Fantasy Fiction Horror

The fluorescent lights in the Natural History Museum's west corridor had been having some kind of nervous breakdown for three days—flickering in a rhythm that suggested either faulty wiring or a really passive-aggressive ghost. Clara had filed two maintenance requests, both of which had been received with the enthusiasm of a man being asked to clean up after the apocalypse.

"Budget's tight," Jerry from facilities had said, like that explained why a major metropolitan museum couldn't afford a fucking light bulb.

"We're closing in ten," her supervisor's voice crackled through the walkie-talkie with all the warmth of a DMV announcement.

Clara stood in front of the newest exhibit, alone in the Children's Wing, which was exactly where she deserved to be at 7 PM on a Friday. Fairy Tales Through the Ages, some private collection from Connecticut that probably involved old money and a family curse nobody wanted to discuss. The placard promised "authentic folkloric artifacts" and "a journey into childhood's darkest dreams," which, great, exactly what parents wanted: their kids having nightmares about museum field trips.

The centerpiece was this cradle. Eighteenth-century German, carved with wolves running in circles around the rim—wolves with their mouths open, teeth rendered in the kind of detail that suggested the artist had maybe seen some shit. The placard read: Cradle of Abandonment - circa 1750. Used in rural communities to hold infants left for the forest.

Clara had gone down a Wikipedia hole about it at 2 AM last Tuesday, which was definitely a sign her life was going great. The practice was documented—deformed babies, extra mouths during famine years, inconvenient pregnancies. Just left them in the woods. The forest could have them. Or wolves. Or weather. Whatever came first.

Except sometimes, according to the really old stories—the ones from before the Brothers Grimm decided to make everything marketable—something else found them.

She knelt beside the cradle, which was probably not in her job description but definitely felt like the kind of thing her therapist would have opinions about. The wood was darker up close, almost wet-looking in the bad light. She traced one wolf's jaw—the artist had carved the inside of its mouth, the ridged palette, even a tiny tongue.

The kind of attention to detail that suggested this wasn't art. This was documentary work.

A sound stopped her cold. Soft. Rhythmic.

Breathing.

Coming from inside the empty cradle.

"Oh, fuck me," Clara whispered, which was exactly the kind of protagonist energy that got people killed in the horror movies she was pretty sure she wasn't cool enough to survive.

Her hand jerked back. The motion sensors in the next gallery clicked off like they'd been waiting for their cue. The fluorescents above her—already having an existential crisis—gave up entirely, and the Children's Wing went dark with the kind of completeness that suggested God had changed His mind about light as a concept.

Clara's phone flashlight felt obscene, like bringing a flood light into a church during a funeral. The beam found the cradle.

It wasn't empty anymore.

The child inside looked maybe two, naked, its skin the color of birch bark in February. Its eyes were open—yellow, reflective, catching the light like a cat’s. When it smiled, its teeth were too sharp, too many, overlapping in rows.

"Sweet Christ—"

"Shh." The voice came from everywhere—behind her, above her, from the walls themselves like the building was finally confessing its sins. "You'll wake the others."

Clara spun around so fast she almost dropped her phone, which would have been her final girl moment over before it started.

There was a figure in the doorway to the Hall of North American Mammals, backlit by the exit sign's glow like the world's worst dating app photo. Tall, impossibly thin, wearing what might have been elegant clothes or might have been rags—honestly hard to tell when someone's been wearing the same outfit since the Industrial Revolution. Its face was beautiful in that way that made you understand why sailors used to wreck their ships: sharp features, large eyes, bone structure that looked like it had been designed by someone with strong opinions about geometry.

Not human. Not quite. Maybe never was.

"This section is off-limits after hours," Clara sputtered, because apparently when her brain panicked, it defaulted to museum policy like that had ever protected anyone from anything.

The thing laughed—gentle, almost fond, the way you'd laugh at a kid who thinks a nightlight can protect them from the dark. "Off-limits. Yeah, we prefer it that way." It moved forward with a gait that suggested its bones bent in directions bones weren’t meant to bend. "You know what humans always fuck up about us? About the old stories?"

The child in the cradle had sat up, watching with those yellow eyes. Clara's flashlight shook like it was auditioning for a found footage movie.

"You think we stole children out of cruelty." The figure crouched beside the cradle with impossible grace, one long-fingered hand stroking the child's bark-pale head. The gesture was tender. The hand had too many knuckles. Both things were true. "You tell stories about wicked faeries and evil witches, about babies stolen and swapped for monsters. You never ask what we saved them from."

Two more children emerged from behind the timber wolf diorama—smaller than the first, moving with that predatory quick-twitch energy of cats who've spotted something interesting to murder. They clustered around the figure's legs, their sharp-toothed mouths working silently like they were practicing words they'd never need.

"The cradles," Clara breathed, her brain finally catching up to the situation like the slowest kid in a race nobody wanted to run. "You took the abandoned children."

"Found them." The correction clearly mattered. "Starving. Frozen. Left to die because they were inconvenient or imperfect or just—" It gestured vaguely with one too-long hand. "—poor timing, bad year, wrong gender. The forest is kinder than you think. It remembers what humanity wishes to forget—that every child deserves to be claimed. By someone. By something."

The first child made a sound between a human baby's cry and a bird's chirp, and Clara's hindbrain—the part that still remembered when humans weren't apex predators—started screaming.

"What did you do to them?"

"Saved them. Raised them. Armed them." The figure's smile was sad and old and tired in a way that made Clara think about geological time. "Your stories call them changelings, like we replaced something precious. But the kids we took were already replaced, yeah? Replaced with disappointment in their parents' eyes. Hunger in their bellies. The cold certainty that they were disposable." It gathered the three children against itself like a Renaissance painting of the Madonna if the Madonna was seven feet tall and hadn't been human in several centuries. "We gave them something else. Something with teeth and claws and the ability to survive what tried to kill them."

