Frances Gilbert

Frances Gilbert – Editor

Children's editorial director at a "big five" publisher, with 32 years of picture book experience. Author of ten published children's books.

Overview

As a children's editorial director with over thirty years of experience at major publishers, I bring an industry knowledge to editing that few other freelancers can offer. I'll help you get your picture book manuscript to the next level — not only in craft and creativity but also in strategic thinking to help it stand out in a crowded field.

I work across a wide range of picture book genres, including humor, rhyming, SEL, nonfiction, and lyrical/emotional.

Your path to publication is unique, so I'll tailor my editing and critique notes to where you are in the writing process and what your goals are — whether that’s a tidying-up copy edit, a careful line edit, or a deeper developmental edit with extensive notes for revision.

(Please upload your full manuscript so I can better review it for a quote.)

I'll provide both text edits and detailed guidance to strengthen elements such as pacing, characterization, phrasing, plot, pagination, and more.

My edits are grounded in a close, experienced reading of your manuscript — not hearsay or outdated "rules" — and reflect a deep understanding of today’s competitive picture book market.

I’ve had the privilege of editing books by beloved authors such as Tammi Sauer, Dev Petty, Mike Boldt, Annie Silvestro, Charlotte Offsay, and many more. I especially enjoy working with emerging writers, helping them develop a distinctive picture book style and authentic voice.

If you'd like to learn a bit more about my approach to children's books, head over to Reedsy's YouTube channel, where you'll find my seminar on picture book basics. I hope you find it useful!

* Note: As I work for a publisher, I must stress that hiring me on Reedsy does not give access to me as an acquiring editor at my work. At work, I only accept manuscripts on submission that come via agents.

Services
Fiction
Picture Books
Languages
English (UK) English (US)

Work experience

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Jun, 2012 — Present
I manage an imprint of picture books, publishing between 15-20 titles a year.

Sterling Publishing

Feb, 2000 — May, 2012 (about 12 years)
I set up the children's editorial department at Sterling, and grew it over the next twelve years to a large and diverse children's business, including board books, picture books, nonfiction, and activity books.

Scholastic Canada

Aug, 1996 — Feb, 2000 (over 3 years)
I acquired and purchased all titles for Scholastic Book Fairs across Canada.

Scholastic Canada

Feb, 1994 — Aug, 1996 (over 2 years)
I managed the Arrow Book Club for Scholastic Canada, acquiring and purchasing titles for ages 8-12.

Portfolio

The Baby Who Stayed Awake Forever

Salsbury, Sandra

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Bunny's Book Club

Silvestro, Annie

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Wordy Birdy

Sauer, Tammi

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Squash & Pumpkin: #SquashGoals

McQueen, G.G.

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
I Don't Want to Be a Frog

Petty, Dev

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Everything in Its Place: A Story of Books and Belonging

David-Sax, Pauline

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Duck Duck Taco Truck

Lavoie, Laura

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Eight Sweet Nights, A Festival of Lights: A Hanukkah Story

Offsay, Charlotte

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
The Passover Mouse

Nelkin Wieder, Joy

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
My Mom Is a Mermaid! (My Life is Weird)

Canterbury, Bill

Doubleday Books for Young Readers

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment

Frances has 94 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Claudia R.

Claudia R.

Dec, 2025

Pinned
I have worked before with Reedsy editors on a different writing project. Their editors have always been excellent professionals. However, Frances went above and beyond. She is a superb editor not only because of her excellent editing skills but for the manner in which she provides feedback to the...
Read more
Frances G.
Wow! Thank you for this wonderful review. It means a lot that you appreciated the focus on the writer's intent. I really enjoyed watching your story come into itself. I would be honored to be your ...
Read more
Stefanie C.

Stefanie C.

Oct, 2025

Pinned
I highly recommend Frances to anyone looking for an editor for children’s books. I’ve worked with two editors before, but Frances truly stood out for her deep picture-book expertise, constructive feedback, and thorough attention to detail. Her comments are always well-reasoned, helping me recogni...
Read more
Frances G.
It makes me so happy to read this! I'm thrilled that you've enjoyed our collaboration as much as I have. It's been so exciting seeing your stories come together, and I feel like I know your charact...
Read more
Julie M.

Julie M.

Oct, 2025

Pinned
If your looking for an editor who is extremely thorough, professional as well as friendly and funny, look no further. As a novice writer for children's picture books, It was a bit intimidationg to send my work off to someone so seasoned in the field. Frances treated me with great respect and kin...
Read more
Frances G.
Wow, what a truly lovely thing to say. I'm so glad you enjoyed our work together as much as I did. Thank you for this wonderful review. It was such a fun project.
Holly R.

Holly R.

Jan, 2026

I truly enjoyed working with Frances. Her feedback on my manuscript was thoughtful and concise. It was clear that she spent time mulling over the manuscript to provide constructive suggestions, as well as compliments where things worked. She also posed several questions that helped me look at the...
Read more
Frances G.
I'm so glad you enjoyed this project as much as I did. Your story was fascinating and gave me a lot to think about. I'd be most happy to work with you again, anytime.
N.J. A.

N.J. A.

Jan, 2026

Frances G. is stellar. I could not be more satisfied with having hired her. She’s professional, knowledgeable, and thorough. Her prices are reasonable, her responses fast, her instructions detailed. Absolutely top notch!
Frances G.
I really enjoyed our collaboration together - thank you so much!

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Frances and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Frances

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Sarah Jane Abbott

Sarah Jane A.

Experienced children's book editor who specializes in picture books, both fiction and non-fiction, sketch dummies, and middle grade novels.

New York, NY, USA

90% reply rate

View profile
JANE DE ROUSSAN

JANE D.

Former publisher with 35 yrs of editing kid's books and literary fiction in CA, UK, EU and US. I'd love to help you craft your next book!

Madison, Wisconsin, USA

95% reply rate

View profile
Sirah Jarocki

Sirah J.

Careful inspections, thorough explanations, and considerate guidance for inclusive picture books and middle grade novels.

Boston, MA, USA

100% reply rate

View profile