Carol Trow

Carol Trow – Editor

I don't just help you get the grammar right - for me, editing is a holistic task, from the content to the blurb; I'm with you all the way!

Overview

I have been editing for just over ten years now and have around 500 books to my credit! Although I have listed some of the topics I have already edited, I always like to meet new subjects - finance and business is a recent addition and I have to say I absolutely love it! What I enjoy more than anything is editing a book in which the writer is really invested, from memoirs (see A Fisherman in the Saddle below) to very erudite books on a niche subject (Peppercorn, his Life and Locomotives for instance). I don't just edit non-fiction; my fiction editing has been for Severn House (now part of Canongate) and Blkdog Publishing mainly as well as authors awaiting placement and I specialise in spotting 'plot holes' and other issues which will make a reader stop, blink and give a bad review. Fiction editing is a very different thing from non-fiction but the attention to detail I bring to books on monetary systems, trains or crime is just as useful when spotting whether the victim is wearing the same clothes when found horribly murdered in an alley as they were when they left the house. These things matter and in the heat of writing can often get missed even by the most careful author. I am here to put that right.I have been described as caring, meticulous, 'hawk-eyed' and I love all of those descriptions, but really, I like to think that my main skill is that I can help a writer fall back in love with their work if they have got a bit stale or if they have stalled with a previous editor who didn't quite 'get' them. To raise the thorny subject of money, once I have given a quote, that is all you pay - I never add a penny, even if the project takes longer. So there is no need to worry about escalating bills. And also, when I join a project, I am there for the long haul, however long that might be!Review from Arnie Witkin:Carol edited my book 'Not a Great Thing in Life' . It was like having your hair done at Vidal Sassoon rather than the local hairdresser in Clapham Common (not that I have anything against Clapham Common). It was like the difference between caviar and cod (not that I have anything against cod). I went from uncertainty to confidence that I really had an outstanding product. I felt in safe hands - a comforting feeling. Carol is thoroughly reliable, responsive and replied to my toing and froing on the same day. She was patient but firm where required. I was delighted with my experience.
Services
Fiction
Dystopian Mystery & Crime
Non-Fiction
History Transportation True Crime
Languages
English (UK) English (US)

Work experience

Self-employed

Jan, 2013 — Present
I have been editing since 2013 and have worked on over 500 books in that time for private clients, Pen and Sword (across the genres of history, crime, well-being, nature, travel and cooking), Severn House (now part of Canongate) and Blkdog Publishing.

Carol has 71 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Juliet W.

Juliet W.

Oct, 2025

Pinned
Truly, I cannot recommend Carol highly enough. Following a bad experience with an editor from another company, I was seriously considering giving up writing altogether. But, I thought I'd give it one more go, and decided on Reedsy. From the very outset, Carol was there pretty much 24/7. Positiv...
Read more
Paul B.

Paul B.

Aug, 2025

Pinned
Working with Carol Trow was the single best decision I made for my book. As an inexperienced author, I needed more than just an editor; I needed a guide, and Carol was exceptional in every way. Her critiques were not only professional and objective but truly invaluable. She has a rare talent for ...
Read more
Leigh M.

Leigh M.

May, 2025

Pinned
As a first timer writing a full manuscript, I didn't actually know just how much help I needed with editing. I decided to collaborate with Carol after her no nonsense, professional, courteous and humorous nature. She has an absolute wealth of experience in writing and editing and guided me throug...
Read more
Carol W.

Carol W.

Jul, 2026

Carol was amazing to work with! I feel so fortuntate that she agreed to take me. Her feedback, both positvie and negative was very useful. She always got back to me in a very timely manner. I have thoroughly enjoyed working with her!
Kimberly M.

Kimberly M.

Jun, 2026

I found working with Carol to be a great experience. As my first time hiring an editor, I was concerned about there being a steep learning curb to overcome. However, with the documents she provided me I found the process of implementing her suggested changes, as well as adding my own, to be very ...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Carol and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Carol

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Chris S.

Academic copy editor with more than 20 years of experience working on history, political science, and travel books and articles.

West Windsor, NJ, USA

100% reply rate

View profile

Caitlin L.

I'm an established literary fiction editor passionate about developing great stories who has worked at Big Five houses in the US and the UK.

London, UK

100% reply rate

View profile

Dominic W.

Experienced book editor formerly @ HarperCollins and Little, Brown, working on a range of fiction including literary, commercial, crime + YA

London, UK

100% reply rate

View profile