Another day, whispering to my own thoughts, counting every step as if it might quiet the voice in my skull, the one that repeats, again and again, that I am too much, and that being too much is never enough in a world that prefers me silent. Silence, for me, was an utopy. Something I`ve never know in my 34 years of life. Silence was a privilege reserved for those blessed with an average mind, and average always sounded idyllic to me. Silence was romance, the soft echo of a laugh. Silence was understanding social rules without dissecting them. Silence was a mind that didn`t torture itself every second, a mind that didn`t trap me on the outside of society`s rules.
I lived alone in a very comfortable apartament in the center of Copenhagen. Very fancy, very clean, yet unbearably loud inside my head. Surrounded by silence, but never truly alone.
It was a regular night; I couldn`t continue reading my favorite book by Kafka. Kafka was like a massive sound system for the voice in my head, amplifying the noise and shrinking any possibility I had of passing among the silent ones. I didn`t read Kafka because I wanted to look like an intellectual snob. I read him because he understood my pain, he was broken like me, and he never lived in silence. Maybe it was just another way to torture myself, to punish myself for being like him and never trying to change it, letting his words pull me deeper into my own noise.
It was almost midnight, three minutes before the clock could announce, with cruel precision, the state of my social life. Three minutes before 00:00, when the world resets without me. And then, as if some warped magic had slipped through the cracks of my apartment walls, I heard a knock at the door.
Magical, because no one ever knocks for the noisy woman who reads Kafka and treats Dante`s Inferno like a romance. No one seeks out the mind that can’t quiet itself. No one ever seeks me out. No one ever knocks for the woman whose screams louder than the city beneath her window.
So, whoever or whatever stood behind that door wasn`t looking for company.
It was looking for me.
And i had the sickening feeling it came to offer exactly what I`ve begged for my whole life: silence... and the chance to be ordinary. The knock came again, slower this time, almost patient. I opened the door, only a crack, just enough to convince myself there was nothing there.
But something was there.
A silhoutte, tall and wrong, as if someone had sketched a human shape from memory and forgotten a few details, like my draws in the middle school. Its presence felt heavier than its body, pressing against my thoughts, thinning the noise in my head just by existing.
For the first time in my life, the voices went quiet, not calm... quiet.
" May I come in?" it asked.
The voice wasn`t deep or monstrous; it was gentle, unbearably gentle, like someone imitating compassion after studying it in a textbook.
It sounded like the kind of voice an average mind might trust.
It sounded like the kind of voice an average mind might trust. And if people like that would trust it, then maybe this way was my only chance, my one chance to feel, even for a single day, what it`s like to be okay, to slip quietly into the norm. I let it in. I forced a smile, the kind quiet people wear so effortlessly, and said, " You`re welcome to come in." It looked at me with something close to amusement and replied, " You don’t need to pretend with me. I know exactly what you are."
What was I? Noise trapped inside my own torture chamber? My mind as a chaotic, screaming prison? I knew that to some people I was a menace; they said I was too smart, too creative, too much. I hated hearing it, so I never thought too deeply about how to describe what I was. I only knew one thing : I was not one of the quiet ones.
As it stepped fully into my apartment, it whispered in the smoothest voice, "Yes thats what you are. And I can turn off that noise you can never stop."
" I can hear you, darling. And don`t worry I could also hear that man who could never silence himself, the one who thought becoming an insect migth finally make him quiet."
The creatur moved through my apartment with a strange familiarity, as if it had lived here long before I ever signed the lease. It touched my books with a certain reverence, especially the ones that had hurt me the most.
"You think your problem is the noise," it murmured. " But the noise is just the price of a dangerous gift." I frowned, "Gift? this?" I tapped my temple. " This is torture."
The creature smiled gently, like someone preparing to comfort a child before taking something precious away.
"Oh darling... your mind isn`t broken, it`s overflowing, people like you never stop creating, imagining, rearranging reality. And creativity, in excess becomes noise."
It turned to face me fully, in the dim light its shape flickered, sometimes human, sometimes a shadow wearing skin.
" I have a proposition," it said. "I can quiet the noise, completely. I can make you average, normal, peaceful."
Its smile widened.
" All you must give me is the part of you that makes the noise in the first place."
I swallowed, "My mind?"
"No" it tapped my forehead lightly, almost affectionately.
"Your creativity."
The room seemed to tilt for a moment, I thought of Kafka, of Dante, of every story that had ever held my broken pieces together.
I thought of the notebooks filled with half - finished ideas, metaphors about insects and hell and cities that screamed louder than I did.
"What happens to it?" I asked.
"I keep it, I nurture it. I use it. I give it a home where it won`t torment you anymore," it said.
That creature stepped closer, and the edges of its smile trembled with hunger.
"Imagine it," it whispered. "A mind without noise. A life where you sleep, where you smile and it isn`t forced, where your thoughts don’t tear at you from the inside.
You`ll wake up quiet.
You`ll wake up normal."
My heart clenched painfully.
Quiet.
Normal.
Average.
Everything I had ever envied.
"And I...?" I asked . "What do I become?"
"Content," It answered simply.
"You will be content."
It extended its hand to me, elegant, almost human. Behind it, I felt the books tremble on their shelves, as if they knew they were about to lose me.
"Give me your creativity," the demon whispered, " and I will give you silence."
I took its hand, the moment our skin met, my mind cracked open, not in violence, but in relief.
Something warm slipped out of me. A pulse, a spark, a thread of light pulling itself free from behind my eyes.
My creativity.
My noise.
My everything.
It left so easily, as if it had been waiting at the door.
The demon inhaled sharply, like someone tasting a rare perfume.
Its eyes fluttered closed in pleasure. Then, silence.
