpillars (Evolution of Us Book 1)

Taylor, Sydney

Sydney Taylor

Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Dive (Young Adult Secrets Series Book 1)

Diehl, Catherine

Real Diehl Romance

Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Developmental Editing
Open Skate (Milwaukee Glaciers Book 1)

Diehl, Catherine

Real Diehl Romance

Developmental Editing Proofreading
Proofreading
Not As Advertised

Avery, Violet K.

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Major Penalty (Milwaukee Glaciers Book 2)

Diehl, Catherine

Real Diehl Romance

Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Cocoons (Evolution of Us Book 2)

Taylor, Sydney

Sydney Taylor

Developmental Editing
Rivals In The Dark

Khubeis , G. K.

Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing
Sorcerer's Spin (Mages and Mavericks Book 3)

Rae, Anise

Rogue Ink Press LLC

Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing
Syphon's Song (Mages and Mavericks Book 1)

Rae, Anise

Rogue Ink Press LLC

Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing
Bar Down: Milwaukee Glaciers Series Book 3

Diehl, Catherine

Real Diehl Romance

Developmental Editing
Survivor's Sniper (Hunt Security Book 3)

Caldwell, Jasmine C.

Steam Heat Press

Developmental Editing
Release (Volktov Bratva Book 2)

Diehl, Catherine

Real Diehl Romance

Developmental Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Proofreading
Thief's Bodyguard (Hunt Security Book 1)

Caldwell, Jasmine C.

Steam Heat Press

Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Tuned Into You

Dorminy, Cindy

Music City Arts

Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing
Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading
Where the Seabird Soars

Babcock, Rebecca

Independently published

Developmental Editing Proofreading
Proofreading
Playing For Love (Moonlight Valley Book 1)

Groome, Charlene

Charlene Groome

Proofreading
Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Precognition (S.O. Security Book 1)

Diehl, Catherine

Real Diehl Romance

Developmental Editing
Mine (Volktov Bratva Book 1)

Diehl, Catherine

Real Diehl Romance

Developmental Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing

Jennifer has 132 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Elena M.

Elena M.

Dec, 2025

Pinned
Jennifer was great. She restored my faith in book coaches and truly helped guide my half-written book to its final page. She is the perfect blend of critic and cheerleader, precisely what I needed on my writing journey.
Nikole S.

Nikole S.

Oct, 2025

Pinned
There are truly no words to express how much I love working with Jennifer. She is incredibly thorough and consistently helping make my manuscript the best it can possibly be. Her eye for detail and creative insights bring ideas that I would have never thought of on my own. I wholeheartedly give ...
Read more
Sydney T.

Sydney T.

Sep, 2025

Pinned
I said this last time, but working with Jenn is my dream come true. This is my second opportunity to work with her, and once again, it's been everything I need as a new author. Jenn has a fantastic pulse on my current genre, and is able to provide feedback that helps me align with those expectati...
Read more
Miranda H.

Miranda H.

Apr, 2026

Jennifer was a great collaborator who provided insightful observations about my manuscript in a very clear and respectful manner. At the end of our time together, she gave me many in-text comments plus a thorough write-up of suggestions. Her comments will be instrumental for me as I continue to d...
Read more
Deb F.

Deb F.

Apr, 2026

Having Jen helping me as I tiptoed into writing and began pursuing my writing goals was amazing. Her feedback helped me shape the plot in ways I couldn’t have on my own. Jen’s insight and comments were precise and professional. I hope to work with her again in the near future. Thank you, Jen, fo...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Jennifer and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Jennifer

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Hailie Johnson

Hailie J.

Editorial Director–turned–developmental editor for voice-driven, character-rich contemporary fiction and memoir

Los Angeles, CA, USA

100% reply rate

View profile
Jessica McKelden

Jessica M.

A detail-oriented developmental + copy editor who will guide you toward feeling more confident about your novel! Loves fantasy + romance.

Puyallup, WA, USA

100% reply rate

View profile
Cameron-Rose Neal

Cameron-Rose N.

Fiction & non-fiction editor specialising in literary, romance and fantasy that challenges readers and lingers long after.

Geddington, UK

100% reply rate

View profile