Sydney Weinberg

Sydney Weinberg – Editor

Perceptive editor of novels and memoirs. With 9+ years experience, I'll help you hone your voice and shape your narrative.


As an acute reader and experienced editor of literary fiction, commercial fiction and narrative non-fiction, I can help you find the authentic contours of your novel, memoir or short story. My editorial approach is detailed, insightful and attentive, guided by established craft techniques but primarily responsive to your individual voice and vision. With a multicultural background and additional experience in literary translation, I bring sensitivity and precision to all my projects.

I primarily offer developmental edits and manuscript assessments. My written reports are longer and more detailed than the industry standard; my goal is not just to improve the work before me, but to give my clients tools to become better writers. I'm very open to discussing your expectations and questions, and I will always include sample edits or excerpts from past work in my offers, so you can see what I do.

Feedback from Past Collaborations:

"I couldn't have dreamed of a better reader. You unlocked a lot for me in the story. Thank you so much for taking my work seriously and sharing your knowledge. Your notes and comments have been brilliant - so professional and thorough. I'm really over the moon and I have you to thank, I couldn't have done it without."
-- Peter McNamara, author of 'The New Place', second place in RTÉ Radio 1 Francis MacManus Short Story Competition (2018)

"I am so lucky to have you. This is perfect. It's been moving, really, to read a fresh response in real-time and this helped to centre me profoundly in respect of this book. You are such a great reader, I am incredibly grateful. You've sent me into a tailspin of realisations and about two months' more work at the very least but it will be a much, much better book.'
-- Niamh Campbell, author of 'This Happy' and winner of the Sunday Times Audible Short Story Award (2020)

Biographies & Memoirs
Chick Lit Contemporary Fiction Cultural & Ethnic Literary Fiction Post-Apocalyptic Psychological Thriller Short Story
English (UK) English (US)
  • Longlisted for the Deborah Rogers Foundation Award 2020
  • Shortlisted for the Bridport Prize 2020
  • Highly commended in the Stack Magazine Awards for Best Original Fiction 2018
  • Awarded Literature Bursary by the Irish Arts Council, 2018
  • Irish Arts Council Agility Award 2022
  • Shortlisted for the Bridport Prize 2022
  • BA in Creative Writing from Florida State University
  • MSc in Literature and Transatlanticism from the University of Edinburgh

Work experience


Jan, 2014 — Present

Dalkey Archive Press

Jul, 2013 — Jan, 2014 (6 months)

Sydney has 34 reviews





Andrew C.

Andrew C.

May, 2024

Sydney provided me with a thoughtful feedback and actionable analysis of my short story. It was abundantly clear the amount of time and attention that she gave my writing.
Dyson C.

Dyson C.

May, 2024

Sydney is incredibly professional and thorough, providing lots of insights on what needs to be addressed as well as giving tips on how to address such issues. Plus it's for a rate that wasn't prohibitively expensive. Very happy and very impressed with the valuable criticisms!
james G.

james G.

Apr, 2024

I'm am overwhelmed by the detail of the edit by Sydney. She was spot on about everything- things that are strong and things that are weak. Much to do. I would use Sydney again without hesitation. jim
Alex P.

Alex P.

Apr, 2024

Sydney was an absolute pleasure to work with! And I give my complete recommendation to anybody thinking of reaching out to her. The quality of the feedback was just brilliant. It was thorough, it was kind and understanding, but, especially, it was honest and useful. My feedback came with detailed notes attached to my short story, but also with an 8 page report that highlighted what worked, wha...
Read more
Justice O.

Justice O.

Feb, 2024

Sydney's developmental edit of my manuscript was staggering. This is the first time I've ever worked with a professional editor and the first time I've ever had professional feedback on one of my manuscripts. Sydney was very understanding, giving me insight into how the editing process works and helping me understand what exactly my manuscript needed. I went into this process knowing that I had...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Sydney and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Sydney

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Carrie Wicks

Carrie W.

Seasoned copyeditor/proofreader with a passion for cleaning up copy, focusing on fiction or nonfiction: art books, cookbooks, and memoirs.

Seattle, WA, USA

100% reply rate

View profile
Lottie Hayes-Clemens

Lottie H.

Editor and proofreader with 3+ years' experience at HarperCollins and an expert eye for detail! Keen on women's fiction and fantasy.

Montreal, QC, Canada

97% reply rate

View profile
Jennifer Hoffner

Jennifer H.

I'm a copy editor specializing in health and memoirs. I've worked with Men's Health, Hearst, HarperCollins, Simon & Schuster, and more.

Allentown, PA, USA

100% reply rate

View profile