Holly McCulloch

Holly McCulloch – Editor

Editor with over 10 years experience, specialising in women's fiction, fantasy and romance. I love helping people tell their stories.

Overview

I am a huge believer in voices. Everyone's voice deserves to be heard. I want to help you shout from the rooftops (or from the bookshelves, whichever comes first).

Having previously worked in trade publishing (as a reader for Conville & Walsh Literary Agency and within fiction editorial for Headline Publishing Group), before moving across to work as a book buyer for the WHSmith bookshops within Harrods and Selfridges, I know what it takes to get published, what it takes to make your book stand out to retailers, and what it takes for your book to be picked up by the readers themselves.

I also know what it takes to be a writer. It can be a lonely road, one that is full of fog and confusing signs. But it doesn't have to be - I can help. I can make the road a little less lonely and a little less confusing.

Within fiction, my main areas of interest include: fantasy, women's fiction, and romance.

My freelance work mainly centres on providing editorial assessments and developmental edits.

Services
Fiction
Fantasy Romantic Fantasy Women's Fiction
Languages
English (UK)

Work experience

Self-employed

Nov, 2019 — Present
Freelance publishing guru and editor.

WHSmith Travel (Harrods and Selfridges Concessions)

Jan, 2013 — Apr, 2014 (about 1 year)
Book buyer for the Harrods and Selfridges bookshops, for both fiction and non-fiction titles, including special collections.

Headline Publishing Company

May, 2011 — Jan, 2012 (8 months)
Oversaw the production process for a large number of high-profile titles, from delivery of manuscript to final files; worked with bestselling authors including Victoria Hislop, Neil Gaiman and Jill Mansell; wrote cover copy and reading-group discussion guides.

Portfolio

For the Love of Beasts

Anser, Lucille

Lucille Anser

A Discovery of Witches (All Souls Series)

Harkness, Deborah

Penguin Books

Just My Luck

Parks, Adele

No. 1 bestselling author Jill Mansell writes with sensitivity and optimism about love, loss and new beginnings in TO THE MOON AND BACK. Not to be missed by readers of Jojo Moyes and Veronica Henry. 'Another super tale from a talented writer' Sun When Ellie Ken... read more
A WALK IN THE PARK is a Sunday Times bestseller by Jill Mansell, not to be missed by fans of Lucy Diamond and Milly Johnson. Reviewers love Jill's books: 'Glorious, heartwarming, romantic' Woman & HomeIt's been a while, but Lara Carson's back in Bath and lives... read more
The Island

Victoria Hislop

The acclaimed million-copy number one bestseller and winner of Richard & Judy's Summer Read 2006 from Victoria Hislop is a dramatic tale of four generations, rent by war, illicit love, violence and leprosy, from the thirties, through the war, to the present da... read more
The Thread

Victoria Hislop

The enthralling novel from the million-copy bestselling author of THE ISLAND and THE RETURN.Thessaloniki, 1917. As Dimitri Komninos is born, a devastating fire sweeps through the thriving Greek city where Christians, Jews and Muslims live side by side. Five ye... read more

Holly has 36 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Natanya J.

Natanya J.

May, 2025

Pinned
Holly will give your manuscript the most beautifully brutal treatment it needs! Having done several rounds of self-edits, and a round of Beta reading, I submitted my Romantasy manuscript for her treatment, and let's say - she has a gift for this! While it is hard to receive a report like this, wh...
Read more
Robin W.

Robin W.

Apr, 2025

Pinned
Holly's report and edit comments were absolutely spot on. Nobody likes having someone else point out the flaws in their creative work, but Holly did so with grace and panache. Every comment was right on the money, and the overall changes suggested will make my work far stronger. I would be very h...
Read more
Holly M.
Robin! Thank you so much for this lovely review! Really made my day / week! I hope the editing goes well, even if you have given me a fear of valleys. I will now always be watching out for an ambush.
Rebecca E.

Rebecca E.

Apr, 2025

Pinned
Holly has been absolutely phenomenal in bringing my book to life! She provided really great feedback through her development edit and truly made my story so much better. She was also just a joy to work with. I love how she not only provided great, thorough critiques, but she also provided positiv...
Read more
Holly M.
Thank you, Rebecca! I so loved your story! I can't wait to see what you do with it!
Jesse J.

Jesse J.

Dec, 2025

Holly has been fantastic through this process. She was a delight to communicate with, and her feedback was professional, astute, and will undoubtedly help me mold my project in the right direction. I plan to reach out again for the next draft or for any other projects.
Holly M.
Ah, I loved reading your book, Jesse. (And would happily re-read.) Not sure I agree with the 5 stars for professionalism, but I did enjoy working with you! Best of luck with the edits, and please r...
Read more
Megan P.

Megan P.

Nov, 2025

I worked with Holly to review and edit my query letter and synopsis. Holly was so responsive and kind! Her feedback on my query was detailed and well thought out. It was clear that she put a lot of thought into her revisions. She was also happy to answer any of my questions about the query proces...
Read more
Holly M.
Ah, it was my absolute pleasure, Megan! Best of luck with the querying!

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Holly and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Holly

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Kate Juniper

Kate J.

Intersectionally feminist, trauma-trained somatic book coach & editor of 15 years, empowering women+ to write their 🔥 novels, NF & memoirs.

Montreal, QC, Canada

100% reply rate

View profile
Victoria Straw

Victoria S.

All-area editor for ten years, trad and indie-pub. I'll want to help you. Romance & Women's Fiction specialist. Immediate starts available.

Reading, UK

100% reply rate

View profile
Emily Martin

Emily M.

Editor specializing in romance, fantasy, and YA, with experience editing NYT bestsellers. Author with Simon and Schuster + HarperCollins.

Boston, MA, USA

90% reply rate

View profile