Karen Robinson - Editor
Experienced copy editor of fantasy, dystopian, paranormal, and speculative fiction. Specializes in working with indie authors.
Request a quote
Verified identity
Overview
I'm an experienced copy editor specializing in working with indie authors, especially within the genres of fantasy, dystopian, paranormal, and speculative fiction.
First and foremost, I am the editor, not the writer. My goal while editing is not to rewrite your work into something that I would write. Instead, I aim for a cleaner version of what you’ve written—the best version of itself, not my version.
I have a solid background in grammar. I know the rules. I understand the rules. I also know how and when to break them. I’m not going to be pedantic and insist on a change just for the sake of correctness if it is going to cause a problem with readability. Fiction is flexible—sometimes sentence fragments are useful, for example.
As a copy editor, I am focused on the details of the story—the sentence-level concerns. Although I do check for consistency (making sure Sally doesn’t suddenly change eye color, for example), I don’t make global comments about your book. I’m not going to give you a list of plot problems or places where characters/scenes should be more developed. That’s the job of a developmental editor (and something that should be done before sending the manuscript to me). If there’s something that really jumps out at me, I sometimes make a comment about it, but I’m not reading your book at that level. If that’s the kind of feedback you are looking for, please work with a developmental editor first. Then come back and let me clean things up at the sentence level.
But don’t take it from me. Here’s what a couple of the authors I’ve worked with have to say:
“In the course of a long career writing analytic reports and technical monographs, I became well acquainted with professional editors. Taking up writing fiction a few years ago, I had difficultly finding an editor who could satisfy my requirements, and so released three novels that were largely self-edited. Recently, a fellow author recommended Karen, and I could not be happier. She is responsive, diligent, meticulous without being overbearing, and affordable. Most importantly, she has a fine feeling for a writer’s style. In the past, I have had to ‘train’ editors to not attempt to reduce my writing to their notion of acceptable ‘lowest common denominator’ verbiage, which has generally not been a congenial exercise. Imagine, therefore, my delight that there was none of this with Karen. From the first, her suggestions enhanced the writing without altering the voice — a rare and wonderful thing in my experience. I recommend her services without reservation and look forward to working with her again in the future.”
~ Owen O’Neill, co-author of the Loralynn Kennakris series
“Look no further for the perfect editor. I initially chose Karen to edit my YA fantasy novel given her impressive education, skill sets, and that she had edited similar books. From our very first interaction, Karen demonstrated a strong, passionate editing philosophy and I immediately felt comfortable working with her. She made many skilled observations that allowed me to polish my novel without changing my voice, which is something of utmost importance to an author. Karen goes above and beyond the scope of an ordinary editor because she possesses a genuine interest in her client’s projects and wants to see them succeed. I highly recommend her and I can’t wait to work with her again.”
~ Amie Irene Winters, author of Strange Luck
Note: I provide line editing, copy editing, and proofreading. If you are looking for a developmental edit or editorial assessment, that comes before the copy editing stage and is not a service I provide. Check out Reedsy's description of the different types of editors: https://blog.reedsy.com/types-of-editing/.
First and foremost, I am the editor, not the writer. My goal while editing is not to rewrite your work into something that I would write. Instead, I aim for a cleaner version of what you’ve written—the best version of itself, not my version.
I have a solid background in grammar. I know the rules. I understand the rules. I also know how and when to break them. I’m not going to be pedantic and insist on a change just for the sake of correctness if it is going to cause a problem with readability. Fiction is flexible—sometimes sentence fragments are useful, for example.
As a copy editor, I am focused on the details of the story—the sentence-level concerns. Although I do check for consistency (making sure Sally doesn’t suddenly change eye color, for example), I don’t make global comments about your book. I’m not going to give you a list of plot problems or places where characters/scenes should be more developed. That’s the job of a developmental editor (and something that should be done before sending the manuscript to me). If there’s something that really jumps out at me, I sometimes make a comment about it, but I’m not reading your book at that level. If that’s the kind of feedback you are looking for, please work with a developmental editor first. Then come back and let me clean things up at the sentence level.
