Amy Spalding

Amy Spalding – Editor

I'm a bestselling author who loves working with other writers to level up their manuscripts. Honest but a cheerleader!

Overview

A note that I am extremely anti-AI and don't want to work with anyone who's used it anywhere in the process. If that's you, another editor will be a better fit for you. And also I ask you to consider, next time, the joy and accomplishment of using your own brain for each and every part, to dive into research instead of trusting a robot, to struggle with your outline instead of handing it off to technology that seeks to smooth out our discourse into the same voice over and over again. Thank you!

Onto business:

Are you a new writer with a brand new manuscript?

Are you getting ready to query agents but don't think you're quite there yet?

Have you had no luck querying agents and want to take another look at your manuscript?

Do you already have an agent but want more feedback before your book goes out on (gulp) submission?

Do you just work better when someone's working with you?

​

Here's what I bring to the party:

​

Eye on character development: growth, consistency, relatability

Thoughts on voice in your work and how to make it as strong as possible

Overall themes and how to bring them out

Help in structure/pacing/story -- all that stuff that makes a book a book

Heightening and highlighting comedic elements in your book (if that's what you're wanting to do!)

Big focus on real emotional reactions; finding "reality" in heightened narratives

Optimistic, encouraging, super reachable, still honest. I am your biggest cheerleader but I'll also call out anything I think could be stronger.

"Amy doesn't just provide feedback in the most encouraging way possible; she gives specific ideas for how to fix what's not working, which makes her observations invaluable. My manuscripts are always stronger after I've gotten Amy's insightful reactions!"

-Developmental Editing Package Client

"As a first-time author, I knew I needed help with my manuscript but wasn't sure where to start. I am so thankful to have found Amy. I appreciate that she took the time to talk to me about my book and what help I was looking for and based on that conversation, she recommended a developmental edit. Her suggestions were spot on and delivered in an incredibly timely manner. More importantly, her feedback was thoughtful, thorough, and kind and I always felt like she was on my team."

-Jenn Smith, Developmental Editing Package Client

"I enjoyed working with Amy very much. She really helped me figure out what my book was missing and how best to move forward. She gave me great insights and valuable ideas on how to work through some of the hurdles. She is invaluable and I look forward to working with her again for the rest of my books. Sheesh...I sound so dry. Look, she's fabulous and I would be lost without her! "

-Julia Heart, Developmental Editing Client

Services
Fiction
Coming of Age Contemporary Fiction Contemporary Romance LGBTQ Fiction Romantic Comedy Young Adult
Languages
English (US)
Awards
  • HRC Visibility Award
Certifications
  • Masters, Media Studies (The New School)

Work experience

Self-employed

Jan, 2013 — Present
I work with clients (and friends and fellow authors) on a freelance basis to provide editorial services, including developmental edits, editorial assessments, and query packages (letters, synopses, first pages) across a variety of genres, but specializing in contemporary young adult and contemporary romance/romcom, particularly LGBTQ+ fiction, but not limited to.

Portfolio

Developmental Editing
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
The Wedding Date

Guillory, Jasmine

Editorial Assessment
The Art of Wishing

Ribar, Lindsay

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Sister of the Bride

Morrill, Lauren

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Catch the Light

Sweeney, Kate

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Cover Story

Gomez, Valerie

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment

Amy has 7 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Kate W.

Kate W.

Sep, 2026

Amy was amazing. Her feedback was so insight and astute, and I had so much fun talking to her. Highly recommend for anyone looking for an editor with a great sense of humor.
Dhiandra T.

Dhiandra T.

Sep, 2026

Amy was so helpful and collaborative. She's quick and efficient with her edits (funny too!). Thanks to her I know exactly what my book needs.
Amy S.
Thank you so much, Dhiandra!! (You are extremely funny too!!)
Glenn S.

Glenn S.

Aug, 2026

This was my second time working with Amy, and once again I found her feedback thoughtful, perceptive, and extremely useful. Having worked with her before, I knew I could trust her to identify places where the manuscript needed more depth or clarity while respecting what I was trying to accomplish...
Read more
Glenn S.

Glenn S.

Apr, 2026

Amy provided a thorough editorial assessment with many insightful and practical notes. Her feedback was clear, constructive, and immediately useful, helping me see both strengths and areas for improvement. She was professional, responsive, and delivered everything on time. I highly recommend her.
Pamela B. L.

Pamela B. L.

Nov, 2025

Amy knew I was a first-time writer and she took time to temper her suggestions as such. She also provided useful links to resources. She was great to work with, and her remarks helped me understand where I needed improvement.
Amy S.
Thank you so much, Pamela! I was so impressed by your work as a first-time writer, and I hope you're inspired to take your work to the next level (and also bake more delicious things).

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Amy and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Amy

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Hilari C.

I am a sharp-eyed, award winning editor with over thirty years in the romance industry. I'll help you tell your story and find your readers!

Glen Head, NY, USA

100% reply rate

View profile

Rosie W.

Copy editor, proofreader, and book coach who has worked with Hachette and HarperCollins. Specialises in psych thrillers and women's fiction.

Edinburgh, UK

100% reply rate

View profile

Dana C.

Editor with more than 12 years experience working with authors to craft award-winning bestsellers at Penguin Random House and Macmillan

New York, NY, USA

100% reply rate

View profile