Clara's phone died—battery, physics, divine intervention, who knew—and the darkness swallowed them whole. She heard the children scatter, heard them moving in ways that violated Euclidean geometry: up walls, across ceiling tiles, sounds that human children shouldn't make because human children still had to obey gravity.

When the emergency lights finally kicked in—red and pulsing like the building's heart was failing—the figure stood directly in front of her. Close enough that she could see it had been beautiful once, before the forest changed it.

"Why show me this?" Clara's voice cracked like ice over deep water.

"Because you work here." It said it like that was obvious, like Clara's minimum-wage museum job was cosmically significant. "Every day in this room, teaching kids about fairy tales. Making them safe. Sanding down our teeth, filing away the parts that matter." It reached out—Clara flinched but didn't run, which was either brave or stupid and probably both—and touched her cheek with fingers cold as winter soil. "But you know, right? You've read the real stories. The ones from before Disney decided to sell happiness. You know we were never the villains."

"You're still stealing children."

"They would have died had we left them. We are saving them." The figure's voice held the patience of someone who'd had this argument before, would have it again, would keep having it until the heat death of the universe. It gestured to the shadows where the children lurked, yellow eyes gleaming like Christmas lights in hell. "The world hasn't changed as much as you'd like to believe. There are still cradles in forests. Different forests—concrete and fluorescent, invisible to people who don't want to see. Still children abandoned in bathroom stalls and back alley dumpsters."

The children were climbing the walls now, casual as squirrels, their sharp fingers finding purchase on flat surfaces. One of them chirped again—a happy sound, or at least Clara's brain was choosing to interpret it as happy because the alternative made her want to cry.

"Foster care system's a fucking nightmare," the figure continued conversationally, like they were discussing weather. "Did you know that? Underfunded, overwhelmed, full of people trying their best with resources that ran out long ago. Some kids fall through. Some kids get left behind." Its smile was gentle, terrible. "We catch them. We've always caught them. We've just had to get creative about where we hunt."

"Jesus Christ."

"He's not really our department." The figure moved past her, the children following—melting into shadows that shouldn't exist under emergency lighting, that violated everything Clara knew about how darkness worked. At the threshold of the North American Mammals hall, it paused. "Next time you teach kids about fairy tales, remember: the monsters in those stories were never the ones with teeth. They were the ones who left babies in the woods and called it survival. Called it necessary. Called it—" Another vague gesture. "—the best option under difficult circumstances."

Then they were gone, and Clara was alone with the empty cradle and the wolves carved forever in their endless circle.

Her walkie-talkie crackled. "Clara? You still in the Children's Wing? I'm heading out."

She looked at the cradle. In the red emergency light, the wooden wolves seemed to move.

"Yeah," she said softly. "I'm here. Just checking the exhibits."

"Weirdo. Lock up when you leave."

In the morning, the lights would work. The cradle would be empty. Parents would bring their children to learn the approved versions of old stories, and Clara would smile and guide tours and talk about the educational value of folklore. She wouldn't mention what moved through the museum after hours, what hunted in the spaces between closing and dawn.

But she'd remember. And sometimes, walking through the Children's Wing in daylight—the safe kind, the kind with families and field trips and kids eating overpriced snacks from the gift shop—she'd notice things. A child's drawing left on a bench, too sophisticated for such small hands. A penny that smelled like forest loam. Tiny tooth marks on the edge of a display case: too many teeth, too sharp, arranged in rows.

The forest was still taking the abandoned. Still giving them teeth. Still offering the kind of salvation that looked like damnation to people who'd never been desperate enough to understand the difference.

And Clara, who had spent her whole life believing museums preserved dead things, who'd gotten a Master's degree to prove it, who'd chosen this career because she thought history was safe—Clara now understood that some exhibits were never meant to be dead at all.

She started leaving her phone charger in her desk drawer. Started keeping the cradle's placard accurate, even when marketing wanted to soften the language. Started noticing which children at school groups lingered too long by the wolves, which ones traced the carved mouths with fingers that understood hunger.

Started wondering, on bad nights when her student loans felt like their own kind of abandonment, what it meant that the monsters in the museum were kinder than the ones who built it.

Posted Jan 17, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

22 likes 5 comments

Deb Titus
05:55 Feb 04, 2026

Oh my goodness, I love this story. I've always believed that the real monsters lived among us, wearing human form. To me, this story is far closer to the truth than most of us realize. I have actually met a few 'monsters' in my day. Thank you, Gareth, for this wonderful tale.

Reply

Eric Manske
13:30 Feb 03, 2026

Glad to see one of your stories in the top stories of preferred genres. My wife and I fostered teenagers and are now raising a grandchild from one of our kids. We definitely had our struggles with the system but also saw those who were doing the best they could under the circumstances.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
15:07 Jan 28, 2026

This story brilliantly reframes folklore by refusing the comfort of clean villains, letting the horror sit exactly where it belongs: in abandonment dressed up as necessity. I love how the museum setting turns preservation into complicity, and Clara’s quiet shifts—what she edits, what she leaves intact—feel like the real moral climax. The final image lingers because it doesn’t ask us to absolve the monsters, only to question why they seem more merciful than the systems we built.

Reply

Jessica Thomp
13:36 Jan 28, 2026

This is a great story! I really love the concept of this. I cannot wait to read more from you. Keep writing!

Reply

Helen A Howard
08:10 Jan 25, 2026

Good story. The real monsters remained hidden.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.