But don’t take it from me. Here’s what a couple of the authors I’ve worked with have to say:
“In the course of a long career writing analytic reports and technical monographs, I became well acquainted with professional editors. Taking up writing fiction a few years ago, I had difficultly finding an editor who could satisfy my requirements, and so released three novels that were largely self-edited. Recently, a fellow author recommended Karen, and I could not be happier. She is responsive, diligent, meticulous without being overbearing, and affordable. Most importantly, she has a fine feeling for a writer’s style. In the past, I have had to ‘train’ editors to not attempt to reduce my writing to their notion of acceptable ‘lowest common denominator’ verbiage, which has generally not been a congenial exercise. Imagine, therefore, my delight that there was none of this with Karen. From the first, her suggestions enhanced the writing without altering the voice — a rare and wonderful thing in my experience. I recommend her services without reservation and look forward to working with her again in the future.”
~ Owen O’Neill, co-author of the Loralynn Kennakris series
“Look no further for the perfect editor. I initially chose Karen to edit my YA fantasy novel given her impressive education, skill sets, and that she had edited similar books. From our very first interaction, Karen demonstrated a strong, passionate editing philosophy and I immediately felt comfortable working with her. She made many skilled observations that allowed me to polish my novel without changing my voice, which is something of utmost importance to an author. Karen goes above and beyond the scope of an ordinary editor because she possesses a genuine interest in her client’s projects and wants to see them succeed. I highly recommend her and I can’t wait to work with her again.”
~ Amie Irene Winters, author of Strange Luck
Note: I provide line editing, copy editing, and proofreading. If you are looking for a developmental edit or editorial assessment, that comes before the copy editing stage and is not a service I provide. Check out Reedsy's description of the different types of editors: https://blog.reedsy.com/types-of-editing/.
Services
Languages
English (UK)
English (US)
Fiction
Dystopian
Epic Fantasy
Middle Grade Fantasy
Steampunk
Urban Fantasy
Young Adult Fantasy
Work experience
Freelance Copy Editor
Self-employed
August, 2012
–
Present
(over 9 years)
Although I have done freelancing here and there since 1997, I started working full-time at freelancing in August 2012. I have copy edited everything from websites to cookbooks but my preferred focus is fantasy and speculative fiction.
Managing/Copy Editor
PLY Magazine
November, 2014
–
Present
(about 7 years)
Managing editor and copy editor for PLY Magazine, a quarterly magazine for spinning fiber.
Line editor
INDIE Books Gone Wild
July, 2014
–
Present
(over 7 years)
Part of the editing team at INDIE Books Gone Wild.
English Faculty Fellow
Ivy Tech Community College, Lafayette, Indiana
August, 2009
–
August, 2011
(about 2 years)
Taught freshman composition and literature courses.
Editorial Assistant
Arthuriana (academic journal)
January, 2009
–
August, 2009
(7 months)
Copy edited and proofread articles; laid out articles for journal
Technical Writer
AgIT Department, Purdue University
June, 2006
–
December, 2007
(over 1 year)
Wrote documentation supporting in-house computer programs and other programs and revised existing documentation.
Instructor
Purdue University
August, 2004
–
December, 2009
(over 5 years)
Taught courses in composition, literature, and Latin. Was a graduate student during this time and earned a PhD in English.
Instructor
Texas A&M University
January, 2003
–
August, 2005
(over 2 years)
Taught courses in composition, literature, and technical writing.
Writing Center Tutor
Blinn College
June, 2002
–
May, 2004
(almost 2 years)
Tutored students in one-on-one writing sessions
Developmental Lab Tutor
Blinn College
August, 2001
–
May, 2002
(9 months)
Worked with students in computer lab during developmental reading and writing courses as a teacher's aide.
