Jonathan Starke

Jonathan Starke – Editor

I've spent 20 years editing debuts and bestsellers for traditional and self-published authors, as well as thoughtful agent queries.

Overview

I'm an award-winning author with 20 years of editing and publishing experience specializing in copy editing, proofreading, and agent query packages. I've edited hundreds of manuscripts from writers at all different stages (debuts to seasoned authors) and helped them develop successful submission packages. My clients have signed with top-tier agents and publishers (HarperCollins, Penguin, Simon and Schuster, Macmillan), become bestsellers (award-winning novel The Boat Runner), and earned multiple number-one spots on the Amazon charts (Nocturnal Admissions: Behind the Scenes at Legendary Nightclubs).

GENRES:

Thriller, Sci-Fi, Mystery, Action and Adventure, Literary, Historical Fiction, Memoir.

WHAT TO EXPECT:

Clear Communication: An initial message to discuss your project. Feel free to ask questions throughout the process; I'm quick to respond.

Thoughtful Editing: I clean, tighten, and proofread your manuscript offering editorial comments and "reader reactions" to the work.

Industry Standards: All edits are completed using Chicago Manual of Style and Merriam-Webster's dictionary.

Targeted Submissions: Specialized editing to bolster your query, synopsis, and sample pages for agents and publishers.

Clean Delivery: You will receive two copies of your manuscript—one with all tracked changes visible and one clean version ready for formatting.

TESTIMONIALS:

• "Hiring Jonathan was the best writing-related decision I ever made. He reads all my work before I send it out, helped me sell my first novel, place dozens of stories in top-tier journals, and guided my writing to new depths." -- Dr. Devin Murphy, bestselling author of The Boat Runner

• "Jonathan helped raise my novel to a prizewinner with his skilled line and copy editing abilities." -- D. E. Lee, author of The Sky After Rain (prizewinner)

ABOUT ME:

Beyond the desk, I'm a former bodybuilder and boxer who loves traveling through Europe, crafting handmade soap, thrifting, and volunteering.

Services
Fiction
Action & Adventure Cozy Mysteries Dystopian Historical Fiction Literary Fiction Psychological Thriller
Non-Fiction
Biographies & Memoirs
Languages
English (US)
Awards
  • Black Heron Press Award for Social Fiction
Certifications
  • MFA in Creative Writing - Fiction
  • MFA in Creative Writing - Nonfiction
  • BA in English and Fiction Writing

Work experience

Self-employed

Jan, 2005 — Present
For 20 years I've offered professional editorial services including copy edits, proofreading, line edits, critiques, and helped authors query agents and publishers. I happily work in a range of genres: literary, action and adventure, thriller, mystery, and memoir.

Palooka Magazine and Palooka Press

Jan, 2010 — Present
Through Palooka and Palooka Press I've evaluated over 16,000 manuscripts, including fiction, nonfiction, poetry, drama, and graphic narratives. I founded this literary magazine and press 16 years ago to create a space for writers and artists to have a truly fair shot at publication and the chance to be seen, read, and recognized without connections or prejudice.

Portfolio

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment Proofreading Query Letter Review
Freeing Nicole: A twisty whodunit

Maughan, D.J.

Hulyeseg Inc

Copy Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Proofreading Book Coaching
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Editorial Assessment Proofreading Query Letter Review
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Lose Yourself

Wetzel, Vince

OT Press

Copy Editing Proofreading
Friends in Low Places

Wetzel, Vince

Vincent Wetzel

Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading Query Letter Review
Copy Editing Proofreading Query Letter Review
The Penny Thief

Paul, Christophe

Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment Proofreading Query Letter Review
Mother of Invention

Wolfson Widger, Caeli

Copy Editing Proofreading Query Letter Review
Copy Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment Proofreading Query Letter Review
Copy Editing Proofreading

Jonathan has 103 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Dany T.

Dany T.

Feb, 2026

Pinned
I had an amazing experience working with Jonathan. He went far beyond what I expected, not only delivering a thorough, high‑quality proofread, but also offering insightful notes throughout my entire manuscript. His feedback was thoughtful, clear, and genuinely helpful. He was incredibly responsiv...
Read more
Jonathan S.
Thanks so much for your very kind words, Dany! Looking forward to helping with your next one too.
Brian W.

Brian W.

Feb, 2026

Pinned
Jonathan Starke is an awesome find: very professional, experienced and encouraging the entire time. I feel like I'm in a giant learning curve and Jonathan was patient with me all the way through, even sharing in my humor over everything. His review and edits to my query letter were spot on, he co...
Read more
Jonathan S.
Thanks so much for your kind review, Brian! Good luck with your query letter. I look forward to working with you again.
Steve P.

Steve P.

Feb, 2026

Pinned
Working with Jonathan was an outstanding experience from start to finish. He delivered the project ahead of schedule, kept me updated throughout the process, and went well beyond what I originally hired him for. His attention to detail, professionalism, and thoughtful engagement with the manuscri...
Read more
Jonathan S.
Thanks for your kind review, Steve! I enjoyed working with you and am wishing you success with Sam's story!
Kara W.

Kara W.

Jul, 2026

I really appreciated his feedback with regard to shaping my query and synopses!
Jonathan S.
Thanks, Kara! I'm hoping the best for you and your novel!
Mary C.

Mary C.

Jul, 2026

Jonathan was a pleasure to work with. He completed the project ahead of schedule, was very responsive, and also added helpful comments. Highly recommended.
Jonathan S.
Thanks so much for the kind review, Mary! I look forward to working with you again.

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Jonathan and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Jonathan

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Sharon U.

Literary and contemporary fiction editor previously with Big 5 and imprints—Penguin Random House, Plume, Dutton, DAW. All genres considered.

Hawaii

100% reply rate

View profile

Anne M.

Visionary editor with a focus on literary fiction and expertise in literary magazines and independent publishing.

Croton-on-Hudson, NY, USA

100% reply rate

View profile

Toby S.

Fiction copyeditor and proofreader, with nearly two decades' experience working with Big 5 publishers, small presses and indie authors.

Birmingham, UK

100% reply rate

View profile