Final Edit and

Creative Nonfiction

Written in response to: "Write a story with the aim of making your reader gasp." as part of Flip the Script with Kate McKean.

Sarah stared at the screen, the blue light reflecting in her tired eyes. "Just one more pass," she whispered. Her fingers danced across the keyboard, perfecting the last chapter of her debut thriller, The Shadow in the Nursery.

It was her masterpiece. The story followed a mother, haunted by a babysitter who wasn't really there, slowly driven mad by the sounds of a crying infant in a house that should have been empty.

She looked at her watch: 3:00 AM. She deserved a break. She pushed her chair back, leaving her home office, the hardwood floors creaking in the silent house. She walked down the long, dark hallway toward the nursery, driven by a nagging, maternal instinct.

The nursery door was cracked open.

Sarah peeked inside. The crib was filled with soft blankets. She smiled, feeling the familiar, overwhelming rush of love for her six-month-old daughter. She leaned down to stroke the baby's soft hair, humming a gentle lullaby.

Suddenly, a cold sweat broke out across her neck. Her heart stopped.

The blankets in the crib were perfectly arranged, untouched, just as she had left them after the nanny took the baby to her mother's house for the weekend.

Sarah felt a hand on her shoulder.

“You really shouldn’t have left me in that chapter,” a cold voice whispered in her ear.

Sarah gasped, spinning around, but the room was empty.

She ran back to her office, her heart slamming against her ribs, and looked at the screen to delete the final chapter.

Her computer was already off.

But as the screen turned black, she saw her own reflection—and behind her, standing in the doorway, was the shadowy figure from her book, wearing her own clothes. Story 1: The Late Shift

I’ve worked the night shift at the remote gas station for three years, and I’ve never been afraid. It’s quiet, the coffee is fresh, and I keep a baseball bat under the counter just in case. At 3:00 AM, a frantic man in a torn suit ran in, locking the glass door behind him. He was covered in dirt, his eyes wide with panic. "You have to hide me," he screamed. "He's coming! The man with no face! He kills everyone!"

I told him to breathe, led him to the back storeroom, and locked it securely. I felt a surge of pride; I was protecting someone. A minute later, I heard the bell on the front door ring. A tall figure in a heavy trench coat walked in, moving slowly. He stopped at the counter and leaned forward. He didn't have a face—just a smooth, pale, void-like surface where his eyes and mouth should have been. My heart stopped. He held up a hand and signed, “Where did he go?”

I realized then why the man in the suit was so frantic. He hadn't been running from a monster. He had been running from the innocent, silent officer of the void, trying to hide the terrible things he had done. I had just locked the witness in the back room with the monster... or was it the other way around? For years, my daughter, Elara, insisted on painting portraits of our family. She was only seven, yet her technique was hauntingly realistic. Her favorite subject was her younger brother, Leo, who she always painted standing by the old oak tree in the backyard. The paintings were always cheerful—Leo smiling, surrounded by sunshine.

Last week, Elara finished a new painting. It was different. The colors were dark, the sky bruised purple, and the oak tree looked like a clawed hand. In the painting, Leo wasn't smiling; he was standing with his back to us, looking down into a deep, freshly dug hole in the ground.

"It's finished, Mommy," she whispered, tugging on my apron. "Now we don't have to look for him anymore." I felt a cold sweat break out as I realized she hadn't just painted the backyard—she had painted the empty space behind the shed where I had finally buried the neighbor's aggressive dog that had gone missing last month, the dog that had been stalking her. The Good Night kiss

For ten years, I’ve watched over my daughter. Every night, I tuck her in, kiss her forehead, and whisper that she is safe. Tonight, she finally looked at me—truly looked at me—and said, "Daddy, why do you look exactly like the man who died in our basement?" I smiled, stroking her hair, and whispered back, "Because he didn't want to leave you alone."

2. The Final Transmission

"All systems are operational," I reported, staring at the blue marble of Earth from the spaceship window. Mission Control cheered. It was a perfect journey. I checked the vitals of the other three crew members in cryo-sleep, just as I was programmed to do. Suddenly, a cold sweat broke out. Programmed. I rushed to the mirror, ripping at my skin, only to find wires underneath. I was never the pilot; I was the cargo.

3. The Portrait

She was the most beautiful woman I had ever painted. Hours turned into days, and I became obsessed with her portrait, capturing every detail of her smile. When I finally added the last brushstroke, she spoke from the canvas. "Finally," she whispered, stepping out of the frame while my hands became stiff and painted. "Now, you stay there." I tried to scream, but I could only smile, frozen in oils, watching her walk out of my studio wearing my skin. 1. The Good Dog

I lay in the dark, shivering, the sound of water dripping—drip, drip, drip—echoing from the bathroom. I reached my hand down, and immediately felt the comforting, rough lick of my dog, Buster. I fell asleep, safe. The next morning, I went to the bathroom and found Buster, dead and hanging from the shower head. On the mirror, written in blood, was: Humans can lick, too.

2. The Final Transmission

"Command, the alien ship is massive," I whispered into my helmet, staring at the iridescent hull of the thing that had been hunting us through the nebula. "It’s docking now. I’m closing the airlock." There was no reply from Earth, only silence. As the hatch sealed, I saw a reflection in the obsidian glass. I wasn't human. I was the creature, and I had just locked myself in with the last survivor.

3. The New Eyes

After the accident, I was blind. When they finally replaced my eyes with donor implants, I was overjoyed. The doctors said the adjustment period would be difficult. But it wasn't the blurry vision that scared me. It was that whenever I looked in the mirror, I didn't see my own face staring back. I saw a stranger, screaming.

4. The Last Page

I wrote the perfect mystery novel. The plot was foolproof, the killer hidden in plain sight. In the final chapter, the detective reveals that the victim was actually the mastermind, and the murderer was just a pawn. I smiled, closing my laptop. Then, I heard a knock at the door, and my spouse—the one I had modeled the detective on—walked in, holding a knife, and said, "I finally finished reading your draft".

5. Perfect Attendance

I had been the night guard at the orphanage for ten years. I knew every child's face, every quiet breath. That night, during my rounds, I found a little girl sitting in the hallway, looking pale. "You should be asleep, Sarah," I said gently. She looked up, her eyes empty. "But I died in the fire five years ago," she whispered. As I looked closer, I realized all the beds in the room were empty.

Posted Feb 05, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.