Sara Oestreich

Sara Oestreich – Editor

An experienced editor of over a decade (indie & trad). I am supportive, creative, and always honest! Female-driven stories are my favorite.

Overview

I have been in love with love since I first snuck a Harlequin novel off my grandmother's shelf. As a lifelong reader and writer, my favorite aspect of the creative process has always been editing—transforming a well-crafted tale and polishing it until it shines.

I specialize as a developmental editor across ALL romance genres. My passion (in addition to tall, dark, and handsome) lies in nurturing strong narratives. I focus on aligned goals, motivations, conflicts, and character-driven plots. I take pride in never skipping a "beat" in a story, ensuring that each rhythm resonates. The authors I work with often note that my eye for detail and honest feedback reinvigorate their passion for working on their stories.

Services I Offer:

Developmental Editing: Three comprehensive feedback rounds, complete with overarching notes, chapter-level, and in-text comments.

Editorial Assessment: One round of feedback featuring an overarching note along with chapter-level comments.

Guided Beta Reading: Assistance in sourcing beta readers, crafting a custom feedback questionnaire for your manuscript, and one feedback round to help integrate edits.

I am responsive and open in my communication. I have been told that I thrive during the editing process, taking a book to the next level. I enjoy collaborating and using questions to advance the story. I believe in helping the author find their voice rather than imposing my own ideas onto the story. It's not my story -- it's yours!

I look forward to helping you make your book the best it can be. Please let me know if you have any questions regarding my work and/or experience.

_______________________________________________

What others say:

"She was prompt, honest, clever, flexible, communicative, clear, kind and so generous with her time, and I had total confidence in her assessment of my work’s strengths and weaknesses. As a new author I was very apprehensive and naïve and Sara taught me so much."

"I can't say enough about Sara! She was prompt and thorough through all rounds of the developmental edit and coaxed a more compelling story out of my project than I dared hope. She has an exquisite eye for detail - the look, the feel, the sound, and flavor of the whole piece of writing that make it sing."

"Sara offered thoughtful feedback on the structure and flow of the narrative and helped bring out the best of my writing. I appreciated her constructive criticism, which pushed me to refine my ideas and strengthen my storytelling. I highly recommend Sara to any author seeking a professional and insightful editor who is committed to elevating the quality of their work. Her expertise, combined with her approachable and collaborative nature, make her an invaluable asset to any writer looking to polish their manuscript."

Services
Fiction
Chick Lit Contemporary Fiction Contemporary Romance Fantasy Paranormal Romance Romantic Comedy Romantic Suspense
Languages
English (AUS) English (CAN) English (UK) English (US)

Work experience

Special Fiction Books

Jan, 2022 — Present
I developmental edit books from start to finish. I begin by offering feedback on concepts based on market trends and a solid foundation for romantic conflict and tension. Then I edit the outline ensuring the book is romance-forward and that all of the story beats are accounted for. I find the outline stage to be important - if I can catch a plot hole or unlikeable character at this stage it won't be baked into the book! Finally, I edit the written book offering feedback to stay true to the heart of the book's story.

Bickerstaff Publishing

Mar, 2017 — Oct, 2022 (over 5 years)
I worked as an editor during the outline and writing stages. Stories were focused on evergreen trope driven romance and market trends. Feedback was collaborative in nature.

Relay Publishing

Apr, 2016 — Present
I have worked for Relay in a number of capacities: Outliner, Concept Creation, and Editor. I feel that experiencing each role has given me a unique insight into each step of the story creation process. My work with Relay includes editing at the outline and writing levels.

Sara has 75 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Lora O.

Lora O.

Mar, 2026

Pinned
You cannot do better than Sara, so don't bother trying! I initially chose to work with her because she was the only editor who showed actual excitement for my project, and that was a choice well made. Sara is genuinely passionate about your story, your characters, and her work as an editor. She t...
Read more
Leisa H.

Leisa H.

Jul, 2024

Pinned
This was my second time working with Sara and she was just as fabulous. She was direct, kind, thorough, thoughtful, and responsive. This fantasy romance book is a THOUSAND times better than when she first took a look. She works some serious magic, let me tell you. My favorite part about working w...
Read more
Doreen B.

Doreen B.

Apr, 2024

Pinned
I can't say enough about Sara! She was prompt and thorough through all rounds of the developmental edit and coaxed a more compelling story out of my project than I dared hope. She has an exquisite eye for detail - the look, the feel, the sound, and flavor of the whole piece of writing that make i...
Read more
Dayna J.

Dayna J.

Jun, 2026

This is my second time working with Sara, and I cannot say enough good things about her. She is communicative, professional, and easy to work with. More than that, though, she puts so much thought into the story, which helps flesh out the plot, the characters' motivations, and the emotional depth...
Read more
Nick M.

Nick M.

Jun, 2026

Working with Sara was an absolutely wonderful experience. She approached my novel with care, professionalism, and a deep understanding of story, character, and emotional impact. From the beginning, she respected the heart of the book while also helping me see where it could become stronger. Her ...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Sara and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Sara

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Joy H.

Fiction & memoir editor for heart-centered manuscripts (clients include Penguin, Simon and Schuster, Macmillan, Hachette). No AI, please!

Grenoble, France

100% reply rate

View profile

Lucy B.

Romance, Fantasy & commercial fiction editor with 6 years experience at a Big Five publisher, working with NY & Sunday Times bestsellers.

London, UK

100% reply rate

View profile

Bob P.

35 year publishing veteran available for editorial assessment, manuscript evaluation, developmental editing, query advice.

Wilton Manors, FL, USA

100% reply rate

View profile