Senior Medical Editor
Cancer Information Group
June, 2000
–
July, 2001
(about 1 year)
Edited and proofread articles for four oncology journals
Copy Editor
Arthur Andersen
September, 1998
–
May, 2000
(over 1 year)
Edited financial documents
Editorial Intern
Texas A&M University Press
January, 1998
–
May, 1998
(4 months)
Proofread manuscripts
Portfolio (46 selected works)
Blood of the Raej
Johnson, Hayley Rae
A Call to Arms: Book One of the Chronicles of Arden
Shiriluna Nott, SaJa H.
Gibben Nemesio is in trouble. His parents are dead, his sister is missing, and he's been left the sole provider for his two younger brothers. With a war brewing in the east and no guarantee of surviving another brutal winter, Gib's life is plagued by uncertainty. To make matters worse, he suddenly finds himself uprooted from his home and drafted into the army. Forced to leave his siblings behi... read more
Strange Luck
Amie Winters
Daisy Darling embarks on a journey to save her ailing father, but instead lands in a dark world built on stolen memories. Now Daisy must risk her life to destroy the world and restore what is lost.
Scorn of Angels (The Descended Book 2)
John Patrick Kennedy
Creation is Doomed… Nyx, Queen of Hell, lies broken and burning in a box at the bottom of the Lake of Fire, put there but her lover Tribunal, who is God’s Son. Nyx’s daughter Epiphenia, has been slaughtered by Tribunal and Lucifer. Her companions, Persephone and Ishtar, were captured and are now suffering unspeakable torture. Lucifer, one Nyx’s second-in-command, has taken over Hell and is rul... read more
The Heart Thief (The Rhapp's Barren Triptych Book 1)
S. Lee Benedict
An urban fantasy novel unlike any other.Ezra Keene is an artistic sixteen-year-old who wants nothing more than to settle in at his new school and put the tragedy of his brother's death behind him. He awakens one night, reeling from a hazy dream, to find his fingers blackened with pencil lead and a new drawing in his sketchbook--a drawing that depicts the grisly murder of someone he knows. The ... read more
Renaria: Into the Adyton
J.L. Wilson
A small memento, a universal power...At seventeen, Leda has her priorities in order: gaming first, real life second. She suffers through school, skips the extracurriculars, and runs home so that she can log-on to Renaria. High school parties? Yeah, right. Her weekends usually involve her prized headset, a pile of gummy bears, and her loyal feline companion, Sphinx, by her side.Unless her mothe... read more
Amendments
H.M. Lynn
Emelia must choose. Her sister or her soulmate.In a world not dissimilar to our own, the Administration have ensured that the human race should not have to live with any regrets.Like millions before her, Emelia now has the chance to go back and make the 'correct' decisions. The little envelope that contains her amendment will change not just her life, but that of the people she loves the most.... read more
Nightfall: Book Two of the Chronicles of Arden
Shiriluna Nott, SaJa H
Gibben Nemesio thought his life was over the day he received a conscription notice demanding he train to be a soldier. When he left his home for Silver City, he never expected he'd thwart a terrible plot to murder the King and become an overnight hero—and he definitely hadn't expected to find love in the form of a handsome mage trainee named Joel.Three years later, Gib has fought his way from ... read more
Finding Sagrado
Roger E. Carrier
Five stars! San Francisco Book Review (August 2014) "A life-altering coming-of-age story filled with magic and imagination." Five Stars! Midwest Reviews, Diane Donovan (May 2014) "Those seeking powerful . . . sagas will find it engrossing." No BS Reviews in New World Authors, by Nick LeVar (June 2014) "This was one of the best novels I've read in a long time. It is a fast, easy read, and if yo... read more
The Mirrored City (Architects of the Grand Design Book 2)
Michael J. Bode
There are two of everything in the Mirrored City, where two rival theocratic factions alternate control of the government. A routine treaty negotiation quickly sets off a chain of events that reveal the city’s deepest secrets.Something stirs in the ruins below. A string of shocking murders leaves mutilated victims posed in grisly tableaus. Parasitic monsters long-forgotten to history work to r... read more
The explosive debut by Lauren ParkesReviews"A chilling tale of love, deception, suspense and greed." "If you like YA fiction and a rollicking plot then this is going to be your cup of tea!" Jenny Knott, Goodreads“The next big thing in young adult thrillers.” Nicola Almond, Twitter advance reader"Startling debut novel from British author, Lauren Parkes." Liz Anne, beta-reader Book DescriptionIf... read more
Told by Mr. Jazz himself, an ordinary cat by his own admission, "Purr Prints of the Heart" is a touching meow-memoir that will strike a chord with anyone whose heart carries paw-prints of love as he shares the story of his life from kitten hood to his final days on earth in the physical sense. Cleverly written in cat likeness with incredible insight, candor, wisdom, and humor, Mr. Jazz takes r... read more
Battle Dawn: Book Three of the Chronicles of Arden
Shiriluna Nott, SaJa H.
