Fiction


Nathaniel Crane liked to think of himself as a man of purpose. He had always carried himself with a kind of quiet assurance, convincing others—and more importantly, himself—that his pursuits were noble. A philanthropist, an innovator, a benefactor of the arts. At least, that’s what he told the papers when they came calling.

But purpose has a way of growing shadows.

It began with a project: the development of a sprawling community center in his hometown, something that would bear his family’s name for generations. On the surface, it was charitable—a gift to the public. But underneath, Nathaniel’s motives were tangled. He wanted the recognition, the plaque, the speaking invitations, the subtle yet intoxicating worship of a crowd.

That night, as he sat alone in his study, he found himself staring at the architectural plans. The lines blurred, the neat squares of classrooms and libraries turning into something skeletal and cold. He realized his chest was tight.

“Why do I want this?” he whispered.

His wife, Marianne, had once asked the same question over dinner. She had a way of cutting through things. “Are you doing this for them, Nathaniel—or for you?”

He laughed it off at the time. But her voice returned now, echoing in the stillness of his study.

For weeks, Nathaniel pressed on. He called meetings, signed papers, and smiled for cameras. Yet a restlessness began to grow inside him. When he spoke at events, his words sounded hollow, rehearsed. He began to notice the way he sought the audience’s applause, lingering just a little too long in the spotlight, measuring his worth by the brightness of their smiles.

Then came the mirror.

It was a strange gift, sent anonymously. An old, gilded piece with a tarnished frame, delivered to his office without a note. At first, he assumed it was some eccentric donor’s attempt at a joke. He leaned it against the wall, not bothering to hang it.

But the mirror had a trick.

When Nathaniel looked into it one evening, exhausted from another round of public relations, he swore the reflection didn’t match him perfectly. The suit was the same, the thinning hair the same—but the eyes were different. In them, he saw hunger. A gnawing, desperate hunger.

He jerked back, his pulse racing.

“Too much whiskey,” he muttered, leaving the office. Yet the image clung to him, haunting him as he tried to sleep.

Over the next week, he tested it. By day, he would glance at the mirror, half in dread, half in curiosity. And always, those eyes—too sharp, too greedy, too calculating—looked back. The reflection smiled when he smiled, but the smile was crueler, thinner, less human.

He stopped telling himself it was imagination.

Instead, Nathaniel began to wonder: Was the mirror revealing something he had hidden even from himself?

One night, unable to resist, he asked aloud: “What do you want from me?”

The reflection leaned forward, though Nathaniel hadn’t moved. Its lips curved into a whisper that he didn’t hear with his ears but in his mind: “Truth.”

His throat dried. He set the mirror in the basement, covering it with a sheet. But truth, once glimpsed, cannot be forgotten.

Nathaniel started avoiding the project. He skipped meetings, leaving subordinates confused. He would sit in his car outside the nearly finished community center and stare at the construction. The banners bore his name in bold letters: THE CRANE CENTER FOR PROGRESS.

The words no longer stirred pride. They felt heavy, oppressive, wrong.

Marianne noticed. “You’ve been distant,” she said one evening as they cleared the table. “This center—it’s supposed to bring you joy. But you look miserable.”

He wanted to confess, but shame clamped his tongue. Instead, he said, “I’m just tired.”

That night, he couldn’t resist. He returned to the basement and pulled the sheet from the mirror.

The reflection sneered.

“You see it now,” it said. “You never wanted to help them. You wanted them to need you. To build a monument to your name.”

Nathaniel trembled. “No—I wanted… I wanted to give back—”

“Lies,” the reflection spat. “You wanted to own them. Their gratitude. Their dependence. Their applause.”

His knees buckled. He clutched the frame as if to steady himself. Deep down, he knew it was right. Every donation, every grand gesture, had been tainted with the same selfish undercurrent. He was not a benefactor. He was a collector—of admiration, of prestige, of control.

The realization was like ice water poured over his heart.

In the weeks that followed, Nathaniel changed. The construction finished, but he refused the ribbon-cutting ceremony. When reporters asked for comment, he gave them none. He withdrew from the board, signing the rights of the building over to the city.

Marianne asked why, but he only shook his head. How could he explain that he had been living with a false face, one even he hadn’t recognized until it sneered back at him from a mirror?

And yet, the mirror remained. He couldn’t bring himself to destroy it. Perhaps he needed it—a reminder of what lurked beneath the surface of intentions, a silent judge to keep him honest.

One evening, he stood before it again. The reflection’s eyes were still sharp, still hungry. But now, there was something else: sorrow.

Nathaniel whispered, “I see you. I won’t let you rule me anymore.”

For a moment, the reflection seemed to soften. It tilted its head, as though in reluctant acknowledgment.

Perhaps redemption was not about erasing the darkness, but recognizing it—naming it—so it could no longer work in secret.

Nathaniel left the basement with unsteady steps. He wasn’t sure who he was without the applause, without the grand gestures. But for the first time in years, he felt something like honesty.

And honesty, though small and fragile, felt like a beginning.

Nathaniel finally understood that the truest measure of intention lay not in what the world applauded, but in what the heart quietly knew. And though the hunger within him would never fully vanish, he had chosen, at last, not to feed it.

Posted Sep 26, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

7 likes 2 comments

Kate Torode
03:03 Oct 09, 2025

Beautiful, and tragically written. A truly insiteful piece

Reply

Julie Grenness
22:00 Oct 08, 2025

This tale portrays an inner angst, prompted by an inanimate object. The writer has admirably explored an inner journey of self-discovery and personal change. The theme and character chosen brilliantly respond to the challenging nature of the prompt. Overall, very well written with a keen writing talent.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.