My head became a clean, white room.
No echoes.
No storm.
No voice telling me I was too much.
For the first time in thirty - four years, I was quiet. I smiled, a real smile, soft, simple and empty smile. The kind of smile average people wear without thinking.
The creature bowed politely, as if our transaction had been nothing more than signing a lease and slipped out into the night with my creativity cupped in its hands like a newborn flame.
And I ...lived.
Peacefully.
Effortlessly.
A perfect average.
Months later, a friend who I could make thanks to the quite new me, Handed me a book.
"Have you seen this?2 she asked. "It’s everywhere, they`re calling this author a genius."
I looked at the cover.
The title was one of my old phrases, one I had whispered to myself on sleepless nights.
The author`s name was unfamiliar, but the writing... the writing creative soul was mine.
Every line, every metaphor, every broken thought stiched into poetry. My noise cleaned and weaponized into brilliance.
I read page after page, waiting for something inside me to recognize itself.
Nothing did, but my hands began trembling.
Not with emotions, I didn`t have those anymore, but with something colder.
The kind of instinct a body has even after the spirit has been wiped clean. I closed the book.
That night, as I went to sleep in my perfeclty quiet mind, I heard something faint.
A whisper.
Not from inside me like my old noise, from outside, pressed against the window.
A familiar voice, dripping with satisfaction:
"Thank you darling, you were right, your noise was too much, your noise was exquisite."
The whisper grew louder, shaping itself into words from my missing mind:
"Shall I come to visit you tomorrow?"
And at that moment I realized... The silence in my head wasn`t peace, it was vacancy.
And the demon wasn`t gone, it was just getting started.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Gaby, what a beautifully told story.. the tug of war in the mind. Masterfully crafted. Well done.
Reply
Thank thank you very Much, i appreciate it so much when people can understand and see the battles and the struggles of my neurodivergent brain, thank you for this compliment
Reply
This story really touched my heart. Thank you <3
Reply
Thank you so much… not more horror that the pain of those who feel the world doesn’t understand the way we perceive things and ourselves thank you so much
Reply
Beautiful ❤️ Very relatable, I've had that kind of visit but I'm honestly afraid of lose myself, even if I'm too much for most people, the demon keeps telling me that he would use my creativity better than me, but I don't care, I end up rejecting his offer every time.
I love you, don't let them dime your soul 😘❤️
Reply
Until now , I still saying no to them , love you too
Reply
Como siempre me haces llorar, no dejes de escribir por favor 😭
Reply
Te amo
Reply
I often wondered what being too much would feel like, as I think I had the opposite problem -never being enough, for some people. But in the end, I am just enough for me. Really like your story and understand the pull of a trade-off. Glad I never tangled with a demon over it.
Reply
For me, being “too much” comes from living in a world that keeps telling me I’m not how a human is supposed to be yet, at the same time, it dismisses my diagnoses because I don’t fit the cliché of what society imagines autism should look like. It’s a strange place to exist: always “not enough” for their expectations and “too much” for their comfort.
Reply
An excellent way to describe it.
Reply
thank you very much
Reply
Great story Gaby. The only thing I am dying to ask is - what's a utopy?
Reply
Hi Rebecca and thank you very much. Everyone imagines utopia as a perfect society.
But I learned that utopia just means one thing:
a world where difference isn’t treated like a disease that needs a cure.
Reply
OK, so it's a typo! Top marks for writing a brilliant story that is not in your given language, but you need to type that word right in your first paragraph!
And I agree about difference. I suppose the simple question is, what is normal?
Reply
Yes it was xd, English is not my mother language
Reply
You’re just amazing ✨
Reply
awww thank you honey
Reply
I loved the chill of your story. Anything demon, alien, dark—love it.
Awe, this part broke my heart: “ Behind it, I felt the books tremble on their shelves, as if they knew they were about to lose me.” It’s like giving away your children.
My only critique is just a light edit. Otherwise, well done. 🖤✨
Reply
Thank you very much
Reply
Exceptional story! You have a great narrative tone and the story flows very smooth. Highly introspective and personal with a genuine ring of truth. Really well done. Keep writing! I want more!
I have never written anything Kafkaesque but if you like Dante's Inferno I put this one out recently: https://reedsy.com/short-story/w0iufi/
Reply
Thank you so much 🥰🥰🥰
Reply
I really love how you've turned an inner moral quander to a sinister horror, turning the concept of selling your soul to the devil but for a neuro divergent person's version of selling what makes them unique for the sake of fitting into normality (I know I can relate sometimes). This is a really fascinating and unique take on this hypothetical, and it made for both a great horror and psychological horror too!
(On a side note, you might want to correct this small typo: "becoming an insect migth finally make him quiet.")
Reply
Thank you very much 🥰🥰 English is not my mother language so I’m very happy of any kind of correction
Reply
Honestly would never have guessed since you write so elegantly, more than most native speakers
Reply
Maybe is my creative who makes that noise , sometimes I want to sell it, sometimes makes me feel safe 🌻🌻🥰🥰
Reply
I liked your story.
I have a question. "No one ever seeks me out." how come the character doesn't seek people out?
also it's minor but I would like to know more about Copenhagen. I know to most people on Reedsy it's mundane but to someone like me that's never had chance to go to Europe it's an exotic foreign land.
I hope you have a great day.
Reply
Hi Frank , as an autistic person I isolate myself in my own mind a lot , and maybe people seeks me out , but I never really noticed or maybe I just ignored , I give to her that part of me , that’s the reason ☺️next story I can explain more how looks my little Denmark 🇩🇰
Reply
Thank you for the feedback. I to have autism guess my is very different than yours.
Ha’ en rigtig god dag
Reply
Tak I lige måde
Reply