For Gibben Nemesio, life hasn’t been easy.Orphaned as a child and drafted into the army at thirteen, he’s no stranger to adversity. He’s fought hard for his coveted position as Seneschal Koal’s understudy and ever harder to make certain his young brothers live to see adulthood. Gib is prepared to sacrifice anything to ensure those closest to him, from his family and friends to his mentor and e... read more
Prophase: DNA Strand 1
Jordana Wells
An unwilling participant in a cryopreservation experiment, engineering student Miranda Donovan wakes after a century to find that basic rights in the post-American society must be earned. Genetic testing reveals her best chance of success lies in a brutal military flight academy, but time is short. She can only hide cryo's crippling effects on her body for so long. Feeling a stalker closing in... read more
Metaphase: DNA Strand 2
Jordana Wells
Brought back from the dead, combat pilot Miranda Donovan finds the price for her resurrection is a steep one. The biomedical laboratory has creatively interpreted the law so the experiments on her can continue. Her determination to escape only intensifies after a horrific, blood-soaked night reveals how much their work has made her a target. The uneasy truce with the biotech lab hinges on her ... read more
Anaphase: DNA Strand 3
Jordana Wells
Having escaped the biotech laboratory that rebuilt her, test subject Miranda Donovan celebrates her freedom by starting a life below the radar with Cris, a passionate engineer. Everything changes when a medical emergency proves that the effects of her being a clone-human hybrid may be far-reaching, not only for her but for everyone else. Torn between love and duty, she must choose between livi... read more
Black Seed (Seed World Book 2)
Kenneth Marshall
The White Seed Brings Life to WorldsThree thousand years ago, the seeds arrived from Earth on hundreds of worlds. The developed worlds formed the Network, connected only by radio and laser. Since the time of the seeds, nothing but information has traveled between the stars. Now a starship, The Child of Ambition, is changing that. Her first mission: to explore the dark worlds, the ones that fai... read more
Harbinger (Dawn of Eight Book 1)
Emme DeWitt
No matter where Noah goes, tragedy strikes. As a banshee, only Noah can see it coming, but it’s all she can do to run away to lessen the damage her voice causes when she sings for the dead. Orphaned from birth, Noah has been trying to control her powers on her own with the help of her guardian Adele. But Noah’s powers are more out of control than ever, and Adele is out of options.As the final ... read more
The Last Shadow Gate: The Shadow Gate Chronicles Book I
Michael W. Garza
Summer vacation was never supposed to be like this.It was bad enough Naomi had to be shipped off to her dad's home for the summer and deal with her half-brother Gavin, but when the siblings are forced to spend their break with their great-grandmother in upstate New York, everything changes. An investigation into the strange disappearance of their great-grandfather forces them to retrace his fo... read more
A Veil of Shadows: The Shadow Gate Chronicles Book II
Michael W. Garza
A desperate search leads to a new world.Naomi and Gavin are on the run. Having narrowly escaped Azzmon’s clutches, they find themselves hunted by Malick, another Shade Lord. He has amassed an army of foul creatures, and the city-state of Tarravale stands on the brink of chaos. Naomi’s ability to open Shadow Gates makes her an alluring target, and the Shade Lord will stop at nothing to possess ... read more
Phase Shift: DNA Strand 4
Wells, Jordana
Out of Phase: DNA Strand 5
Wells, Jordana
Snow (Black Ice Trilogy Book 1)
Elliot, Mikayla
Blizzard (Black Ice Trilogy Book 2)
Elliot, Mikayla
Blood Hound (Alexi Sokolsky: Hound of Eden)
Baldwin, James Osiris, Robinson, Karen
The Squeamish Vampire
Saygo, Andrei
The Steel Harvest (Volume 1)
Miller, J D, Robinson, Karen, Oberth, Jennifer
StoneDragon
Cross, Adrian
Black Diamonds
Cross, Adrian
Forsworn (The Last Oracle) (Volume 2)
Wibberley, Emily
Renaria: Into the Adyton
Wilson, J.L., Michaels, Jo
One Ghost Too Many! (Ghost Town Detective Agency) (Volume 1)
Garza, Michael W., Garza, Gavin M.
Tribes of Decay: The Decaying World Saga Book I
Garza, Michael W.
The Hand That Feeds: A Prequel to the Decaying World Saga
Garza, Michael W.
The Last Infection: A Prequel to the Decaying World Saga
Garza, Michael W.
NeverHaven: Vision of the Elder Book I
Garza, Michael W.
In Through The Outdoor: Stories from the Beyond
Garza, Michael W.
Drums in the Abyss: Rise of the Elder Book I
Garza, Michael W.
The Elder Unearthed: Tales of NasNoroth and the Cult of the Elder
Michael W. Garza
Just A Kiss
Spivey, Carol
A Simple Tale of Water and Weeping
King Larsen, Kami
The Crown's Inheritance: A LeNoir Legacy Story (The LeNoir Legacy)
Faulkenberry, Cristen
Karen has 18 reviews
Professionalism
Professionalism
Quality
Quality
Value
Value
Communication & Punctuality
Communication & Punctuality
Karen was prompt, efficient, and clear about her expectations and what she would provide. I couldn't ask for more than that.
Kevin Dvis, December 2021
Overall great experience working with Karen. She explained her process, was prompt in all communications and touched base with me as she went along to let me know how editing was going. She zeroed in on things that I would never have caught. I would definitely work with her again and recommend her for copy editing, especially if you're writing something based on the medieval time period as she'...
Read more
Melissa Manzone, December 2021
Karen was great to work with and does a wonderful job. I had a few questions throughout the copyedit process and she was always quick to answer any questions I had. Her suggestions and feedback were always nice and constructive. Definitely would recommend!
Maddox Grey, October 2021
It was a pleasure working with Karen Robinson. I learned so much and I look forward to working on future projects and books again. Thank you so much.
Eliot Esparza, October 2021
The decision to hire an editor was the most daunting one for me. I'd never hired an editor, and while I knew it would be a smart investment, there are so many talented and experienced editors on Reedsy to choose from. Karen's sample edit was what set her apart from the others. Her attention to detail was impressive, especially for a clean manuscript that had been edited by a traditionally publ...
Read more
Kerry Lorimer, September 2021
Explore the Reedsy Community
Reedsy is a community of top publishing professionals. Join Reedsy today to browse 1000+ profiles.
Fiona McLaren
Shaping novels into the best version of an author's vision. Former clients published by HarperTeen, Macmillan, and more. US and UK markets.
Limassol, Cyprus
Leonora Bulbeck
Friendly and experienced copyeditor with a passion for young adult and adult fantasy and science fiction.
Woking, United Kingdom
